This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Closer Look At Hannah Dustan’s Affair

1396 words - 6 pages

A Closer Look at Hannah Dustan’s Affair

Throughout literature, there have been many tales told about strong, brave heroes and mighty, wily savages and beasts. However, one story that still speaks to students today is that of a heroine by the name of Hannah Dustan, who killed ten Indians with the assistance of her two fellow captives. Together, they escaped capture, and Hannah Dustan told her tale again and again to individuals she encountered. Because she did not write her story down, others did it for her. In particular, John Greenleaf Whittier and Jonathan Carver both wrote compelling tales of Hannah Dustan’s capture, but it is only by looking at the differences between the essays, the reader gleans a more complete picture of Dustan’s experiences and societal issues that were occurring during the time period. For instance, gender roles, and savagery versus civility, and revenge are three themes running throughout both essays; all of these themes are still echoing throughout society today.

Hannah Dustan was a married mother of fourteen children who survived a vicious Indian attack in her village. The invading Indian tribe killed her newborn, threatened her husband and family, and took Dustan and her nanny as prisoners. The two were then given over to a smaller tribe, along with a previous captive named Samuel Lennardson, and forced to move with them to north Central New Hampshire. During their captivity, there were threatened with running through a gauntlet naked. Instead of running through the gauntlet, Hannah asked her fellow captive, Samuel Lennardson, to help her steal the Indians’ tomahawks while they were sleeping. They then killed most of the Indians in the camp, scalped them, and sold the scalps for a bounty.

Jonathan Carver, who wrote Travels through the Interior Parts of North America (1778), gives a brief account of Hannah Dustan’s captivity. In it, he describes Dustan’s attack, capture, and revenge. Straightforward, the only social or political commentary can be found in the author’s juxtaposition of words in the first and last paragraphs: “weaker sex” and “Amazonian intrepidity.” Both of these phrases have different connotations and provide the reader with two pictures; one picture is that of a frail creature, the other of muscular, weapon wielding warrior. Using these phrases at the beginning and end of the piece forces the reader to look at where Hannah Dustan started and the events that unfolded to create the person she became at the end of her capture.

John Greenleaf Whittier, author of Legends of New England (1831), also has a piece in his book regarding Hannah Dustan. Written 53 years after Carver’s account, it varies greatly. The facts remain the same; Dustan was attacked, and she defeated her captors. Whittier’s version is full of different imagery, details, and more aggressive language. Although written years later, the tale grows in detail. When speaking about the character of a woman, “Her sphere of action is...

Find Another Essay On A Closer Look at Hannah Dustan’s Affair

A Closer Look at Girl´s Life

2227 words - 9 pages . Another reason being a girl is awful has to deal with insecurity. When a girl sees another girl who is dressed better, looks better, or has more money, they instantly feel insecure about themselves. Right at that moment they begin asking themselves questions like, “Why am I so ugly?”, and “I wish I could look as great as her”. Feeding the body with insults like this can make the girl want to leave where she is at that moment. For a while she will no

A Closer Look at Lupus Erythematosus

1336 words - 6 pages compared to healthy people (Somers 2014). How is Lupus diagnosed? There is no one test that can confirm a diagnosis of lupus. Doctors will use tests as the antinuclear antibody (ANA) test, examine blood count, do a liver and kidney assessment, and even look at proteins in the urine to confirm a diagnosis. Drug treatments Some of the treatments that are used to manage lupus are antimalarials, that can reduce flaring, immunosuppressive drugs to

Taking a Closer Look at Michael Jordan

1082 words - 5 pages charities. Michael Jordan changed the way people look at and play basketball in many ways, such as his super athletic ability made people want to watch him, and he made basketball way more popular. Work Cited "Michael Jordan Biography." Bio.com. A&E Networks Television, n.d. Web. 21 Feb. 2014 "NBA.com: Michael Jordan Bio." NBA.com: Michael Jordan Bio. N.p., n.d. Web. 21 Feb. 2014. Google word search michael jordan "World Biography." Michael

A Closer Look at John Dillinger

2390 words - 10 pages thanks to having a very good lawyer while John did not get off as easy. Being his only offense a lawyer told him to just plead guilty and the judge will take it easy on him, but that is not what happened at all. John Dillinger went to court without a lawyer thinking it would go smoothly but instead the court sentenced for ten to twenty years in prison for a fifty dollar theft(“Bio.com”). His wife divorced him which lead to him trying to escape with

Jeffrey Dahmer: A Closer Look at a Murderer

1741 words - 7 pages Jeffrey Dahmer: A Closer Look Jeffrey Dahmer was responsible for a series of horrific murders of seventeen young men from 1988 until he was caught on July 22, 1991, in Milwaukee. This single individual grabbed the attention of the entire nation and brought to light the idea that no one in society should be trusted. Dahmer presented himself to be a normal yet quiet man, by leading a discreet and unnoticeable life. But the horrendous details of

A Closer Look at Like a Winding Sheet

924 words - 4 pages and wife. Mae is giggly and attentive, teasing her husband for sleeping so late. Then it happens. Mae observes Johnson’s position saying, “You look like a huckleberry…in a winding sheet…” (Norton 1498). The winding sheet is simple and innocence at first but the symbolism behind it means much more. It’s not necessarily the fact that it was a sheet, but that it resembles a shroud used to dress the dead- a foreshadowing for her death. Another

A Closer Look at The Book of Acts

2389 words - 10 pages -church can draw knowledge to incorporate these heart-felt actions are historical context, literary contexts, interpretation and application. Although technically anonymous, most biblical scholars agree that the book of Acts was written by the physician, Luke. Luke was a traveling companion of the Apostle Paul in Rome for two years. The physician was perhaps a gentile, but at least a Hellenistic Jew. He was a native of Antioch. The book of

A Closer Look at King John of England

1399 words - 6 pages de Lion? At first it certainly doesn't look like it, but perhaps if one digs a little deeper they'll see that Winston Churchill's statement really is true. John's family background wasn't exactly ideal. His father Henry II is best remembered for causing the untimely demise of the Archbishop of Canterbury, an affair which ended with Henry kneeling at the grave of Archbishop Thomas Becket and having himself voluntarily whipped by the monks there

A Closer Look at the Organization of CEO

2693 words - 11 pages A Closer Look at the Organization of CEO Question C: A new CEO has been appointed to a large organisation of 35,000 employees. Sales are static, costs are increasing and staffs appear to be unhappy. She wants to know what is going on. 1. Introduction With an organisation of huge resources, they are able to afford for a more in-depth analysis. Looking into the problem, sales can be static due to various

Taking a Closer Look At Your Personal Ministry

979 words - 4 pages how the book has impacted me. As a result of reading this book I have grown closer in my relationship with Christ our Savior. The icon of individualism was born from people who have replaced God with some other tangible item. Chapter 4 Hostetler talks about this expanding culture of individualism (46-47). The Cowboy Ethic was the title of this chapter and it is a great illustration of what it looks like to do things on your own without Gods

Case Study: Closer Look at a Medication Regimen

3539 words - 14 pages Case Study: Closer Look at a Medication RegimenBackgroundHistoryNB is a 40 year old, 5 foot 7 inch, 148 lbs (67kg) African American female admitted through the emergency department (ED) with loss of consciousness, possibly related to a drug overdose. Subsequently, she was transferred to the medical/surgical floor with a medical diagnosis of renal failure and rhabdomyolysis due to immobility and cocaine. Her histories were ascertained from her

Similar Essays

A Closer Look At Pain Essay

1183 words - 5 pages PAGE [Type text] [Type text] [Type text] A Closer Look at Pain: ProstaglandinsMost health conditions involve some form of pain, whether it is a toothache or maybe it is as serious as something like cancer. Nevertheless, the sensible thing to do is to depict the cause behind this feeling of pain and find a solution to alleviate it. For centuries, natural remedies have been proven to alleviate pain such as white willow bark (Salix alba) and

A Closer Look At Character Essay

1176 words - 5 pages English 102A Closer Look at CharacterIn any literay work, it is absolutely essential to have characters, whether major or minor. It is also necessary to develop these characters through out the story. Character development gives the reader insight to the more important meanings or lessons of the story. These lessons are usually brought out by the events that take place within the story. Looking at Guy De Maupassant's piece "The Necklace", we see

A Closer Look At Mimas Essay

1522 words - 6 pages scientists have researched. Mimas shape is not quite big enough to hold a round shape. Mimas is known to be the smallest known astronomical body that is thought to be rounded in shape due to the result of its self-gravitation. Mimas orbits at a range of 115,280 miles from Saturn in a time frame of 22 hours 37 minutes. Mimas’ orbit makes it the closest major moon of all moons of Saturn. Mimas is known to be tidally locked to Saturn and has one side

A Closer Look At American Suburbia

1326 words - 5 pages Toni Troell Film Appreciation Cherie King March 20, 2002 A Closer Look at American Suburbia In American Beauty (1999), which was directed by Sam Mendes, we are confronted with the images that have consumed mainstream American life. Mendes exploits these images that we, as Americans, have created around ourselves as a means of hiding our true nature. In American Beauty, Mendes plays on the natural tendencies of the viewers to seek