A Comparative Analysis Of Shamanistic Healers In Celtic And Native American Cultures

1150 words - 5 pages

Many different forms of medicine are currently practiced in the world. In fact, as our text states, “in all cultures, some people have become recognized as having special abilities to treat and diagnose health problems.” (Miller 107) Without argument, phytomedicinal and supernatural healers are two forms of medical treatment that have been around for longer than any other, regardless of culture. It has been estimated that shamanism has been practiced for over ten thousand years (Tyson 3). Native American and Celtic healers are often known as shamans.
Shamanism has always been an interest of mine, mainly in the Native American and Celtic Irish forms of medicine. Native Americans as well as Celtics have always held a certain mystique that is worthy of great exploration. From animal spirit guides that aide in healing to the shamans that are often the “go-to” men of the Native American and Celtic communities, the shamanistic tradition of medicine is one that has been admired and practiced by many that do not share the same ethnicity as theses traditional healers. Although the use of animal spirit guides is often ridiculed, as are the sacred spiritual journeys and conversations that these magnificent healers take, there are many unexplainable events that lend credence to the practices and abilities of the Shamans of the Native American culture.
The Irish Celtic culture also utilizes shamans, as well as many phytomedicinal methods for healing their sick. Although information on the shamans of the Irish Celtic culture is harder to find, shamans are just as prevalent in medicine of the Irish Celtic culture as they are in the Native American culture.
Regardless of the specific culture, cross-cultural evidence indicates some common criteria of becoming a healer (Miller 107) as well as common criteria of the roles that shamans take in the healing process. For the purpose of this paper, we will examine the similarities and differences between Irish Celtic and Native American shamans and their position in their respective cultures.
For the Native American shaman the world of animals, the world of plants, the world of minerals, and the world of humans are all intertwined (Wolfe 3). Shamans in the Native American culture are viewed as a revered member of society, are often male, and are the sole healers of their people. While anyone can become a shaman in the Native American culture, the attainment of the status is an arduous process, and is considered a feat of great courage. The introduction of self to the spiritual world in such an intimate way has been considered dangerous because of the risk of insanity, as well as the risk of possession by angry spirits (Wolfe 237). From ancient times to modern times, shamans have been considered to be the link between the physical world and the spiritual world. (Wolfe 3). The Native American shamans utilize many sacred objects in their workings, which are considered sacred solely because they come from nature....

Find Another Essay On A Comparative Analysis of Shamanistic healers in Celtic and Native American Cultures

Gender and Dreaming in Mapuche Shamanistic Practices

1616 words - 6 pages nature of the illness a victim is suffering. Some illnesses are physical. However, some are the result of witchcraft or are caused by the loss of the soul, possession by evil spirits or divine retribution by the spirits. Refusing to follow the instruction provided to them by the spirits can result in punishment and cause healers to become ill themselves. For example, Mapuche individuals who are called and instructed to become machi often attempt

American history paper: Vietnamese War and the American Revolution, a comparative analysis

2103 words - 8 pages powers in the 19th century. Major victories at Trenton and Princeton, N.J., in late 1776 and early 1777 restored patriot hopes, and victory at Saratoga, N.Y., which halted a British advance from Canada, all contributed to Britain's eventual defeat. In 1781, the last major battle fought between American and French forces defeat the British at the Battle of Yorktown. The revolutionary war finally ends in 1782 with the signing of the Treaty of Paris

Stereotypes and Stereotyping of Native American in The Pioneers

2138 words - 9 pages , Cooper's depiction of the infamous Chinkachgook is widely considered to be the original archetypical basis for Native American figures as seen in American literature.  However, Cooper's characterization of Chinkachgook, known by a variety of names, including John Mohegan and Indian John, is based solely on the white perspective, and as a result, is a highly unrealistic and historically inaccurate stereotype.  Moreover, Cooper clearly romanticizes

James Baldwin's Narration and Analysis in Notes of a Native Son

1353 words - 5 pages point of view on life; beginning with the day his father died, to the time that his father was buried. James Baldwin is an outstanding author, who creatively displays his ability to weave narration and analysis throughout his essays. The binaries between life and death play a huge role in Baldwin’s “Notes of a Native Son.” The day that James Baldwin’s father died, his mother had borne her last child. Although the day his father died


1100 words - 5 pages COMPARISON OF JAPANESE AND AMERICAN CULTURES As Mahatma Gandhi said, “No culture can live, if it attempts to be exclusive” (Mahatma). Our culture identifies who we are and how we behave in social environments and provides us with a foundation in which to live our lives and raise our families. Each individual culture has certain customs and courtesies that are important. Exposure to the cultures of others can be intimidating and can leave a

Comparison of the American and Chinese Cultures

1890 words - 8 pages language of both these countries are not only different in meaning and sound, but also reflect the way in which the people in these societies live, believe, and function. Religion usually plays a big part in the cultures of the world and is the basis for their beliefs and values. In many countries religion is very important, so important that some cultures use it in every aspect of their lives. China like some other countries is a multi

A Comparative Analysis of Political Communication in Turkey

1757 words - 7 pages A Comparative Analysis of Political Communication in Turkey Case In Turkey case of this paper, I will try to analyse Turkish media system with the theoretical framework which is developed by Daniel C. Hallin and Paolo Mancini in the article of Comparing Media Systems, Three Models of Media and Politics. I will make an attempt in order to investigate the basic characteristics of the media systems in Turkey, moreover I will bring the relationship

Chinese and American Cultures

4381 words - 18 pages Chinese and American Cultures Chinese-Americans authors Amy Tan and Gish Jen have both grappled with the idea of mixed identity in America. For them, a generational problem develops over time, and cultural displacement occurs as family lines expand. While this is not the problem in and of itself, indeed, it is natural for current culture to gain foothold over distant culture, it serves as the backdrop for the disorientation that occurs

The Rise of a Native American Balladry

1601 words - 6 pages The Rise of a Native American Balladry First, it will be necessary to review some important points. In the early days (1600-1770s), importation/adaptation was the dominant process. British songs and ballads were adapted to the frontier experience, Victorian morality and Puritan ethics. Songs which contained subject matter which was completely irrelevant to the

The Success Plan of a Native American

1805 words - 7 pages completing school, being financially stable, and being able to give my kids a better future. In order for me to achieve the success I desire I will have to take into consideration the negative and positive influences on my life. Also, my success will depend on my ability to accurately set goals as well as change habits, and environment (neighborhood) that may interfere with my success. In order to achieve my future desire of success I must be

African and Native American Influence in America

2013 words - 8 pages of smallpox in terms of number of deaths, realignment of tribal alliances, and subsequent changes in Canadian and American Indian Cultures. The Europeans were surprised at the mode of life of the Native Americans even as they saw that lifestyle to be opposing to their own. For one thing, as shown in writings by the Europeans, they were consistent in their amazement at the personal liberty of the Indians and especially their freedom from rules

Similar Essays

Cultural Values And Communication Norms: A Comparative Analysis Of Two Cultures

2192 words - 9 pages make up over 85% of the people of Indian origin in the country. Among the reasons I chose to write on Indian culture is it being my roots and also to go deeper to learn more about my own culture. Indian culture actually has a big influence to the Malay culture, which is why I chose to make a comparison for these two cultures. Early Malay literature is almost completely derived from Hindu epics; Ramayana and the Mahabharata. Even today, a major

Native American Cultures, Tribes, And Religion

813 words - 3 pages Even though there are numerous Native American tribes and cultures, they all are mostly derivatives of other tribes. For instance, in the southwest there are large number of Pueblo and Apache people including, the Acoma Pueblo tribe, Apache Chiricahua, Jemez Pueblo, and Apache Western. In this section, largely populated groups in certain regions (northwest, southwest, The Great Plains, northeast, and southeast) religious ideas, practices, and

The Analysis Of The Struggles Of An African American Man And A Native American Man

1624 words - 6 pages It has long been said that people turn to religion during their most desperate and loneliest moments. This theory was very evident in the lives of two very different real-world people: Black Elk and Malcolm X. Black Elk, a Lakota Sioux Indian, and Malcolm X, an African-American, had many similar experiences despite their differences in geographical location, methods, and religion. Malcolm X and Black Elk turned to Islam and the Sioux’s

A Comparison Of Celtic And Gallic Culture .

1158 words - 5 pages described in the two sources. So vast is the difference, that perhaps it should be concluded that the Celts of the myth and the Gauls of Caesar should be considered as two different cultural entities. Either one should conclude that the Gallic and Celtic cultures are separate, or that one is a precursor of the other.Let us begin with the most basic aspect and consider the times and places from which these sources originate. Caesar's text comes from