A Critical Account Of Freud’s Understanding Of Religion

976 words - 4 pages

Sigmund Freud; Father of the psychoanalytic school of psychology, was not a friend to religious belief. Freud’s understanding of religion, to put it bluntly, was that of an illusion. That is to say, not necessarily false, but developed in response to the need to overcome the conflict between our sexual natures and the nature of civilisation. From this, we can attempt to critique said theory in order to see how “valid” it really is in the face of religion. For Freud’s position to be truly valid, we have to prove that the Oedipus complex is a fully universal sexual trauma, and that buried trauma can really manifest itself in the form of religion. He believed himself to have proved both of these conclusively, and in turn, believed that because of the oppressive nature of religion, it should be overthrown. However, in light of recent research, very few of Freuds theories on religion seem to hold any water. And this is where this essay begins.
The place to start (in theory) is to critique the methodological issues behind Freud. As is common practice in the Psychodynamic field of psychology, Freud developed a generalized version of his theory from a limited amount of very carefully selected case studies, often from patients whom exhibited behaviours of extreme proportions (e.g. The Wolf Man; Sergei Pankejeff) . Although studies of extreme behaviours allow the psychologist to study said behaviours far easier, it would be illogical to assume that the traits exhibited would be applicable to the general public.
Naturally, it can be said that Freud was a man of revolutionary intellect, but his tendency to take mere speculations and present them as facts is the net stop on the disassembly of his theories on religion. Freud used Darwins theory of the primitive unit “The Primal Horde” as evidence for the development of the Oedipus complex and the beginning of primitive religions in his work “Totem and Taboo” (1913). Unfortunately, the whole idea of the horde was just speculation on the part of Darwin meaning that it was generally not respectable as evidence. In fact, now it’s believed that although the horde may have existed, it probably wasn’t the only social structure in early society. This now commonly accepted down-playing of the “Horde” as the primitive structure in society is possibly (in my own opinion) the greatest issue with Freuds account of religion today.
Obviously, for Freud, the psychosexual trauma present in our psyche is a crucial component to his theory on the origin of religious practice. However, the work of Bronislaw Malinowski, by using anthropological evidence, seemed to attack Freud’s position in his 1927 work “Sex and Repression in Savage Society” . Malinowski used the example of the people of the Trobriand Islands, whom he visited during the conflict in WW1 . The research produced from this study was not to prove that the Oedipus complex was false, but to state that in matriarchal societies, (such as the Trobriands) where the...

Find Another Essay On A Critical Account of Freud’s Understanding of Religion

Sigmund Freud’s Elements of Personality Essay

689 words - 3 pages shadowed by his second daughter and fifth child Anna Freud which would go on to become a well known and famous Psychologist of her own. With her greatest work being she founded Child Psychoanalysis, and she summarized the Ego’s Defense Mechanisms in 1936. Freud’s second child a boy was worn in 1889 and named Jean Martin in honor of his mentor Jean-Martin Charcot. Freud would later have two another sons Oliver born in 1891, and Ernest in 1892. Over

A Sociological Account: Summary of Hodgkinson

876 words - 4 pages looks at society as a whole system and forms the idea that all parts of society are made up of different components called social institutions. These institutions hold society together and form what is known as the social structure, for example, the economy, the family, the education system, religion etc... Functionalist sociologist would not look at the motives of the individual girl but explain what arranged marriages do to keep society

The Battle Of Gettysburg - A Fictional Account

1404 words - 6 pages account, you have been selected to pass on a piece of history that would otherwise be lost. Hear my words well." Seventeen. Such a young age to kill, seventeen. Seventeen years seemed little preparation for watching my friends shot at my left and right and, rather than mourn the tragic losses of these fine young men, hit the ground and come back swinging. No thoughts. Only instinct. Duck, roll, load, fire. Dodge, jump, kill. All at

A creative "personal account" of the Holocaust

510 words - 2 pages Death Creeps Upon UsLife is really getting bad these days. Last week I only got one piece of bread, and with my already weak, starving condition I was sure I was going to die. I found a few worms one day though and ate them. That probably kept me alive a little longer. I also only got 3 cups of water last week. My lips have been chapped since I got to this camp, my skin has been dry, and in 3 weeks I have only gone to the bathroom 4 times. The

A critical analysis of the work edited by Elizabeth Hatton called Understanding TEACHING: Curriculum and the social context of schooling

3801 words - 15 pages To understand teaching requires understanding that classrooms are not isolated from the world. The classroom is comprised of members from different families, students from diverse socio-economic backgrounds and nationalities. It is the complex potpourri of personas and cultures, which make a classroom an exciting place to teach and learn. Hatton (1994) asserts that this medley is in all probability overseen by a white female from an upper-middle

Bioethics: Understanding the Values and Beliefs of Science and Religion

591 words - 2 pages and importance. A famous Greek philosopher, Socrates, once said, “The unexamined life is not worth living.” Ethics is about examining life that will add dimension and will look in a full perspective of life to the understanding beyond science in the midst of moving forward to the understanding of full human existence and to discern religion aspect. As a health care provider, we must make a deliberate effort to understand our own values and

Primitive Religion, a description of ancient religion

1210 words - 5 pages primitive religion in practice today is the Aboriginal tribes of Australia and the Native American bands in Canada and the United States. Although often scrutinized many of these tribes continue to practice their primitive ancestors myths, rituals, and beliefs today in modern society.After studying and developing a greater understanding of primitive culture, both religiously and historically, this writer must take a firm position in agreeing

Freud’s Theory of Psychosexual Development Applied to "Finding Nemo"

1999 words - 8 pages more in depth, you will find that he was not that crazy as you might have thought. For example, in this paper you will come to find that personality and Freud’s views on it aren’t really that off point. In the movie Finding Nemo, there is a father name Marlin, and a little son named Nemo. The personality of Nemo is he is an off the wall little clown fish that likes to take chances and is what we would call a hyper-active child. He likes to

A review of the article "Introducing percents in linear measurement to foster an understanding of rational-number operations" A critical reading

550 words - 2 pages Teaching Children Mathematics; Feb 2003"Introducing percents in linear measurement to foster an understanding of rational-number operations"Pages: 335-339"Traditional instruction in rational numbers focuses on rules and memorization." Teachers often give students instructions such as, "To add fractions, first find a common denominator, then add only the numerators" or "To add and subtract decimal numbers, line up the decimals, then do your

Religion: A Source of Violence

923 words - 4 pages unanswered” (103). Questions: What would it take to have all of the head religious figures in todays society come together and form a tour to promote religious unity and the promotion of non-violence? Would this cause conflict amongst the elites countries and the poor countries? Should religion be taught in schools to help promote understanding of religion and to eliminate regions hatreds and myth that could lead to future animosity and genocide

Understanding nourishes belonging, a lack of understanding prevents it

1426 words - 6 pages Untitled Understanding nourishes belonging, a lack of understanding prevents it To ensure that we have a healthy society it is important that we have knowledge about each other, a sense of who we are and who our community is and this will lead to a greater understanding. With such understanding the connections, relationships and idea of acceptance within a community is going to be strengthened. Indeed, understanding nourishes

Similar Essays

Critical Analysis: Understanding Religion In The Workplace

961 words - 4 pages requirement. The employee has to inform the employer about the conflict and as a result has been discharged or disciplined or discriminated against for not complying with the conflicting employment requirement (HR Specialist, 2013). An employer may request use of vacation and personal time to observe Sabbath as a reasonable accommodation. The EEOC has ruled both ways on this as an accommodation. At the time of employment, a clear understanding of

Critical Account Of Mill’s Liberty Principle

1406 words - 6 pages There are essentially two polar views in relation to the liberty of people within society. Anarchist fundamentally believe that the state should have no power to impose limits on its people, whilst those in favour of total government control, believe that liberty should be disregarded and the state allowed to implement any law or policy that it so chooses. In his work ‘On Liberty (1859), John Stuart Mill outlines an alternative, which is a mix

Gramsci's Concept Of Critical Understanding Essay

798 words - 3 pages that told them they had to adhere to the ideologies of the dominant class, thus using these orthodoxies and using them as discursive resources in order to form their own religious ideologies. They took discursive assumptions about what their religion told them, shaped their perspective in order to direct their actions to form their own beliefs about their economic situation. These instances are examples of how religious rituals added to the plausibility structure required to develop a critical understanding of their situation.

Description Of Freud’s Psychodynamic Theory Essay

1475 words - 6 pages The various components of our conscious and subconscious the id, ego, and superego lives in all of us and affects what we do and think, according to Sigmund Freud. Freud was a pioneer in the field of psychology for his various theories. Arguably Freud’s most important contribution to the field of psychology is his psychodynamic theory. The studies of the differences in the conscious and subconscious within what we think and what we do. Freud’s