A Comparison Of Homecoming And Before You Were Mine

1523 words - 6 pages

A Comparison of Homecoming and Before You Were Mine
The poem ‘Homecoming’ is about the poet (Simon Armitage’s) wife’s
childhood and about their relationship at present. The poem begins
with the poet talking about his wife at nursery. The poet shows us
that it is about a child by describing a character wearing ‘one canary
– yellow cotton jacket’ as it signifies childhood. The child gets her
jacket ‘scuffed’ and ‘blackened’ in the cloakroom and her mother makes
‘proper fist of it’. In the next paragraph the character ‘sneaks’ out
of the house and plans to run away but end up retracing her ‘walk
towards the garden gate’ and goes home. In the last paragraph it talks
about the poet’s relationship with his wife. Carol Ann Duffy’s ‘Before
You Were Mine’ is about her feeling guilty that she was born as she
believes that she ruined her mother’s life. The poet describes her
mother as being a ‘high – heeled red shoes relics’.

Both poems ‘Homecoming’ and ‘Before You Were Mine’ themes explore
relationships. In ‘Homecoming’ Simon Armitage concentrates on
relationships by describing the events of his wife’s childhood showing
her conflict with her parents at different ages and stages of her
life. When Armitage’s wife was at nursery she conflicts with her
parents after scuffing and blackening her coat and her mother reacts
to this by making ‘proper fist of it and points the finger. Temper,
temper’. In ‘Before You Were Mine’ Carol Ann Duffy’s relationship with
her mother is off guilt. In the poem Carol Ann Duffy feels guilty that
she has destroyed her mother’s life by being born. The poet feels like
this as she describes her mother as being a lively young adult having
‘small bites on your neck’ symbolising romance as those bites are love
bites. Duffy also tends to repeat ‘before I was born’ as it implies
that her mother was different fundamentally. The two poems are similar
in the way that they are about relationships about mothers conversely
they explore relationships in different ways. In ‘Homecoming’ Simon
explores relationships with conflict however Duffy in ‘Before You Were
Mine’ explores relationships with guilt.

The poem ‘Homecoming’ is structured as each paragraph has
significance. The first paragraph is a universal reference to all
relationships. The second paragraph shows conflict between Armitage’s
wife and her mother while his wife was at nursery. The third paragraph
again shows conflict between Armitage’s wife and her mother at a older
age of about sixteen where Armitage’s wife is about to runaway from
home. In the last paragraph it shows the transition of Armitage’s
wife’s life changing. Carol Ann Duffy’s ‘Before You Were Mine’ is
structures chronologically which means it is structured in order of
time. The first stanza shows Duffy’s...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of Homecoming and Before You Were Mine

This is a short story of mine.

656 words - 3 pages A Lesson Before It Was Too LateFive servants walked into their master's studying room with energy and confidence, but came out with disappointment and confusion. They were fired by Mrs. Burston, their master. Mrs. Burston fired them not because of shortage of money, nor because she was dissatisfied with their work, she did for the benefits of her sonMrs. Burston, who grew up in a wealthy family, married an owner of a well-known corporation, Mr

Theme of Loyalty in Homecoming and The Hunger Games

1197 words - 5 pages Loyalty is like glue, since it keeps the camaraderie in a relationship intact. If someone breaks the loyalty, then that trust and camaraderie are damaged as well. But yet, one can remain loyal without sacrificing one’s needs or desires. Examples of this have often appeared in modern day literature. For example, take the Tillerman siblings from Cynthia Voigt’s novel, “Homecoming.” In this novel, the oldest sibling, Dicey, has to take care of her

Have you ever read a story, and were so intrigued

766 words - 3 pages Have you ever read a story, and were so intrigued that you wish you were the main character so that you could change the way they reacted to certain things? I have, and when I read "Footfalls" I found myself doing that very thing. "Footfalls" was written by Wilbur Daniel Steele, an amazing author who really knows how to capture the reader's attention and involve them in the story. In the story, a man named Boaz Negro is against Campbell Wood

A comparison of the short stories "Good Country people" and "Where are you going, Where have you been?"

1040 words - 4 pages not, and wiser and smoother conmen see this, and take advantage of them. In the end, they are proven to be the phonies that they really are, and are left more vulnerable, and more open, than they were before they tried to infiltrate the world in which they didn't belong. If there were a shared moral to these stories, and there is most definitely not an obvious one, they'd both be somewhere along the lines of "Be happy with what you have, because

How Successful Were Hitler And Mussolini Dealing With The Problems Of Their Countries Before 1939?

2866 words - 11 pages it already was. Mussolini replaced the worker unions with the Corporations that allowed employers and workers to solve their problems peacefully and to get to some kind of agreement, what ended riots and lockouts that prevented the economy from growing. The German version of the Corporations was the German Labour Front that had the same aim. These measures, taken by Mussolini as well as by the Nazis, were only a facade that gave the illusion of

Comparison Of "Their Eyes Were Watching God" And "Winesburg, Ohio"

907 words - 4 pages "Their Eyes Were Watching God" and "Winesburg, Ohio" Both Zora Neale Hurston's Their Eyes Were Watching God and Sherwood Anderson's Winesburg, Ohio provide great examples of community, although there are stark differences in the way the two respective authors present them. In Their Eyes Were Watching God, the main character Janie moves to the town of Eatonville, Florida with her second husband Jody Starks. The move was

Think of a situation you have encountered or have heard of in which there were in-groups and out-groups

671 words - 3 pages *Describe a few of the groups.*What traits account for the groups falling into each category?*What types of influences did those groups have on their members?In-Group and Out-Groups: Everyone wants to belongEveryone at some point in their lives have been apart of a "group". It may have been the "in-crowd" or the "out-siders" but you belong or were associated with one. With every group, there is a certain role to play, and/or privileges

"Journeys, irrespective of their form, usually present challenges and barriers that have to be met before a final goal is reached." Do you agree?

1148 words - 5 pages Most journeys regardless of their physical, emotional or even psychological nature present challenges and barriers which must be overcome before the goal or purpose behind the journey is reached. These challenges and barriers are both obstacles which we must surpass and signposts which mark the progress of our travels. They can take any form from physical tests of courage to psychological disorders that impede the journeyers from their paths

Talks about the levels of religion (Tolerant and intolerant)that were found in North America before 1700).

535 words - 2 pages Although the colonies established before the 1700s were formed by people who emigrated from countries of strict Christianity, many colonies developed their own religious beliefs. By the year 1700, there was a scale of religious freedom ranging from high tolerance to low tolerance. Groups of strict, accepting, and very liberal religions were spread throughout the colonies. Thus, among the British North American colonies, several differences

Comparison of Willy Loman in Miller's "Death of A Salesman" and Troy Maxon in Wilson's "Fences" Compares the 2 main characters and questions whether they were good fathers.

638 words - 3 pages , and many could say that he is too hard and cold towards him. Willy in a way believes that his grown sons could not have done any wrong when they were younger and do no wrong now. But these two fathers are not totally bad. There are many good personal traits that they both display in these books. But as stated as before, they weren't perfect at all.In many ways, both Willy and Troy were in fact good fathers. They worked hard to provide for their

"Wish You Were Here by Incubus" a poetry analysis of the song wish you were here. this is classified as a lyric poem.

834 words - 3 pages , pretend that I am weightless" (line 3). While he is thinking, the wind is blowing, and he embraces it because maybe it blows away his thoughts. The second stanza of the poem is just repeating "I wish you were here" four times. Repeating this line is emphasizing that he lost someone (most likely a lover) and wishes that they would come back and share this moment with him. Even though it is unclear who he is wishing for, you are led to believe that it is

Similar Essays

Before You Were Mine By Carol Ann Duffy

687 words - 3 pages Before you were mine by Carol Ann Duffy Before you were mine ==================== 'Before you were mine' is a poem written by Carol Ann Duffy. It’s a retrospective poignant dramatic monologue, which tells us about her mother's life ten years before Duffy was born. The title suggests that it's a love poem which shows the strong mother and daughter relationship that they had. The poem starts off with a positive image. "…laugh on with

Homer's Odyssey: Themes Of Homecoming And Reunion

3290 words - 13 pages before our time."   The Lord of Ithaka thought himself to mean that they would not go down into the House of Death until they themselves were dead, but Odysseus' time comes quite sometime before his own death.  Hades is the only consummate image of the engulfment, for Odysseus emerges a man reborn, and called 'twice mortal' by Kirke.  The Odysseus of old and his 'deep heart at sea' are forever forgotten and

A Comparison Of Dover Beach By Matthew Arnold And Prayer Before Brith By Louis Mac Neice

1299 words - 5 pages A Comparison of Dover Beach by Matthew Arnold and Prayer Before Brith by Louis MacNeice 'Dover Beach' by Matthew Arnold, written in 1867, and 'Prayer Before Birth' written in 1951 by Louis MacNeice share many similarities despite being written nearly on hundred years apart from each other. This essay will explore the issues and ideas that both poems share, in addition to drawing attention to some of the key differences

Importance Of Religion In A Lesson Before You Die

2168 words - 9 pages A Fatalistic Predisposition before Settling In In an 1973 interview conducted by Forrest Ingraham and Barbara Steinberg, Ernest J. Gaines states that although he is not devoutly religious, it is his belief that “for you to survive, you must have something greater than what you are, whether it’s religion or communism, or capitalism or something else, but it must be something above what you are” (Gaines and Lowe 52). When applied to the narrator