A Comparison Of The Gift Of The Magi, By O. Henry And Country Lovers, By Nadine Gordimer

2519 words - 10 pages

The purpose of this paper is to compare and contrast two stories. I have chosen The Gift of the Magi, by O. Henry and Country Lovers, by Nadine Gordimer to accomplish this assignment. My intentions are to compare the author’s writing style, their differences in setting and theme, and note similarities as well. I will focus this paper on not only technical aspects of the author’s writing style, but their use of symbolism in their writing as well. The love the protagonists felt for each in both stories differed as well as the gifts they shared. In O. Henry’s love story, the love between the main characters was sweet and pure. Even though the characters were poor, their love generated precious gifts. Nadine Gordimer’s love story involved a darker theme of forbidden love during apartheid, the gifts given were in secrecy and harbored lies. Of all gifts given, it is not the cost of the gift that gives it worth; it is the condition of the giver’s heart and their intent that determines its true purpose and worth.
Each author chose to write his or her story in third-person point of view. This view made it possible for the theme of the story to be revealed with an omniscient tone. Each author made a change to first-person when needed to help reveal the resolution. By using point of view this way, both authors were able to hold the reader’s interest until the end. For O. Henry, it helped reveal a special love that made his story as precious as its characters. Nadine Gordimer did the same in ending her story with Thebedi’s interview. Even though the story was darker, it gave the reader a feeling of a hopeful new life for Thebedi.
O. Henry wrote “The Gift of the Magi” set in the time in which he lived, 1906. Nadine Gordimer wrote Country Lovers in 1975, which was also the time she lived. Even though these times were very different, some characters in each of the stories shared common ground in being underprivileged. The love felt between the main characters was innocent and pure at first. Both authors used symbolism of gifts to build the exposition of their story.
Gifts given have many languages, types, and nuances. People like giving gifts to their loved ones and friends. A gift’s worth is determined by how close a person is to the person being gifted. Parents and children exchange gifts, as do siblings, friends, teachers, co-workers. The gifts I give to my family are different from gifts to my co-workers. The amount of money spent and time invested in obtaining the gift also differs. Most often, my co-workers receive hand-made gifts such as baked goods, or chocolate spoons to dip in their coffee. Even though these gifts are hand-made, they are still worth as much as store bought gifts. Godbout (1998) states “Today, still, nothing can be initiated or undertaken, can thrive or function, if it is not nourished by the gift. This, to begin at the beginning, is true of life itself, which, at least for the moment, is neither bought nor obtained by force but...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of The Gift of the Magi, by O. Henry and Country Lovers, by Nadine Gordimer

The Shocking Truth in Nadine Gordimer’s Country Lovers

753 words - 4 pages prevent it just floored me. It saddens me greatly of the cultural differences that are present in a South African society. In this story, Country Lovers by Nadine Gordimer, it is clear this is a story of inter-racial relationships and the intolerance held by the culture of South Africa in the 1970s (Clugston, 2010). We see how the innocence of children do not see the differences that are so obvious to adults. We see that love can come from

Escape From the Dread of the Future in "The Defeated" and Willa Cather's "Paul Case" by Nadine Gordimer

801 words - 3 pages Both Nadine Gordimer's "The Defeated" and Willa Cather's "Paul Case" are about characters who dread the life they see around them. Fearing this outcome, they strive desperately to put as much space as possible between their present circumstances and their future dreams.Miriam and Paul use similar defense mechanisms to deal with the realities in which they live. This mechanism is denial. On her birthday, instead of having a party in her lowly

Analysis of The Duel by O. Henry

729 words - 3 pages . people who aren’t from our city don’t know what it’s like to live here, they don’t understand what it takes out of someone to constantly put up with the stench, the noise, the exorbitant prices of everything & the long unending winters. In the duel written by When O Henry (real name William Sydney Porter) which depicts the lives of two non-natives who emigrated to the big apple from a city located near the west coast. One studied business the

“Once Upon a Time.” by Nadine Gordimer

719 words - 3 pages but typical. Instead of dealing with characteristics synonymous with fairy tales, the author injects an issue that plagues modern day society: security, fear and peace of mind. Gordmier also comments on racial discrimination (that was and is still a problem for South Africa and nearly all other countries).The story opens with Gordimer awakened by a bump in the night and cannot go back to sleep due to her fear (a similar situation many people have

Gift Of The Magi Analysis

855 words - 3 pages criticisms made by Current-Garcia, Peel and Voss, which all appreciate the significance Henry placed on both the concepts of romantic love and self-sacrificial love."The Gift of the Magi" concerns of the mutual self-sacrifice between husband and wife, evincing the notion that "love conquers all". 'O. Henry crystallized dramatically what the world in all its stored-up wisdom knows to be of fundamental value in ordinary family life. Unselfish love

July’s People by Nadine Gordimer

2193 words - 9 pages "July’s People" by Nadine Gordimer In July’s People, Nadine Gordimer gives a very detailed and knowledgeable explanation of the political turmoil within South Africa. By expressing the emotions of a family involved in the deteriorating situation and the misunderstandings between blacks and whites, she adds a very personal and emotional touch, which allows the reader to understand the true horror and terror these people experienced

"Africa Emergent" by Nadine Gordimer

554 words - 2 pages Some hundred years ago, the oppressed broke away from the oppressor. They fought for the freedoms that we have today. Through different movements such as Black power, Black pride, and Black is beautiful, we've come to see the true power that we hold as individuals and a group. When the oppressed secedes from the oppressor, they must free themselves of oppression. Nadine Gordimer explores the theme of defying oppression through the use of

The Gift of the Magi Theme Analysis

939 words - 4 pages Jim went through a lot in order to show their love and make sure the other had a gift they would cherish, and to do this they had to make a major sacrifice because of their poverty- selling the item of theirs they loved. O`Henry is a talented author who has many stories and novels with distinct and ideal themes. Some say that the situation in “The Gift of the Magi,” was the same in the end as it was in the beginning. However, the narrator suggests that their act of love and sacrifice has added value to their relationship.

once upon a time by nadine gordimer - college - essay

1463 words - 6 pages story of an intruder (white supremacy) and the havoc he wreaks. Gordimer ends "Once Upon a Time" with violence. A Literary Analysis of Nadine Gordimer’s “Once Upon a Time” By Emily Hines In Nadine Gorider’s “Once Upon a Time”, the most important element is its theme. The entire story is set about telling its readers that human beings create their own destruction. The setting of the two parts of the story is important as well as the ironic structure

"My Son's Story" By Nadine Gordimer: Themes and issues in the novel (when private "affairs" become public)

2276 words - 9 pages , particularly his son, Will, a writer. ''The book is really about the problems the ordinary forms of love bring within a particular context,'' said Ms. Gordimer, ''in which love of country is inextricably bound up with these other types of love. And by love of country, I don't mean gung-ho patriotism, but involvement with the time.'' Ms. Gordimer, who is 66 years old and lives in Johannesburg, says she cannot speculate on how South Africans will

Two Short Stories: The Gift of Magi and A Telephone Call

1300 words - 6 pages In the short stories “The Gift f Magi” by O. Henry and “A telephone Call” by Dorothy Parker, two women are troubled by how their significant others view them. While O. Henry’s Della is able to see that Jim is not touched, Parker’s narrator is left with uncertainty because her significant other does not call back, stuffing her with skepticism. In O. Henry’s “The Gift of Magi”, a young couple in love has to get surprise gifts for each other

Similar Essays

The Gift Of The Magi And Two Thanksgiving Day Gentlemen By O. Henry

1724 words - 7 pages To understand the characters in O. Henry stories we must understand what motivates each character to do the things they do. How stories that seem similar and have a common theme can change drastically when we begin to analyze their subtle differences. The O. Henry stories “The Gift of the Magi” and “Two Thanksgiving Day Gentlemen,” both follow a similar theme. The stories are about sacrifices that people make in order to give someone a better

"The Gift Of The Magi" By O. Henry: The Moral Of The Story

803 words - 3 pages The definition of love is " a deep, tender, ineffable feeling of affection and solicitude toward a person." In "The Gift of the Magi," the two main characters possess a love for each other that is so strong that they are willing to sacrifice their greatest treasures for each other, with no regrets. Also, they do not obsess over superficial things like appearances. Therefore, the moral of the story is that it is not the material things that

Gender Roles And Marriage In The Proposal By Chekhov And Country Lovers By Gordimer

2650 words - 11 pages In the following essay I will compare and contrast gender roles and marriage between “The Proposal” by Anton Chekhov and “Country Lovers” by Nadine Gordimer to showing how women tried to survive in controlling their identity. This essay will compare and contrast each of the characters used by two very different writers. The early 1900’s era was not kind to people in their struggle for what they tried to accomplish with their lives. Nadine

Comparison Essay On "Gift Of The Magi" And "The Necklace"

1299 words - 5 pages Comparison Essay The two short stories, "The gift of the Magi" written by O. Henry and "The necklace written by Guy de Maupassant are both composed of two young, beautiful women Mathilde and Della. Even though they are in different composed stories that have similar characteristics that convey throughout the story such as, they are both emotionally and financially depressed, have loving husbands, and both want to achieve something in an