A Critical Evaluation Of The Representation Of Crime And The Agencies That Deal With It In John Grisham’s “A Time To Kill”

4313 words - 17 pages

A Critical Evaluation Of The Representation Of Crime And The Agencies That Deal With It In John Grisham's "A Time To Kill" A Time To Kill was John Grisham's first novel, and by his own admission there is "a lot of autobiography" in it. This legal-procedural novel follows the trial of a black father, accused of murdering the two white youths who raped his ten-year-old daughter. The main protagonist is not the defendant, Carl Lee Hailey, but the young white "street lawyer" , Jake Brigance, whom he employs to keep him from the gas chamber. The central issue of the book is the justification for murder (as the title suggests), and the construction of a defence around the insanity plea to "give the jury a way out" of conviction. However, the novel itself is about more than just rape, murder, and the inside of a courtroom. It covers a plethora of other issues, such as unethical practices inside the legal system, racial hatred, a "˜sliding scale' of acts that range from highly criminal though to merely unethical, and the everyday struggle of those agencies and individuals that are required to deal with them. In this essay I shall provide a critical evaluation of the fictional portrayal of some of these issues.The primary agencies that deal with crime in this book are the individuals who comprise the courtroom and judicial system, including judges, jurors, police officers, expert witnesses and, most notably, lawyers. In this novel the "˜traditional' detective, usually either a police officer or a private detective, is replaced by a lawyer. Whilst both are portrayed as "˜questing for truth and justice', "˜traditional' detective stories centre around the apprehension of the "˜villain', whereas in a legal-procedural novel, such as A Time To Kill, the story centres around the courtroom procedures that occur after a suspect has been apprehended. In detective novels it is assumed that the detective is never wrong, and that once unmasked the courts will find the perpetrator guilty as a matter of due process. However, in the legal procedural the suspense is maintained by observing the complex dance that is trodden inside a courtroom, between the agencies dealing with crime, as the gulf between "˜the law' and "˜justice' is ruthlessly exploited.Although Grisham practiced law for 10 years, his writing style displays a certain ambivalence towards both lawyers and the law. Jake is Grisham's "˜Avatar', and there are many parallels between the author and his creation. Both represented people, not companies, making them street lawyers and Grisham believes that "much of what [Jake] says and does is what [he] would say and do under the circumstances." Grisham's portrayal of Jake strongly reflects his disdain for the role that market forces play in the legal system. Jake faces a constant internal struggle between his ideals and his driving wish to achieve the "˜American Dream'. For example, Jake's legal fees are "based...

Find Another Essay On A Critical Evaluation Of The Representation Of Crime And The Agencies That Deal With It In John Grisham’s “A Time To Kill”

Evaluation Of The New Deal Essay

693 words - 3 pages musicians obtain a steady form of employment that would help lift the nations’ spirit. The federal Emergency Relief Act provided relief money for a limited time to those workers who had been laid off. For the black workers, the NAACP was created; it was one of the most important groups fighting for the rights of blacks and is still involved in the black community today. Minorities were still unchanged in the labors. Even under the new deal, blacks

The Grapes of Wrath, by John Steinbeck and To Kill A Mockingbird, by Harper Lee

1666 words - 7 pages protagonist, Scout. The theme of To Kill a Mockingbird is that individuals affect society in both good and bad aspects. With this intention, Lee demonstrates the idea by utilizing a mockingbird as the primary symbol of the novel and characterizing Scout to reveal and understand that both good and bad exist in the world. Scout learns that all a mockingbird does is good, it sings, but never does anything that people hate (Lee 90). Consequently, in the

Criminal profiling should become a common tool in criminal investigations because it provides a plethora of critical information that has led to the arrest of elusive and dangerous criminals in the...

3241 words - 13 pages profiling in the United States. Criminal profiling should become a common tool in criminal investigations because it provides a plethora of critical information that has led to the arrest of elusive and dangerous criminals in the past. Used on rare occasions, and almost exclusively on serial murder cases, criminal profiling analyzes all aspects of a crime. A criminal profiler examines the different phases of a crime, the key elements involved, and

Crime Rate Comparison Los Angeles vs. Susanville: The crime rates of a big city and a small town were compared to show that a large and diverse population causes a higher rate in crime.

887 words - 4 pages , 2005) Even though the gang problem is a factor in the crime rate, it ties into the problem of the high population in Los Angeles. Susanville will have want-to-be gang members once in a while, but the city police are able to keep it under control. The population in Susanville is small enough that the police and the community are able to be more hand-in-hand.In larger societies, more provisions for dealing with crime are made, as well. Courthouses

A critical evaluation of one of the theoretical approaches used to describe pattern/object recognition.

1206 words - 5 pages all the possible forms of a pattern. For example, humans would have to possess templates for every possible form of the letter H and to store this number of templates has been widely regarded as implausible (Eysenck & Keane, 2000). Feature theories deal with the flexibility problem of template theories as they suggest that templates are only needed for each feature and not each pattern, therefore less information needs to be stored in memory

Review of a time to kill

663 words - 3 pages A Time To Kill A courtroom drama, full of conversation and debate, can achieve gripping effects and touch the heart of the audiences. Each and every character grabs a hold of the law and throttles it. Jake Brigance (Matthew McConaughey) helps Carl Lee Hailey (Samuel L. Jackson) to defend his accusation of murder towards two white guys who had raped and attempted to kill Carl's little daughter Stacey aged 10 at the beginning of the film. The


3103 words - 12 pages (Tame, 2009).In the research, we can find that all the methods McDonald's have used in internal communications are specific to meet the needs of target groups and provide an effective access with appropriate technical support. For example, the success of MDUK is not a casual case since the publication team of McDonald's UK has put many efforts on researching employee reading preference. However, it is wise to realize that internal communications are

“You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view – until you climb into his skin and walk around in it” Discuss this statement, with reference to ‘To Kill a...

1151 words - 5 pages Compare/Contrast Essay Compare/Contrast Essay "You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view, until you climb into his skin and walk around in it." Discuss this statement with reference to "To Kill a Mockingbird" and "A Time to Kill" The novel To Kill a Mockingbird (TKaM) and the film A Time to Kill (ATtK) were set in the south of the United States in the

The essay talks about immirgation being a political issue in Europe and how the UK and Germany deal with it

2080 words - 8 pages its own culture that has pretty much been in place since the Treaty of Westphalia with a few changes due to peace treaty conditions after major wars.Countries have allowed immigration for a number of reasons firstly that they had no grounds to stop it, that there was a shortfall in certain areas of the labour pool and they were receiving displaced fellow countrymen or skilled artisans. Before World War One there was fairly unrestricted movement of

A Critical Evaluation of 'Lamb to the Slaughter' by Roald Dahl

999 words - 4 pages 'Lamb to the Slaughter' is a intriguing murder story set in the 1950's America written by the well renowned children's author Roald Dahl. The plot is threaded with irony, which injects it with dark humour. In this critical evaluation I will determine whether Mary Maloney premeditated the murder of her husband or if it was a spur of the moment act or 'crime of passion'.The short story is set in America and this is clear due to words such as

The prejudice that was used against Tom Robinson in the book To Kill A Mockingbird. It uses the OJ Simpson trial to compare and contrast.

595 words - 2 pages two trials all the victims, Nicole Brown and Ron Goldman in the OJ trial and Mayella Ewell in Tom Robinson's trial, were white. In To Kill A Mockingbird the victim was Mayella, a poor white girl who was abused by her father. Although it wasn't proved her father abused her, Mayella knew she could blame the crime on a black man and get away with it because of the racial tension in the south. One of the victims in the OJ Simpson case was Nicole

Similar Essays

A Critical Evaluation Of The Complexities Of Crime And Social Harm

2271 words - 9 pages , Talbot and Walters (2010) p. 139 are harms that are committed in the process of profit making which then case harm to either the consumer or the workers. Corporate crime is a prime example in showing where crime does come into play and how it differs with social harm. One Criminologist that tried to explain the concept of white collar crime was Edwin Sutherland who in Muncie, Talbot and Walters (2010) p. 147 states that the powerful businessmen

The Role Of Federal Agencies In Fighting Digital Crime

781 words - 3 pages challenges that limit enforcement efforts against digital crime. The Department Of Justice has had to address evolving challenges such as mortgage fraud, corporate fraud, and cyber crime including online child pornography. As it seeks to balance and address competing and new priorities, the department faces several key challenges. The FBI is continually faced with capital challenges in its transformation efforts to develop its

Assess One Or More Of The Asia Pacific’s Territorial Disputes And Provide A Critical Evaluation Of How It/They Link/S To Broader Issues Of Potential Conflict In The Region.

3549 words - 14 pages AI 3001 Asia-Pacific International RelationsAssess one or more of the Asia-Pacific's territorial disputes and provide a critical evaluation of how it/they link/s to broader issues of potential conflict in the region. After World War II, there is a long period which lasted more than 25 years that all the states in the world needed to resume their spirits and conducted their post-war reconstruction, especially the states in the Asia Pacific. At

Censorship A Crime Of The Ages. This Essay Deals With The Crime Of Censorship Of Literature, And How We Cannot Allow It To Keep Developing In Our Nation (Usa).

521 words - 2 pages A CRIME OF THE AGESYears ago, British playwright John Osborne uttered the statement, "Censorship is the most common social blasphemy because it is mostly concealed, built into us by indolence, self-interest and cowardice," his words, however old, remain true even today. Censorship. The very word suggests the oppression of the human race. Though the history of The United States of America has been a prosperous one, the banning of literature