A Close Textual Analysis Of Corporate Layoff Memos

1396 words - 6 pages

All employers occasionally must deliver bad news to their employees, but few bad news situations can compete with the delicate task of announcing layoffs. In an electronic age, when layoff notices delivered via email are quickly leaked to outsiders, CEOs must take into account not only the employees who will be affected by the layoffs, but also the reporters, bloggers, and stock analysts who will undoubtedly see the emails. In an attempt to please these multiple audiences, employers—like the three CEOs who wrote the memos that are the focus of this column—often downplay the negative news or sandwich it between hopeful predictions about the future. While this strategy may mitigate the short-term effects of announcing bad news, it can also backfire, angering employees who feel they have been deceived.
A multi-pronged approach to studying these memos (and others like them) can reveal a multitude of rhetorical features that will be useful to academics and practitioners alike. In this article, I discuss and apply close textual analysis (CTA) to the three corporate layoff memos, focusing particularly on the use of euphemism to mask bad news messages.
Close textual analysis: A brief overview
Close textual analysis as a method of rhetorical criticism, advocated by scholars such as Michael Leff (1986, 1988) and Stephen E. Lucas (1988, 1990), asserts that a “close reading” of a text can “reveal and explicate the precise, often hidden, mechanisms that give a particular text ... rhetorical effect” (Burgchardt, 2005, p. 563). Employing this method can make explicit how a text can affect its audience in particular ways. Proponents of close textual analysis suggest that its power lies in its simplicity, which nonetheless leads to important insights. As Jacinski explains, “Close readers linger over words, verbal images, elements of style, sentences, argument patterns, and entire paragraphs and larger discursive units within the text to explore their significance on multiple levels” (2001, p. 93).
Close textual analysis is an ideal method for novice rhetoricians because it does not require a complex theoretical grounding; the analysis begins tabula rosa—with the textual artifact itself. CTA keeps the text at the center of the analysis and rewards critics who return to the text again and again, “slow[ing] down the action within the text” through multiple careful readings (Lucas, 1988, p. 249). Furthermore, CTA can be a particularly useful method for studying short texts—such as these layoff memos—because their length allows us to conduct a “microscopic” (Lucas, 1990; Slagell, 1991) reading of the text, enabling critics and writers alike to see rhetoric at work in business communication.
Possible avenues for analysis
When applied to the layoff memos in this column, close textual analysis suggests several potential avenues for rhetorical investigation. For example:

• A careful study of pronoun use by the three authors reveals striking differences...

Find Another Essay On A Close Textual Analysis of Corporate Layoff Memos

Close analysis of kybla khan

1001 words - 4 pages EssayWrite a close analysis of Samuel Taylor Coleridge's "Kubla Khan"Kubla KhanA vision in a dream. A fragment.The poem Kubla Khan is a strange, mystic poem that some people believe to be the most romantic poem ever written. A reason why this poem is strange is that with this poem there is a prologue. Within this prologue Coleridge explains about reading a book on Kubla Khan, then taking opium and going of in to a dream. Also in the prologue

A Close Analysis of Act3 Scene V of 'Romeo and Juliet'.

1211 words - 5 pages seeks to cover up Juliet's actions.Each member of Juliet's primary family has abandoned her. Still a young person in need of an older person's support, she flees to the Friar as a source of aid and counsel. Juliet's isolation is nearly complete, and yet she is calm and resolute, as she determines to die rather thant enter into a bigamous marriage with Paris : 'If all else fail, myself have power to die'.In conclusion to this close analasys of Act

Textual Analysis of "While I Live", John Marsden

532 words - 2 pages used by the author.Throughout the novel a variety of themes are produced and these can be related to Shakespeare's play "Othello". Both texts share themes of love, tragedy and responsibility that are used to portray the writer's message. Both texts involve the death of a loved one that is close to the main character and both deaths effect the main character to a large extent.

Write a sustained close analysis of 'Kubla Khan' paying attention to both the form and content of the poem.

2595 words - 10 pages expresses Coleridge's subconscious thoughts on paradise, poetry, intellect and spiritual being. After all the poem does invite a lot of psychoanalytical readings, especially as it was, by Coleridge's own admission, the result of a dream - a psychological curiosity. Moreover, the poem could be said to express the failure of the French Revolution, as this was a cause that was close to Coleridge's heart

Close Textual Analysis of Volume II, Chapter II of Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein

2034 words - 8 pages expedition; Robert is completely surrounded by ice and finds a man who is in very poor shape and taken on board: Victor Frankenstein. As soon as Victor’s health improves, he tells Robert his story of his life. Victor describes how he discovers the secret of bringing to life lifeless matter and, by assembling different body parts, creates a monster who guaranteed revenge on his creator after being unwanted from humanity. Volume II, Chapter II of

Present a detailed textual analysis a the short (2-3 minute) film extract from 'Casablanca'.

1583 words - 6 pages sees Ilsa.As Rick looks up, the camera sweeps across the room in the direction of his eye line, and we see Isla standing by the window and turning towards Rick, with horizontal shadows of the blinds across her. The camera then makes a sharp cut to a close up of her face and shoulders, which makes the sighting of her appear more dramatic. Again, the blinds harshly shadow her face, adding to the drama.The camera cuts back to Rick and follows him as he

Textual Analysis of Epic of Gilgamesh and Book of Genesis of the Holy Bible

1082 words - 4 pages A Textual Analysis of Genesis and the Epic of Gilgamesh The stories of the floods found in both Gilgamesh and Genesis contain many striking similarities that are inevitably beyond mere coincidence. One could surmise that both of these stories might have a basis in common historical occurrence. However, despite the fact that both of these works discuss a common topic, the portrayal of this event is quite different. Like identical

Close critical analysis of Coleridges Frost at Midnight

1655 words - 7 pages understanding of Romantic poetry that I will conduct my close critical analysis of 'Frost at Midnight' to examine the extent to which the poem embodies and explores the key concerns of Romanticism. 'Frost at Midnight' is a poem written without calculated adherence to established poetic conventions. Comprising four stanzas of varying length, it is written in blank verse and adopts a conversational tone. The flexibility of the meter complements

Close analysis of the film "Witness" by Peter Wier

1207 words - 5 pages move". John empties the bullets from the chamber and tells Samuel a loaded gun is very dangerous. When Rachel enters, a close up of her face emphasizes her concern when she sees Samuel playing with the gun, and, not knowing that it is now harmless, takes it from him holding it distastefully by the butt. The Amish believe it is wrong to take the life of others under any circumstance and it is only for God to do so. Eli talks to Samuel and quotes

Corporate Social Responsibility: An Analysis of Google

2310 words - 9 pages ?accountid=10382Carroll, A. B. and Shabana, K. M.. 2010. "The Business Case for Corporate SocialResponsibility: A Review of Concepts, Research and Practice."International Journal of Management Reviews, 12: 85-105.doi: 10.1111/j.1468-2370.2009.00275.xChen Jia. 2009. "Writer sues Google for copyright infringement." China Daily,December 16. http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2009-12/16/content_9184029.htmEntertainment Close - Up. 2012."Consumer Watchdog

Textual Analysis on lines 35-70 in Scene V, Act I of Macbeth.

935 words - 4 pages Lady Macbeth has read her husband's letter concerning his meeting with the three weird sisters and their predictions. One of the witches had prophesized that Macbeth would become the king. Lady Macbeth is pleased but she knows that Macbeth may be ambitious but he couldn't possibly carry out the murder of King Duncan which would probably be necessary to give him the crown. She knows that without her intervention Macbeth will never be a king. The

Similar Essays

A Close Analysis Of Plutarch's "Parallel Lives"

1041 words - 4 pages an informant on Antony's character. Plutarch recounts a story that was told to him by his grandfather concerning the physician Philotas of Amphissa, Antony's wasteful protocol for his feasts, and Antony's son Antyllus' extravagant gift giving. When Plutarch says, "These are the stories my grandfather told me whenever he had the chance to talk about Philotas" he implies that he often talked with his grandfather, and thus had a close relationship

A Textual Analysis Of The Opening Sequence Of Gladiator

1849 words - 7 pages A Textual Analysis of the Opening Sequence of Gladiator In this essay, I will explain the opening sequence of Gladiator in detail. I will describe the effects it has on the audience, and look at the way it makes them feel and the way in which events are portrayed. I will look at in depth: The themes and atmosphere, the camera

Textual Analysis Of Writing Guides

3606 words - 14 pages . Where once the teaching of composition was left primarily to English teachers, there are now other sources—namely reference guides on writing—that claim to have the formula for success. There are a number of publishers who have capitalized on employing rhetorical strategies of sarcasm and humor to gain a larger share of the reference guide market. In this paper I will examine a few of these writing guides—specifically: Barron’s Painless Writing

Textual Analysis/Critique Of Maus Ii

947 words - 4 pages purpose. Placing himself right in the middle of the comic, Spiegelman demonstrates to the reader just how close the work has gotten to him.You have to sympathize with both Art and his father throughout the book, although for different reasons. Art feels guilty about not having experienced the horror that his mother and father did; simply being a second generation survivor that can't ever fully comprehend the effects of the Holocaust because he did not