A Criticism Of The Manifesto Of The Communist Party

917 words - 4 pages

Marx, in the late 1840’s, outlines most of his economic philosophy in the Manifesto of the Communist Party. He leads us through his materialistic conception of history, outlining the major class difference between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. He transitions this into a more teleological argument of the necessary evolution from the bonds of capitalistic slavery to communism, and criticizes all modern versions of socialism. Concluding with statements relating the modern communism movement to his underlying philosophy, Marx brings full circle the cry for a communist revolution. This paper will both argue for the validity of the materialistic conception of history based on division of labor and the rise of the proletarian as a force, and justify Marx’s brutal criticism of other types of socialism. However, Marx’s flips into praising communism as the inherent answer to economic and societal problems, and even states a list of short-term demands. Communism’s rise from the ashes of failed capitalism will be shown to be a perhaps misguided attempt at corralling the current and future intrinsic problems of capitalism into an impossible generalization impractical in the face of the modern relative luxury of the American Proletariat. Marx leaves us with unanswered questions as to the practicality and implementation (as well as perhaps the need) of a communist fix to capitalism’s complications.
In the first section entitled “Bourgeois and Proletarians,” Marx expounds on his view of the past as the “history of class struggles” (Tucker, 473). He introduces in the first few sentences the key division of the oppressor and the oppressed. For his purposes, the oppressor is considered the dominant class in a society, and the oppressor is represented by the working class. Marx examines history with an economic conscious, and rightly determines that the social construct has and still revolves around a division of labor. He references ancient Rome and its plebeians and slaves, as well as the serfs and vassals in the Middle Ages to give examples. These four social groups are what Marx considers “subordinate gradations” in a structured class society (Tucker, 474).
The single most important relationship in human existence is that between a man and his method of production. Though not explicitly referenced in this text, Marx believes that all social classes are a result of this relation to production and the pursuant requirement of humans to fulfill basic and false needs. As history advances, what becomes important is not the individuals and the events that surround them, but the further clarification and organization of labor. This progression from simple family units all the way to the emergence of the bourgeois as it exists in Marx’s time (and arguably still exists in the twenty-first century) justifies the view of history as the explicit march and development of...

Find Another Essay On A Criticism of the Manifesto of the Communist Party

Theories and Aims of the Communist Manifesto

972 words - 4 pages Stephen Flippin Erik Stumpf Theories and Aims of The Communist Manifesto The ideas presented by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels in The Communist Manifesto, while widely controversial, are some of the most influential political philosophies ever written. Most importantly, their political aims and theory on historical change provide a chronicle on how historical stages, class struggle and the monumental events of the mid-nineteenth century were

Historical Theory of the Communist Manifesto

988 words - 4 pages telegraph by Samuel Morse, and a new piece of writing called the Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. Marx and Engels wrote the Communist Manifesto because they were not happy with the way the governments were dealing with the economy. They both disagreed with the idea of capitalism, and joined the Communist League. The Communist League was a secret society that wanted to get rid of the “old bourgeois society,” and replace it with a

The Revolution of 1848 and Karl Marx's The Communist Manifesto

1612 words - 6 pages looming over Europe, and that countries would begin to see that communism is a way to help countries. Marx believed that many countries in Europe would begin to support his ideas. The second part of the Manifesto states that the communist are allies to the proletariat party. Marx says this because the proletariats are the working class people, the people who he was trying to promote. Marx felt that working class people should have

The Ideas of Karl Marx and The Communist Manifesto

2025 words - 8 pages The Ideas of Karl Marx and The Communist Manifesto It has been shown by many historians, scientists, and psychologists that people are affected by the world around them. This is exactly what caused Karl Marx to write his Communist Manifesto. The living conditions of the working class-his proletariat, as well as that of the bourgeoisie (the upper class) must have had a profound effect on his views and ideals. In France the

Religion at the time of the Communist Manifesto

1242 words - 5 pages (New York: Harper and Row, 1987) 13 [2] Anthony Armstrong, The Church of England, Methodists and Society 1700-1850 (New Jersey: Rowman and Littlefield, 1973) 178. [3] Lichtheim, George. Marxism. (New York: Frederick A. Praeger, 1961.) 33 [4] Armstrong, 178 [5] Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, Manifesto of the Communist Party, trans. Samuel Moore (Chicago: Charles H. Kerr Publishing Company, 1989) [6] Friedrich Engels

Society at the Time of the Communist Manifesto

1554 words - 6 pages Society at the Time of the Communist Manifesto Much was going on in society at the time the Communist Manifesto was written by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels. Society was undergoing many changes and issues, and many events took place as a result of this. To many people in England it seemed that the middle class was taking control—and Marx and Engels agreed

The Communist Manifesto

1370 words - 6 pages Political theorist, Karl Marx and Fredrich Engels wrote, Communist Manifesto, which is the documentation of the Communist party, published February 1848, in London. This is one of history's most influential literature pieces. This manifesto was written during a period known as “the hungry 1840's”, which accounted to their ideas and theories (Boyer 151). The Communist Manifesto contained many challenging ideas that changed the mind set of every

The Communist Manifesto

677 words - 3 pages ; By reading The Communist Manifesto written by Karl Marx and Frederick Engels I can better see why people have bought into this idea. Before reading this I was a less educated American supremacist. I felt my way was best and didn’t take much time to read in to the other sides` way. I now support the other countries in the way they govern their countries. This means that the United States can use it’s wealth to buy up more of the Earth’s

The Communist Manifesto

1163 words - 5 pages producers and in-person servers. (Reich, p.1) In “The Communist Manifesto” Marx claimed that conditions of existence and prosperity of bourgeoisie ultimately will be directed toward destruction of bourgeoisie as a class. (Marx, p.34-35) These essential conditions create set of destructive consequences for bourgeoisie. Marx highlighted that property relations, expansion of production and trade induced by constant revolutionizing of production which

A great article on the early and late life of Karl Marx....also includes information on the communist manifesto

512 words - 2 pages consolidated to form the Communist League, and Marx and Engels were commissioned to formulate a statement of principles. The program they submitted, known throughout the world as the Communist Manifesto, was the first systematic statement of modern socialist doctrine and was written by Marx, partly on the basis of a draft prepared by Engels. Marx contributed the central propositions of the Manifesto, which embody the materialist conception of

Karl Marx's The Communist Manifesto

1301 words - 5 pages Karl Marx's The Communist Manifesto The Communist Manifesto written by Karl Marx and Frederick Engels formulates the basic concepts of Communism. Faith and reason can be used to explain parts of this document. The Communist Manifesto has definite views dealing with faith, and along with this, religion. In the Manifesto, Marx states that religion is not needed in Communism because a society under Communism is classless. Marx uses

Similar Essays

A Criticism Of The Manifesto Of The Communist Party

2077 words - 9 pages outside of the workplace in the form of company-owned dormitories and shops. Wage-laborers are reduced to the bare minimum of subsistence, in a shockingly modern interpretation of Marx’s accurate 1840’s writings. However, it is important to note that this drastic form of exploitation seems only to occur in non-western civilization in direct relation to the social regulation enforced in the developed world. The Manifesto of the Communist Party is

The Manifesto Of The Communist Party

1603 words - 6 pages The Manifesto of the Communist Party Drafted in 1848 by Karl Marx and Frederick Engels, the “Manifesto of the Communist Party” outlines the views, tendencies, and aims of the communist party through the so-called philosophy of historical materialism (Distante). These views were expressed throughout four distinct sections of the “Manifesto of the Communist Party.” The first section describes the relationship between the bourgeois

Summary Of The Communist Manifesto Essay

523 words - 2 pages Summary of "The Communist Manifesto" The Communist Manifesto is a document written by Karl Marx, with the help of Friedrich Engels. It was written in the mid 1800s and is concerned with the inequalities in the social classes of the time. It is a story about what is wrong with the government and social class system. It talks about the history of inequalities in social class, solutions to the inequality, and the intent of Communists.Karl Marx

A Summary Of The Communist Manifesto By Karl Marx

1614 words - 6 pages A Summary of the Communist Manifesto by Karl Marx Karl Marx was an idealist. He observed the cruelties and injustices that the poor working class endured during the period of industrial revolution, and was inspired to write of a society in which no oppression existed for any class of people. Marx believed in a revolution that would end socialism and capitalism, and focus on communist principles. The Manifesto of the Communist Party, written