A Comparison Of Pride In King Lear And The Duchess Of Malfi

1568 words - 6 pages

The Sin of Pride Exposed in King Lear, and The Duchess of Malfi  

In this brief monograph, we shall be hunting down and examining various creatures from the bestiary of Medieval/Renaissance thought. Among these are the fierce lion of imperious, egotistical power, a pair of fantastic peacocks, one of vanity, one of preening social status, and the docile lamb of humility. The lion and the peacocks are of the species known as pride, while the lamb is of an entirely different, in fact antithetical race, that of humility and forgiveness. The textual regions we shall be exploring include the diverse expanses, from palace to heath, of William Shakespeare, the dark, sinister Italy of John Webster, and the perfumed lady's chambers of Ben Jonson and Robert Herrick.

The tragic hero of Shakespeare's King Lear is brought down, like all tragic heroes, by one fatal flaw, in this case pride, as well as pride's sister, folly. It is the King's egotistical demand for total love and, what's more, protestations of such from the daughter who loves him most, that set the stage for his downfall, as well as calling to the minds of the Elizabethan audience of Shakespeare's day the above-cited biblical edict. This daughter, Cordelia, can be seen as the humble lamb mentioned earlier, and her love and filial devotion go not only beyond that of her sisters (which is nil) but beyond words, thus enraging the proud king whose subsequent petulant rebukes extend to a bit of ironic Freudian projection: "Let pride, which she calls plainness, marry her" (I.i.125). Here, Shakespeare is emphasizing Lear's pride by having him indulge in the common tendency of despising in others (and in this case wrongly) what one is most guilty of oneself. Lear's rash pride is also underscored in the exposition of the first scene by Kent, who feels it his duty to speak out "when power to flattery bows" (I.i.144). Only pride bows to flattery, and Kent is in essence telling Lear that his pride is getting the better of him.

Another aspect of pride which appears in King Lear, as well as Webster's The Duchess of Malfi, is that of the preoccupation with reputation and social status. In the latter play, it can be seen in Ferdinand's speech to the Duchess in act III, scene ii, in which he tells her an allegorical story about reputation, love, and death (See appendix). Given the Duke's choleric disposition and unnaturally obsessive fixation on his sister's sexual activity, it is not altogether certain how far his speech is motivated by pride and how much it is a product of another mortal sin (not treated here), lust. All the same, it is indicative of an overall world view in which pride of place is woven into the social fabric of the time. (Indeed, things are not so very different today, 400 years later--Plus ca change...)

The Duchess offers up her own little allegorical tale at the end of act IV, scene iii in which she relates the fable of the salmon and the dogfish to her murderer-to-be,...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of Pride in King Lear and The Duchess of Malfi

A Comparison Between the Plots of King Lear and Much Ado about Nothing

1194 words - 5 pages from his position of power, offering each of his daughters a share of his land in exchange for proclaiming their love for him. Cordelia refuses to do so, and is banished. In the alternative plot in King Lear, Edmund is turning his father on his legitimate brother, Edgar. In Much Ado about Nothing, the rising action begins as soon as Claudio lays eyes on Hero. From here he begins to court her, hoping to marry her. Now in comparison, these plays

Othello & King Lear - A comparison

1210 words - 5 pages is recorded in the Stratfordregister of 1654 grew up into the man who wrote such famousplays still known all over the world, as we type.Imagery used in Othello and King Lear.In Othello and King Lear Shakespeare uses a lot ofimagery. The main image in Othello is that of animals inaction, preying upon one another, mischievous, lascivious,cruel or suffering, and through these, the general sense ofpain and unpleasantness is much increased and kept

Analyzing Shakespeare´s Account of Human Nature in King Lear in Comparison With Other Authors

1697 words - 7 pages portray that human nature is either entirely good or entirely evil. He seems to suggest, however, that it is not impossible for one to move from one end of the spectrum of human nature to the other, as multiple characters go through somewhat of a metamorphosis where their nature is changed. In this paper I analyze and present Shakespeare’s account of human nature in King Lear in comparison with other authors that we have read throughout our year

Women in The Duchess of Malfi and The Changeling

1853 words - 7 pages Missing Works Cited TWO WOMEN AND ONE FATE The Duchess in John Webster’s tragic play, The Duchess of Malfi, and Beatrice Joanna in Thomas Middleton and William Rowley’s The Changeling, are both strong women living in a male-dominated society. The two women attempt to free themselves from this subordination by choosing to love that they desire. Both pay with their lives for this

The Duchess of Malfi: A True Villain

1994 words - 8 pages According to Webster’s dictionary, the definition of ‘villain’ is “a character in a story, movie, etc., who does bad things” (Merriam-Webster). In John Webster’s play, The Duchess of Malfi, the plot line revolves around a duchess and her two brothers. The Duchess of Malfi is a very twisted and complicated story where the characters are not as they seem. One of the most significant parts of the story line is that the characters that appear to be

Comparison Shakespears plays: King Lear vs. Hamlet

1107 words - 4 pages love over actual devotion. Nevertheless, he inspires loyalty in subjects such as Gloucester, Kent, Cordelia, and Edgar, all of whom risk their lives for him. The tragedy illustrates the complete chaos which reigns in a state not governed by a strong ruler. Shakespeare constructed King Lear on an old folk story which exists in many countries and versions for example our version 'Gold over salt' which has same plot but ending of a fairy tale.Hamlet

The Theme of Incest in The Duchess of Malfi

922 words - 4 pages One can begin the discussion on the theme of incest in ‘The Duchess of Malfi’ by understanding the social conception of ‘incest’. Talcott Parsons says-“ it is not so much the prohibition of incest in its negative aspect(maintaining sexual relations) …(Instead) Incest is withdrawal from the obligation to contribute to the formation and maintenance of supra-familial bonds on which major economic, political and religious functions of the society

An Analysis of Bosola in 'the Duchess of Malfi'

1242 words - 5 pages suggest he is a convincing character, Bosola, at times, falls into set roles of the Jacobean Tragedy; malcontent, satirist and avenger. Webster uses Bosola to fulfill these conventions of the genre and to direct and drive the plot, especially after the Duchess' death. Even though Webster uses Bosola in this way, he is more than a mere tool as his character extends beyond the established roles of the genre, giving a more complete character

Consequences of Ambition Exposed in Macbeth, The Maid's Tragedy, and The Duchess of Malfi

3336 words - 13 pages a contemporary catchphrase like "The sky's the limit" or the Army slogan "Be all you can be"-the stuff of graduation cards and commencement addresses-promote ambition. Yet ambition has not always been valued. Seventeenth-century Jacobean drama often casts it in a negative light. Unbridled ambition yields deadly outcomes, the literature suggests. Macbeth, The Maid's Tragedy, and The Duchess of Malfi each illustrate the severe consequences of

John Webster's Play The Duchess of Malfi

2660 words - 11 pages John Webster's Play The Duchess of Malfi In the opening of The Duchess of Malfi takes place between Delio and Antonio, a steward of the Duchess and his friend. Webster makes his audience aware that Antonio has journeyed outside Malfi, to France. The words "France, Frenchman, French" all appear within the first four lines of the text, a blunt indicator to ensure that the audience, however inattentive, grasps the point that Antonio has

John Webster's "The Duchess of Malfi.".

1234 words - 5 pages woo because none dare woo us..." Although some may read the line as the Duchess's way of justifying her straightforward propositioning of Antonio, it could also be her way of commanding her life. The Duchess's tenacious nature is clearly illustrated in Act III scene ii, is a recurring theme and becomes even more apparent as the Duchess faces her executioners. She remains strong and unyielding declaring " I am Duchess of Malfi still." Continuing

Similar Essays

A Comparison Of The Outcomes Of Othello And King Lear

558 words - 2 pages The Tragic Outcome of Othello and King Lear   Two Sources        In Othello and Lear, Shakespeare contrasts two endings that tragedy can bring.  As Lear is thrown from kingship, he begins to see through his previous misconceptions about love, justice, and the nature of authority.  Othello, on the other hand, held no real misconceptions about the world.  He begins the tragedy nearly

William Shakespeare's Twelfth Night And John Webster's "The Duchess Of Malfi" Comparison Of The Role That Women Played

1539 words - 6 pages works portray women as sexual objects of male desire. In Webster's play, Ferdinand's incestuous longing for his sister, The Duchess of Malfi, is based on sick feelings of lust towards her. His sexual innuendos are evident throughout the play:Ferdinand: And women like the part, which, like the lamprey,Hath ne'er a bone in'tDuchess: Fie, sir!Ferdinand: Nay,I mean the tongue [Act 1, Scene ii](http://www.english-literature.org/essays/webster.html

A Comparison Of "Old Goriot" And "King Lear"

2020 words - 8 pages untimely death at the hands of a friend of Vautrin's. Cordelia's husband, the King of France, attacks England in order to help Lear in his fight with his daughters. Similarly Mme Couture, Victorine's self-appointed guardian and friend, aids her in her battle to win back her father's affections. Lear discovers quite quickly that he has made a fatal error in judgement by favouring Goneril and Regan over Cordelia. His realisation sends him mad

A Comparison Of The Plot Development Of King Lear And Much Ado About Nothing

1179 words - 5 pages development. Shakespeare uses a lot of dramatic irony in his plays, and this always helps the reader get set up for what is coming after that. The play King Lear and the play Much Ado About Nothing by William Shakespeare each have their own use of plot development, but they also share some qualities as well. The play King Lear by William Shakespeare was written with a very well thought out plot development that makes it a very intriguing story. “The