This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Critical Analysis Of The Article "Progressive Wal Mart. Really." By Sebastian Mallaby

1216 words - 5 pages

In his article “Progressive Wal-Mart. Really.” Sebastian Mallaby argues that Wal-Mart’s $50 billion in discounted gains is helping the well being of American shoppers. Malay concludes with “If critics prevent the firm from opening new branches, they will prevent ordinary families from sharing in those gains. Poor Americans will be chief among the casualties”(623). Mallaby is arguing if critics don't allow Wal-Mart to open new branches poor Americans won’t be able to share in gains like savings, jobs, and better local economy. Wal-Mart might have all these gains for the American shopper, but he doesn't talk about the negatives. For every gain there’s a loss. I disagree with Mallaby’s argument; Poor Americans, including Wal-Mart employees, are excluded from sharing in those gains because they work unpaid hours, and the inability to get health care coverage. Wal-Mart keeps these employees from sharing in these gains by keeping them in scared and in poverty. Ever since I started working at a market I then realized not only Wal-Mart excludes its employees and the poor from sharing in gains. The low paid employees at Wal-Mart will never share in gains as long as they work at Wal-Mart. Mallaby admits Wal-Mart can treat their employees and other retailers unfairly, but as a result everyone can share in the 50 billion in savings that American shoppers consume annually. The pay that employees get is the price they must pay for low priced merchandise. Because of the minimal pay to employees, Wal-Mart strengthens its’ consumer buying power. Giving the American shoppers the savings they need, Wal-Mart’s has ultimately been them successful. Wal-Mart has potentially wiped out the middle class as an employer, but the employees can now work and get government financial and medical assistance. Mallaby claims Wal-Mart employees should be thankful they could work and still get medical. At the cost of sending workers home with little pay, American shoppers can save money on a shopping trip. Mallaby argues Wal-Mart is a business with growth, and American shoppers should be thankful for Wal-Mart’s low prices that save consumers money. However, mallaby doesn't mention why consumers are getting such low prices, the employees become victims because of low prices.
Mallaby argues when Wal-Mart opens store people apply for job proving that not everyone “believes the pay and benefits are unattractive” (621). Although Wal-Mart create jobs, that does not mean it’s a great job; it could be the only job. Wal-Mart employees are losing gains when they work unpaid overtime. In her article, “Up Against Wal-Mart” Karen Olsson states that Wal-Mart makes more than 6.6 billion in profits annually, yet the workers are getting paid bare minimum of only 1,500 a month (608). According to the NCCP, the average poverty income is making $20,000 a year. Wal-Mart employees live in poverty making only $18,000 a year. Greg Denier, a communication director for UFCW, argues, “Americans cannot live...

Find Another Essay On A Critical Analysis of the Article "Progressive Wal-Mart. Really." by Sebastian Mallaby

Swot Analysis of Wal-Mart

3324 words - 13 pages Outline I. Summary of Wal-Mart A. What is Wal-Mart B. Economic Factors of Wal-Mart C. Customer Relations D. Employees II> External Analysis A. External opportunities B. External Threats C. Competitors D. Foreign Markets III. Internal Analysis A. Internal Strengths B. Human Resource C. Quality products For as long as I can remember I have seen Wal-mart stores up in almost in every town that I have traveled through. The store started by Sam

Globalization of the Wal-mart Essay

1030 words - 4 pages Wal-mart is the biggest retailer of the world. They made every effort to achieve this success. In this essay I will focus on the Globalization of the Wal-mart and international organizations for trade which helped it grow.The first Wal-mart store was opened in 1962 by Sam Walton. Sam Walton always used only one business policy that is "Sell stuff that people need everyday just a little cheaper than everyone else, sell it at that low price all

FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF SEARS VS. WAL-MART

5340 words - 21 pages they didn't need high dividend. So we can guess the sears is stable in his business and net income, it didn't need so much net income keep in his account, at the same time it's shareholder want dividend to invest other project. But Wal-Mart is more active, it wants to open new market, so it keeps enough money to investment.WACC Analysis- Weighted Average Cost of CapitalWhy Use WACC? Corporations create value for shareholders by earning a return

Wal-mart & Wal-mart Grocery Financial Analysis

6457 words - 26 pages company mistakenly thought it could compete with the farmers for market share. Wal-Mart appears to have learned from this mistake, but it is a salient example of the obstacles companies face when conducting business internationally versus domestically.Situational AnalysisEnvironmentWal-Mart and Wal-Mart Superstores are impacted significantly by domestic and international economic activity. The company operates inside and outside the United States

Wal-Mart SWOT Analysis

1070 words - 4 pages Evaluate the general environment of Wal-Mart using the framework in Chapter 2. What are the key opportunities and threats facing Wal-Mart? (This is the "OT" of a SWOT analysis)The opportunities for Wal-Mart are tremendous. This huge retailer began with an idea from Mr. Sam Walton in 1962 in a small town in Rogers Arkansas. The Wal-Mart Chain had evolved from a chain of stores called Ben Franklin stores that Mr. Walton and his brother operated

Wal-Mart Business Analysis

1518 words - 6 pages For the final project I chose to complete a management analysis on Wal-Mart. Covered in this paper are the issues of productivity, hiring practices, corporate social responsibility and culture, diversity and affirmative action, the use of information technology, leadership, teamwork, and managing ethics.Productivity is very important to any successful business. Wal-Mart has increased its productivity through many different advances. Business

Wal-Mart Analysis

1730 words - 7 pages will ensure continued revenue and market share growth via foreign expansion, the foray into new domestic markets (the urban market) and concentration strategies in existing markets by enhancing the one-stop-shopping appeal of the current units. One red flag that the company analysis uncovered was that Wal-Mart does not have a formal mission statement. The lack of a mission statement influences the cohesiveness of goals, objectives, and

wal-mart analysis

580 words - 3 pages data. While offering very low prices, Wal-mart was still concerned by the quality of the products sold in its stores, also pushing suppliers to improve their manufacturing chain. Therefore, being able to always offer products at lower prices constitutes a competitive advantage. As this advantage comes from the efficient operation of the integrated Wal-Mart model, it is also sustainable because competitors cannot easily lower the prices of theirs products without changing their operating model.

Wal-Mart Financial analysis

1079 words - 4 pages Commission, "no one financial statement tells the complete story. But combined, they provide very powerful information for investors. And information is the investor's best tool when it comes to investing wisely."Retail Manufacturing Company - Wal-MartWal-Mart is a global retailer and one of the best-managed companies in the world. Discounter Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. had sales over $400 billion, nearly 10 percent of U.S. retail sales, in year that

Critical Analysis of a Systematic Review Article

2246 words - 9 pages their methods lead to positive project outcomes, improved performance is not consistently realized. The authors argue that the associations’ one size fits all approach to best practices is insufficient for project success and thus conducted systematic research (SR) to determine if something else is the cause of project success. The current paper will present a critical analysis of the 2011 article, “Now, let’s make it really complex

Critical Analysis of a Published Article

1197 words - 5 pages writer started his article by saying that he has been always married. Has there any person been married all his life? The answer is no but the writer is trying to explain how his marriage was and the type of marriage it was. For example, the writer said that he never met his partner before his marriage or they met a little time without being alone. All these he may present, all arranged marriage arguments are not bad, as some people thought

Similar Essays

Critical Analysis Of Internal Resources And External Environment Of Wal Mart

922 words - 4 pages Critical Analysis of Internal Resources of Wal-Mart and External Environment. External Environment We have used Porter’s five forces on the discount retail industry to understand external environment(Porter, Michael E., Competitive Strategy(1988). 1. Threat of new entrants: Low a. Highly price competitive nature of the discount retail industry with already established players vying for market shares forbids new entrants. High entry barriers

This Case Study Is Based Upon The Case Article By Peter A. Stanwick And Sarah D. Stanwick Titled; ‘Wal Mart: But We Do Give Them A 10 Percent Employee Discount’, In Which Addresses The Ethical Issues...

1472 words - 6 pages Case Study: Wal-MartJune 12, 2012This case study is based upon the case article by Peter A. Stanwick and Sarah D. Stanwick titled; 'Wal-Mart: But We Do Give Them a 10 Percent Employee Discount', in which addresses the ethical issues facing Wal-Mart. According to Stanwick and Stanwick (2009, p. 409), the culture "has created a number of twenty-first-century problems for Wal-Mart."SummaryThe authors' viewpoint is that of the Wal-Mart employees are

Wal Mart How They Got Their Start And Bad Reputation From Employees, This Article Entails, Lawsuits, Timeline,And Discrimination

677 words - 3 pages The first Wal-Mart variety, opened in 1962, by Sam Walton in Rogers, Arkansas .The Superstore Giant now sells almost everything!. Although Wal-Mart began as a small variety store; within five years, Wal-Mart had opened an additional 23 stores with a total of 12.6 MM in sales. In May 1971, Wal-Mart acquired their first 100 percent stock split and listed on the NYSE one year later, within months, again Wal-Mart had yet another 100 percent stock

Analysis Of Wal Mart

2707 words - 11 pages Analysis of Wal Mart Wal Mart is the largest retailer in Canada , Mexico and USA. In addition to that Wal Mart has been known in USA not only for its dimensions but also for a very big number of reasons and good values. I think the best way to start an analysis about Wal mart strategy is to see where the company is now with the use of a brief Swot analysis. As far as the Strengths are concerned , I think that one of