This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Second Language Acquisition Essay

3146 words - 13 pages

Background to L2 Writing
“Writing for L2 students was until the 1970s, primarily perceived as language practice, designed to help students manipulate grammatical forms or utilise newly learned vocabulary items “(Ferris, 2002:p. 3). An example will be `write about what you did last week` which practises the past tense form. Teachers used to adopt a product approach which focuses on correcting all language errors rather than organisation or ideas of the text. Teachers will mark each writing piece as the final draft and assume students will not repeat their mistakes again in future writings (Grabe and Kaplan, 1996).
“However in the 1970s, native English speaking composition practitioners and theorists began to focus on writers themselves and on the process they used to write texts” (Ferris, 2002: p. 4). This led to major paradigm shift from product approach to process approach and had implications on L1 writers and consequently L2 writers adopted the process model as well focusing more on ideas rather than the accuracy of the written work (Ferris, 2002).
(Zamel, 1985) was among the main advocates to encourage the idea of allowing insights from L1 to encourage L2 writing, however studies showed that “pedagogical suggestions designed for L1 writers needed to be critically revaluated before transferring it to L2 writers” (Ferris, 2002: p.4). Among the many distinctions is that L2 writers’ errors often relate to incorrect transfer from their L1 and inadequate acquisition of L2 (Ferris, 2002).

Controversy surrounding corrective feedback
Teachers give students CF for many reasons, first they believe CF is part of their job and is expected of them from parents, students and stakeholders. It is also because students can revise their own work, write a more accurate draft and acquire a better language (Ellis, 2008). However, “the research literature has not been unequivocally positive about the role of CF in writing development “(Hyland and Hyland, 2006:p.83) and this following section will discuss the negative and positive perspective of CF in L2 writing.
Truscott (1996) holds a strong view against CF in writing and argues that correcting grammar and language errors is harmful and detrimental to L2 writing. He makes the point that CF can demotivate students “even students who believe that correction is a necessary part of learning do not enjoy the sight of red ink all over their writing” (Truscott, 1996:p. 354). Students when they see their errors might avoid attempting complex structures and instead only write in simpler sentences which are grammatically correct in order to avoid mistakes.
Truscott (1996) points out how Second language acquisition (SLA) suggests that learning is not a linear process and that learners learn in a certain order. This means when students are “corrected on a point for which they are not yet ready, the correction is not likely to have much value” (Truscott 1996: p.344) and doesn’t necessarily indicate any learning has...

Find Another Essay On Second Language Acquisition

First and Second Language Acquisition Essay

1339 words - 5 pages First and Second Language Acquisition In our everyday lives, the origin of our ability to communicate is usually not often taken into consideration. One doesn't think about how every person has, or rather had at one time, an innate ability to learn a language to total fluency without a conscious effort – a feat that is seen by the scientific community "as one of the many utterly unexplainable mysteries that beset us in our daily lives" (3

SECOND LANGUAGE ACQUISITION FOR LEARNERS Essay

1196 words - 5 pages Teaching and acquiring second foreign languages are necessary to have various knowledge that relate to different ways or methodologies. As a known initially the people have (L1.) mother tongue after the birth. It is learned from the way of audition and this acquisition starts with maternity and infanthood. The mother tongue learners learn the main rules and patterns which is L1. Therefore, second language acquisition becomes impalpable. Most of

Comparing first and second language acquisition

1866 words - 7 pages Essay«Comparing first and second language acquisition»«Comparing first and second language acquisition»Language acquisition is the subdiscipline of applied linguistics and the area of researches of psycholinguistic.Language acquisition is "picking up' a language, not learning it consciously but by being exposed to it in natural situations (e.g. as a child learns its first language). Often contrasted with language learning

Comparing first and second language acquisition

1866 words - 7 pages Essay«Comparing first and second language acquisition»«Comparing first and second language acquisition»Language acquisition is the subdiscipline of applied linguistics and the area of researches of psycholinguistic.Language acquisition is "picking up' a language, not learning it consciously but by being exposed to it in natural situations (e.g. as a child learns its first language). Often contrasted with language learning

Krashen’s Hypotheses of Second Language Acquisition

1678 words - 7 pages Krashen’s Hypotheses of Second Language Acquisition For decades, foreign language teachers wandered in a scientific abyss. Until 1983, there had been little real research dealing with the ways in which someone acquires a second language. Teachers mostly used the audiolingual classroom model that had been in place for the past twenty years (or, even worse, the literally ancient grammatical translation model that had been used by

The Impact of Culture on Second Language Acquisition

959 words - 4 pages concerning the language learning difficulties from different perspectives. One of the theories to explain second language acquisition issues from the sociocultural/sociolinguistic point of view is Brown’s (1980) Optimal distance Model, which is in parallel with Schumann’s (1986) Acculturation Model. Brown (1980) and Schumann (1986) state that both second language learning difficulties and the level of mastery in that language can be determined

The Impact of Age in Relation to Second Language Acquisition

2029 words - 9 pages Illinois provided in their case study, “Critical Period Effects in Second Language Learning: The Influence of Maturational State on the Acquisition of English as a Second Language” that, “some investigators have suggested that a critical period theory must predict that children are better than adults at learning second languages” (63). In order to prove or disprove the idea that children are able to better acquire second languages at a higher rate

How do teachers apply the second language acquisition approaches?

938 words - 4 pages Now days it is essential to acquire a second language which let people interact with other cultures, in a global world, as it is known, there are different approaches related to a second language acquisition, but how are they practiced in a real classroom? To get a general idea which can potentially clarify this question, two classes were exanimated to compare and contrast theory and practice. Here the descriptions and results: First of all

Addressing Challenges on Acquisition of Reading Comprehension to Second Language English Speakers

1818 words - 8 pages Addressing challenges on acquisition of reading comprehension to second language English speakers. Where does the gap lie? Background to the study In our country, South Africa, we know that we are faced with so many socio-economic issues Some of these issues are poverty, high crime, HIV/AIDS epidemic, child-headed families, abuse in the family, illiterate parents and alcoholic parents just to name a few. These social make it even harder for us

Second Language Acquisition essay Essay by anitarios, University, Bachelor's, B+, November 2008

3015 words - 12 pages BAB III BAB III METODE PENELITIAN Metode Penelitian dan Rancangan Penelitian Pada bab ini akan dibahas hal-hal yang menyangkut tentang metode penelitian dan rancangan penelitian. Metode Penelitian Metode yang digunakan dalam penelitian ini adalah survey yang dirancang dengan maksud untuk memperoleh informasi tentang gejala-gejala pada saat penelitian. Penggunaan metode ini didasarkan pada

Language Acquisition Principles

1029 words - 4 pages Stephen Krashen is one of the experts when it comes to language acquisition. He has theorized on the subject of second language acquisition for years and has been quite influential in this field of linguistics. He approaches the subject of second language acquisition by presenting his five theories for acquiring a second language. Aida Walqui is another expert; however, she approaches the subject from the aspect that contextual factors are

Similar Essays

Second Language Acquisition Essay

3332 words - 13 pages The essay was focused on the following question: What possible explanations are there for the failure of EFL students to achieve native-like competence in a second language. SECOND LANGUAGE ACQUISITION The outcome of first language acquisition is a success in children. Children acquire the grammar of the ambient language. Adult language acquisition, on the other hand, results in varying degrees of success or failure to acquire the target

Second Language Acquisition Essay

2391 words - 10 pages SECOND LANGUAGE ACQUISITION ASSIGNMENTFaced with the reality that few students attain the native-like competence the following question arises what are the root causes of this problem?. Many researchers agree in that L2 learners are bad at L2 learning, in spite of the fact that they make an effort to improve their speech, by imitation, they still have a foreign accent, or they make mistakes when they apply the rules of grammar in their writings

Second Language Acquisition Essay

2014 words - 8 pages Introduction Through the years, language teachers, psychologists and others have had varying ideas of how languages are learned. Second language acquisition has multiple models, including cognitive based models, sociocultural models, and models regarding input and interaction. In this paper, my goal is to take one prominent model of SLA, the interactionist model, and determine how this model actually plays out in the classroom. I seek to answer

Second Language Acquisition In Childhood Essay

1254 words - 5 pages Children acquire their native language, which fall within a wide range of languages, at a very early stage of development. During development, a child begins to show signs of verbal communication, usually starting out as cooing, babbling, recognizable words, and later two or more word sentences. This occurrence is also seen in the development of second languages. Second language acquisition is the study of how second languages are typically