A Comparison Of Dover Beach By Matthew Arnold And Prayer Before Brith By Louis Mac Neice

1299 words - 5 pages

A Comparison of Dover Beach by Matthew Arnold and Prayer Before Brith by Louis MacNeice

'Dover Beach' by Matthew Arnold, written in 1867, and 'Prayer Before
Birth' written in 1951 by Louis MacNeice share many similarities
despite being written nearly on hundred years apart from each other.
This essay will explore the issues and ideas that both poems share, in
addition to drawing attention to some of the key differences.

'Dover Beach' is about the thoughts of a man on his honeymoon, who
shares his sentiments about the suffering of the world and that fact
that his 'love' is the only thing which is positive about his life.
'Prayer Before Birth' describes the thoughts of an unborn child,
making a plea to be kept safe against the dangers of the earth. Both
poems refer to, are about, are interested in, and are concerned with
criticism of the world, and distressed narrators; while some
differences can be observed. For example: The unborn child in 'Prayer
Before Birth' is certain of what the world is like, and he knows what
might happen to him. Matthew Arnold, on the other hand expresses
uncertainty in his poem. Even with slight differences, the predominant
themes /preoccupations of the two poems are the same.

It is clear that both poets feel disillusioned with life, and consider
that there is little in life which is joyful or cause for optimism.
Indeed, Matthew Arnold refers to a world which, "Hath really neither
joy, nor love, nor light, nor certitude, nor peace, nor help for
pain." Louis MacNeice is much more specific in is list of things which
bring pain to individuals: the lectures of old men, the strife with
bureaucracy, the humiliation of lost love, the ingratitude of
children, and the ungratefulness of beggars, the sub doing to peer
pressure, the dryness of his life that might cause doom, and the
obstacles and intimidation that he might confront.

Matthew Arnold feels that mankind has always been aware of the
essential 'human misery' that exists in the world, and refers to
Sophocles to reinforce his point. It is appropriate for Arnold to have
used Sophocles in the second stanza, as Sophocles has always written
about human misery (his most famous tragic pieces being Oedipus Rex
and Antigone); therefore this proves Arnolds point that human misery
has been studied before.

The persona in Matthew Arnold's poem seems to spring in part form the
loss of spirituality in the world. He uses the metaphor 'The Sea of
Faith' to describe the 'withdrawal' of people's belief in religion.
Whereas it was once a 'bright girdle' is now in retreat and all that
is heard is the 'melancholy, long, withdrawing roar'

Although Louis MacNeice, makes a brief reference to religion, 'a white
light/ in the back of my mind to guide me', generally there doesn't
seem to be much help for the dishonesty and...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of Dover Beach by Matthew Arnold and Prayer Before Brith by Louis MacNeice

Analysis of "Dover Beach" by Matthew Arnold

606 words - 2 pages Reading this poem brings out many deep emotion inside of me. Feeling of sadness and loneliness are just some of the few feelings I have. This poem is well written and is backed with many vivid imagery and clear metaphors. Mr. Arnold describes a number of settings and beauty in dover beach. This poem is written in free verse with no particular meter or beats to it. Mr. Arnold uses

Hope is pathetic. Analysis of poem "Dover Beach" Matthew Arnold

515 words - 2 pages In the poem Dover Beach, the poet uses conflicting imagery to give meaning to the poem. The differences in the way that the poet sees the relationship between the beach and the sea and the way that most people would see it become more pronounced as the poem develops. He also uses the change in attitude from the first stanza to the last to emphasize his...

"Prayer before birth" by Louise Macneice and "Baby Song" by Thom Gunn.

1131 words - 5 pages Louis MacNeice's and Thom Gun's poems use the first voice to look at birth through babies' eyes. They help us see that babies, unborn or newborn, are living but powerless beings. They can think and feel but cannot make decisions or changes in their lives. MacNeice's piece is burdened with desperate pleas from the womb for a chance to live while Gunn's poem takes...

Self Reponse to Prayer Before Birth Louis Macneice

621 words - 2 pages A good poem does not need superb text; it needs superb use of poetic techniques and a good structure. 'Prayer before birth' is a fine example of a good poem; however, the text is superb too.My self response for this poem was first negative but afterwards I agreed with some points....

Matthew Arnold's Dover Beach

1591 words - 6 pages Matthew Arnold's 'Dover Beach' Matthew Arnold's 'Dover Beach' employs the sounds of language in three ways, through onomatopoeia to aurally represent the actions occurring on the beach, a varying meter which mirrors the varying heights of the waves on the beach, and a rhyme scheme which searches for its identity. In each stanza of the poem when the sounds of language are chaotic, the visual descriptions in the poem are tranquil, but when the...

A Comparison of Fahrenheit 451 and Dover Beach

1194 words - 5 pages      Fahrenheit 451 is a well-written book that tells a story of a dream world and one man who wakes up from that dream. Montag, the protagonist of the story, brings home a book of poetry one day and begins to read the poem Dover Beach by Matthew Arnold to his wife and her guests. Many critics think that Bradbury picked this poem because it paralleled life in his book. The poem Dover Beach can be compared to Fahrenheit...

Comparison: dover beach and do

1272 words - 5 pages A man stands on the cliffs of Dover, looking out at the ocean. He is self-absorbed and experiencing feelings of dejection. This man goes on for stanzas uttering thoughts to himself, at least that is what one could surmise from the indifferent tone. Then, when the reader is convinced that the man is simply philosophizing out loud to himself, the man addresses for the first time another party. That party is a woman, one that he refers to as...

Comparison: dover beach and do

1272 words - 5 pages A man stands on the cliffs of Dover, looking out at the ocean. He is self-absorbed and experiencing feelings of dejection. This man goes on for stanzas uttering thoughts to himself, at least that is what one could surmise from the indifferent tone. Then, when the reader is convinced that the man is simply philosophizing out loud to himself, the man addresses for the first time another party. That party is a woman, one that he refers to as...

The Comparison of Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold

640 words - 3 pages Through their writing, Karl Marx and Matthew Arnold show their opposing views on the importance of internal and external functions of culture. In the first chapter of

Tidal Influences Essay on Matthew Arnold's "Dover Beach"

1073 words - 4 pages English 461 Romantic and Victorian PoetryOctober 2, 2001Tidal InfluencesMathew Arnold's poem, Dover Beach, is narrative in style and emphasized by the use of the present tense. The reader is immediately drawn in by this lyrical approach. Although this poem is told in the present tense, Dover Beach seems to be a recollection of an earlier time....

Change - Analysis of 'Growing Old' by Matthew Arnold

794 words - 3 pages Growing OldWhat is it to grow old?Is it to lose the glory of the form,The lustre of the eye?Is it for beauty to forego her wreath?Yes, but not for this alone.Is it to feel our strength -Not our bloom only, but our strength -decay?Is it to feel each limbGrow stiffer, every function less exact,Each nerve more weakly strung?Yes, this, and more! but not,Ah, 'tis not what in youth we dreamed 'twould be!'Tis not to have our lifeMellowed and...

Similar Essays

Dover Beach by Matthew Arnold Essay

1561 words - 6 pages Written by Matthew Arnold around 1851 while one his honeymoon, Dover Beach is a dramatic monologue addressed to his wife, Frances Wightman, and “any woman listening to the observations of any man” (Cummings); during this time, the world had just come out of the Romantic era and was entering the era of the industrial revolution. New inventions in technology were changing the world and science such as biology and astronomy were challenging long...

Dover beach by matthew arnold Essay

1162 words - 5 pages Matthew Arnold's Devolpment of Setting In the poem "Dover Beach",witten in 1867 Matthew Arnold creates the mood of the poem through the usage of different types of imagery. He uses a dramatic plot in the form of a soliloquy. Arnold also uses descriptive adjectives, similes and metaphors to create the mood. Through the use of these...

Analysis of dover beach by matthew arnold

581 words - 2 pages "Dover Beach" "Dover Beach" a poem about a sea and a beach that is truly beautiful, but hold much deeper meaning than what meets the eye. The poem is written in free verse with no particular meter or rhyme scheme, although some of the words do rhyme. Arnold is the speaker speaking to someone he loves. As the poem progresses, the reader...

Analysis of "Dover Beach" by Matthew Arnold

1497 words - 6 pages "Dover beach" is a beautiful poem written by a famous poet, Matthew Arnold; from the romantic era. The poem is melancholic and pessimistic in nature and shows human misery through the ages. The diction changes as the poem progresses, from the beginning till the end, soft and loving to hard and rough, respectively. The images are centered around the ocean, this is...