This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Contrast Of Moral And Natural Liberty

702 words - 3 pages

Winthrop stood tall among his peers and the community as he was acquitted. Upon his acquittal he felt is necessary to explain to the community how he was justified in what he had done. More specifically, how he was justified in exiling two residents of Hingham. Winthrop chose to speak of liberty. He speaks of not one, but two liberties; natural and moral. These two liberties contrast in both origin and in guidance.
Firstly, a major way in which these two liberties, natural and moral, contrast is in their origin. Winthrop states that natural liberty is “common to man with beasts and other creatures”. Natural liberty is a liberty that man is born with, though they do not retain heritage alone, as they must share it with the wildlife that is born around them. It is a liberty that is most feral in nature, aligning man with the “beasts” they walk among. “It is a liberty to evil as well as to good”. Natural liberty does not inherently stem from either side of the coin, ...view middle of the document...

These two liberties not only contrast in origin, but in the way each guides one as well. When addressing one’s natural liberty, one “hath the liberty to do what he lists”. It allows one to operate as they so please without restriction. It proves to be “incompatible and inconsistent” with authority, and “cannot endure the least restraint of the most just authority”. With absolute freedom to do as one so choses, one is likely to deny the common law imposed upon citizens. Expressing and embracing one’s natural liberty is acceptable, though maintaining for too long “makes men grow more evil”, eventually turning man into something “worse than brute beast”. Exercising one’s natural liberty for too long will lead to one’s downfall, ultimately causing one’s own damnation.
Natural liberty may make one a wild beast; however, it is moral liberty that will keep one on the correct path. Moral liberty is the “proper end and object of authority”. It is with this liberty one will be guided in the proper manner to enter civility, and live together with one’s fellow man. Moral liberty cannot “subsist” without this “object of authority”. This liberty holds so true and righteous, “you are to stand for, with the hazard of your lives, if need be”. One must subject to authority with moral liberty, as it is truth and peace; it wants to lead one in the direction of justice. Moral liberty is to be one’s resolve in all manners of defense against the wicked and evil. Succumbing to moral liberty will make one more open to authority and eventually set one free, as “it is the same kind of liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free”.
Natural liberty may at first appear to be the ideal liberty to live with, but without a strong sense of moral liberty, one is likely to fall into a trap of self-damnation. These two liberties certainly contrast not only in origin, but most definitely in guidance as well. Though, without subjection to both can cause just as must chaos, for it is harmony one should seek when choosing to live.

Works Cited

Barnet, Sylvan, William Burto, and William E. Cain. "From The Journal of John Winthrop." Literature for Composition: Essays, Stories, Poems, and Plays. Boston: Longman, 2011. 165-66. Print.

Find Another Essay On A Contrast of Moral and Natural Liberty

A Contrast of Oral and Literate Cultures

923 words - 4 pages to ensure that important knowledge is passed down and retained for future generations. This practice establishes a great reverence for elders in a society, as they are the keepers of all things known to a society. This is in contrast to the literate culture of today wherein someone of any age with the ability to read has access to any and all knowledge available.Our writing is merely an expression of the oral traditions mankind has employed for

Compare and contrast natural science and social science

2230 words - 9 pages Research and the SciencesThere has long been an ongoing argument: Is social science scientific? Which approach is better in conducting natural sciences and social sciences? It is believed that 'hypothetico-deductive' approach may be applicable to the natural sciences while it does not relate well to the social sciences. By analyzing research from different levels, this essay presents a judgment that social sciences are sciences. First of all

Is The Statue of Liberty a Lie?

1781 words - 7 pages Is The Statue of Liberty a Lie? The issue of immigration has shaped the history of the United States throughout the years of its existence. People from numerous different countries have immigrated to America in search of a better life and new opportunities. While Americans often ponder whether immigration is a benefit to society, legislators have recently enacted many anti-immigration laws which have been enforced to keep control over

A Comparative Study of Natural Philosophy and Modern Science

695 words - 3 pages Science is a body of verifiable knowledge, which is empirical and contains a set of guidelines, which are to be used when investigating the unperceived, known as the scientific method (Webster 656). Before the Scientific Revolution, which initially began during the mid sixteenth century, science was predominantly known as Natural Philosophy. Natural Philosophy is a term applied to the objective study of nature and the physical universe. The

The Power and Protection of Religious Liberty

1131 words - 5 pages security for the people who lived in poverty or lived confusedly. Religion deifies some value and religious doctrine which can control the desire and impulsion from people’s heart. Should religious liberty be protected by the specific provisions under national or international law? My answer is absolutely Yes. Religion is a special thing indeed, and the religious liberty is a significant and specific part of human rights. There are different kinds

The Constancy of Change: A Journey to Marriage Equality and Celebrated Personal Liberty

2158 words - 9 pages fluctuate while others remain unchanged. Since becoming an adult and now in my 40’s, I’ve come to understand that no liberty granted to an American citizen should be taken lightly. I am an avid voter and have been since I was 18. I relish in my right to own property; my home is my castle and I simply love it. More recently, I’ve taken advantage of obtaining a college education; with help from the government, by means of student loans and grants

Moral right and wrong are just a matter of opinion

1547 words - 6 pages The Concise Oxford Dictionary (p925) describes morality as: '1) Principles concerning the distinction between right and wrong or good and bad behaviour; a system of value and moral principles. 2) The extent to which an action is right or wrong'. What is morally right in relation to one moral framework can be morally wrong in relation to another, and unfortunately no one moral framework is the final word in true morality. We all live our lives by

The Comparison of Symphony and Liberty

924 words - 4 pages Liberty (v5) Supplier: Softlink Liberty is simple while having all of the functionality that any library would require! Liberty is committed to growing and changing with the needs of individual libraries, and it would probably best suit a special library. While having fully integrated core modules (which are designed to save the user time), Liberty also has a number of additional modules which can be

Moral and Immoral Conversions in A Tale of Two Cities

1837 words - 7 pages Moral and Immoral Conversions in A Tale of Two Cities A conversion in the Webster's Dictionary is described as a change from one belief to another. In the novel A Tale of Two Cities, the acclaimed author Charles Dickens uses his great imaginative power to create a superior artwork in literary terms. A Tale of Two Cities is an in-depth story about the lives of people in the two countries of France and England during the French Revolution

A Character and Moral Study of George Milton

1163 words - 5 pages , George “hadda”, but if George’s actions were not completely selfless, then maybe Lennie didn’t die for the right reasons. The question George being morally sound is a heavy question and one that will never be answered. George Milton is an intensely creative and compassionate man, but also one that experiences a lot of moral conflict. George takes Lennie’s welfare upon him and does his best to keep Lennie in line and keep them out of trouble

life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness

2373 words - 10 pages In June of 1776 Thomas Jefferson began to draft The Declaration of independence. He completed it and had it signed on June 28, 1779. A very famous line from this document would have to be “life, liberty and pursuit of happiness.” (Thomas Jefferson, The Declaration of Independence, June 28, 1776) Today we can see that those rights are not exactly being protected. It is evident through the everyday killings, the people being locked up due to

Similar Essays

A Contrast Of Moral And Natural Liberty

744 words - 3 pages Winthrop stood tall among his peers and the community as he was acquitted. Upon his acquittal he felt is necessary to explain to the community how he was justified in what he had done. More specifically, how he was justified in exiling two residents of Hingham. Winthrop chose to speak of liberty. He speaks of not one, but two liberties; natural and moral. These two liberties contrast in both origin and in guidance. Firstly, a major way in

Investigation Of Natural Moral Law Essay

865 words - 3 pages can be to either justice law or authority. This essay will consider how useful the application of natural moral law can be to Justice. Justice is establishing a society in which equality of liberty/freedom is promoted and provided. Hovner and Westacott (2000) say that ‘any society I would like to live in must prize individual freedom, but not to the exclusion of social responsibility or of justice. Justice is fairness

Of Necessity And Liberty Essay

1698 words - 7 pages outcomes, despite the possible interference of free-will. The “conjunction of like objects” agreement that Hume gives in Part I satisfies the determinist aspect of compatibilism. While liberty is inherent within the construct, it serves a determininst end when one considers the natural laws and maxims that Hume ascribes to human behavior. The improved form of liberty that Hume proposes attributes a sense of moral responsibility lost in Hume’s

Statue Of Liberty: A Lie? Essay

988 words - 4 pages Statue of Liberty: A Lie? As I sat on a park bench in the middle of Manhattan, eating a pack of stale peanut butter crackers, I couldn't keep myself from thinking about the woman I had met the day before. The lady I met seemed to be a strong woman of high morale, but after our interaction I came to the conclusion that she was living a lie. Well-known and noticeably the tallest female in the community, many people looked up to her as somewhat