This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Critical Analasis Of The Case Study Health Screening At Work

1840 words - 7 pages

This essay will critically assess a case study involving screening of health professionals. Firstly it will define health promotion and its attributes, then by using relevant course materials it will evaluate a number of issues in relation to the case study. It will consider what is characterised by the term 'good practice', look at the things that may strengthen the initiative and discuss the ethical dilemmas that may be associated with the scheme.

The World Health Organisation (WHO, 1986) defines health promotion as

"...the process of enabling people to increase control over, and to improve, their health. To reach a state of complete physical, mental and social wellbeing, an individual or group must be able to identify and to realise aspirations, to satisfy needs, and to change or cope with the environment. Health is, therefore, seen as a resource for everyday life, not the objective of living. Health is a positive concept emphasising social and personal resources, as well as physical capacities. Therefore, health promotion is not just the responsibility of the health sector, but goes beyond healthy lifestyles to psychosocial wellbeing"

Jones and Naido (2000) portray five approaches to health promotion; Medical, Behaviour change, Educational, Client- centred and Societal change. The Portsmouth Health initiative described in the case study is based on the medical approach as its aim is to encourage people to seek earlier detection of illness and disease.

The Portsmouth initiative can be seen as an example of good practice as identified in this description, since it aimed to improve the health of the staff. The Ottawa Charter (1998) terms this kind of initiative as 'empowerment' as it raises its clients awareness of the issues involved; it also allows the clients to read useful material about the tests.

Professional staff were given leaflets about the screening test being promoted and given an explanation of what the initiative involved. There is also the statement of further screening being available after the initial tests and as Juttmann et al (2001) explains, people who have regular screening tests are more likely to have something diagnosed early in life, and therefore have a better chance of being successfully treated. Another reason why health promotion and screening should be continuous is because diseases such as aids, BSE or heart disease are not reported frequently in the media and so they tend to be forgotten about.

Good practice was also demonstrated in the case study by the evaluation of the initiative. However, there are two types of evaluation the first being 'outcome evaluation' which is to help to rationalize the effort and resources that went into the project and it shows that it was worthwhile and effective. The second type is 'process evaluation' which provides the support that a company needs to keep their project going, it also highlights any errors made which can help a company to make improvements for the...

Find Another Essay On A critical analasis of the case study Health screening at work

The Negative Impact of Health Screening

1133 words - 5 pages well as misconceptions of patients. The risks posed by health screening are explained, keeping in mind common misunderstandings among patients. This report also includes recommendations to ensure patients are better informed in the future. 2.0 Body of Contents 2.1 Overdiagnosis – a common issue in many screening tests Many health screening tests tend to produce false positive results, or find abnormalities that may not cause any harm at all

Case Study: Passive Aggressive Behavior at the Work Place

1062 words - 5 pages Case Study: Passive Aggressive Behavior at the Work Place Introduction Passive aggressive behavior can be described as an indirect expression of hostility and discontentment within a given situation by an individual or a group of people. These feelings may be expressed through actions such as procrastination, resentment, intentional inefficiency, sarcasm, and other negative tendencies like chronic lateness. Considering it from an occupational

A critical evaluation of an IS case study (Fedex)

1917 words - 8 pages FedEx A Critical Analysis of an IS Case StudyWhat is E-commerce? Commerce is the buying and selling of goods and services. Over the past few years' commerce has moved from traditional features of selling products, but one main feature stays the same, the people.This essay will discuss how the FedEx Corporation used e-business and IT to grab a competitive advantage within their market place, this can be achieved by following some IS strategies

Critical Thinking Case Study: Implementing a Customer Relationship Management Tool at ImageStream

1975 words - 8 pages with most of ImageStream's decisions, the company (and this case study) will use the U.S. Army's "task, conditions, standards" model in identifying the problem and devising a solution. The "task, conditions, standards" framework provides structure to the fluid critical thinking and decision making process. The success of outcome-based decision making relies on accurate, clear definition of a single task.The U.S. Army provides military and civilian

Case Study about Work System Framework of a Company

4058 words - 16 pages Executive Summary TradX is a company that aims to sell furniture to retailers and special targeted companies. By analyzing the case study, which is on TradX Company, we came up with two different work systems for the company's trade actions. The work systems are "Replenish Retailer Inventory" and "Direct Selling." Moreover, the performance variables for the business processes are discussed in detail in the report. The report then talks about

A Critical, Contextual Review of the Work of Keith Haring

1039 words - 5 pages Keith Haring was an artist and social activist whose work continues to embody concepts of birth, death, sexuality and war, all from the perspective of a gay man living in New York City during the 1980’s. Throughout his career he devoted much of his time to public works, brimming with social messages, which were often quite political. His work very clearly demonstrated the way much of what was going on in the world at the time personally

A Critical Look at The Taming of the Shrew

1877 words - 8 pages strong opposition for Petruchio. Her representation at the end of the play, however, is very docile and submissive. There were several points in the play during which she demonstrated her new found domesticated personality. Firstly, she showcased it by saying what Petruchio wanted her to, regardless of the absurdity of the statement. In addition to the already mentioned sun-moon incident, Kate referred to the old and decrepit Vincentio as a

Taking a Close Look at the Work of Richard Grusin

3421 words - 14 pages Sensationalization, Media & Affective Emotion International Studies 550 Kirsten Polley  In this paper I take a close look at the work of Richard Grusin on premediation and remediation, alongside Brian Massiumi’s idea of the half-life of disaster, to argue how mediation affects current events - specifically through the story of the recent loss of Malaysian Airlines flight 370. Media has played a large part in shaping American history, since

Corporate culture at - a case study

1393 words - 6 pages architectural style or interior décor of offices, by what people wear to work and how people address each other. One company that has adopted a very unique culture is 1998, two Stanford students abolished their postgraduate study plans and created, the now worldwide biggest search engine on the Internet. Larry Page and Sergey Brin opened their first office in a friend's garage together with three employees and until

Leading Innovation At Kelvingrove (A), Case Study

1883 words - 8 pages initial start by O’Neil into implementing some of Spalding’s radical innovative ideas, O’Neil was side tracked into a separate project at the St. Mungo’s Museum of Religious Life and Art. The St. Mungo’s work provided some insight and allowed experimentation with some of the innovative ideas Spalding wanted to use at Kelvingrove of using storytelling to organize themes within the museum. In 1993 with the work complete at St. Mungo’s O’Neil

A Critical Study at the Dissemination of Ideas and Trends Through TV and Advertising in the past 20 years: Do We Define Television or Is TV Defining Us?

2421 words - 10 pages skills taught in classrooms." (Goodstein 2). This might be true if children are only allowed to watch educational and family-oriented programming like Sesame Street or Mr. Roger's Neighborhood. But this is not the case, especially with television now aimed at portraying reality: a reality that perhaps is not most adequate environment for a child to grow in, lest based their critical knowledge upon. "Evidence accumulated over two decades suggests that

Similar Essays

Health, Safety And Welfare At Work

2354 words - 9 pages Health, Safety and Welfare at Work Health and safety in the workplace is not only the responsibility of the designated Health and Safety Officer, it is the duty of all members of staff to be responsible for the safety of everyone they may have to deal with during the working day; both their colleagues and members of the public. The Health and Safety Executive are a body whose role is to promote safety in the

Critical Reflection Of Group Work On International Students' Mental Health Issues

838 words - 4 pages forces to obtain the same goals. According to the authors, a group can work effectively by respecting one another, having open communication, understanding each other’s roles and providing time for regular meeting to achieve desired outcomes. Sargeant, Loney, & Murphy (2008) also shared the same view regarding the criteria of an effective group work. These criteria were applicable in the process of our group work as the group formation and topic

The Pros And Cons Of Health Screening

2471 words - 10 pages The Benefits and Dis-benefits of Health Screening. The Contribution of Psychology in Health Screening. Health screening, according to Durojaiye, (2009), is a systematic application of a test or inquiry to identify individuals at risk of a specific health problem. This enables further investigation or direct preventive action, among individuals who have not sought medical attention on account of their symptoms of that problem

The Pros And Cons Of Health Screening

2257 words - 9 pages The Benefits and Disbenefits of Health Screening and the Contribution of Psychology in Health Screening. Health screening, according to Durojaiye, (2009), is a systematic application of a test or inquiry to identify individuals at risk of a specific health problem. This enables further investigation or direct preventive action, among individuals who have not sought medical attention on account of their symptoms of that problem. The