A Comparison Between The Italian And German Opera; Specifically Using Examples From Guiseppe Verdi And Richard Wagner

2497 words - 10 pages

The Italian opera and the German opera are two different fields that both share characteristics, some of which are paralleled, and some of which contrast. Specifically, Giuseppe Verdi and Richard Wagner use motifs such as: redemption through love, patriotism, and sacrifice which run throughout both of their operas. The theme of betrayal also seems to be echoed throughout both operas; yet they are each used to project a different response. The significance of this comparison demonstrates that Verdi and Wagner may allude to the same references, such as Victor Hugo, Shakespeare, and Byron, but the operas The Flying Dutchman (German opera) and that of Nabucco (Italian opera) are completely different in context, and musical style; perhaps even The Flying Dutchman is a musical imitation of Italian opera while still trying to originate his own musical ideas as well.The Italian opera has three main genres: the Baroque, the Romantic, and the Modern. Italian opera first started to materialize in the seventeenth century, and approximately two hundred years later, the Romantic genre was introduced. Throughout the seventeenth century there were many developments in Italian opera due to Claudio Monteverdi (1567-1643), who wrote his first opera in 1607 (La Favola d'Orfeo) which to this day, is still performed. He introduced ideas such as the bel canto and buffa styles. Having a strong connection between the instrumental music and words was of major importance to Monteverdi, and this became a major theme for other opera composers to follow.The Romantic operas started to appear in the early 19th century. Romantic operas stress the world of imagination and emotions and through its music and aria's was this theme magnified. Giuseppe Verdi (1813-1901) was one the composers of this era who changed the way composers would forever more look at operatic writing. His first successful opera Nabucco was immediately well received by the public for its amazing choruses, and vigorous music. One of the chorus interpretations Va, pensiero, sull'ali dorate, was so well received that it was said to have helped unify Italy as it gave useful meaning to the struggle for Italian independence.Nabucco, which was first performed in 1842 in Milan at Teatro alla Scalla, is short for Nabucodonosor, or in English, Nebuchadnezzar. This opera has four acts, and to the libretto by Temistocle Solera based on the biblical story of Nebuchadnezzar. In part one the Priest Zaccaria tells the Jews that there still may be peace due to the presence of a hostage, Fenena,(the younger daughter of Nabucco). Zaccaria gives Fenena to Ismaele, (the nephew of the King of Jerusalem). Ismaele tells her to escape even though they love one another. The King (Nabucco) enters and Zaccaria disobeys him, and threatens to kill Fenena with a dagger. Ismaele intervenes to save her. Nabucco responds by ordering the destruction of the temple, and the Jews curse Ismaele as a traitor.In part two Nabucco is away at war and...

Find Another Essay On A comparison between the Italian and German Opera; Specifically using examples from Guiseppe Verdi and Richard Wagner

The Farce of Heroism An opinion paper on heroism using examples from "The Gemeral" and "Birth of A Nation".

875 words - 4 pages " seemed rather tragic and depressing. While the heroism portrayed in both films tended to be satirical and offered a jab at the concept of heroism in war. There is one main congruency between the two films and that being: Heroism is best suited for what your true beliefs are.Birth of a Nation, which was the most watched film of all time, was filmed and released after World War I had broken out. With the imminent U.S. involvement upcoming, the

Italian and German Fascism: Similarities and Differences

1045 words - 4 pages considered as the common enemy for both Germany and Italy, because France invaded territories of both two countries. All characters above may be not enough, but they are somehow representative for the similarities between Italian Fascism and Nazi's Germany. Italian fascism and Nazi German: different, yet alike. Although the two states differ in many areas, they share more than one common experience. Both of them, Fascism and Nazism, were very

Symbolism of Italian and French Theatre and Opera

2412 words - 10 pages and Italian operatic styles. The ensuing Querelle stemmed from the ideological and aesthetic differences between these two operatic styles, with the opera buffa coming to be perceived as a threat to French absolutism (Higgins, 2012). Jean-Jacques Rousseau reported that Paris was divided on the one hand by the wealthy, influential, and the “ladies” who supported French music. In fact women’s preference for the French opera reflected their

The Life and Works of Giuseppe Verdi

1705 words - 7 pages for themselves Verdi’s father Carlo was a landowner and innkeeper, and his mother was a spinner. When Verdi’s mother Luigia was 26 she and his father Carlo welcomed a baby girl they gave the name Giuseppa Francesco Verdi but she was not to see her brother become a world renowned romantic opera composer because she tragically died in the year 1833 from a debilitating form of meningitis at the time of her death she was 17 years old. I believe

Fulfilling Destiny: A comparison between "The Alchemist" by Paulo Coelho and "Jonathan Livingston Seagull" by Richard Bach

823 words - 3 pages main character from Jonathan Livingston Seagull, by Richard Bach, found his life exceedingly meaningless, so when he discovered his Personal Legend, it gave his life meaning. Jonathan tested his limits, destroyed his relationship with the Flock, and became an outcast, just to fly. From The Alchemist, by Paulo Coelho, Santiago followed his Personal Legend, even when it meant crossing an entire desert. He knew he could never be truly happy, living

All About German and Italian Unification

581 words - 2 pages popular to the middle class than the other two because Sardenia appeared to be a liberal, progressive state displaying national unification. That is what the people were striving for. They thought Mazzini's ideas too radical- and they were trying to get away from religion running the nation as it had done in the past. They wanted a distinct separation between church and state.Cavour was the man who made the change, but he sought unity only for

Why Spaghetti Westerns Should Simply Be Westerns: An analysis of the Western Genre using examples from "The Searchers" and "For a Few Dollars More"

1930 words - 8 pages more of a Western than one from an Italian director with a very different adaptation of the genre.The Western hero exists on the periphery of both the community and the wilderness and never loses touch with either. The hero is motivated to uphold civilization by his own code of honor. This often leads him to acts of vengeance (Schatz, 51). The Searchers stars John Wayne who plays the role of Ethan who has recently returned home from the Civil War

Atraction/Repulsion A criticism paper/statement from an art school student discussing the role of attraction and repulsion using examples of sculptors working in the 1970's.

737 words - 3 pages blood rolling around one another. Morris at the same time argues that art needs a 'baseness, a kind of primitiveness, as part of our experience". Richard Serra splashes molten metal against a wall. Metal being a traditional material then altered in an untraditional way creating a new beauty. Eva Hesse's transformed materials like muslin and cheesecloth into works that have been criticized as "funerary" and stressed "deathliness". Joseph Beuys is

A Comparison between Othello and The Trial

1303 words - 5 pages A Comparison between Othello and The Trial    In the same way that the concept innocence and arrogance appear at cross-purposes, a comparison between "Othello" by William Shakespeare and " The Trial " by Franz Kafka at first sight appears contradictory. On closer analysis however, both these terms and these two works can be shown to have demonstrated the same inseparable idea.   The philosophy of both times introduces the ideas


930 words - 4 pages criticisms. From the very beginning, the opening of this excerpt from Rameau’s first opera is neither crude nor devoid of expression as Rousseau maintained. Rameau effectively conveys the atmosphere of a raging sea, out of which emerges a great fire-breathing monster, by using rapid pulsations and scales in the strings and flute to depict the wind and the waves. In dramatic accompanied recitative, Aricie begs Hippolyte not to fight the monster

German And Irish Immigration Comparison

535 words - 2 pages States to try and rid themselves of hardships and establish new lifestyles.In a comparison of the political effects of German and Irish immigration, it is clear that the Germans and Americans were quickly attracted to the politics of the United States. The Irish quickly gained control of New York?s Tammany Hall and obtained the patronage rewards. Shortly thereafter, Irishmen dominated police departments in the big cities of the United States. The

Similar Essays

German And Italian Unification. Essay

531 words - 2 pages a presidency of the Pope with a federation of the Italian states. It was obvious that Italy sought a homeland free from foreign rule, but lacked the leadership to unify the various states.King Victor Emmanuel II and Count Camillo Di Cavour would provide this leadership with their policies and actions. Being the strongest, largest, and most liberal state, Piedmont-Sardinia was able to lead the unification. Cavour's foreign policy was anti-Austrian

Italian And German Unification Essay

553 words - 2 pages Italian and German Unification After 1848, Italian nationalists looked to the kingdom of Sardinia for leadership because Mazzini had failed in Rome. Sardinia's king, Victor Emmanuel II named Count Camillo di Cavour his prime minister. Cavour was a wealthy aristocrat and a moderate nationalist. He also was a realpolitik. Realpolitiks were shrewd,purposeful politicians who wanted to unite Italy by well chosen alliances, not romantic rebellions

Giuseppe Verdi The Opera Singer. Essay

696 words - 3 pages Elisabetta de Valois, who he was secretly set up to marry, but had never met. In a forest called Fontainebleau the two people stumble upon each other and fall in love. But when Lerma, the Spanish ambassador, arrives, he tells them that as a condition of the peace treaty between France and Spain, Elisabetta was made to marry Fillipino, Carlo's father.Carlo, in his misery, goes to the cloister of the monastery of St. Just, where his grandfather, Carlo

Using Examples, Explain The Difference Between Obscene And Indecent Materials.

890 words - 4 pages so many people would be as offended. From being in radio, I can remember an obvious instance in which we talked about a performance by Janet Jackson at the super bowl. Her breast popping out of her outfit could be deemed as "Patently" offensive, indecent material presented over the airwaves because many people were watching and it was on cable television. So I can clearly state that the main difference between the two, is that obscene material