Critical Comparison Of Theories And Approaches Of Community Organizing

1546 words - 7 pages


In this essay I shall make a critical comparison of different theories and approaches of community organising. By focusing on main aspects of Paulo Freire and Saul Alinsky’s models of community organising I shall discuss how applicable these models are in the UK. By drawing examples from experiences of applying Root Solution Listening Matters (RSLM) and Participatory Action Research (PAR) frameworks in my practice. I shall demonstrate relationships and differences between the two. By addressing key elements of theories of power and conflict I shall highlight the main characteristics of both and use these theories as lenses to view some problems in the communities. By comparing models of community enterprise I shall reflect on future opportunities of a budding community enterprise. Finally by outlining the methods of evaluation I shall reflect on my chosen framework for evaluation of my work.

I have applied a qualitative methodology for this essay to provide a literature review and given examples, where relevant, drawn from my practical experiences of working with communities in Bordesley Green (BG), Birmingham and in overseas.


Paulo Freire, and Saul Alinsky’s approaches:
Paulo Freire, and Saul Alinsky are a few of the pioneers of global grassroots collective movement, which is at the heart of community organising. Their theories are based upon organising communities from the below, who are most deprived, socially isolated and segregated and disempowered due to social, economic and political systems. The essence of Freire’s epic book titled “Pedagogy of the Oppressed” (1972) is about challenging the state imposed bureaucratic top down “banking education system” that increases dependency and restricts democratic thinking of becoming a free individual. He calls for “liberating education”, a process where an individual understands about oppression, subjugation, etc. He proposes that engaging with “dialogues” and creating a “conscientization” process among educators and students are called participation. This participation from engagement builds respect and community spirit, what he describes as “praxis” that generates social capital and strengthens community cohesion. As Blackburn (200:7) rightly points out that socially constructed obstacles such as deprivation, and poverty are not a continuous phenomena in an individual’s life instead “conscientization” process can empower the individual to break those barriers and build capacity of critical thinking to bring changes forward.

Saul Alinsky, famously known as the father of community organising movement and the author of Rules for Radicals (1971) on the contrary argued that oppression, inequality, injustice, and deprivation are root causes of disempowerment, these may demoralise people, as a result they may feel they are defeated and disfranchised (Thomson 2005:200). To Alinsky, at this point, they must organise themselves, get agitated, rebel...

Find Another Essay On Critical Comparison of Theories and Approaches of Community Organizing

Comparison of Moral Theories Essay

908 words - 4 pages Comparison of Moral Theories A discussion of moral theories must begin with a discussion of the two extremes of ethical thinking, absolutism and relativism. Moral Absolutism is the belief that there are absolute standards where moral questions are judged and can be deemed right or wrong, regardless of the context. Steadfast laws of the universe, God, nature itself are the forces that deem an action right or wrong. A person’s actions rather than

Comparison of Universities and Community Colleges

672 words - 3 pages Comparison of Universities and Community Colleges When you graduate high school you have your choice of what kind of an education you want to get. You have your choice of going to a 4-year university, or a 2-year college. In order to decide you will compare the two and use the comparisons to come up with your final decision. Questions to ask yourself would be, what are you looking for in college, how do you want to learn, and how much

Comparison and Contrast of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy Approaches with Postmodern Therapy Approaches

711 words - 3 pages Postmodern counseling approaches have begun to challenge the paradigms of modernistic counseling theories. Modern theories emphasize the use of empirically validated treatment approaches to psychotherapy. The modernistic therapy perspective endorses the premise that psychological problems are the result of disturbances in cognitive processes. The focus of cognitive behavior therapy (CBT) is on helping clients to examine and restructure their

Comparison of Theories of Attachment

2275 words - 9 pages , etc. Bowlby also states that infants tend to bond and become attached to one key figure, usually the mother, in which he calls, ‘monotropy ’ he considers this to be strongest bond, and is distinctive between mother and child. In comparison to Bowlby, Freud developed ‘cupboard love theories’ of attachment with two different view-points. According to psychoanalytic views, Infants become attached because of their carer’s capability to satisfy an

A Critical Review of Qualitative Methodological Approaches

1546 words - 6 pages investigates using an inductive approach that aims to ensure that the theory presented is grounded in observations that have been made and not based on abstract theories. Data collection and analysis are undertaken simultaneously and through constant iterations, instances and themes emerge to inform the theory. Grounded Theory involves different stages of data analysis; open coding, axial coding, and selective coding. The data can be derived from

Comparison of Theories on Personality

1731 words - 7 pages Comparison of Theories on Personality Abstract This paper is a comparison of three different viewpoints on the subject of personality. Carl Jung, B.F. Skinner, and Carl Rogers all had very different outlooks on what defined someone’s personality. As an added feature I have included myself as a theorist because my views are also different from the previous mentioned theorists. This paper will also look briefly into the background of

A Comparison of Practical and Principled Nonviolent Action Theories

3804 words - 15 pages A Comparison of Practical and Principled Nonviolent Action Theories Introduction The phrase "nonviolent action" brings to mind a wide variety of sometimes conflicting images. The image of a Chinese student at Tiananmen Square standing in the way of a tank was portrayed around the world, along with the stories of those who were shot and run over by those tanks. Indian participants pressed forward undauntedly in columns and then in groups

Sex Work and the Law: A Critical Analysis of Four Policy Approaches to Adult Prostitution

1810 words - 7 pages Throughout Sex Work and the Law: A Critical Analysis of Four Policy Approaches to Adult Prostitution Frances Shaver discusses the need for change for women working as prostitutes. Shaver explains the ongoing problem surrounding prostitution in Canada and provides four possible ways to resolve the issue in her work. Three well thought out points Shaver writes about are the health benefits as well as personal safety for the women in the sex

A Critical Comparison of The Stag And Roe-Deer

1339 words - 5 pages A Critical Comparison of The Stag And Roe-Deer There are six stanzas, which are each seven lines long. This is written in free verse, it has no rhyming scheme and there is no rhythm that I can see. The lines are about ten words long, apart from the last two lines, which are shorter. The title is simple and straightforward. It is significant that the whole of the stanza is about people except for the last line, which is about the stag

Critical Comparison of Porphyrias Lover and My Last Dutchess

1442 words - 6 pages Critical Comparison of Porphyrias Lover and My Last Dutchess Both of these poems are based around the concept of power and possesion. They tell the story of obssesional lovers. The effect of using dramatic monologue to convey this idea is very effective. The first poem, Porphyrias Lover, was written in the mid ninteenth century, around 1842. It is the dramatic monologue of the Lover. It is not made known who the recipient of this poem

Critical analysis for theories of international relations

1809 words - 7 pages that are trying to destroy the blessings of independence, democracy in its own sense and the freedom of the people. As slowly as it can get, most of the nations are now deteriorating due to the war that is in existence against the strongest state and country that is known to possess super power. Critical theory is being defined as the manner in which the society is being criticized as well as the literature that is attached to it. By this, it means

Similar Essays

Community Organizing And Policing Essay

3091 words - 12 pages vision, develop community cohesion, and solve or reduce the impact of problems and issues. "As crime and violence increase in the communities, community organizing and community policing plan strategies to combat these problems." ( "The city of Long Beach’s Department of Community Development and Police Department provide services and programs to residents and community organizations to maintain and

The Role Of Organizing In Critical Thinking

525 words - 2 pages The Role of Organizing in Critical ThinkingThe role of organizing in critical thinking is necessary in processing information that we receive on a daily basis. Without organization, there would be confusion within the everyday thought process. Organization takes all of the valid points produced while critically thinking and presents those thoughts in a pattern that is easily understood. In this paper I will detail the importance of the role of

Approaches To Learning Theories Of Learning Styles And Learning Strategies

642 words - 3 pages learner actively uses the theories formed and also tries them in new situations. The latter takes him back to the start of the cycle. )- Concrete Experience (The learner is encouraged to become involved in new experiences.)- Reflective Observation (The learner reflect on his experience from different perspective. Enough time and supportive feedback is helpful in this stage.)- Abstract Conceptualisation (The learner forms ideas and logical

Richard Speck And Comparison Of Theories

2481 words - 10 pages Introduction Varying theories such as rational choice theory, trait theory, and social structure theory are commonly used to explain why crime happens. Application of these three theories in discussing the crimes of Richard Speck can help us to better understand which of the theories may apply and perhaps help give us insight into why he committed his crimes. But they are more beneficial when not looking at a single specific crime, but the