This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Comparative Analysis Of Gramsci’s Theory Of Cultural Hegemony And Balkin’s Theory Of Cultural Software

880 words - 4 pages

Gramsci’s theory of cultural hegemony and Balkin’s theory of cultural software both examine the evolution of ideologies and their impact within a society through different perspectives. Gramsci’s approach focuses on the concept of hegemony, whereby gaining the consent of the people forms the means of gaining political and economical control. This approach is the point of contention in Balkin’s analysis, where Balkin criticises the concept of hegemony as being to monolithic and homogenous,. Instead, he puts forth his approach of studying ideology via the presence of injustice as a better alternative. This paper thus serves to look into the validities of Balkin’s claims with regards to Gramsci’s theory of cultural hegemony.
Balkin’s first criticism against hegemony is that it is too monolithic a model, as it deals with only a dominant ideology in a society. Balkin argues that in reality, ideology is a confluence of many different types of cognitive mechanisms - a group of heterogenous and partly reinforcing ideological effects (Balkin,1998). He uses the term “conceptual bricolage” to bring forth the point of the dynamism of ideology as a whole. Balkin felt that Gramsci has a dualistic approach of just dominant and the subaltern, which does not account for real life scenarios.
However, this may not be an accurate reflection of Gramsci’s approach of gaining dominance through gaining the consent of the people. As highlighted in Gramsci’s Pre-Prison Writing, in order to achieve leadership “they [the subalterns] must think as workers who are members of a class that aims to lead the peasants and the intellectuals: a class that can only win and only build socialism if it is aided and followed by the great majority of these social strata.” (Gramsci, 1994). This hegemonic relationship between the dominant class and the subaltern posits the influence of the subaltern masses on the ideology of the dominant class. The ruling class needs to be able to make a large part of the subalterns’ ideologies as its own. This brings to light the dynamic relationship between the ruling class and the subaltern as, in order to maintain its power, a ruling group needs to be able to bring together different ideologies from various groups and effectively incorporate them into a single dominant ideology, that the vast majority will agree with. The confluence of the many different types of cognitive mechanisms can be seen when Gramsci talks about how the “expansiveness” of hegemony to the demands of the subalterns will affect the effectiveness of the leading group to lead. Thus Gramsci indirectly puts forth a pluralistic model whereby the dominant ideology is the result of the bricolage of various subaltern’s ideology.

Find Another Essay On A Comparative Analysis of Gramsci’s Theory of Cultural Hegemony and Balkin’s Theory of Cultural Software

Little Red Riding Hood: A Comparative Analysis of Two Cross-Cultural Retellings

807 words - 3 pages Cap and her grandmother is a rather fragile one. Little Red Cap is an innocent character. She sees no danger in giving detailed information about the location of her grandmother’s house, her destination, to a complete stranger: “Her house is right under three large oaks. You must know the place from the hazel hedges near it” (Grimm 620). She is also a naïve character, following the advice of the wolf to gaze upon the flowers

Co-Cultural Theory Assignment

901 words - 4 pages influence one to converge and diverge in order to feel welcomed by the dominant group. Throughout, Co-Cultural Communication Theory there are dynamics that impact interracial communication. Field of experience plays a significant role in how you communicate with other groups. The cost and rewards are typically for minority groups, having networking abilities and the same communication abilities, as the dominant group is a salient factor in the

Cultural Industries – Theory Assignment

648 words - 3 pages Cultural Industries – Theory Assignment The dominant traditions have an important role to many economies in terms of assessing change and continuity that involves the growth of prosperity and employment in the cultural industries. The process to determine the best solution may be complicated and tiresome as controversy surrounds these traditions. Profit generating and control may be the main reasons of these approaches, but they also carry

Vygotsky and His Socio-cultural Theory

1100 words - 5 pages Throughout the history of early childhood education educators have used various theorists’ theories to develop children’s learning and development. One of the most significant theories is the socio-cultural theory by Vygotsky. His theory consists of how private speech is used by children and the importance of the zone of proximal development. Vygotsky’s theory is well used in the education environment today and educators use it to be able to

Cultural Hegemony in The United States

2190 words - 9 pages reap the rewards. These privileged few get what they desire not through force, but through Antonio Gramsci’s idea of hegemony. Hegemony is the “process in which a dominant group gains – for its own interests – the approval of a subordinate class through the use of intellectual, moral, and cultural encouragement” (Mascia-Lees 151). This method does not ensure power to a certain group. Instead, it allows for power shifts between groups. If the

Cultural Morality: Comparative Analysis between a Fine Balance and the Poisionwood Bible

1500 words - 6 pages Cultural Morality Comparative Analysis between A Fine Balance and the Poisionwood Bible Cultural relativism really emphasizes the concept that each individual cultural belief differs from one societal class to another; in consequence, moral and ethical principles are related to what a certain culture perceives to be considered acceptable or unacceptable, right or wrong. Jack Donnelly, a teacher at the University of Denver, he states, "when


1428 words - 6 pages ways of writing short stories. Their own life experiences often influence the way they use psychoanalytic theory. Both Poe and Gilman lived various times. However, it was their personal life that influenced the writing. Gilman married a man who began to develop controlling ways. Therefore she soon fell into deep depression. A doctor advised her to stop writing and start living a normal lifestyle. However, “such a claustrophobic existence

IB Psychology Option PSD Theory: Historical and Cultural Influences on Psychodynamic Perspective

1353 words - 5 pages Freud created his theory in the Victorian era, which was greatly influenced by Western culture. Freud's theory was primarily introspective but he used clinical data to support his theory making it mostly inductive. The assumptions he used as a foundation for his theory were influenced by various intellectuals of his time and past historical figures both philosophical and literary. He used Greek mythological characters and words to name different

Relfection on "The Theory behind the Dictionary: Cultural Literacy and Education" by Hirsch

687 words - 3 pages In the reading, "The Theory behind the Dictionary: Cultural Literacy and Education," they had some great reasoning for their ideas. I liked the author’s whole explanation of someone may know how to read, but until they fully understand the whole background of what they are reading, they are not getting anything from the reading. The reader and the author are not "communicating." They also explain why reading ability measured in how well a person

Comparative Theory Essay: Ethnohistory and The Postcolonial Perspective

1421 words - 6 pages timelines of mankind, one can start cumulating the facts around how humans have evolved throughout hundreds and thousands of years. Using anthropology as a theory of history is the ability to understand the social and cultural behaviors that connect the concept of human culture. As historians there are many benefits from using anthropology, studying the behaviors of human kind and all of its variations is a true example of evolution through time

You are on a long road trip when a woman spies you reading Streetwise by Elijah Anderson. How do you respond (using crime and cultural theory to back your opinions) when she makes this statement:

1065 words - 4 pages could enable students to escape the influences of "street" values and experience middle-class norms. They would be around people whom they could gain cultural capital from and have opportunities to build healthier networks, groups, and support systems through extracurricular activities such as sports. However, the success of such a program might be contingent on how far along the student was in his education. The key is to start as early as

Similar Essays

Gramsci's Theory Of Hegemony Essay

2938 words - 12 pages and Gramsci’s ideas differ slightly, but they both agree that civil society “is the sphere in which intellectuals operate, whether in cooperation with the state or in opposition to it.” What is different between the two is that, according to Bates, “Croce’s aim was to create an alternative to Marxism, Gramsci’s was to offer Italians a Marxist alternative to Croce.” Croce sees hegemony as a means of cultural leadership, whereas Marx and

Cultural Theory In The Works Of Tarantino

1163 words - 5 pages 1. Substructural capitalist theory and postdialectic Marxism The main theme of Werther's[1] essay on cultural theory is a subpatriarchial reality. But if capitalist destructuralism holds, we have to choose between semanticist pretextual theory and the preconstructivist paradigm of reality. "Sexual identity is fundamentally elitist," says Sartre. Cultural theory states that the collective is impossible. It could be said that

Cultural Values And Communication Norms: A Comparative Analysis Of Two Cultures

2192 words - 9 pages Communication is one of the most important aspects of our lives. It is a process that ties us together and helps us to get most of our work done. Communication plays a big role in transmitting cultural values from one generation to the next. Communication can be categorized as two; verbal and non verbal. In a multiracial country such as Malaysia good communication can be considered as a savior to keep everyone united. Being a multiracial

The Theory Of Comparative Advantage Essay

749 words - 3 pages Buy American. In recent years, and especially since the recession, this has been the mantra of ‘patriots’ across the nation. The recent jobs bill that went through Congress may even have subsidies to encourage it. But what effect would buying products made in the United States really have? Would it create jobs for Americans? Would it save the flailing auto industry? Or would it ultimately hurt our economy? According to the Theory of Comparative