This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Comparative Study Of Market Efficiency In Emerging Markets: Performance Of Passively And Actively Managed Funds

1942 words - 8 pages

Literature review:
Stiglitz-Grossman Model:
The exceptional model put forward by Stiglitz and Grossman (1980) provides the basis of this paper. Stiglitz and Grossman in this outstanding paper suggest that equity markets are shaped in an “equilibrium degree of disequilibrium”. In their opinion, it is impossible for a competitive economy to always be in equilibrium. Hence the assumption of perfect markets even for market information is completely ruled out as the market comprises of informed and uniformed investors. This unequal dissemination of information accounts for the practicality of their model in explaining how information asymmetry and market efficiency is correlated with superior ...view middle of the document...

The components of the model represent the following:
U_At – Average utility from active management for a certain period.
R_Pt – Average return from passive management for a certain period.
R_At – Average return from active management for a certain period.
δ – Level of market efficiency. If δ > 1, markets are not perfectly efficient, if δ = 1, markets are perfectly efficient.
R_At-R_Pt = the difference between the average return of an actively managed fund over the average return of a passively fund.
c_At – Cost (e.g. fees, margin etc.) of active management for a certain period.

Likewise, the model below expresses the utility gained by an investor from investing in a passively managed fund:
U_Pt (R_Pt,c_Pt )=R_Pt-c_Pt (2)

Note: for the utility function of passively managed fund investors δ is absent.

Following the Stiglitz-Grossman model:

U_At (R_Pt,R_At,c_At=U_Pt (R_Pt,c_Pt) (3)

This then signifies that markets are truly inefficient:δ>1 and R_At-R_Pt>0
Therefore: C_At>C_Pt

Mutual fund performance:
Again, the debate on the performance of active management over passive counterparts has been reviewed by scholars. Malkiel (2003) argued that the cost of transaction and obtaining advantageous information are too high with regards to searching for concealed information that can yield surplus returns beyond the market benchmark given near market efficiency in global equity markets. Malkiel (2003) also suggest that there is strong evidence to show passive investment in all markets. Still on the cost active investing, French (2008) stresses that since the cost of active management is high; there is the arising need to look towards passive investment strategies. Sorenson et al (1997) shows that in 1997, a small percentage of mutual funds (about 11%) actually outperformed the S&P 500; agreeing with the conclusion to shift focus to passively managed investment strategies. However, these analyses are focused only on developed markets and do not precisely distinguish between emerging markets and developed markets.

Tax efficiency of Passive management:
Tax advantage is an important consideration to make when comparing actively managed mutual funds and passive fund returns. Poterba et al (2002) views on actively managed funds suggest that actively managed funds shifts the burden of capital gains from trading to their shareholders. Their study also shows that investment in US equities of mutual funds and passively managed funds (Exchange traded funds) generated similar returns when adjusted for tax notwithstanding the lower fees of the passively managed fund. Gardner et al (2005) also confirms this with emphasis on the tax advantage of passively managed funds over actively managed funds. The massive volume of mutual funds trading exacts more tax burden on their shareholders than passive fund shareholders.

Fund returns analysis:
Other studies have contributed to the debate between...

Find Another Essay On A comparative study of market efficiency in emerging markets: performance of passively and actively managed funds

Deliverance: A Study of Medicaid and Managed Care

4632 words - 19 pages Deliverance: A Study of Medicaid and Managed Care Since the inception of Medicaid in 1965, the program has seen extraordinary growth in expenditures and enrollment. From 1989 to 1992, the increases in Medicaid spending were the largest since the program began in. Enrollment in Medicaid by AFDC families grew from 3.8 million in 1990 to 4.4 million in 1992, almost a nine percent annual increase (Coughlin et al. 1994). During this period

COMPARING THE PERSISTENCY OF DIFFERENT FREQUENCIES OF STOCK RETURNS VOLATILITY IN AN EMERGING MARKET: A CASE STUDY OF PAKISTAN

2718 words - 11 pages study has the following objective: “to compare the variance structure of high (daily) and low (weekly, monthly) frequencies of data”. This study extends the work on volatility of the emerging financial markets. ARCH/GARCH models are employed in this study to compare the volatility behavior of the different frequencies of data (daily, weekly and monthly). The heteroscedasticity is major characteristics of developing market so need for the

A Comparative Study of Japanese and English

2661 words - 11 pages This study will explore selected phonological, typological, orthographical, morphological and syntactical features of the ‘isolate’ language, Japanese, and analyse how far these features differ from English, itself an Indo-European language, with specific emphasis placed on how accessible Japanese speakers would find learning English as a second language, and vice-versa. The Japanese language is spoken by almost the whole of the East Asian

A Comparative Study of Oedipus and Chinatown

825 words - 4 pages There are many common ties between the ancient story, Oedipus the King, and the 1974 film, Chinatown. Many of the similarities between these stories are easily understood, while some require deeper study. Oedipus, who is the lead character in Oedipus the King, and Jake Gittes, who is the main character in Chinatown, are both men who are living in corrupt cities, and are determined to seek out the truth, at any cost. As John Fawell states

A Figure in the Emerging Study of Psychology: Wolfgang Bringmann

1168 words - 5 pages closer to him than a mother or a father( Rieber and Robinson 8). Wundt grew up with a lack of friendship, and for the most part the village boys rejected him. Wundt enjoyed daily visits from the three friends he had growing up that would tell him fascinating adventures that would exercise Wundt young childhood like mind. These stories led to his day dreaming and poor performance in his studies. Wundts day dreaming eventually affected his

A comparative study of Sydney -A comparative study of Sydney Carton in Dickens' novel, A Tale of Two Cities, and Romeo Montague and Juliet Capulet in Shakespeare's play

1257 words - 5 pages A comparative study of Sydney Carton in Dickens' novel, A Tale of Two Cities, and Romeo Montague and Juliet Capulet in Shakespeare's play, Romeo and Juliet, requires the reader to analyze various aspects that the transforming effect love can have on a personality. As we study each character, it is relatively easy to see that no matter how painful love can be, it is usually to one's betterment to have experienced it. Love affects each person

Financial Markets Notes: The Flow of Funds and Determination of Interest Rates

2715 words - 11 pages TOPIC 3: The Flow of Funds and Determination of Interest RatesObjective 1Identify the main features of the role played by the different sectors of the economy in the flow of funds between surplus and deficit units.3.1 The flow of fundsIn Topic 1, one of the main functions of a nation's financial system that was identified was to facilitate the transfer of funds from surplus to deficit economic units, in primary financial markets, by the creation

Emerging Markets in Asia

1392 words - 6 pages Emerging Markets in AsiaUniversity of PhoenixJanuary 8, 2004Emerging Markets in AsiaOver the past decade the world has witnessed rapid long-term economic growth for East Asian countries. These newly developing countries are experiencing growth rates in GDP between 6% and 7%, compared to the 2% to 3% for most industrial economies. If this growth continues, South Korea and Taiwan could take away America's distinction as the world's richest country

A Reflective and Comparative Study of the Oppression and Persecutions Toward Roma in History

1069 words - 5 pages , Europe’s right-winged media groups willingly broadcast the Roma in a negative light, thus perpetuating the stereotype. With the law systems in many of these countries providing insufficient rights to the Roma people, Roma often find themselves vulnerable to unmerited persecutions, and in some cases are chastised outside of the confines of the law. The discrimination against Roma that exists today diverges little from that which has existed across

A Comparative Study of Regional Planning in Britain and the Netherlands

1726 words - 7 pages The first selected article is “A Comparative Study of Regional Planning in Britain and the Netherlands” which is written by Ashok K. Dutt in 1970. While there is not any guiding question asked in the paper, author highlights the importance of the developments in Regional Planning after World War II. He believes that the organic integrations of cities are over, and an era of a more integrated and comprehensive planning has started. Within the

A Comparative Study of Nelson Mandela and Adolf Hitler

1790 words - 7 pages A Comparative Study of Nelson Mandela and Adolf Hitler Adolf Hitler and Nelson Mandela are vastly different men, however in many ways through out their lives they both held a huge influence over their countrymen, the politics of their country and inevitably they both shaped the course of history for better or worse. Their fight, was not won without a struggle, but was helped by their masterful oratorical skills and the

Similar Essays

Impact Of Vertical Mobility On Employee Efficiency: A Comparative Study Of Public And Private Health Sectors

2647 words - 11 pages ruled out four factors effecting efficiency namely seniority, age, state of the labor market when hired and age-at-the-time-of-hiring. Now the question arises how to determine the efficiency of employees and the key factors to measure it. Mater (1941) in his research implied the method of efficiency determination consisting of four steps: (I) the definition of what each task involved, (2) the determination of a standard of quality of performance

Financial Performance Of Islamic Banking And Conventional Banking In United Kingdom A Comparative Study

1423 words - 6 pages Chapter 1: Introduction 1.1-Introduction to Chapter: This chapter describes the brief introduction about research title, research aims, research objectives, research hypothesis, research context and research limitation used in this research. 1.2-Research Title: Financial performance of Islamic banking and conventional banking in United Kingdom- A Comparative Study. 1.3-Research Aim: The Aim of this research is to analysed and evaluate

Performance Of Mutual Funds Essay

1791 words - 8 pages emerging economies like Brazil, Russia are going to continue their current performance in near future. [9]B.P.S. Murthi, Yoon K. Choi, Preyas Desai, “Efficiency of mutual funds and portfolio performance measurement: A non-parametric approach”, European Journal of Operational Research 98 (1997) 408-418 [10]Ioannis E.Tsolas, “Precious metal mutual fund performance appraisal using DEA modelling”, Elsevier 39(2014)54–60 [11]Bijan Roy and Saikat Sovan Deb, “The Conditional Performance of Indian Mutual Funds- An Empirical Study”, 2003, no.593723 and PP. 1-24

Productive Efficiency And In Efficiency Of A Production Possibility Frontier

1408 words - 6 pages Productive Efficiency and In Efficiency of a Production Possibility Frontier (PPF) Introduction The production possibility frontier is also known as the (PPF) in the economics world. It is simply a graph or diagram that does clearly show the production rate of two goods and/or services that an economy does produce efficiently or inefficiently over a given period of time. It accurately shows the production levels of the maximum to the minimum