A Comparison Of Barna Di Siena’s Mystic Marriage Of Saint Catherine And Rogier Van Der Weyden’s Saint Luke Drawing The Virgin And Child

1519 words - 6 pages

A Comparison of Barna di Siena’s Mystic Marriage of Saint Catherine and Rogier van der Weyden’s Saint Luke Drawing the Virgin and Child


Development in art often follows two tracks: development over a period of time and also differences in regional development. Both changes are seen in the comparison of Barna di Siena’s Mystic Marriage of Saint Catherine and Rogier van der Weyden’s Saint Luke Drawing the Virgin and Child. Originating in Italy, the Renaissance began in the mid to late 13th century. Barna da Siena was one of the early Renaissance artists influenced by Duccio di Buoninsegna and Simone Martini. Barna di Siena’s painting is dated around 1340 and Rogier van der Weyden’s painting was painted nearly a century later around 1435. Rogier van der Weyden had the advantage of development in perspective and modeling that developed over time, but was also from the Flemish school of art, a style totally different from that of the early Italian Renaissance artists. What lends these paintings so readily to comparison is the fact that the general symmetrical composition of two main figures and the sizes of the two are approximately the same. However, it is clear that a century and a different region has created stylized differences that are very clear.

Barna di Siena’s Mystic Marriage of Saint Catherine exhibits a highly dramatic style that was not seen in his mentor nor in his fellow student Lippo Memmi’s work. The symmetric composition consists of two main figures, Saint Catherine and the adult Jesus. In the painting, Jesus is seen placing a ring on Saint Catherine’s finger and taking her as his spiritual bride. Both figures appear to be very light and frail and the draperies they wear do not show the human form that they cover but rather dominate the shapes. Also, this painting is in the tradition of older secular works of art where each piece of work was a compilation of many scenes that told a story. The two main characters in the painting display elegant mannered poses and all the figures appear arranged in rather unnatural poses. There is a small scene at the foot of the Saint Catherine and Christ figures. This is thought to be the Christ child with the Virgin Mary and grandmother, Saint Anne. Below these two scenes are three smaller bordered scenes. The central one depicts two enemies reconciled by an archangel and the outer ones show Saints Michael and Margaret fighting demons. All these images show the triumph of good over evil, with the middle characters shedding their weapons and embracing. All these small pictures support that the painting was commissioned by Arigoi di Nero Arighetti to celebrate the end of a feud.

Painted on a panel, this painting was done in tempera, a pigment dissolved in egg. The chief medium till the late 1400s, tempera dries very quickly and when it does it gives a flat and dry appearance. This painting has sharp brushstrokes that do not fuse together and the forms have...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of Barna di Siena’s Mystic Marriage of Saint Catherine and Rogier van der Weyden’s Saint Luke Drawing the Virgin and Child

Saint Dominic Guzman of the Dominican Order, Saint Francis of Assisi and Saint Thomas Aquinas

2320 words - 9 pages the most faithful interpreter of Catholic traditions and inspired by Aristotle. Saint Dominic and the Dominicans, Saint Frances of Assisi and the Franciscans and Saint Thomas Aquinas and Thomism all played a significant role of early Christianity. Saint Dominic was born in Calaruga, Old Castile, Spain, the Son of Felix Guzman and Blessed Joan of Aza. He studied at the University of Palencia, where he was ordained. Saint Dominic was a man of

Living the Life of a Saint

1063 words - 5 pages In a Catholic society, such as Valle di Sole in Lives of the Saints by Nino Ricci, it is common for people to be named after saints, making Hagiography, a study of the lives of the saints, a study of high importance. Essentially, in Ricci’s novel, the characters draw many parallels from their name saint, such as personality, notable events, and martyrdom, which eventually leads to living a life comparable to their name saint, as if destined by

Symbols and Composition of the Statue Saint George by Donatello

803 words - 4 pages Saint George is a statue that was sculpted by Donatello in the prime of his career. From top to bottom, this realistic statue displays a sort of defiance towards his enemies and a sense of pride in his country. This begins with his expression of pride and inner turmoil on his face and ends with the wide stance of his feet, a mighty shield in-between. Even the platform he is standing on and the composition of his body help contribute to the

The 1980 Eruption of Mount Saint Helens and Its Impact

1523 words - 6 pages Mount Saint Helens, located in the Pacific Northwest in southwestern Washington, stood approximately 9,500 feet above sea level prior to its eruption in 1980 (Tarbuck, 2012). Part of the Cascade Mountain Range, it is a composite volcano constructed of alternating layers of lava flows, ash, and other volcanic debris with steep, symmetrical sides . It also belongs to the North American segment of the Pacific “Ring of Fire.” This is where the

Drawing on the Gospels of Matthew and Luke, and the Character Development of Joseph and Mary in the Nativity Story

2150 words - 9 pages Messiah (Luke 2:38) would be born in the ‘House of David.’ This would be possible if a boy was born after his mother’s marriage and home-taking but before consummation (Derrett 264). In Matthew (1:24-1:25), it is stated that Joseph did not consummate his marriage to Mary until after Jesus’ birth. When Joseph names the child Jesus in Matthew (1:25), he has via the conventions of Jewish culture adopted him into the messianic family line (Weaver 395

The Life of Saint Birgitta

1510 words - 6 pages was married at the very young age of thirteen and when she was twenty-six she had already given birth to eight children. One of these children would follow in her mother's footsteps and also become a famous holy woman: Saint Catherine of Sweden (Mazzoni 37). Birgitta was married to Ulf Gudmarsson who, like her father, was a Swedish lawman. Ulf was five years older than Birgitta and surprisingly their marriage was a good one. Ulf was a happy man

The Life of Saint Ignatius

1972 words - 8 pages Saint Ignatius’s life was from 1491-1556. He was born to Beltran de Onaz Loyola and Dona Marina Sanchez de Licona they were married in 1467. Ingnatuis father died when he was sixteen years of age, and there was no record of his mother’s birth or death. It is not known if Saint Ignatius ever saw or knew his mother. The reason for that belief was because he was nursed by a common woman who lived in one of the villages and her name was Maria Garin

The Church of Saint Raymond

1083 words - 5 pages The religious site that I chose for my course assignment is the Church of Saint Raymond, a historical landmark. One could say that it definitely stands out boldly in the neighborhood that its located in which is the Castle Hill/ Parkchester proper in the Bronx. Growing up I frequently visited the church and was always astounded by its massive size and incredible architecture. Compared to the dimly lit parish of Santa Maria, which always smelled

Analysis of The Saint-Chappelle

1360 words - 5 pages architecture that would dominate Europe cathedrals far into the future. The Saint-Chappelle, a Gothic Style cathedral commissioned by Louis IX, represents the rise of a changed church as it uses reason and logic found in scholasticism to create beautiful pieces of architecture. The Saint-Chappelle was influenced by the first Gothic Church, built between 1132 and 1144, which was the St. Dennis Abbey near Paris (Anderson 12). The Saint- Chappelle was

The Life of Saint Francis

671 words - 3 pages was alive. St. Francis died on October 3, 1226 in Assisi. His message continues to live on because he has millions of followers now. St. Francis is now the patron saint of animals. St. Francis’ beliefs and mission connects to many moral heroes today. St. Joseph may have grew up a little differently than St. Francis did but they carried out God’s mission in the same way. Although St. Joseph was not loved as a child this connects to St. Francis

The Teaching of Saint Gregory

1155 words - 5 pages A. “The Teaching of Saint Gregory” contains many theologically concepts as God and Creation, Christology, human Sin and salvation, eschatology and resurrection. Owing to the limited space, I will only explore some key elements which I think are worthy to be discussed. First, Gregory depicts the God’s attributes – it begins with the faith of Trinity- God created the world and humankind, the Son saved humankind and the Spirit sustained the

Similar Essays

Rogier Van Der Weyden Essay

776 words - 3 pages profoundly affected the developing artist, introducing elegance and subtle visual refinements into the bolder, Campinesque components of such early paintings by Rogier as St. Luke Painting the Virgin. It was in Bruges, where Rogier may have resided between 1432 and 1435, that he became thoroughly acquainted with van Eyck's style (http://humanitiesweb.org). The spiritual essence of a scene was displayed with similar technical virtuosity by Van der Weyden

The Story Of Saint Catherine Laboure

1221 words - 5 pages described in the liturgy of the day. On the eve of the Feast of Saint Vincent de Paul, July 19, the Sister Superior spoke to the novices about the virtues of their Holy Founder and gave each of them a piece of cloth from his surplice. Catherine earnestly prayed to Saint Vincent that she might with her own eyes see the mother of God. She was convinced that she would see the Blessed Virgin Mary that very night; and in her conviction, Catherine fell

Kerouac And Tyler, "On The Road" And "Saint Maybe" Comparison And Critique

2055 words - 8 pages "Saint Maybe", by Jack Kerouac and Anne Tyler, the authors stress upon life as a set of experiences and how these builds a person.Utterly and completely carefree are the characters, blowing and twisting on the maelstrom of their whims, each lunging twinge of a mental process reflected in miles. A laughing blue sky above waiting to swallow one alive, a gleefully roaring engine burning hungrily in front, the road and its devils grinning wickedly

A Comparative Study Of The Lives Of Saint Francis Of Assisi And Saint Bernard Of Clairvaux

1197 words - 5 pages journey. Showing signs of deep compassion and understanding even as a young child when reproached by his father for having left his wares unattended to chase down a beggar in order to give the poor man the full contents of his pockets. Saint Francis' life of materialism, worldly concerns and pleasures slowly lost its hold on him and he awakened to God's plan for his life’s work. While Saint Bernard had been raised, it seems with a keen