A Comparison Of Viktor Frankl’s Man’s Search For Meaning And Sigmund Freud’s The Future Of An Illusion.

1002 words - 5 pages

Similar Illustrations
Sigmund Freud and Viktor Frankl have both experienced similarly dramatic social and political changes within the early twentieth century Austrian environment, but their psychological theories are very different when compared. Frankl mentions that his development of logotherapy stems from Freud’s psychoanalysis but puts much more emphasis on individual control over the self in regards to attitude and interpretation of events. Logotherapy, or therapy through defining meaning, touches on many of the facets of positive psychology as developed by Martin Seligman and Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi. Frankl identifies the three stages of mental distress as an inmate travels through a concentration camp: shock and disgust, apathetic and emotional death for protection, and following liberation is a period of almost disillusionment and disconnect with society. These stages Frankl experienced and observed personally throughout his years as an inmate in Nazi run concentration camps.
Frankl stresses the importance of finding meaning in suffering and continuous hope of liberation in regards to increasing the chances of survival in such a dehumanizing and disease ridden environment. Meaning has also been emphasized in positive psychology but termed differently, called resiliency. Resiliency was studied directly in regards to Holocaust survivors; they were constantly finding new ways to challenge their minds in order to maintain their humanity. Frankl mentions his own experience of rewriting his scientific paper that was confiscated the first day of his imprisonment, an act that was proven to give him meaning to survive through his trials. As Frankl mentions multiple times through his explanation of logotherapy and meaning in life, one quote summarizes the entire novel. Nietzche’s quote: He who has a why to live can bear with almost any how. Sources of meaning according to Frankl can be categorized as follows: creating work or doing a deed, experiencing or encountering a variation of love, and the attitude an individual takes to unavoidable suffering. All three are also mentioned in positive psychology similarly, as experiencing fulfilling work, finding and nurturing love or relationships, and one’s personal demeanor to uncontrollable circumstances.
Freud determines meaning as something much more different that personally derived. In fact, meaning according to Freud is controlled by civilization and the society surrounding the individual. Freud asserts that civilization is imposed upon the resisting masses by a minority group seeking control over nature and instincts, such that are destructive and anti-social. The ideal society that Freud seems to be repeatedly referencing admittedly is nonexistent; but this ideal civilization is one that exhibits care and nurture towards its citizens in order to circumvent the natural and destructive tendencies of the individual. Since this ideal does not exist, coercion is taken by the...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of Viktor Frankl’s Man’s Search for Meaning and Sigmund Freud’s The Future of an Illusion.

Viktor Frankl's Search for Meaning in his work Man's Search for Meaning

1296 words - 5 pages In his work Man's Search for Meaning, Viktor E. Frankl narrates his experience in a concentration camp which led to his development of logotherapy, a form of existential psychoanalysis. He was an abused prisoner in Nazi concentration camps, and there he found himself contemplating to his own bare existence. His entire family was killed in these camps, and his possessions as well as much of his life's work were taken from him. In the brutal

Sigmund Freud’s Theory of Psychoanalysis

1782 words - 7 pages . Freud determines that the dream was conceived as a fantasy of revenge against her father and Frau for starting an intimate relationship when Dora has repressed feelings for Frau. In the end, Freud’s treatment of Dora is cut short when Dora abruptly decides to end treatment, an act that Freud believes was perpetrated out of vengeance. In Dora’s case, Freud believes that Dora projected her emotions towards Herr K, the neighbor, onto him, leading

Sigmund Freud’s Elements of Personality

689 words - 3 pages gratification that they were more likely to develop anxiety and seek oral gratification later in life by smoking or nail biting. (Woolfolk, 2012) Works Cited • Breger, Louis (2000). Freud: Darkness in the Midst of Vision--An Analytical Biography • Ferris, Paul (1999). Dr. Freud: A Life • Gay, Peter (1998). Freud : A Life for Our Time • Roazen, Paul (1992). Freud and His Followers

A reaction paper to freud's book "Future of an Illusion"

888 words - 4 pages Freud and ReligionFrom the beginning of human kind's existence in this universe, religion has always been an important concept of life for every civilization. In his book "Future of an Illusion", Sigmund Freud critiques religion psychoanalytically and comes to a conclusion where he thinks religion is an illusion. As an atheist, he mainly argues that mankind will be better off when they stop their meaningless belief in religions. This paper is

A Man's Search for Meaning An evaluation of Victor Frankl's Book

921 words - 4 pages A Man's Search for Meaning: Victor FranklWe all interpret our lives in individual ways. Our experiences and even our current situations play a role in how we interpret our existence. How we perceive ourselves in extremely stressful situations can greatly affect our own well- being. How concentration camp prisoners interpreted their circumstances affected if they survived or not.Many of the prisoners had to strike out their entire former lives

A Search for Hope and Meaning

879 words - 4 pages heartbreak still has the mindset of an idealist. His wish is to go to Africa and change the world. This diametrically contrasts Beneatha’s new and revised outlook towards life and humanity. Beneatha describes life as a marching circle (Hansberry, 1635). The parable being, that a person can envision and dream the grandest of possibilities, however, at the end of it all, he will end up right back where he started (1635). Fighting for hope and one’s

A Comparison of Illusion in The Cherry Orchard and A Doll's House

2033 words - 8 pages be resolved.  He ends up in a better state superficially, but internally, his refusal to accept an illusion has led to his intense dislike for himself and his moral base.  If he could have somehow reconciled his beliefs with the life he actually led, he wouldn't have ended up as bitter or sad a person like he did.         Throughout each of these plays, the main character (or characters) faced a reality that they ceased to accept, and instead

Viktor Frankl and the Development of Logotherapy

2265 words - 9 pages paper and wrote his book titled, “The Doctor and the Soul from Psychotherapy to Logotherapy". The book focused on the importance of logotherapy and existential analysis. After its publication he taught at the University of Vienna Medical School (Frankl, 2006). He then threw himself into the creation of his next book, “Man’s Search for Meaning”, a book about his psychiatric and personal observations of the concentration camps, and had completed

The True Future of an Illusion: An Analysis of Freud's Critique of Religion

1788 words - 7 pages In his book Future of an Illusion, Sigmund Freud critique uses his method of psychoanalysis on religion. By comparing the relationship between human and religion to that of a child and his parents Freud effectively demonstrates that religion is a product of the human mind. After exposing religion as a an illusion Freud concludes that humanity will be better off when it has forgone religion. This paper will argue that Freud's assertion that

The Search For Meaning and Life

1471 words - 6 pages ” a reader can understand what a life without meaning can do to someone. Welty has created a master piece that even 10 years after of being published can be used to teach lessons to the people of today and hopefully lessons for future generations. Works Cited Flower, Dean. “Eudora Welty and Racism.” The Hudson Review (2007): 325-332. Academic Search Premier. Web. 24 Feb. 2014. Friedman, Walter A. “Editor’s Note.” Business History

The Illusion of Love in Faulkner’s A Rose for Emily

533 words - 2 pages William Faulkner’s “A Rose for Emily” takes the setting of an old shabby house, in which Emily poisons her lover to death. Though some people suggest the house should be a symbol for isolation, I believe the house, like the rose, is the emblem of love. Both of the two symbols are meant to be of promising connotation, but egoism takes happiness away from love. House is commonly referred to as another word for warm home and love. Since the

Similar Essays

Philosophical Analysis Of Viktor Frankl's "Man's Search For Meaning"

926 words - 4 pages Viktor E. Frankl's essay "Man's Search for Meaning" offers an inspiring look into the core of human existence. He uses his own personal experiences to draw conclusions about human nature. While a prisoner in Nazi concentration camps, Frankl witnessed the horrors of dehumanization daily. As a neurologist, he was able to use his psychology background to analyze his own personal experience and that of his fellow inmates. He watched as every freedom

Man’s Search For Meaning Reflection Essay

665 words - 3 pages Victor Frankl’s Man’s Search for Meaning often brings to mind the resilience of the human spirit. As he recounts his daily activities inside one of the Germany’s concentration camps the belief that God has given us the capabilities to handle whatever is thrown at us. Of course, not everyone survived; to say that life in a concentration camp is manageable would be an insult to the victims who survived the heinous abomination. While Frankl walks

Man's Search For Meaning By Viktor E. Frankl

2062 words - 8 pages . A valuable aspect of Man’s Search for Meaning is the questions it provokes. Frankl talks a lot about meaning and why there is suffering in life. This forces the reader to consider his or her meaning in life. People often shy away from the topic of meaning and human suffering because it makes them deeply examine their beliefs. People generally will not fully know what their meaning is

Book Review: "Man's Search For Meaning" By Viktor Frankl

957 words - 4 pages , the objective of logotherapy is to fulfill the patients future, or rather the meanings wanted to be fulfilled by the patient. He states that a man's search for meaning is "the primary motivation in his life and not a 'secondary rationalization' of instinctual drives (Frankl 120 - 121)." It is not a "defense mechanism" as some doctors believe, but a basic and primitive urge. In the "Logotherapy in a Nutshell" portion of Man's Search for Meaning