A Comparison Of Conflict And Labeling Theory In The Context Of Youth Gangs

1911 words - 8 pages

Many have attempted to explain gang involvement in today's society. However, there is an underlying activity of youth joining gangs that does not seem to have enough media coverage or thorough explanations. As the name suggests, youth gang membership is about the juvenile population creating and joining gangs. Research indicates that youth gang membership exists in contemporary north America (Bernburg et al. 2006; aLilly et al. 2011; Maclure and Sotelo 2004; Sims 1997; Wiley et al. 2013; Yoder et al. 2003). This paper will examine the factors associated with youth gang membership using Karl Marx's conflict theory and labeling theory in comparison. Although conflict theory helps explain why a troublesome economy and coming from a low-socioeconomic status contributes to gang involvement, the theory has its limitations. On the other hand, labeling theory is unable to fully explain youth gang involvement based on the aforementioned factors. That being said, it can give a better explanation based on the factor of government intervention in the lives of citizens such as the context of stop-and-frisk which lead to unwarranted searches.
As mentioned in lecture, labeling theory asks two critical questions: what is crime, and who is criminal? This is the central tenet of labeling theory because the focus is on what activities constitute criminal behaviour within the context. This means that over time, the general perspective changes in regards to what can be labeled 'crime.' For instance, society is known to react negatively towards prostitution in the past; whereas the contemporary reaction is primarily to legalize it.
That being said, labeling is more than a reaction to an activity. To elaborate, labeling is also about the government intervention in the daily lives of citizens (Bernburg et al. 2006; aLilly et al. 2011; Wiley et al. 2013). This includes the practice of stop-and-frisk that is performed by police officers on potential suspects, or anyone for that matter because they can do it unwarranted. Moreover, the result can be innocent youth being interrogated by this means of intervention. Consequently, youth may internalize this label of a potential criminal which raises a key issue of labeling theory that explains future criminality and gang membership. As mentioned in the lecture, labels can be positive that result in a higher self-esteem. In this case, a stop-and-frisk on an innocent youth is a negative label that can not only lower the person's self-esteem, but result in a forced self-realization that they are a deviant. Therefore, government intervention can explain why youth join gangs in the context of labeling theory.
Bernburg et al. (2006) implement how labeling theory not only applies to an individual youth; but also to the youth's social network. Again, this can be visualized by the scenario of government intervention. Essentially, when government intervention of a juvenile individual creates a negative label, the youth's social...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of Conflict and Labeling Theory in the Context of Youth Gangs

The Dell Theory of Conflict Prevention and In China, Human Cost Are Built Into an iPad

1194 words - 5 pages the population stays and try to fend for life. Thomas L. Friedman made a good point in his article “The Dell Theory of Conflict Prevention” however after reading Charles Duhigg and David Barboza’s article “In China, Human Costs Are Built Into an iPad” I believe the people matter more than anything. Some country’s governments are putting too much weight on other counties and the money they can make by doing business with them and not enough

The History of Gangs in America.

2253 words - 9 pages more than ready to join.The Nuestra Familia is a prison gang made up of largely inmates from Northern California. The conflict between Nortenos and Surenos street gangs in California has lasted for over thirty years. Most of the problems date back to the California prison system and arose from the conflict between inmates affiliated with the La EME (many from East L.A.) versus EME dropouts and inmates who were originally from Northern California

Discuss the use of group work theory and skills and apply to your role as a child or youth practitioner.

1373 words - 6 pages overcome obstacles. Relating to both of the modelling stage theories that Tuckman and Belin both done. Applying to my role as a youth worker working within a team, I am clearly going with Belbin’s team theory because I believe that everyone has their own role in a team some people are better than others in doing different roles. I strongly believe that Belbin’s developing stage model is very good for team building for me as it looks at the

"Understanding and Responding to Youth Gangs: A Juvenile Corrections Approach"

913 words - 4 pages "Understanding and Responding to Youth Gangs: A Juvenile Corrections Approach"Youth gangs are very attractive to youths in the inner-cities of America. These gangs are usually very corrupt and violent. What many people do not realize is that these gangs are having a large impact on not only the youth of America, but this country in general. A youth gang is a group of adolescents, primarily twelve to eighteen years old, whose members describe

Labeling of McCandless in Jon Krakauer's Into the Wild

1211 words - 5 pages McCandless story with fragments…from my own youth…I do so in the hope that my experiences will throw some oblique light on the enigma of Chris McCandless,” (Krakauer’s note). He stated there that he ‘hopes’ to make a better presentation of McCandless’s life for he wanted to show that he deserves respect. He mirrored his own experiences and explained why he did it to draw some conclusion on why McCandless did it as well. Krakauer also said that

The Evaluation And Labeling Of Children With Disabilities

1706 words - 7 pages The information given me by various professionals who have repeatedly evaluated my daughter is the biggest issue that I face in my life. In order for me to resolve my issue I need to explore whether my issue lies with the professionals and the process of evaluation, or with me not wanting to accept that my child is disabled.My six and a half year old daughter, Malia, began to show signs of delayed development at age eighteen months. Her speech

The King of Gangs

1799 words - 7 pages because of the total isolation he has from society. He embraces counterculture as a result of the long 200 years of remaining parasitic. This alienation drives Dracula to yearn for something that can identify with him: he bites people so that they to will become vampires. Gangs use a unique and disturbed ritual called jumping in that equates only them to Dracula, as the modern possessors of this alienation from society. Peers of

Youth Gangs Across the Globe

4812 words - 19 pages criticized for lacking a "core definition." As a result, a host of youth group activities as diverse as fraternities to street corner gangs were analyzed in that now classic research work. Today, astute journalists, prosecutors, legislators, and scholars generally evade definitions, yet there is a tendency to be completely unfettered about using the words "gang member" and even applying them to individuals. In the prominent sociologist Malcolm W

Gangs: A Brotherhood of Violence

526 words - 2 pages What is brotherhood? How does it apply to those involved? Why does it exist? Merriam-Webster’s Dictionary defines brotherhood as “an association for a particular purpose.” To gang members, young and old, brotherhood is an escape from society’s constant pressure to fit in, to succeed, to conform to social norms. It is within a brotherhood that gang members find peace and comfort. Brotherhood is a way of life; it is the very essence that allows a

Description and Analysis of the Different Types of Gangs in the US

1409 words - 6 pages ). Gangs serve a multitude of purposes for their members. The gang becomes their family. They are able to trust them, rely on them, and the gang gives them a sense of self and importance. Gangs have the ability to offer status, refuge, protection, and opportunity of stigma free life within this population (Tower, 2013, p. 82). In the PBS show Interrupter ex-gang members and ex-gang enforcers joined together to help prevent shootings and killings

The Uneven Distribution of Resources and Power of the State: The Context of Poverty of a Lumads in Mindanao

811 words - 4 pages Antonio D. Fontanilla, Jr. 4-AB Political Science The Uneven Distribution of Resources and Power of the State: The Context of Poverty of a Lumads in Mindanao The situation in Mindanao for the past decades has been varying from the issues of conflict to the achievement of apparent peace in the eyes of many Filipinos. We can always hear the news of war, bombing, kidnappings and the most affected by these are the displaced people living in the

Similar Essays

The Comparison Of Functionalism And Conflict Theory

974 words - 4 pages Functionalism and conflict theory are two theories that influence the purposes of schooling. These two theories are both different and similar in their view and relation to schooling. Basically, the differences lie in the way these two theories explain transmission, as well as way functionalists are more accepting and conflict theorists want to change things. The two theories are similar in their views of structure and culture."Functionalism

Youth Participation In Gangs Essay

1262 words - 5 pages Youth participation in gangs actually decreased from 1996 to 2004, but the violence within these gangs has not. Homicides committed by youth gang members still remain as a monumental problem across the United States of America. The Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention reported in its 2004 survey of youth gangs that there were an estimated 760,000 gang members that year. Many of the kids affiliated with gangs come from lower

A Comparison Of Moral Conflict In Antigone And A Doll's House

1510 words - 6 pages Conflict Between Individual Morals and State Laws in Antigone and A Doll's House              Mother, should I trust the government?  Or should I trust myself?  This dilemma is a common one in a great deal of literature.  In Antigone and A Doll’s House, the main theme is the question of whether one should be true to oneself or true to one’s state or society.  Should Nora (in A Doll’s House) and Antigone (in Antigone) “follow the rules

A Comparison Of Two Representations Of The Bosnian Conflict

1218 words - 5 pages drama in a way that will influence the public opinion and generate support against these atrocities. He has used images, which show the mass destruction that the Croats have caused which persuades the audience to feel negatively towards them.The News report, which was aired on 23rd April 1993, is a report of the real destruction caused during the conflict in Bosnia. The news reporter uses a serious tone when introducing us to the report and warns the