A Comparison Of Two Accounts Of Life After Death

992 words - 4 pages

A Comparison of Two Accounts of Life After Death
Materialism is the view that the body and mind are inseparable, and
for there to be life after death then the body must be resurrected,
this is much like the Christian view of life after death.

John Hick was a materialist and he argued that, in certain
circumstances, it would be possible that the dead could exist as
themselves after death, if an exact replica were to appear. Hick uses
thought experiments to show the person who dies in this World is the
same person who is resurrected in the next. He uses examples of using
a character called John Smith. If John smith were to disappear from
his home in the USA and then suddenly appear in India with exactly the
same characteristics, there would be no doubt that this is the same
John Smith. Also is John Smith died, but the suddenly reappeared again
in India with all the same characteristics then there would be no
doubt that it was the same John Smith. Again if John Smith died but
then God re-created John Smith in the next world then he would be the
same person.

This idea of the Soul and being inseparable from the body is also
voiced by Gilbert Ryle who described it as the ‘ghost inside the
machine,’ but he also denies that a persons characteristics are
determined by the soul. This thought is contrasted by Dualism.

Dualism is a belief where the mind/soul determines the personality and
the body is the shell for that personality. The body is contingent and
will therefore decay, but the mind is immortal and will exist forever.
It is also believed that the soul is associated with higher realities
such as truth, goodness, justice and contemplation, and if a man
spends his life contemplating these realities then the soul can enter
eternity after death.

This view is supported by Aquinas. According to Aquinas the soul
operates independently of the body, and only things that are divisible
are open to decay. The Soul is not divisible, unlike the body and will
therefore decay and die whilst the soul lives on. This view of the
Soul been separate to the body was accepted by Descartes too.
Descartes said that it was conceivable for us to...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of Two Accounts of Life After Death

A Comparison of Two Newspapers

1300 words - 5 pages A Comparison of Two Newspapers When we first look at these two newspapers, the first thing that comes to our attention is the different differences of the front pages of the two. “The times” has a more sophisticated feel to it, while the “Daily Mirror” seems trendier with its pictures and stylish typeface. While both papers share the same headline (about David Blunkett and the visa of his former lover’s nanny), they

A Comparison of Two Advertisements Essay

1820 words - 7 pages A Comparison of Two Advertisements Advertising is a way of publicizing a product that you want to sell. There are many of different things to advertise, such as clothes, shoes, cars, watches etc. Advertising promotes the latest goods that are out in the shops. Advertising effects me everyday because every time I see a advertisement it attracts me to the product and I think about buying it or saving up to buy it

A Comparison of Two Advertisements

1925 words - 8 pages A Comparison of Two Advertisements Advertising is a tool used by businesses to inform us about their products and to persuade us to buy them. Advertisements are all around us: on billboards, in magazines, in newspapers, on the Internet, on airplanes, in shop windows, on posters and banners, on leaflets and so on. Advertisements attempt to persuade the subconscious that our lives would be improved if we bought the

A Comparison of Two Advertisements

1703 words - 7 pages A Comparison of Two Advertisements Advert 1 - Pulsar watches I found this advert in GQ magazine. GQ magazines demographics are young single or married working men, from around 20 to 40. The Articles in this magazine vary from fitness to fashion to bikini models to interviews with such stars as Collin Farrell and Thierry Henry. The advertising agency have decided to target the range of watches at this group of

A Comparison of Two Newspapers

827 words - 3 pages A Comparison of Two Newspapers There are many tabloid and broadsheet newspapers but now however there are online versions of these popular papers. Two examples, one tabloid and one broadsheet, are The Mirror and The Guardian. When newspapers first came out there were no online versions as the Internet was not invented yet, and therefore was a very basic but effective form of communication. Times move on and therefore

A Comparison of Two Advertisements - 1090 words

1090 words - 4 pages A Comparison of Two Advertisements I have looked at 2 advertisements, one is from 'Sugar' magazine and the other from 'Style' magazine. The advertisement from Sugar, is for 'L'Oreal Paris Colour Pulse Hair Dye'; the advertisement from Style is for 'Clinique Autumn 2004 close up on lips: modern metallics'. All advertisements are aimed at specific target audiences and as such require different ideas, linguistic devices

A Comparison of Two Advertisements - 3161 words

3161 words - 13 pages A Comparison of Two Advertisements I am going to compare two advertisements which I took from the magazine 'Marie Claire.' 'Marie Claire's target audience is young, sophisticated women, aged 18-30s. In the magazine, there is lots about fashion, beauty, relationships and general women's issues. I have chosen two different advertisements to compare. Both advertisements have very different, effective persuasive techniques

A Comparison of Two Murderers

1388 words - 6 pages In the Edgar Allan Poe stories "The Cask of Amontillado" and "The Tell-Tale Heart" the most prominent and important themes that are used are death, logic, and irony. The characters of the narrator and Montresor in these stories are both coldblooded murders that kill for selfish, and inane reasons who firmly believe that their actions are justified even though their rationalizations only make sense in their own minds. They both try to convince

Compare the accounts of two major supermarkets

3287 words - 13 pages Introduction to ReportThe attached report will analyse and compare the financial status of two UK supermarkets, Morrisons plc and Somerfield plc, for a potential investor who wishes to become a minor shareholder in one of the two company's. To perform this investigation the 2002 financial accounts of both company's have been used, this information will also include the financial data from the 2001 period, for further comparison between years

Classic Slave Naratives, A comparison of the accounts of Gustavus Vassa and Frederick Douglass

669 words - 3 pages ' stories are filled with details of struggles slaves endured on a daily basis. They are well written accounts of slave life. Both Authors' backgrounds and circumstances differed, but the message of the brutality of slavery is identical.

The Deathly Facts of Life: A Theme of Inevitable and Unexpected Death in Two Gothic Works

755 words - 3 pages AP English Lang/Com27 November 2013The Deathly Facts of Life: A Theme of Inevitable and Unexpected Death in Two Gothic WorksDeath is an aspect of life that applies to all, and the end of life signifies an entrance into the unknown. Horror movies and Gothic literature often include death since it invokes fear and grief. In both Alfred Hitchcock's Psycho and Edgar Allan Poe's "The Masque of the Red Death", dark characters contribute to developing

Similar Essays

Compare And Contrast Two Beliefs About Life After Death. Assess Which Of These Two Views May Provide A Stronger Philosophical Basis For Belief In Life After Death?

1402 words - 6 pages One definition of death is the “the complete and permanent cessation of all vital functions in a living creature, the end if life”. All philosophers agree that our earthly life in our physical form will end; however philosophers disagree on the meaning of “end of life” as many people agree on death as the end of our existence however while others argue that we continue in some form after death. Many ideas relating to our

Compare Two Poems With Like Themes Comparison Of Robert Frost's "After Apple Picking" And "Stopping By The Woods On A Snowy Evening"

639 words - 3 pages Robert Lee Frost, born in San Francisco, Mar. 26, 1874; he died in Boston, Jan. 29, 1963. He was one of America's leading 20th-century poets and a four-time winner of the Pulitzer Prize. An essentially pastoral poet often associated with rural New England, Frost wrote poems whose philosophical dimensions transcend any region. In a lot of Robert Frost's poems he talks about nature. Two particular poems of his, "After Apple Picking" and "Stopping

Comparison Of Two Short Stories "The Yellow Wall Paper" V. "Death By Landscape"

1303 words - 5 pages "Death by Landscape" v. "The Yellow Wallpaper""She was tired a lot, as if she was living not one life but two: her own, and another, shadowy life that hovered around her and would not let itself be realized…" (391). For many, the "shadowy life" of mental illness hinders one's ability to be happy and whole. Mental illness and delusion has been a fascinating but devastating topic throughout human existence, and as such, has provided much

Life After The Death Of Our Sun

1166 words - 5 pages drawing closer to the end of its life, and the giving us all the more reasons to venture into space exploration and the possibilities life outside the realm of earth.What will happen after half a billion years from now? The same warmth of the sun that once fostered our birth will be threatening our very existence. Sun will be running out of its Hydrogen fuel, and starting to burn its Helium ash (a byproduct of Hydrogen burning). The rate of energy