1952 Film East Of Eden As Midrash. What "Problem Points" In The Bible Does East Of Eden Address? How Are These Areas Resolved? Is It A Modern Midrash On The Cain And Abel Story?

813 words - 3 pages

In the 1952 film East of Eden, director and darshan Elia Kazan attempts to resolve the moral tension in the Cain and Abel story by depicting Cal as a sympathetic character. The ambiguity of the biblical account is responsible for much of this tension. God does not offer a reason for accepting Abel's gift and rejecting Cain's. Neither of the brothers have a distinct personality, and so the motivation for the murder is left to speculation. Why is Cain's punishment seemingly mitigated and what should the reader draw from the story? Kazan and Steinbeck together sort through such problems, using their imaginations to fill in textual gaps and formulating an interpretation relevant to their day.Why would God favor Abel and not Cain? This is the biggest problem for Kazan and Steinbeck. Unfortunately, the biblical text does not provide a clear answer, so they must come up with one on their own. Perhaps the sacrifice itself was bad. After Adam loses nearly all of his money, Cal takes it upon himself to reimburse his father. Anticipating World War I, the son invests five thousand dollars in beans and upon the war's arrival, bean prices skyrocket. Ecstatic, Cal plans to surprise his father with the money for his birthday. When that long anticipated day arrives, Aron informs Adam of his engagement to Abra and his father is thrilled. On the other hand, when Cal presents the money to his father, he replies, "Do you think I could take a profit from that?...I don't want that money." Even though his intentions were good, because the money came from the war, Adam refuses to accept it, breaking his son's heart. Thus, Kazan and Steinbeck have formulated a reason for God's behavior. Apparently, Cain's gift originated from a faulty source whereas Abel's was pure and honest. This explanation also provides a motive for murder.Why did Cain kill Abel? Again, information given in the biblical text is meager and gives no insight into Cain's motivation. Kazan and Steinbeck attribute it partially to jealousy. In response to Cal's gift, Adam replies, "I'd be happy if you'd give me something like, well, like your brother's given me." Immediately his son breaks down and runs out of the house. When Abra, whom Cal is fond of, follows to comfort him, Aron yells, "Don't you ever touch her again!" compounding his grief and jealousy. This scenario, in...

Find Another Essay On 1952 Film East of Eden as Midrash. What "problem points" in the Bible does East of Eden address? How are these areas resolved? Is it a modern midrash on the Cain and Abel story?

East of Eden Summary Essay

1658 words - 7 pages This World War I centered book is called East of Eden, and it was written by John Steinbeck. East of Eden primariy takes place within the Salinas Valley located in Northern California. The valley is described to have rich odors and lively geological features. These include the Gabilan Mountains and the Salinas River. In the Salinas Valley, an Irish immigrant named Samuel Hamilton moves into the valley with his wife Liza. Although the Hamiltons

East Of Eden Essay

1063 words - 4 pages Mary TeisingerMr. FineranAP Literature & Composition24 September, 2014What Saves Cal? "The East of Eden"Many people wonder what saves Cal in the movie "The East of Eden". There are several different answers someone can come up with. Cal is stubborn and is look upon as evil. Nobody around him really knows why he acts evil, but they don't show affection towards him because he is not approachable. He tends to act up and his jealously got the

East Of Eden

1063 words - 4 pages Mary TeisingerMr. FineranAP Literature & Composition24 September, 2014What Saves Cal? "The East of Eden"Many people wonder what saves Cal in the movie "The East of Eden". There are several different answers someone can come up with. Cal is stubborn and is look upon as evil. Nobody around him really knows why he acts evil, but they don't show affection towards him because he is not approachable. He tends to act up and his jealously got the

East Of Eden

1063 words - 4 pages Mary TeisingerMr. FineranAP Literature & Composition24 September, 2014What Saves Cal? "The East of Eden"Many people wonder what saves Cal in the movie "The East of Eden". There are several different answers someone can come up with. Cal is stubborn and is look upon as evil. Nobody around him really knows why he acts evil, but they don't show affection towards him because he is not approachable. He tends to act up and his jealously got the

East Of Eden - 1063 words

1063 words - 4 pages Mary TeisingerMr. FineranAP Literature & Composition24 September, 2014What Saves Cal? "The East of Eden"Many people wonder what saves Cal in the movie "The East of Eden". There are several different answers someone can come up with. Cal is stubborn and is look upon as evil. Nobody around him really knows why he acts evil, but they don't show affection towards him because he is not approachable. He tends to act up and his jealously got the

East of Eden Response

1121 words - 4 pages he sees Alice, his stepmother, smiling as she cleans. He is flabbergasted. Her smile is equally as shocking to Adam as if he had just seen her naked because Alice does not show much emotion. However, this experience opens his eyes not only to what is standing in front of him, but, on a deeper level, to the duality of life. Dual means two, or, a pair of something. Therefore, duality of life is the principle that there are two sides to everything

The Story of Cain and Abel(Summarized)

627 words - 3 pages to exist because of Cain. Beowulf is the Savior, who represents good, who fights all evil in order to sustain happiness of all the people. He is the hero of all heroes. Once he takes a vow, he stands by it. This story of Cain and Abel is in the Old Testament of the Bible. Many Christian followers, just as the Anglo-Saxons did, still look upon this story as an important moral teaching. There is a belief that Christians preach, which is "if

The Significance of Sibling Rivalry in Steinbeck's East of Eden

1513 words - 6 pages book. Steinbeck's dramatic account of the Trask brothers and their rivalry in East of Eden is an impressive tale, but it is also a familiar one that closely echoes a story from ancient literature-it is an allusion of the well-known story of Cain and Abel in the Bible. In the Bible, the brothers Cain and Abel are the sons of Adam and Eve. Cain is "a tiller of the ground" (Genesis 4:2-5) a farmer while Abel is "a keeper of sheep" (Genesis 4:2-5

How Cathy is evil in the book "East of Eden" by John Steinbeck

1483 words - 6 pages filled the jar halfway with the blood. She then buried the evidence of the chicken. She then took off the apron in the kitchen and put it on the stove. She poked the coals until the apron caught on fire. Again before leaving she hid the evidence of the jelly jar. She remorselessly locked her parents in their house and set it on fire. Her parents sad death did not make Cathy shed a tear as she was looking into a new exciting career

East of Eden - Self Knowledge

1193 words - 5 pages -identity, while caused by individual circumstances in a person's life, is salvageable to anybody through the idea of free will. Steinbeck advocates the notion of free will throughout the novel, especially via the character Lee as he relates it to the story of Cain and Abel in the bible. Free will is a natural law given to all humans, which allows them to choose to do whatever they want to do, offering the ultimate possibility to anybody to attempt

East of Eden: An Interpretation

3443 words - 14 pages knew he didn't want to be evil, and with this inspiration he wouldn't be evil. III. As a theme I see the basic story of Cain and Abel reinvent itself within the Trask family generation after generation. It was interesting because all the characters whose name began with the letter "A" represented the good and benevolent son to Adam and Eve that is Abel. Examples of these are Adam, Aron, and Abra. And likewise, the characters whose name

Similar Essays

East Of Eden With Cain And Abel

1726 words - 7 pages do with one’s life is completely up to the individual. John Steinbeck’s use of the biblical story of Cain and Abel builds on the idea that a person is completely responsible for choosing what becomes of them in result of a word, an action and a memory. Undoubtedly everyone has the choice whether or not they wish to triumph over the pain and the sins they are struggling with. After all, look at Ghandi he witnessed children burdened with evil inheritance walk away surmounted because of their strength to rein over evil. Works Cited Steinbeck, John. East of Eden. New York, New York: Penguin Group, 1952. Print.

John Steinbeck's East Of Eden: Modern Biblical Story Of Cain And Abel

2348 words - 9 pages in some way. East of Eden (1952) by John Steinbeck is a modern retelling of the biblical tragedy of Cain and Abel. The story is reenacted through the lives of two generations of the Trask family. Cyrus Trask, the patriarch of the family and his two sons Adam and Charles live on a farm in Conneticut. Charles cries out in anguish for his father's love, but his father ignores his cries and loves Adam best. Because of his father's favoritism

Essay Describing The Use Of Religious Aspects In The Book "East Of Eden" By John Steinebck; Uses "Timshel" And The Story Of Cain And Abel; Shows Different Aspects Of The Characters Using These Stories

904 words - 4 pages be allowed a choice between good and evil, and a choice he is granted through the concept of timshel. By using the Biblical story of timshel, Cal lets down his fierce walls to try to please his father.Steinbeck uses the Bible in many ways. In East of Eden, however, it is most prominently used to scrutinize that human character. Through the story of Cain and Abel and the interpretation of timshel, Steinbeck explores human drama rather thoroughly

What Savs Cal In East Of Eden

595 words - 2 pages Faith 1Faith M. DennyMr. FineranAP Lit24 September 2014The movie East of Eden has many allusions throughout it. A main one is how Cal and Aron show similarities with Cain and Abel (two brothers in The Bible). In the biblical version, Cain murders his brother, then is cast away from his family. When cast away, he is doomed to live east of Eden. Although there had been many similarities up to then, when Cal (basically) murders Aaron, he is not