This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Commentary Of The Poem "The Broken Tower" By Hart Crane

1690 words - 7 pages

A Broken Tower, by Hart Crane, is a metaphor-rich poem that is very ambiguous but seems to describe the difficulties of the creative process and the way in which the artist is bound and compelled by it. Crane uses many religious metaphors and references, directly mentioning God and also bells, which are associated with churches. It is possible to interpret the poem in a religious sense, but it could be argued that religion and art are similar metaphors; that, for the poet, his writings are both a method of spiritual expression and a search for truth. The title, ‘A Broken Tower’, refers to a continuing metaphor in the poem and suggests the deconstruction of established paradigms which is necessary for artistic progress. Throughout the poem, Crane speaks of destroying a stone tower and building a new one from within himself; and as the poem progresses, the tone shifts from negative to positive. The poem is simple stylistically and consists of ten quatrains with an abab rhyming pattern.Crane begins the poem with one of the predominant metaphors, the bell. This also has religious significance, as it is associated with the call to prayer in the morning. However, Crane’s bell does not call people to God but rather ‘gathers God’. Also strange is the fact that the tone of the first stanza, though regarding dawn and God (traditionally positive), is quite negative. The poet is ‘dropped down the knell of a spent day’ and his ‘feet chill on steps from hell’. This curious negativity shows Crane’s rejection of the traditional, symbolised by established religion. Normally, to go ‘from pit to crucifix’ would be positive as it symbolises moving towards God, but the poet’s disdain for the traditional manifests itself in the decidedly negative tone of the first stanza.He then speaks of the belltower, which is a mighty stone structure. In it is a ‘corps of shadows… whose shoulders sway’, representing the bells. The bells, described as ‘shadows’, are contrasted with the implied concreteness of the tower. Also, their ‘antiphonal’ ringing creates chaos within the poet. Traditional concepts of positive and negative are reversed, with the Sun presented as an overpowering force that captures the stars, rather than a bringer of light and hope. In the second stanza Crane describes both the visual and auditory aspect of the bells. Sound is manifested in voices, singing or the pealing of bells; and Crane asks: ‘Have you not heard, have you not seen” the bells.Interestingly, the bells then ‘break down their tower’. Although this is the first mention of the tower in the body of the poem, it is already associated with traditional religion and because of the bells. This breaking of the tower symbolises the destruction of accepted norms and paradigms, a deconstruction in fact, but the poet is not in control of this-- the bells ‘swing [he] know[s] not...

Find Another Essay On A commentary of the poem "The Broken Tower" by Hart Crane

Hart Crane´s My Grandmother’s Love Letters: The Difference Between Generations

1049 words - 5 pages stand out better while briefly summarizing what appears to be the purpose of the poem. Imagine feeling defeated, the bond between grandmother and grandchild broken by the unwillingness to listen and the heartbreak that follows. That’s what Hart Crane did so beautifully in the poem, “My Grandmother’s Love Letters” by using simplistic words to convey a much deeper and complex meaning that many can relate to.

The Tower of London Essay

992 words - 4 pages white washed by King Henry III (McGillick)(Jarus). This is the reason the tower is called white tower and the fortress is call the Tower of London. The Tower of London has been used for a wide variety of affairs. One of the more interesting things it has been used for is holding the crown jewels (Jarus). The estimated value of the crown jewels is 32 billion dollars (25). The jewels were moved to the Tower of London in 1303 when there were a

The Tower of London

1530 words - 6 pages a fortress from which to repel rebellions. The Tower also was converted to a shelter for King Richard II and his family during the Peasants' Revolt of 1381, during which the Tower was even temporarily taken. Richard and his brother were able to safely hide themselves before the tower was taken; however, the Archbishop of Canterbury, the Royal Treasurer, a tax official, and a doctor were all executed by the leader of the revolt, Wat Tyler, in the

The Tower of Babel

1469 words - 6 pages one who designed the Tower of Babel seems to defend it, by stating that it is a monument of idea and an attribute to its creators. The Tower of Babel is meant to glorify the old usage of monuments to honor individuals and social ideas. It represents a maze of glued-together architectural blocks that are unfinished, damaged, and incomplete. The already discussed commentary has revealed that the monument of Babel glorifies controversial regimes and

The Tower Of London

678 words - 3 pages The Tower of London      The Tower of London, the oldest fortified palace in Europe, was built by William the Conqueror in the late 1000's. It has served as a fortress, prison, palace, and the final resting-place of many people ("Tower of London" Encarta 1). Its history is full of amazing and horrific stories of life and death. To truly appreciate this magnificent group of structures a look must be taken

The Tower Of London

584 words - 2 pages the Tower was the cubby and selfish Rammulf Flambard the unpopular Bishop of Durham. He was not executed in the Tower because he was able to escape one nigh he "pushed his bulk through the window and slide down a rope to freedom. The next person to discuss in Henry VI was put in the tower in 1465. He was put to death with lots of secrecy.After he was put to death his family and the people of London were informed that when he heard the news of

Maggie: A Girl of the Streets by Stephen Crane. Anlyzes the use and necessity of violence by Crane in the novel

667 words - 3 pages accurately portrayed the working class part of New York City. Crane also used this scene to show that people did not suddenly become violent as adults; it was introduced to them at a young age. Whether their parents beat them, as the Johnson kids were, or got involved in street brawls themselves, it all had a profound effect on how the children of the Bowery came into adulthood. By beating Jimmie constantly, and allowing him to watch them beat each

Commentary on Anne Sexton´s Poem, A Twist on the Tale of Cinderella

711 words - 3 pages time or another, the beautiful fairy tale Cinderella has been in nearly every child’s life at one time. Anne Sexton manages to put a twist in her version of Cinderella, born in 1928-1970. Sexton was well-known as an Outstanding Contemporary poet with a vivid style of writing in her literature. The irony way of word choices was used in this poem not holding back on the sarcasm, harshness, to dramatize the events in the story. The Cinderella

Commentary on the poem Night of the Scorpion

461 words - 2 pages Commentary on the poem Night of the Scorpion Commentary The poem “Night of the Scorpion”, written by Nissin Ezekiel has an interesting contrast of good and bad hidden within it (an essence of equality). The poet has made the mother’s experience of getting bitten by a scorpion sound very painful and endless. The poet has conveyed this by using some descriptive language. E.g. “May the poison purify your flesh of desire, and your

Commentary on the Poem: The Lais of Marie de France

1020 words - 5 pages The Breton lai, Milun is the ninth among twelve lais in the collected works known famously as the Lais of Marie de France. It is a narrative about a courtly love and family bond that become divided by an overpowering marital system. Written in England, the lai of the legendary medieval poet, Marie de France, can be traced back to the 12th century. Virtually nothing is known of the writer. Any information identified, including her name and

Loneliness, a theme in The Open Boat by Stephen Crane

774 words - 4 pages captain was not truly asleep, he did not stir at the time and give assistance. Even when he faced the danger alone, the correspondent acted bravely: “The presence of this biding thing did not affect the man with the same horror that it would if he had been a picnicker. He simply looked at the sea dully and swore in an undertone./ Nevertheless, it was true that he did not wish to be alone. He wished one of his companions to awaken by chance and keep

Similar Essays

The Broken Heart A Poem By John Donne

902 words - 4 pages giving Love a face. The poem is extremely negative and often describes Love as something that could kill. This also produces sympathy from the reader. This is seen through the line, “By him, as by chain’d shot, whole ranks do die.” Using personification as an expression shows how much the Donne is upset to have allowed Love to get the best of him. His experience with love and the process of being broken hearted has led him to envision Love as a

Maggie: A Girl Of The Streets By Setephen Crane

1577 words - 6 pages face of such brutality, what are such delicate creatures as Maggie and Tommie supposed to do? They cannot survive, and as is true in the animal kingdom, those weakened by any form of compassion or love are crushed between the jaws of dispassionate carnivores. Having established a cycle of violence and shown that his characters are merely responding to stimulus, Crane solidifies his social commentary by personifying the environment until it

"A Girl Of The Streets" By Stephen Crane

2497 words - 10 pages Maggie: A Girl of the Streets by Stephen Crane shows that the environment that a person is raised in will have an effect on that person's life in the future. The story is a tragedy of a family, the Johnson's, who are living a life of poverty and abuse in the slums of New York City in the late 19th century. The main character, Maggie Johnson, has a dream to escape her life of poverty and brutality. Maggie is described to have "blossomed in a mud

"Maggie: A Girl Of The Streets" By Stephen Crane

1301 words - 5 pages "Maggie: A Girl of the Streets", written by Stephen Crane, is a novel about a young girl who is trying to find her way through life. She comes from a family with an alcoholic mother and father, and a brother who is very brutish. However, Maggie grows up as a beautiful young girl who has romantic hopes of a better future. She constantly dreams of wealth and culture and is determined to lead a better social life as she grows older. Despite her ill