A Critique Of The Juliette Beck Speech

963 words - 4 pages

A Critique of the Juliette Beck Speech

Juliette Beck's speech, "Reclaiming Just and Sustainable Communities in the Age of Corporate Globalization" neither adequately described the problems of globalization as it is currently structured, nor did it provide any answers to the problems with it, either the real problems that actually exist (labor and environmental exploitation) or the problems that Beck purported (large corporations). Primarily, Beck's speech was flawed in that it was incoherent and empirical incorrect. For instance 1) it purported the idea that globalization was "not inevitable", 2) it called upon the myth of "small is beautiful", confusing the real problem with globalization (Capitalist structure) with a false problem (the scale of the Corporate in a globalized world), and 3) it was often merely incorrect in some of the ideas and statistics that it stated. Also, the speech was not true to its title (well, maybe it was in that both were basically ridden with non-sense), in that it did not give real economic or political alternatives to Corporate Globalization.

First, globalization already exists. The world's economic structure is already on a global scale. Although change is possible, the idea that we can regress back into history, destroying a globalized world and making Localism over all is not only a bad idea, but a useless, silly one. Capitalism, by its nature, is acquisitive, as is also imperialism. As long as either exist (usually joint hand and hand, at least in this point of pre-history), they will seek out, with the world's wonderful technology and knowledge, the few unmolested areas left in the world. These forces, by the sheer scale that they exist on, are impossible to overthrow at local levels, as people such as Beck would have you believe. Some other system, a large global one, would have to exist in order to ensure that either of these acquisitive systems would be unable to acquire and exploit the world en masse. Localism, by its nature, cannot address problems that exist beyond local levels. Globalization, it should be obvious, is one of these. Too bad for us on the left certain supposedly left political analysts of global activity cannot pick up this basic truth.

Maybe part of the reason one analyst in particular is unable to realize the futility of localism is that she has succumbed to the false romantic ideology that "small is beautiful". Much in the same way as libertarians and conservative, Beck beat on the drum of Localism, relating to the audience the 'horrors' of such companies as Wal-Mart, Nike, and Starbucks. She advised us not to shop at these as they (in the case of Wal-Mart) "drive out mom and pop stores" in local communities. As an alternative, we should shop at locally own stores, and buy "fair-trade" coffee. One should not try to persuade others into action on the basis of one's own guilt, for it is...

Find Another Essay On A Critique of the Juliette Beck Speech

Movie Critique for The King’s Speech

1143 words - 5 pages Stokes PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 1 Lanita StokesMr. BhattacharyaInterpersonal Communication 125October 20, 2011Movie Critique for The King's SpeechI watched The King's Speech for my movie critique at home. This film tells the story of Prince Albert, the Duke of York, and how he overcame a life-long speech impediment with the help of Lionel Logue, a speech therapist from Australia.The movie begins with Prince Albert (Colin Firth) attempting to

A Deconstructionist Critique of Chopin’s The Awakening

527 words - 2 pages A Deconstructionist Critique of Chopin’s The Awakening The multiplicity of meanings and (re)interpretations informing critical studies of The Awakening reveal a novel ripe for deconstructionist critique. Just as Chopin evokes an image of the sea as symbolic of Edna’s shifting consciousness (“never ceasing, whispering, clamoring, murmuring, inviting the soul to wander in abysses of solitude,”138), likewise the deconstructionist reading of a

"The Great Gatsby" - A Critique of Capitalism

1159 words - 5 pages F. Scott Fitzgerald’s masterpiece, The Great Gatsby, can be read as a critique of capitalism. Fitzgerald created a world where class and money are the essence of everyone’s desire. The plot and the settings of unfolding events in The Great Gatsby are perfect examples of structures of capitalism, along class lines, which allows for a Marxist capitalist critique. Even though Fitzgerald wasn’t a socialist or Marxist himself, he shows in his book

A Critique of DiLorenzo's The Real Lincoln

1898 words - 8 pages A Critique of the Real Lincoln The Real Lincoln: A New Look at Abraham Lincoln, His Agenda, and an Unnecessary War, by Thomas J. DiLorenzo completely shatters the illusion of the 16th President as the liberator of the slaves. DiLorenzo provides convincing evidence for Lincoln’s overt racism as expressed in his documented views on racial supremacy as stated in his desire to colonize all American blacks outside the United States (p. 4

A Critique Of the Stanford Experiment

561 words - 2 pages A Critique Of the Stanford Experiment'The Education of a Torturer' is an account of experiments that has similar resultsto that of Milgram's obedience experimentsthat were performed in 1963. Though bothexperiments vary drastically, both have one grim outcome, that is that, 'it is ordinarypeople, not psychopaths, who become the Eichmanns of history.'The Stanford experiment was performed by psychologists Craig Haney, W. CurtisBanks, and Philip

“From the Frontier of Writing”: A Critique

1076 words - 5 pages battle between two forces much like the battle being fought at the time between North and South Ireland. The first image we see is that of someone driving through the frontier, this can be seen as the representation of how Heaney feels when his work is being put through the motion of publishing. As said in the first stanza "when the car stops in the road, the troops inspect its make and number," this is a metaphor as to how one would critique

Dear Shakespeare: A Critique Of The Tempest

738 words - 3 pages Dear Shakespeare: A Critique of The Tempest To Mr. William Shakespeare,      I am going to get right down to business. I am writing to you regarding our recent collaboration on The Tempest. In my opinion I think we need to make a couple of changes. The first is in regards to Caliban and the second has to do with Prospero.      As I was reading the section of the play where Caliban takes

A Critique of the Categorical imperative

1890 words - 8 pages A Critique of the Categorical imperative Immanuel Kant was without doubt one of the most influential Philosophers of his time. He was born in Koinsberg, Prussia on the 22nd of April 1724, and died on the 12th of February 1804 at the age of 79. Throughout his life Kant contributed his ideas to many major fields of Philosophy; however his biggest contribution was to the realm of ethics, when he developed the concept of the categorical imperative

A CRITIQUE OF THE SERVICE MANAGEMENT IDEAS

2031 words - 9 pages Dynamic service sector development is one of the most actual trends of the modern economy. Over the last decade, the number of service organizations has significantly increased, increased employment in this sector has expanded the range of services and competition has intensified as well. Specificity of management service organizations is being actively studied since 60 -70ies of the twentieth century. Service management is recognized as a

A Marxist Critique of the Occupy Movement

1450 words - 6 pages For a movement that impacted the country both socially and politically, the occupy movement started out relatively small. According to Peter Katel of the CQ Researcher, a group of 1,000 protesters settled into Zuccotti Park, in New York City, in mid-September of 2011. This group, motivated by the growing chasm between the wealthy and middle classes hoped that non-violent protest could enlighten lawmakers and bring about economic change. The

A Journal of the Plague Year Critique

2111 words - 9 pages A Journal of the Plague Year is a first person account of what it was like living through the times of the plague. It recollects stories and other accounts of plague times heard by and collected by the Defoe from other involved individuals. Explains many aspects before, during, and after the plague of their ways of life and culture. Tells of tales of survivors of the plague but mostly off different tales of deaths and how they died in many

Similar Essays

A Review Of The Beck Youth Inventories For Children And Adolescents

1501 words - 6 pages The Beck Youth Inventory Test was developed in 2001 by Judith Beck, Aaron Beck, John Jolly, and Robert Steer. The purpose of this psychological testing tool is a brief self-report to measure the distress in children and adolescents (Flanagan & Henington, 2005). The Beck Youth Inventory includes using five self-administered scales. The five tests include the Beck Depression Inventory, Beck Anxiety Inventory, Beck Anger Inventory, Beck

Analyse How The Film Edward Scissorhands Is A Critique Of Society Nbcs Year 10 Speech

1027 words - 5 pages Thesis- Society has a trouble accepting people that aren’t of the same status as them, Edward Scissorhands is a critique of society because it shows us the unhealthy obsession people have with unique things, money and social status. Society has trouble accepting people that aren’t of the same status as them Edward Scissorhands is a critique of society because it shows us the unhealthy obsession people have with unique things, money and

A Critique On A Critique Of A Speech: Lessons In Leadership From Fdr

795 words - 4 pages Everybody Will ALWAYS Judge You A Critique on a Critique of a Speech Many people throughout history have read and reread and discussed, critiqued, dissected, and reinterpreted other people’s stories and speeches. They all try to find a new way to look at them and try to make everybody listen to their ideas of what they mean. They pick out every tiny little detail of the said speech until there’s not much more to admire and sometimes they often

A Critique On Jinnahs Speech

1839 words - 8 pages powerful and effective. The given extract is the concluding part of Jinnah’s speech at the All-India Muslim League session at Calcutta on 12th December 1917. Jinnah sheds light on the prominent wrongs that the British were doing by depriving the natives of their rights and refusing them a say in their government. He tried to awaken a realization among the people, telling them that the present conditions they thrived in were not acceptable and could