This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Content Analysis Of Organizational Dissent As Portrayed On Primetime Television

2040 words - 8 pages


There has been much research done on organizational dissent, but there is a dearth of research dedicated to how television shows portray dissent over the airwaves. In Deviating From the Script: A Content Analysis of Organizational Dissent as Portrayed on Primetime Television by Johny T. Garner, Emily S. Kinsky, Andrei C. Duta, and Julia Danker, the authors attempted to combine these two theories for their study. Using the data collected by the authors and their research team, the authors resolved to measure how effective the dissent was in creating change. Organizational dissent is important in nonfictional workplaces for a variety of reasons, and these results indicate one potential influence on organizational members that may depict dissent as futile (Garner et al., 2012, p. 620). The authors set about trying to quantify organizational dissent on network television in the primetime hours. The authors also argued that organizational dissent was the challenge of status quo and the benefits of this challenge was of value to both the dissenter and the organization as well. This review will provide a critical analysis of the article as well offer some insights into where the authors’ research could go further.

Hypotheses and Philosophical Perspectives

Garner et al. provided three hypotheses for their content analysis of primetime programming. First, the authors hypothesized that dissent would be portrayed as ineffective. In this hypothesis, effectiveness was defined in terms of receiving emotional support and/or achieving instrumental change. The second hypothesis was centered on to whom the dissent would be expressed. The authors used four potential dissent audiences: supervisors, subordinates, coworkers and people outside of the organization. This postulation speculated that the supervisor above all other groups would receive the most feedback in this area. Similarly, the third and final hypothesis supposed that the dissent would be pointed toward a person or group that could do something to resolve the point of contention.

The authors used the cultivation theory as an undertone for their research and combined that with an overall notion of outcomes based on television viewership. Morgan (2000) noted that “the cultivation theory explains how attitudes can be changed over a longer period of time” (as cited in Garner, Kinsky, Duta, & Danker, 2012, p. 610) and Gerbner (1990) used the cultivation theory’s argument that television programs present generally consistent messages to viewers and that those messages shape viewers expectations for ‘‘real life’’ (as cited in Garner, Kinsky, Duta, & Danker, 2012, p. 618). The authors posited that the result of sustained television viewership would transfer to how the viewer reflected on their own worldview. Garner et al. used a cultivation theory interpretation on their data to presume that viewers would be more likely to see dissent as ineffective and therefore pointless and at minimum it is...

Find Another Essay On A Content Analysis of Organizational Dissent as Portrayed on Primetime Television

Corruption as a Consequence of Colonialism - as portrayed in Achebe’s The African Trilogy

978 words - 4 pages Corruption as a Consequence of Colonialism - as portrayed in Achebe’s The African Trilogy All quotations are taken from the 1988 Picador edition of Chinua Achebe’s The African Trilogy " He has put a knife on all the things that held us together and we have fallen apart" (Things Fall Apart, 145) The things that held the Igbo tribe together were their close bonds of clan kinship, unified allegiance to their gods, and their democratic

The analysis of the character of John Hammond as portrayed in the film and the book

857 words - 3 pages play God that occurs in the novel. This P.T. Barnum type of character is then well liked by the audience and changes the whole outcome of the story. Because Hammond is portrayed as an old man who made a couple mistakes, it would not be justified in the film if Hammond were to die, and so he doesn't.The impact that this transition has on the theme is incredible. Jurassic Park was written in 1990, amid the fever of the information age when seemingly

analysis of vitamin c content

703 words - 3 pages . It is well known that ascorbic acid (vitamin C) deteriorates on heating and on exposure toair.Describe, giving experimental details, how you would investigate these two factors.P.4Experiment V03 Analysis of commercial vitamin C tabletsPurpose:To determine the vitamin C(ascorbic acid) content of a vitamin C tabletI2(aq) + vitamin C ((( ( + 2H+(aq) + 2I-(aq)1. Standard solution 2. No. of moles of I2 = No. of moles of vit.Cknown concentration No. of

Emergence of Television as a Mass Medium and Leisure Time

2777 words - 11 pages Emergence of Television as a Mass Medium and Leisure Time Early in the twentieth Century the advent of public radio broadcasting brought cheap and effortless entertainment into the homes of millions of people. The invention and use of television as a means of channelling information on a wide scale was revolutionary. The world had recognised how influential and useful a tool the radio was in disseminating information

Web 2.0 and User generated content: The effect of user generated content on the quality of published content is a hotly discussed subject

1351 words - 5 pages Web 2.0AbstractThe effect of user generated content on the quality of published content is a hotly discussed subject, with many supporters for both sides of the argument. It is felt that non-experts publishing material online gives ambiguity to the validity of the information supplied. Also, there is the issue of the publication of offensive material on the web. On the other hand, it is believed that the combined knowledge of essentially all

The Image of Persons with Disabilities as Portrayed in a Newspaper

3873 words - 15 pages with disabilities, as reflection of the society’s perspective about them. Content analysis of media is a traditional mass communication research method used to assess a wide range of media content trends (Poothullil J.M.Martin 2008). This research paper advocates for increased newspaper analysis within the disability studies field. Using a short term media research study about Hindustan Times (HT) Newspaper daily and its news coverage of

Satirical Analysis on Reality Television

626 words - 3 pages The Ironic Satire of Reality TelevisionWhen you think about the content and fibre of reality television there's really not much there. Many people feel that reality television is the best production to come from ABC, NBC and all the corporate conglomerates trying to make easy money. That's exactly what they are doing. Selling easily produced television to easily minded recipients. The first problem with reality TV is that it isn't even reality

A Comprehensive Discussion on the Similarities of Change as discussed in The Heart of Change and Organizational Behavior and Management

2201 words - 9 pages organization. While each book offer’s similar insights on change through organizational behavior, there are slight differences. One author provides insight through the use of case studies and opinions while the other relies on academic work through theories, research, and supporting evidence. In the paragraphs to follow, there will be a careful comparison between Kotter’s Eight Step Change Model for implementing change powerfully and successfully as

Women of "The Underdogs" We were asked to write a 7-8 page paper on Mariano Azuela's "The Underdogs," and how women were portrayed in it, as well as whether or not we felt the portrayal was accurate

2386 words - 10 pages show up on her doorstep and allow her to care for them. War Paint, on the other hand, has a wild personality and refuses to let her life be dictated by outside influences; she joins the rebel band as a fighter, not a caretaker. There were real women who would have embodied the characteristics of War Paint and Camila and participated in the same or similar activities during the revolution, but there were also many other women who did nothing of the

This essay explores the effect that television (as a new media form) has on culture

2138 words - 9 pages viewers with some control over the content of a program and of related information referenced in the program. This capability is especially useful with such applications as video-on-demand, internet browsing, home shopping and banking, and multi-player games. Such innovations as these, have made for TV to be used in a variety of ways, not possible in its early days. When television was invented, it was in black and white and screened light

Effects of Television on Children: A Chain Indicating Their Behavior

1101 words - 4 pages sex is more central to daily life than it truly is (281). As reported by Moody, “Whether we are talking about sexuality as a whole, erotic sex, sex roles, or sexism, we can find many stereotypical examples of each study in television (113). Sexual content appears in 64% of all TV programs (Collins, Elliot, Berry, Kanouse, Kunkel, Hunter, and Miu 281). Watching sex on TV predicts and may hasten adolescent sexual initiation (280). For example

Similar Essays

Analysis Of Freedom Of Dissent

1568 words - 6 pages wanted to believe was not an option when it came to following a creed, it was more than probable that one’s government had made that choice for its people. Roger Williams, having been educated by Sir Coke on religious ideals, seemed to be bothered by this fact and was fervent to change this as his former master whom had spent time in a London jail for his own ideas (Humanities, 1983). Anne Hutchinson, being the daughter of a dissenting puritan

A Content Analysis Of Twitter’s Top Athletes

2074 words - 8 pages 10 Twitter,” 2014). According to Clavio and Kian (2010), the shear number of followers of athletes and sports organizations on Twitter warrants increased scholarly communications research on topics such as produced content, audience awareness, audience gratification, athlete gratification, and public relations impact (p. 486). A number of studies have already tackled these areas and more. Theoretical Framework The selection of scholarly

Analysis Of A Television Advertisement Aimed At Raising Awareness On The Issue Of Road Safety

1305 words - 5 pages Analysis of a Television Advertisement Aimed at Raising Awareness on the Issue of Road Safety In order to analyse the advertisement, it is necessary to look at the different techniques used throughout. The advertisement has been created in order to promote road safety, and is from a series of advertisements called ‘THINK!’ The specific advert I am to analyse is called ‘Backwards’, and deals with the decision of whether or

A Summary Of Educational Content On Three Breast Cancer Websites

756 words - 3 pages treatments. Many women are using the internet for educational information, support groups, and treatment choices. With this in mind, three Breast cancer sites were reviewed for content and a discussion of the possible impact on the information to health care providers follows the analysis.Y- Me National Breast Cancer Organization ( provides online material in English, Spanish, Vietnamese, Korean, and Chinese. Content includes