This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Critical Review Against Dunning's Eclectic Theory

5612 words - 22 pages

INTRODUCTIONIt is true of everything that the first steps ate both the most important and the most difficult. To begin with, theorization consists of a set of definitions of concepts. The basic concepts underlying the eclectic theory of the multinational enterprise (MNE)(1) are currently being criticized by the internalization theorists(2) in that the 'ownership advantage' is 'double counting,' that is, the internalization and location factors are necessary and sufficient to explain the existence and growth of the MNE. The controversy seems to require a thorough examination of the concept of the 'ownership advantage'. However, the examination should extend further afield. Our objective in this paper is to assess critically the three basic concepts in the eclectic theory, i.e., the 'ownership advantage,' the 'internalization advantage,' and the 'location advantage' and to suggest the beginnings of an alternative framework to deal with the MNE and FDI (i.e., foreign direct investment).REDUNDANCY OF THE 'OWNERSHIP ADVANTAGE'Some Features of the Electic TheoryFirst of all, we must set up the target of our examination. The eclectic theory, Mark I, as advocated by Dunning is as follows [Dunning 1981:79]:1. It (i.e., the firm) possesses net ownership advantages vis-a-vis firms of other nationalities in serving particular markets. These ownership advantages largely take the form of the possession of intangible assets, that are, at least for a period of time, exclusive or specific to the firm possessing them.2. Assuming condition 1 is satisfied, it must be more beneficial to the enterprise possessing these advantages to use them itself rather than to sell or lease them to foreign firms, that is, for it to internalize its advantages through an extension of its own activities rather than externalize them through licensing and similar contracts with independent firms.3. Assuming conditions 1 and 2 are satisfied, it must be profitable for the enterprise to utilize these advantages in conjunction with at least some factor inputs (including natural resources) outside its home country; otherwise foreign markets would be served entirely by exports and domestic markets by domestic production.Four features of the eclectic theory should be noted here, as far as they are concerned with our argument. Firstly, needless to say, the concept of the advantage is a relative concept; i.e., advantage of a firm vis-a-vis the others tautologically means their disadvantage vis-a-vis the firm. The advantage is understood from the viewpoint of economic competitiveness and profitability, and thus it takes the form of an economic asset whether tangible or intangible. Thus, the asset value is measured by capitalizing the stream of expected future earnings by means of the rate of return. Secondly, the concept of internalization is interpreted as internalization of an 'ownership advantage' rather than that of an imperfect market.(3) Thirdly, the existence per se of the 'ownership...

Find Another Essay On A critical review against Dunning's Eclectic Theory

Critical Theory- A Social Theory Essay

1690 words - 7 pages , political and economic. The critical theory is known to be one of the theories that have been defined in different ways by different theorists depending on how they understood the theory. This paper will mainly discuss the literature review of the Critical theory and how it can be applied to television. To be precise I will focus on analyzing or criticizing feminism in a television series known as “Sex and the City”. I chose to criticize feminism

A Critical Review of Qualitative Methodological Approaches

1546 words - 6 pages unsuccessful behaviours of the executive coach and seeks to make recommendations as to the direction for coaching practice and training. Works Cited Brocki, J. M., & Wearden, A. J. (2006). A critical evaluation of the use of interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA) in health psychology. Psychology & Health, 21(1), 87-108. Gee, J. P. (1999). An introduction to discourse analysis : theory and method. New York: Routledge. Gee, J. P

Critical Analysis of a Systematic Review Article

2246 words - 9 pages (complicated)” (Geraldi et al.). The analysis will review the authors’ justification for the study and the transparency and rigor demonstrated in the five common systematic research phases described by Gough, Oliver, and Thomas (2012, p. 8). The reader will find this paper has two main sections and a closing. The first will provide the previous discussed critical analysis and then a brief summary of the overall value of the systematic research. The

Business Strategy Models- A Critical Review

3712 words - 15 pages Business Strategy - Critical Review (Strategy Models)It is the purpose of this paper to critically review several of the most important business models used by strategic managers in SBUs, we will review strategic models and frameworks proposed by the most influential business strategists and scholars and assess their values within today`s operating environment.Business strategy refers to the aggregated strategies of single business firm or a

A Critical Review of Francis Schaeffer

3352 words - 14 pages inconsistent they are with the past law or opinion" (p.218). He uses the example of abortion to explain how this has happened. There has a been a shift from the natural occurrence of child birth to having mankind make that decision. That means that society is going against nature when it is concerned with child birth. The changes in science is another theoretical assumption presented by Schaeffer. This is where Schaeffer describes how science has

The Míkmaw Concordat: A Critical Review

1823 words - 8 pages the Mi’kmaq and Catholicism. Further, Henderson’s exploration of the doctrine of Aboriginal imperium and dominium and it connection to the Concordat is important in understanding of Aboriginal rights in Canada. Not only does Henderson provide a text which highlights a not very well documented aspect of Aboriginal history does so using post-colonial theory in order to decolonize the ways in which society views of history and Aboriginal peoples

More Than Just A Victim: The Critical Race Theory (CRT)

989 words - 4 pages when such groups abundantly know that have the tools to generate violence? Has anybody looked, in first instance, at the great danger that domestic guns make in inappropriate hands? What about to demand in a unilateral group to revise the use of guns in our country? As a member of a social community and of a minority group, I think we still have to learn more about to protect us from ourselves. Bibliography Trevino, J., Harris, M., & Derron, W. (2008). What's So Critical About Critical Race Theory? Contemporary Justice Review , 11 (1), 7-10.

A critical Appraisal of Kohlberg's Theory Of Moral Development

1986 words - 8 pages Lawrence Kohlberg was born in Bronxville, New York on October 5th in 1927. He served as a professor at Harvard Univarsity. He started as a developmental psychologist in the early 1970s and became famous for his later work in moral education, especially his theory of moral developmentFor his doctoral research Kolhberg studied differences in children's reasoning about moral dilemmas. He hypothesized that moral difficulties motivated their

Good Sex? A Critical Review of School Sex Education

5381 words - 22 pages Since the 1960s, sex education in North American schools has been surrounded by controversy. Sex education evolved from brief units about anatomy to a preoccupation with the prevention of unwanted pregnancy and sexually transmitted diseases (STDs). By the 1990s, sex education occurred within comprehensive interventions that presented it as but one means of promoting holistic health. A critical review searching for a sex-positive perspective


818 words - 3 pages A critical review of Hope & Fraser's 'Beyond Budgeting'Jeremy Hope & Robin Fraser are two of three founders of the Beyond Budgeting Round Table (BBRT), a UK based non-profit organisation. The pair have led research into Beyond Budgeting since BBRT's inception in 1997, and have since written a book called 'Beyond Budgeting: How managers can break free from the Annual Performance Trap' (Hope & Fraser, 2003) detailing the first five

A Critical Review of F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby

1615 words - 6 pages A Critical Review of F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald is a universal and timeless literary masterpiece. Fitzgerald writes the novel during his time, about his time, and showing the bitter deterioration of his time. A combination of the 1920s high society lifestyle and the desperate attempts to reach its illusionary goals through wealth and power creates the essence behind The Great Gatsby

Similar Essays

Discussion Of The Contribution Of Dunning's Eclectic Theory

1951 words - 8 pages advantages to producing abroad?" This issue was then incorporated by John Dunning in his eclectic theory, which combines location advantage, ownership advantage (Ownership advantage theory), and internationalization advantage (Internalization theory) to form a unified theory of FDI. In addition, Dunning's theory is also highly related to the Product life cycle theory. According to Product life cycle theory, in the stage 3, the standardized product stage

A Critical Review Of Kelly’s Personality Theory In Personality Development

2648 words - 11 pages , 2013). George A. Kelly, an American psychologist born in 1905 in Kansa, is one of those major contributors in the field of personality psychology (Warren, 1998). In this paper, I am writing to critically review George A. Kelly's perspective on personality. I will first review Kelly's philosophy of personality. Then, I will review major concepts of Kelly's theory. Finally, I will critically evaluate Kelly's theory and share personal reflection on

Critical Review: Bradley A. Thayer, Bring In Darwin: Evolutionary Theory, Realism, And International Relations

1203 words - 5 pages In Thayer’s article, he makes an attempt to incorporate Darwin’s Evolutionary Theory into the international security studies. The article tries to answer a central question that what are the implications of Evolutionary theory to realist theory of international security and in what way can peace be achieved if warfare is part of human nature? This paper agrees with Thayer that Evolutionary theory provides a scientific theory foundation for

With Reference To At Least Three Companies Of Your Choice, Critically Evaluate Dunning's Eclectic Paradigm As A Framework Explaining The Reasons Why Companies Engage In Foreign Direct Investment

3043 words - 12 pages case because "the eclectic theory is not a theory but a paradigm (Masahiko.I 1991 pp456).Explaining the reasons for FDI is a complex task; there is no single theory that can easily explain the phenomena. In spite of criticisms, Dunning's EP has been the leading explanation of the growth of FDI over the past two decades, due to its broad appeal. It remains a powerful and robust paradigm (vis à vis other paradigms) for firms to apply when