A Comparision Of The Work Of Paul Willis With Respect To Bowles And Gintis

1879 words - 8 pages

A Comparision of the Work of Paul Willis with Respect to Bowles and Gintis

During the 1800s it was a starting point for a sociological
perspective based on the ideas of Karl Marx (1813-83). They were ideas
of conflict and inequality in education, families and household.

In 1976 followers of the Marxist approach Bowles and Gintis conducted
a survey of the education system, which provided them with similar
information to that of Karl Marx. Then in 1977 Paul Willis provided a
critical analysis of that of Bowles and Gintis and conducted his own
survey as a Neo-Marxist of the education system (Learning to Labour).
Although both views were based on the sociological perspective of Karl
Marx there was a considerable difference.

Paul Willis research was carried out between 1972 and 1975 it took
three years. He travelled round following 12 working class boys deemed
“the ladz”. They represented everything that school didn’t they were
completely the opposite. They didn’t want individual promotion, no
qualifications, and no job that required training or job satisfaction.
The students who did everything that was expected of them were
labelled “ the earoles”.

Compared to Bowles and Gintis, Willies investigation was carried out
very differently. His study was a small-scale view; it was micro and
therefore was an interpretivist’s view of society rather than that of
Bowles and Gintis, which was a structuralist’s view of society. It was
macro. For example when studying the education system Bowles and
Gintis would look at education as a whole and study things like social
class and origin of background from this they would draw up a
conclusion to why students behave as they do and why they end up in
certain jobs.

Whereas Willies actually went to the main source of the study where
everything was going on, the foundations. He went into the classroom
and conducted his research there. Willis research is an example of an
eclectic approach to sociology, composed of elements drawn from a
variety of sources. He uses an ethnographic and interactinalist
approach, the study of individual human societies (the ladz) and a
perspective focusing on particularly on how individuals respond.
This is a major difference between the two investigations.

Bowles and Gintis believe that the hidden curriculum teaches ideology
of the social system. It disguises the unfairness of the system and
tries to make you accept it. It tries to legitimate inequality and
make it seem normal. It makes them experience what Marxists describe
as false class-consciousness and that they are not aware of their true
identity. They say that the pupils don’t really question the hidden
curriculum they just fail in life. The reason why they end up in
factories is because they have rejected the messages of the education


Find Another Essay On A Comparision of the Work of Paul Willis with Respect to Bowles and Gintis

A Comparision of Andromache and Hernani

1052 words - 5 pages follow what duty dictates in life, just like Andromache did, who, at the end of the play, is the only victor. On the other hand, Hernani is not based on classical mythology and would not have been known to the audience when it was first presented. Unlike Andromache, it takes place in the recent past in the sixteenth century, presenting a fictitious depiction of the Spanish court with the only real character as Don Carlos. As part of the Romantic

A short comparision of nature and humans and the man in Jack Londons "to build a Fire"

821 words - 3 pages not believe what an old man had warned him about going out alone after fifty-below " a man should travel with a partner" he remember the man saying. But he was hard headed and thought that he could still make it. After he made the fire he realized he had forgotten to make it out in the open where snow would have not fallen off of trees onto it. But do to his miscalculations, which is just human to do, the fire failed to stay lit and went out due

A Comparision of Tennyson's and Eliot's Dealing With Self Crisis in Poetry

1461 words - 6 pages Both Alfred Lord Tennyson’s “Ulysses” and T. S. Eliot’s “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” involve the narrator’s dealing with a self crisis, characterized by a state of despair at their current situation. Ulysses is not content with his return to kingship after the adventures of The Odyssey and Prufrock is self-deprecating, hating himself for his indecision and his perceived lack of worth. Yet while Ulysses resolves to take action to regain

Isrealite Settlement in Canaan- with respect to Callaway/Miller theories and the books of Joshua and Judges in the Bible

2180 words - 9 pages phrase "to this day." Throughout the biblical expositions an event is concluded with the telling of the outcome and the idea that the outcome has remained that way over a period of time, e.i. "to this day." Thus we as historians must remember that biblical accounts cannot be taken as literal truth and that sometimes discrepancies can be found.Although there are inconsistencies between the two books, extremely important basic similarities give

The Connection between the Monotheistic Traditions of Christianity, Judaism and Islam with Respect to Divine Revelations within the Traditions

3390 words - 14 pages In looking at the world, one would not be surprised to find a great variety of people with varying beliefs and cultural traditions according to the culture’s history and geographic location. But what might strike one as odd is a great similarity across most of those people as well: a belief in God. And not just any God, but a single God who has divine knowledge and power over humanity. Yet with these commonalities, the three traditions of

The Activity of Sodium-Potassium Active Transport with respect to the Concentration of Cytoplasmic Sodium

867 words - 3 pages Due to the nature of amphotericity and the conformation of plasma membrane, large or ionic molecules can not permeate through plasma membrane freely. To help with those transportations, protein involved transports are adopted. One of which is active transport, that uses energy to move substrates against electrochemical gradient. Among many active transport cases, sodium potassium transportation has been most widely studied for it is expressed in

Cooling of the Human Body with Respect to Vaporization of Sweat

364 words - 2 pages at normal skin temperature the heat of vaporization is higher, 2427 J/g, because the cohesion of water molecules is greater at that lower temperature, so it takes more energy to break off into the gaseous state (Kotz, Treichel, and Weaver 247). The bodily response of perspiration takes advantage of this intrinsic property of water. In other words, because water requires a lot of heat to convert from liquid to gas, a lot of heat can be exported out

Corporal punishment with respect to the private and public sphere

1520 words - 7 pages are met. The public sphere’s position is much different in the sense that the government along with all schools have no authority to physically discipline school children anymore. Authority to exercise corporal punishment often leads to abuse of power, child abuse and feelings of superiority. All of the above mentioned factors will contribute to the future for a common-law defence of reasonable disciplinary chastisement in South African law

The Concept of Efficiency with Respect to Process in Business Management

1067 words - 4 pages ) produce their goods. This essay will introduce and discuss the assembly line and industrial robots in developing countries. It will first discuss and describe assembly line and industrial robots with the present time, then suggest some possible solutions. Change process of production and assembling is a way to save the cost and time of product. It working like that goods of discrete parts moving from one workstation to next workstation at a

Comparision of Judaism and Zoroastrianism

944 words - 4 pages Comparision of Judaism and Zoroastrianism Religion has been a major focal point in any society and in any culture. Starting from the first civilizations in Sumer and Ur to the vast metropolitans of today like New York and London, religion has been around and played a key part in lives of people. Possibly two of the oldest religions in the world, Judaism and Zoroastrinism share distinct qualities that are still alive today. Both

Paul Ehrlich and His Advancements to the World of Medicine

1170 words - 5 pages experiment with dyes in Leipzig, where his university studies continued. In 1877, Paul Ehrlich published a paper on dyes. A year later, he graduated as a doctor of medicine. Ehrlich's major contributions to science began as soon as he became a doctor. Now a doctor Paul Ehrlich became assistant and eventually the senior house physician at the Charite Hospital in Berlin. While working at the hospital, Ehrlich grew to be known as an expert

Similar Essays

Analyze The Style Of Paine’s Work With Respect To How Rhetoric Contributes To The Author’s Purpose Ap English Lang Essay

765 words - 4 pages to want separation from Britain. He created many famous pieces of work particularly, his pamphlet, Common Sense, which sold over half a million copies and was read out loud in public to evoke the craving for revolution in Americans. Another famous work of Paine is his collection of articles altogether called The Crisis. Through the use of loose sentences, rhetorical questions, and personification Paine succeeds to create a passionate tone that

A Distant Episode By Paul Bowles

826 words - 4 pages The single effect is the main idea that the writer wants to convey to his readers. The writer musters all his powers and tools to achieve this successfully such as in a Distant Episode. A Distant Episode, in fact, is regarded as a landmark in the history of the English short story genre. It is so important in a field called Orientalism, which shows the orient in the eyes of the West. This short story, in other words, shows the difference between

A Comparision Of Somalia And The United States Of America

1349 words - 5 pages associated with Islam. The Sunni Muslim’s pray five times a day, do not eat pork products, and do not drink alcohol. It is also common for men to have up to four wives at one time. However, Somalis are not as traditionally religious as Muslims in many other cultures (Countries and their Cultures). Unlike Somalia, the majority of the United States citizens follow Christianity. Several other religions practiced in the United States, include

Comparision Of The Tragic Characters In Othello And King Lear In Accordance With Aspects Of A Tragic Character

1842 words - 7 pages The Greek philosopher Aristotle set forth the guidelines for a tragedy in his work Poetics. According to Aristotle, the tragic character in a tragedy is a person, not all good or bad, who begins in a rank of high degree and importance and then experiences a downfall due to a tragic flaw. In the end of most tragedies, the character comes to a realization of his flaw after enduring a great deal of suffering. William Shakespeare, an English