A Comparison Of Mrs. Tilchers Class And Death Of A Naturalist Coleg Gwent Assignment

1073 words - 5 pages

Appreciating Literature
A Comparison of Mrs. Tilcher’s Class
and death of a naturalist
Kerry Mears | English Literature | 8th November 2017
The two poems are both tragic in the sense of that they are both about loss of innocence, loss of childhood. As you read them you get the feeling that they are reminiscing on their childhoods and the things that bought them both joy and sadness.
Out of the two poems I found myself drawn more towards Mrs. Tilcher’s Class written by: Carol Ann Duffy.
The reason I preferred this poem is because there are things mentioned that took me back and got me thinking about my own childhood, especially the following quotes “The chalky pyramids rubbed in to dust, A window opened with a long pole, The classroom glowed like a sweetshop, A good gold star by your name”. To me this screams primary and junior school.
As it shows growth from childhood through to adolescence I found this in the following quotes “the laugh of a bell swung by a child” and then from the last stanza “ you ran through the gates, impatient to be grown, as the sky split open in to a thunderstorm”. This poem also uses a feature called sensory imagery, the sentence that jumped out to me containing this feature is “ A xylophones nonsense is heard from another form”. As it reminded me of being in a class when I needed to concentrate in junior school and primary school classes were just messing around on the instrument during a music lesson. That being said the second poem The Death of a Naturalist written by: Seamus Heaney shows similar themes as this poem also describes youth and loss of innocence. The child in the first stanza has a fascination of nature and countryside especially with frogspawn and frogs. Going by the quote “But best of all was the warm thick slobber of frogspawn that grew like clotted water, you could tell the weather by the frogs too they were yellow in the sun and brown in the rain”.
The metaphors in both poems both show growth the following quotes to prove this are “As the sky split open in to a thunderstorm” and “ Here every spring I would fill jampots of jellied specks”. The form of this poem however is different to In Mrs. Tilcher’s Class as there are only 2 stanza’s and they both show unpredictability and they are both chaotic. The narrative points of view on both poems are adults reflecting on their childhood. However The Death of a Naturalist reminded me more of my grandparents back garden especially being around the garden pond during the spring and summer months.
Both poems also describe growth through mentions of the time of year, “All year the flax-dam festered in the heart of the townland”, which is a sentence from Death of a Naturalist and then from In Mrs. Tilcher’s Class “Over the Easter term the inky tadpoles changed from commas in to exclamation marks”, “That feverish July, the air tasted of electricity” The sentence “A rough boy told you how you were born, you kicked him, but you stared at your parents, appalled,...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of Mrs. Tilchers Class and Death of a Naturalist - coleg gwent - assignment

Commentary On "Death Of A Naturalist"

1026 words - 5 pages In the poem "Death of a Naturalist", Seamus Heaney seems to suggest that humanisation and simplification of essentially foreign and incomprehensible phenomena often occurs through education and authority. Through the dramatic contrast in tone and diction between the first and second stanzas, Heaney emphasizes how observations of the harsh reality and threat of natural hierarchies can shatter childlike naïveté and admiration for the

Seamus Heaney's Poems: Death of a Naturalist and Advancement of Learning and Roe Deer

2996 words - 12 pages Seamus Heaney's Poems: Death of a Naturalist and Advancement of Learning and Roe Deer The assignment that I will be undertaking is based on the poems Death of a Naturalist, Advancement of Learning and Roe Deer. The Nobel Prize winning poet Seamus Heaney, who was Irish, wrote the two poems Death of a Naturalist and Advancement of Learning. Ted Hughes, who has written a variety of stories, one of which was the famous Iron

Growing Up in the Poem Death of a Naturalist

866 words - 3 pages 'Death of a Naturalist' is concerned with growing up and loss of innocence. The poet vividly describes a childhood experience that precipitates a change in the boy from the receptive and protected innocence of childhood to the fear and uncertainty of adolescence. Haney organizes his poem in two sections, corresponding to the change in the boy. By showing that this change is linked with education and learning, Haney is concerned with the

Compare and Contrast Death of a Naturalist, An Advancement of Learning

1474 words - 6 pages Compare and Contrast Death of a Naturalist, An Advancement of Learning and The Early Purges. In this essay I am going to discuss ‘Death of a Naturalist’, ‘An Advancement of Learning’ and ‘The Early Purges’ by Seamus Heaney. I will focus on the similarities and differences between these poems in terms of what they are about, their language and themes. The first out of the three poems by Heaney that I have studied is ‘Death of a

Explore the ways Seamus Heaney presents emotions and experiences in “Digging” and “Death of a Naturalist”

672 words - 3 pages a bottle”, as it shows that he cares about his well-being. In “Death of a Naturalist”, Heaney refers to a male frog as a “bullfrog”, this is quite mature language, so this shows an element of pride that he has learned this. Heaney’s relationship with “Miss Walls” is clearly a tentative one, this is shown when she tells her students about “the mammy and daddy frog” as she is evidently using immature language to avoid touching upon a taboo subject

Discuss the poems Death of a Naturalist and Personal Helicon by

1140 words - 5 pages Discuss the poems Death of a Naturalist and Personal Helicon by Seamus Heaney Both poems examined revolve around the youth of Seamus Heaney. In both poems the reader is told about Heaney's memories as a child and his progressing memories as he grows up and understands his surroundings more from an adults perspective. This essay will look at and evaluate how the adult has been moulded from his childhood experiences, Discuss and explain

A Comparison of Mrs. Hale and Mr. Wright in Trifles, by Susan Glaspell

1342 words - 5 pages make Mrs. Hale feel better when she feels guilty for not paying Mrs. Wright a visit. They both have a mutual respect for one another. Because of the way the two speak to one another, it is obvious that Mrs. Peters holds her in some high regard. In the play Trifles, a handful of people are thrust into a situation that allows us to compare their personalities. The comparison of Mrs. Hale and Mr. Wright is captivating because both characters have

Comparison of Death of a Salesman and The Glass Menagerie

869 words - 3 pages contrastively, of Arthur Miller’s Death of a Salesman along with Tennessee Williams’ The Glass Menagerie and each playwright’s application of non- realistic technique. The first major transition in Death of a Salesman transpires as the main character, Willy Loman, is imagining that his teenage sons, though now both in their 30’s are washing his fairly new Chevy automobile. The audience is gradually led into transition by a

The Ways Youth is Lost in Death of a Naturalist, Cold Knap Lake, On My First Sonne and The Song of the Old Mother

1270 words - 5 pages The Ways Youth is Lost in Death of a Naturalist, Cold Knap Lake, On My First Sonne and The Song of the Old Mother In 'Death of a Naturalist', 'Cold Knap Lake', 'On My First Sonne' and 'The Song of the Old Mother', each poet writes about a loss of youth, or a sense of youth no longer being present. The writer of each poem writes about childhood and children are portrayed. In 'Death of a Naturalist', Seamus Heaney writes

Creating a Culture of Empowerment and Accountability - Class - Assignment

1596 words - 7 pages school culture was. There were multiple issues in the school which disgrace the culture of SMdP. Like late arrival of students was the part of school culture. There were physical fights among the students. There was no mutual respect for teachers and class mates. As both were not concerning with respect it’s obvious when a school culture was not representing respect among teacher then eventually students will also disrespect each other as they were in

A Comparison of the Dream in Death of a Salesman, Ellis Island, and America and I

1451 words - 6 pages The Dream in Death of a Salesman, Ellis Island, and America and I       The American dream is as varied as the people who populate America. The play The Death of a Salesman by Arthur Miller, the poem "Ellis Island" by Joseph Bruchac, and the poem "America and I" by Anzia Yezierska illustrate different perspectives of the American dream. All three authors show some lines of thought on what the freedom inherent in the American dream

Similar Essays

A Comparison Between Death Of A Naturalist And Digging

865 words - 3 pages A Comparison Between Death of a Naturalist and Digging For GCSE course work we have to compare two poems from a foreign culture. The two poems we picked were both by the popular Irish poem ‘Seamus Heaney.’ The two poems we’re looking at ‘Death of a Naturalist’ and ‘Digging’ could be seen as autobiographical. ‘Death of a Naturalist’ is basically about a young boy who had a keenness for nature, which has disintegrated throughout a summer

A Comparison Of Heaney "Death Of A Naturalist" And Larkin "First Sight"

1084 words - 4 pages The initial observation is that both poems contain connotations of nature, Death of a Naturalist focuses on frogs and First sight on Lambs. Both contain two stanzas, however the structure is not as standard in Death of a Naturalist as it contains a stanza of 21 lines followed by one of 12 whereas First sight has two stanzas of 7 lines.There are images of winter and death present in First Sight, "Meet a vast unwelcome, know nothing but a sunless

An Appreciation Of Death Of A Naturalist

595 words - 2 pages ?Death of a naturalist? is a poem about growing up and loss of innocence. The poem is organised into two sections, which follows the boy through childhood. The boy becomes a reflective Adult, from an unquestioning boy. It seems Seamus Heaney is concerned with the progression from innocence to experience. This is shown in the first paragraph when he talks like a child: ?Miss Walls would tell us how.? This shows the fact that the child is in

Seamus Heaney's Blackberry Picking And Death Of A Naturalist

2078 words - 8 pages Seamus Heaney's Blackberry-Picking and Death of a Naturalist Blackberry Picking gives a lucid description of basically, picking blackberries. However it is really about hope and disappointment and how things never quite live up to expectations. ‘Blackberry picking’ becomes a metaphor for other experiences such as the lack of optimism already being realised at an early age and the sense of naivety looked upon from an