A Critical Evaluation Of The Issue Of Taking An Item From Work

2290 words - 9 pages

The act of stealing items from work can be considered as a crime under criminal statute. The theft act 1968 states that a person is guilty of committing a crime of theft if that person ‘dishonestly appropriates property belonging to another with the intention of permanently depriving’. In saying that the four main criminological presepectives, which include: classical, positivist, interactionist critical criminology, interpret the act of stealing an item from work differently. Ultimately, the issue of taking items from work is important as the idea of what constitutes stealing from work can be blurry. Throughout this essay comparatives and differences on each perspective will be discussed in terms of human nature, social order, how they define stealing from work and how they explain it.
Classical criminology perspectives define human nature as a rational decision that is governed by the individual’s free will (Walklate, 2013: 16), thus when an individual steals from their place of work they are consciously and freely committing this act. Classical criminologist further the idea that humans are regarded as rational beings as they are held entirely responsible for their own actions by society (Jones, 2006). Classical criminology is closely linked with the principles of right realism, in that the individual has a rational choice as to whether to steal from work. However, right realism and classical criminology alike fails to recognise that there other contributing factors leading towards a rational decision, such as biological factors that can influence the individual's ability to think rationally.
Therefore, positivist criminology rejects the principles of classical criminology and focuses on the idea that human nature is built upon individual biology. Positivism argues that individuals can posses abnormalities (Walklate 2002), and these abnormalities are atavistic which can lead that individual to deviate. Ultimately, positivism argues that an individual's behaviour is influenced or determined by other forces and they have no direct control over their own actions (Jones 2006, Vito et al 2007). Thus suggesting that individuals have no control over their ability to steal items from work. Positivist criminologists have gained acceptance of the idea that human nature is multi-factorial by that it is a matter of biology, psychology and social aspects and describes how individuals become socialised by learning to control their individual impulses and actions (Maguire et al, 2012).Positivism supports the idea of strain theory which suggests that human nature is to seek to achieve high goals. Merton, a founder of strain theory, argued that whilst all individuals seek to be successful, there are individual attitudes towards achieving these necessary goals; and these attitudes can lead to different behaviours (Jones, 2006). Furthermore, tensions and strains occur when the individual struggles with the balance between the legitimate and illegitimate...

Find Another Essay On A Critical Evaluation of The Issue of Taking an Item from Work

A Critical Evaluation of Small Business

9577 words - 38 pages A Critical evaluation of small business in South wale and UKAbstractTraditional training separates learning from the work context in which the newly acquired knowledge is to be applied. This requires the worker themselves to apply imparted theoretical knowledge to knowledge in practice, a process that is grossly inefficient. The ENRICH approach builds on organisational learning theory to intertwine working and learning. The ENRICH methodology

Critical Evaluation of a Research Article

766 words - 3 pages . The authors believed that prior research on this subject was too biased and did include interviews with the participants involved in the adoption proceedings.Participants in StudyThe participants in the study were eight mothers, eight fathers, and nine children. All those interviewed were from the Midwest area of the United States. The adoptions were completed from a mixture of international, private, and foster care agencies. Some families had

Evaluation of the Work of the Group

2242 words - 9 pages sitting, below everyone else, was set apart from the rest of the group. In this case, the levels showed how the sitting character was aside from the rest of the group because the character was guilty of a crime someone else was currently taking the blame for. The song expressed that the accused couldn't provide an alibi and so suffered his sentence, though there was no physical evidence condemning the accused

An Analysis of Forrest Gump, from a Social Work Perpective.

1135 words - 5 pages Forrest GumpAssignment 2The movie Forrest Gump stars Tom Hanks as a considerate, yet somewhat simple man, who sits down on a bus stop bench and tells his fascinating life story to basically anyonewho will listen. This movie is much different then the typical box office hits, which is why I chose it to analyze, it addresses many different social issues from Forrest Gumps innocent yet, matter-of-fact point of view.In the movie Forrest deals with

"The Merchant of Venice": Critical Evaluation

1142 words - 5 pages the Bible to get what they want as shown in Act 3 Scene 3 Line 88."This was a venture sir that Jacob served for,"When Shylocks daughter Jessica runs away with a Christian, Shylock becomes almost dead inside and very blood-thirsty. Leah, his wife is dead and Jessica is all he has left. Jessica is an only child and Shylock seems very over protective of her. For example in Act 2 Scene 5 Line 12 he says-"There are my keys,"And tells Jessica to lock

Paris street, Rainy day - Gustave Caillebotte This essay is basically taking a detailed look about the work of an artist named Caillebotte.

1767 words - 7 pages and it's now exhibiting at the art institute of Chicago. The general scene that's taking place in the painting is there is couple of people absorbed in their own world walking through the rain. It is such a beautiful painting it is guaranteed to catch our attention. Every little detail Caillebotte used to make this painting beautiful is terrific. Paris Street, Rainy day is painted using oil on canvas. "It is the process of painting with pigments

The Issue of Female Circumcision from a Medical Anthropology Perspective

1106 words - 5 pages bleeding (Shell Duncan 2001, 1015). Female circumcisions have strong cultural background meanings. A medical anthropologist would avoid approaching this issue with an ethnocentric mindset. It is helpful for the issue to be thought about from a cultural relativist perspective in order to understand the issue from the culture that it is related to (Gordon 1991,4). Also, one should consider how this issue of female circumcision relates to health

Benefits of Taking the Bus or Riding a Bike To School or Work

660 words - 3 pages cannot find a parking spots on campus; Public transportation or bicycle are the great ways to help you to move from your home and to the campus. I believe you should take a bus or a bicycle to work or study to protect the environment as well as your health. By taking the buses or bicycles, students can decrease the cost of living, improve the quality of their lives, and protect the environment. Most of the students can't afford to pay a car

An essay comparing the issue of abortion from the religious views of Catholics, Jews, and Buddhists.

1347 words - 5 pages Fate of the UnbornThroughout history, there has been a diversity of opinions regarding induced abortion from various religions and countries. To this day, there is no unified agreement within different religions and law authorities concerning the morality of abortion. Looking at abortion throughout time and around the globe provides an enlightening perspective on this important issue. Catholicism, Buddhism, and Judaism emphasize on the

A Critical Evaluation of the Complexities of Crime and Social Harm

2271 words - 9 pages Walters (2010) “Crime is doing something forbidden by law. That could mean stealing a mobile phone, vandalism, graffiti, mugging, stealing or taking and selling drugs” (Muncie, Talbot and Walters, (2010), p. 3). This definition of crime is very much focused on the ideas of what criminologists would class as ‘street crimes’, crimes that are generally committed by the poorer people within society, young people who come from council estates. However

The Qualities of a Good Sibling: An Evaluation Essay

875 words - 4 pages personality develops and help to mold them as a person. According to Jeffrey Kluger, a writer for TIME, there has always been an argument regarding what is actually the most influential in shaping an individual. Many scientists believe our parents or even our genes are what shapes us the most. Kluger concluded that scientists are starting to believe our siblings are actually the greatest influence in the molding of one’s personality (“The New Science

Similar Essays

A Critical Evaluation Of An Inspector Calls

1166 words - 5 pages An Inspector Calls Critical Evaluation - The main goal of this essay is to write about the role of Inspector Goole in the play. Other details will also going into consideration. An Inspector Calls Critical Evaluation The main goal of this essay is to write about the role of Inspector Goole in the play. Other details will also going into consideration. An Inspector Calls is a play wrote by J.B Priestly. The first scene shows a

A Critical Evaluation Of An Is Case Study (Fedex)

1917 words - 8 pages FedEx A Critical Analysis of an IS Case StudyWhat is E-commerce? Commerce is the buying and selling of goods and services. Over the past few years' commerce has moved from traditional features of selling products, but one main feature stays the same, the people.This essay will discuss how the FedEx Corporation used e-business and IT to grab a competitive advantage within their market place, this can be achieved by following some IS strategies

'a Memorial Tribute To Yeats: An Exploration Of His Work Through The Application Of Critical Readings'

1814 words - 7 pages application of different readings, resistant and Marxist, the reader is able to successfully draw alternate meanings from the poem. Thus allowing the poem to be received from various critical positions, as well as having the ability to transcend time and context depending on which reading is applied to the poem.Through Yeats' ability to construct poetry that can still have a profound impact upon its audience, although different to that of its day, his

A Critical Evaluation On The Corporate Communications Of Mcdonald’s

3103 words - 12 pages MKIB372A CRITICAL EVALUATION ON THE CORPORATE COMMUNICATIONS OF MCDONALD'STABLE OF CONTENTSPage1. Executive Summary 32. Introduction 43. Internal Communications 53.1. Intranet system 53.2. Employee magazine 83.3 Other internal methods 104. External Communications 114.1. Official website 124.2. Social media 164.2.1 Facebook 165. Recommendations 206. References 22 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARYThe report provides a critical evaluation on several