This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Critical Analysis Of The Thirty First Amendments To The Constitution

2040 words - 9 pages

A Critical Analysis of the Thirty First Amendments to the Constitution


In November 2012, a proposal to insert a new article into the Constitution was put before the people of Ireland. The new amendment is specific to children’s rights and proposes to extend and strengthen current provisions in the Constitution concerning these rights. The foundation for the Children’s Rights Referendum is from a number of different sources. In addition, the bill was passed by the Oireachtas and approved by a majority vote at referendum. Nonetheless, the bill has not yet been signed into law, pending the legal outcome of a challenge to the validity of the constitutional referendum. Moreover, if the bill is signed into law, Article 42.5 of the Constitution will be deleted and Article 42A will be inserted into the Constitution. Furthermore, the Thirty-First Amendment to the Constitution includes four vital elements, each addressing constitutional protection for children. This paper will attempt to explore the matter in greater detail.


Primarily, current provisions in the Constitution prevent any State intervention concerning marital families, where there is a serious risk to the child. In addition, the current law restricts married parents regarding adoption law. Furthermore, there is a concern that currently a child’s wishes is not taken into account regarding custody proceedings. Additionally, the State cannot impede decisions of the marital family even if they are conflicting with the child’s best interest.
As stated by David Kenny
The impetus for this change is most frequently attributed to Ms Justice Catherine McGuiness, acting as chair of the Kilkenny Incest Inquiry in 1993. She suggested that the strong emphasis on the rights of the family in the Constitution, may, consciously or unconsciously, cause people to give more value to the rights of parents, at the expense of the rights of the child.

Most importantly, the proposed new amendment which will replace the current Article 42.5 of the Constitution consists of the following provisions. Many of the new provisions underpin what is already set out in the Constitution. The structure of Article 42A is as follows.

Article 42A

1.The State recognises and affirms the natural and imprescriptible rights of all
children and shall, as far as practicable, by its laws protect and vindicate those rights.

2.1° In exceptional cases, where the parents, regardless of their marital status, fail in
their duty towards their children to such extent that the safety or welfare of any of their
children is likely to be prejudicially affected, the State as guardian of the common
good shall, by proportionate means as provided by law, endeavour to supply the place
of the parents, but always with due regard for the natural and imprescriptible rights of
the child.

2° Provision shall be made by law for the adoption of any child where the parents
have failed for such a period of time as may be...

Find Another Essay On A Critical Analysis of the Thirty First Amendments to the Constitution

Analysis of the 1st and 2nd Amendments

1143 words - 5 pages Among the most quoted and reviewed amendments in the United States Constitution's Bill of Rights are the 1st and 2nd Amendments. Many Supreme Court cases have involved these amendments and it's obvious how relevant they are to our government and to our individual citizens, even after more than 200 years. These amendments practically define not only our Constitution, but us as a nation, and the freedoms offered therein.The 1st amendment gives us

Impact of the First and Fourteenth Amendments on Religious Freedoms

1361 words - 6 pages exceptionalism. The importance of religion to America as a nation, means that religion is granted certain freedoms that make passing laws regulating it difficult. The first and fourteenth amendments essentially protect the establishment of any religion as well as protecting the freedom to exercise this religion, whilst creating a distinctly separate Church and State. The religious freedom granted in these amendments has changed over time

Violation of the amendments

625 words - 3 pages Violation of the AmendmentsAfter the 9/11 attacks many people in the United States where left with terror and fear, as well as retaliation for those that caused it including violating the United Sates Constitution. Al-Qaeda a Muslim terrorist group responsible for the 9/11 attacks is what caused the American people to pursue the Muslim group taking them as a threat to society, as well as making us Americans have a different view on them. As war

The Main Features of the Soviet Constitution of Ninteteen-Thirty Six

2053 words - 8 pages The Main Features of the Soviet Constitution of Ninteteen-Thirty Six In 1936, Stalin judged the time ripe for drafting a new constitution which would preserve his autocratic power in the country. It was adopted by popular vote the following year and went into effect on January 1st 1938. Main features of the Constitution ================================= According to the Constitution, Communist Russia

Thematic Essay: Amendments to Constitution

895 words - 4 pages establishes two methods of proposing amendments, by either Congress or by a national convention requested by the states. Under the first method, Congress can propose an amendment by a two-thirds vote of the Senate and of the House of Representatives. Under the second method, Congress must call a national convention for the purpose of considering amendments when two-thirds of the state legislatures "apply" to Congress for such a convention. Only the first

The Bill of Rights Amendments

1238 words - 5 pages the US constitution is part of the Bill of Rights that guarantees all American citizens the right to keep and bear arms. This amendment gives citizens right to own a firearm. The right to bear arms and gun control is the most controversial amendment that has raised heated debate, among Americans. The right to bear arms has remained a hot issue in the United States. Every American citizen feel that, they have a right to gun ownership as

The First and Second Amendments and Modern Issues

944 words - 4 pages The first and second Amendments to the Constitution of the United States provide us with some of our most treasured freedoms and rights: Freedom of press, freedom of speech, the right to petition and freedom of religion are provided for in the first amendment. This gives individuals the right to speak freely, protects the printing and disseminating of public (non-government classified) information, gives individuals and groups the liberty to

A Critical analysis of The film Platoon

980 words - 4 pages apply elsewhere fade out for Barnes and others" (Kauffman 24). While serving his time Taylor experience the war in its full spectrum, from the homesickness and the comradery of the men to the nightmares of battle.The enemy is the North Vietnamese and the Viet Cong but you rarely view them except as shadowy figures in the jungle or momentarily illuminated by the light of a flare. There are no defined battle lines and the combat scenes lead you to

A Critical Analysis of Oedipus the King

882 words - 4 pages Sophocles background influenced him to write the drama Oedipus the king. One important influence on the story was his exposer to tragedy all around him. Jeffrey buller in “Sophocles” told us that Sophocles learned the art form of tragedy from Aeschylus. Sophocles later went to the Great Dionysus a competition for the greatest tragedy and won first place over Aeschylus. Also, Sophocles shows tragedy in the play by telling us about the legend the

A critical analysis of the play, "Ernest"

1065 words - 4 pages way that this play is related to year 11 students - similarly to the first point - is conformity. In those days, it was what fashionable people would do, and society should conform. Now days, it's what "cool" people do, and how society should conform, and Oscar Wilde knows that this is how we human beings operate. An example of this is when Gwendolen says in a heated dispute with Cecily about whether she wants bread or cake: "Bread and butter

The First Amendment of the United States Constitution

1308 words - 5 pages The United States Constitution was signed on September 17th, 1787. It did not include a bill of rights and it did not include their freedoms. And so, on September 25, 1789 Congress passed the first ten amendments, which were later ratified on December 15, 1791. The Bill of Rights was created by the Founding Fathers with the intent of restricting the powers of the new national government. The Bill of Rights, however, consists of 10 amendments

Similar Essays

The First And Second Amendments To The Constitution: A Brief Examination Of The Two

916 words - 4 pages The Bill of Rights is the first ten Amendments to the United States Constitution. They were added by the Founding Fathers to assert inalienable rights that would exist despite the power of the federal government. Careful consideration was made in creating these laws, as they were meant to stand the test of time. The wording, even the punctuation, has helped interpret various meanings in effort to encompass the ever-changing aspects of what is

Court Cases Challenging The First Ten Amendments To The Constitution

2286 words - 9 pages . This manner of “testing” of The Bill of Rights and of other amendments to the constitution is extremely important to ensure that the law is interpreted correctly and can be upheld in a consistent manner. Many of the cases that the Supreme Court tries are influenced by previous decisions made by those same Justices, or by Supreme Court Justices that came before them. By stringing cases together and associating rulings with one another, the law

The Importance Of The First Amendment: Which Of The Amendments To The Constitution Is Most Important And Why?

897 words - 4 pages rights given to each of the unique and individual thirteen colonies, now part of the United States of America. Specifically, the First Amendment includes the most important rights for a truly democratic society: the rights of religion, speech, press, assembly, and petition. Without these valued rights there would be no new ideas; we would all conform under totalitarian rule for fear of punishment, quite like in the fictional world of dictatorship

Fourth, Fifth, And Sixth Amendments To The Constitution

1212 words - 5 pages CJL 4064 Amendment Project As requested by the committee chair, I have examined the 4th, 5th, and 6th Amendments of our Constitution. It is imperative for the participants of the Constitutional Convention to update, and furthermore, enhance the Bill of Rights. The amendments were created with a valuable perspective on individual rights in the 1700's. Today, in 2010, our country has developed in the use of language, our principles, and