This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Comparison Of 'at Sea' And 'capture Of Walter Schnaffs' By Guy De Maupassant

3178 words - 13 pages

A Comparison of 'At Sea' and 'Capture of Walter Schnaffs' by Guy De Maupassant

I have studied several stories written by Guy De Maupassant. In my
essay I shall examine, in detail, two stories initially, and then
later I shall expand, to other stories. The first story I have chosen
is ‘At Sea’. In this story there are two loyal brothers, who work as
fisherman. In this harsh life, you must choose the most beneficial
outcome; otherwise you are foolish, detrimental and may starve. In
this story, one of the Javel brothers gets his arm caught in the nets.
The other refusing to release the nets, forces the brother to have his
arm amputated and also become gangrenous. ‘Cutting the cable meant
losing the net, and the net was worth money, a great deal of money’,
This is the ‘having is keeping’ attitude, in which these brothers live
by, which is understandable in their hazardous, living conditions.

‘At Sea’ represents a different manner of poverty from the worldwide
view. Not simply that the brothers need nourishment, but that
everything is valuable. The ‘Having is keeping’ attitude is a strong
theme throughout. After the older brother Javel ignores the pain his
brother is going through. He chooses to allow his brother to have his
arm torn off, and yet the younger brother refuses to let his arm rot.
He uses it as a trophy, to parade it, showing to people how brave he
is. Claiming he let his arm get torn off, for the sake of the nets,
and some fish. ‘No, I wont! It’s mine, I’d have you know; its my own
arm after all.’ This was as if, he, too was proud of the ‘having is
keeping’ creed. Words such as ‘roughness’ and ‘ransacking’ imply that
‘At sea’ is a very physical and hard life.

The story has black comic moments, as the brother buries his own arm
in a coffin. ‘The whole crew of the trawler followed the funeral of
the severed limb.’ Although this may be found funny, in a sick way,
others may have found it anti-clerical. The positioning of the
incident, and the characters can be seen as a metaphorical hospital,
the younger brother is in need of a donor, it is well known that
family are the best donors. However the older brother refuses to
donate and instead keeps his ‘organ’, therefore leaving the younger
brother worse off, for the time being, but, fate takes a hand as he
survives and continues on, proud of what has happened.

The second story I have chosen is ‘Capture of Walter Schnaffs’. This
story was based at the time of the Franco-Prussian war (1870-71). At
the time France had suffered a humiliating defeat to the hands of the
Prussians, which is now part of Northern Germany. The stereotype of a
Prussian soldier is a fearless, vicious soldier, as seen in many
movies as the ruthless Germans. An incident that occurs in the story,
when Walter is searching for refuge, is that he appears at...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of 'At Sea' and 'Capture of Walter Schnaffs' by Guy De Maupassant

Situational Irony in O’Henry’s The Ransom of Red Chief and The Necklace by Guy de Maupassant

793 words - 4 pages Situational irony is used in both O’Henry’s “The Ransom of Red Chief” and “The Necklace” by Guy de Maupassant but the effect of the techniques on the tone of each story is very different. In O’Henry’s story, the protagonist, Red Chief, is being kidnapped by two criminals, Bill and Sam. There are many ironic events that occur in the story. For example, the reader expects Red Chief to want to go back home to his family but instead, he is having

The Necklace by Guy de Maupassant

1354 words - 5 pages Honesty can prevent years of misery, guilt and regret which Guy de Maupassant depicts throughout “The Necklace.” Guy de Maupassant, a French writer, born in 1850, was considered one of France’s greatest short-story writers. His writings were mostly influenced by the divorce of his parents when he was thirteen years old and by great writers such as Shakespeare, Schopenhauer, and Flauber. His parent’s divorce caused his stories to depict

The Necklace by Guy De Maupassant

1679 words - 7 pages vigorously searching for Mme. Forestier ‘s necklace, Loisel and Mathilde come to the conclusion that they will tell her that a piece of the necklace broke and that they will return it to her once it has been fixed. Here, the author shows how both Loisel and Mathilde are not being honest to Mme. Forestier about what really happened to her necklace. Guy De Maupassant shows this theme directly by making it obvious that the characters are willing to lie

The Necklace by Guy De Maupassant

1520 words - 7 pages In Guy De Maupassant short story, “The Necklace,” he uses the necklace as a symbol of deceptive appearance. There is proof in this story that one’s appearance can be deceiving. The significance of theme is that throughout, it reveals which is that looks can be deceiving. Mathilde and the necklace itself are two pieces of evidence that shows that appearances can be deceiving. The reader gets the impression, from the author’s description of the

The Necklace, by Guy de Maupassant

951 words - 4 pages can revamp your life. Guy de Maupassant, the author of “The Necklace” uses literary devices to prove people come before materialistic items. A common literary device, symbolism is used in this story. Symbolism is when something has a greater meaning within itself. The example of this in the story is the necklace. When looking at necklaces at Madame Forestier she finds one that just jumps out at her. She believes it is everything she wants in

The Necklace by Guy de Maupassant

787 words - 3 pages The Necklace by Guy de Maupassant ?The Necklace? The theme of Guy de Maupassant story ?The Necklace? seems to be suggested by the line, ?What would have happened if Mathilde had not lost the necklace??. Mathilde Loisel grew up in poverty and had no expectations in life. When she got married, her and her husband would sit around the dinner table and imagine they were eating a luxurious meal. They would imagine

"The Necklace" by Guy de Maupassant

1052 words - 4 pages In "The Necklace", Guy de Maupassant creates an irony about the Mme. Loisel, who always dreams she would live in a luxury life, which later costs her ten years of working to pay off for what she dreams for. Mme. Mathilde Loisel was born in a poor family, so she dreamed someday she would have a husband who is "rich and distinguish" (194). Unfortunately, she ends up getting married to, as the author describes, a "little clerks" who can't satisfy

The Life of Guy de Maupassant Exposed in The Necklace

2400 words - 10 pages The life of an author may often reflect through their works. This is the case in the short story, The Necklace, written by Guy de Maupassant. An ironic and a self-explanatory tale, The Necklace is written filled with twists that might just make you doubt your stand in life. Characters which anyone might not think much about, symbols that many seem to miss, and principles that few seem to understand, The Necklace might just be short but with it

Use of Setting to Reflect Main Character in "The Necklace" by Guy de Maupassant

807 words - 3 pages In “The Necklace,” Guy de Maupassant uses setting to reflect the character and development of the main character, Mathilde Loisel. As a result, his setting is not particularly vivid or detailed. He does not even describe the ill-fated necklace—the central object in the story—but states only that it is “superb” (7 ). In fact, he includes descriptions of setting only if they illuminate qualities about Mathilde. Her changing character can be

Guy De Maupassant The Necklace

784 words - 3 pages . Although, Maupassant tends to mainly focused on what was happening at the time of the moment and touches very little on how the character feels about the situation. As seen on a particular sentence, "and this life lasted for ten years" (182), he never reveals how she feels about the ten long years that she had to work, but merely the fact that she had to workMaupassant leads up to his story by introducing a lower class wife who envied the typical

Irony in The Necklace by Guy de Maupassant

866 words - 4 pages "The necklace itself is representative of the theme of appearances versus reality.”(Gale) Guy de Maupassant was a popular French writer who wrote many short stories. One of his most popular works is “The Necklace”. The story is about a girl named Mathilde Loisel who has always dreamed of something she can never have, and just when she gets a chance, she loses her friend’s necklace that makes her life turn for the

Similar Essays

A Comparison Of A Vendetta By Guy De Maupassant And The Red Room By H.G. Wells

1517 words - 6 pages A Comparison of A Vendetta by Guy de Maupassant and The Red Room by H.G. Wells I am aiming to look at the differences and similarities of two writer's methods of creating tension in their stories. The two stories I am looking at are 'A Vendetta' by Guy de Maupassant and 'The

Biography Of Guy De Maupassant Essay

476 words - 2 pages It's done well. just teels about his life well written, but correct grammerBiography on Guy de MaupassantGuy de Maupassant was born on August 5, 1850 at Chateau de Miromesnil in France. He was a descendent of a very old French family. As a boy, Maupassant went to school at Yvetot in Normandy, and then attended Lycee at Rouen. During his childhood and youth in Normandy, he picked up a great deal of experiences that he later put to use in many of

Views Of Women In The Necklace By Guy De Maupassant A&P By John Updike

1138 words - 5 pages Views of Women in The Necklace by Guy De Maupassant A&P by John Updike "The Necklace" by Guy De Maupassant, and "A&P" by John Updike were written in two different centuries by two authors of very different backgrounds. However, each story expresses very similar views about women. The women in these stories are self-centered creatures who control men with their sexuality, and end up damaging the men's life. The main character in "The

Contrasts The Conclusions Of "The Jewelery" By Guy De Maupassant And "No One's A Mystery" By Elizabeth Tallent

748 words - 3 pages "The Jewelery" by Guy de Maupassant and "No One's a Mystery" by Elizabeth Tallent are two stories which both imply different types of conclusions. These authors use completely dissimilar elements to approach their final message. "The Jewlery" and "No One's a Mystery" are two very unique stories. Although they do not have many obvious similarities, they both explore underlying expression of love and betrayal.In the story "The Jewelery" the gender