A Critique Of "Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior Iu Acp Composition Critique Essay

827 words - 4 pages

1
A Critique of “Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior”
In “Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior,” Elisabeth Panttaja offers a claim through her analysis on how Cinderella is not the helpless victim she is known for, or the motherless protagonist. She compares the mothers to prove Cinderella is not superior and in fact it is the mothers who are. The text presents Panttaja’s argument that Cinderella along with her mothers actions are not morally correct compared to what the story is known for, Cinderella lets her mother control the prince which is not morally correct. Panttaja’s argument relies on an analysis of details from a specific version of the tale Cinderella and the Grimm Brothers’ version. While her thesis “Cinderella succeeds not because she is more patient or virtuous than her stepsisters or stepmother, but because she is a craftier, willing to employ powerful magic to defeat the forces arrayed against her” (286) can be discussed. Panttaja does not cover the specifics of the theme of the fairytale; nor analyzes them as deeply for the argument to be effective.
Panttaja argues that Cinderella is not the the character everyone sees her to be; Cinderella is actually not so good hearted and has a mother there for her. Panttaja believes that Cinderella’s mother plays a key role into the moral of the story along with the decisions Cinderella makes (Panttaja, 286). Although the mother is dead she still remains superior with the most power. Throughout the story the dead mother uses magical powers to put Cinderella at the top. The alleged topic of the famous story is known to be about love but is really about the mother / daughter relationship. Panttaja argues that the "evil" stepmother and the real mother are very similar, wanting the best for their daughters and doing everything to make them the best. Unlike the original story in Grimms the prince is "enchanted" to Cinderella from the mothers magic (288). The two stories also differ one calling Cinderella "deformed" and the sisters "fair" and visa versa (288). In conclusion, the story talks more about the mothers than the love that cinderella finds.
Panttaja builds her strongest argument when discussing the mother and step mother. Panttaja uses the mothers morals to draw parallels between the mother and step mother. Both mothers share the same goals for their daughters, “a future of power and willing to do anything for it” (288). They do this so their daughters have an “advantage marriage”. Panttaja interrogates the mothers morals and...

Find Another Essay On A Critique of "Cinderella: Not So Morally Superior - IU - ACP Composition - Critique Essay

The Not So Cinderella Story Essay

1581 words - 7 pages it was barely big enough for one, filled the room. She only had a few keepsakes, but her favorite was the framed photograph of her and her father that was sitting on her dresser. Her mom had left when Bethany was only six years old. Her dad then remarried to a very unpleasant woman and then passed away a few years after. It has been eight years since he died. So now, Bethany was stuck with her “Evil Step Mother” as she liked to call her, but her

This essay is a critique on how shrek depicts and discusses servral issues such as the theory of a utopia and how society view people who are different than the so called "norm"

1423 words - 6 pages The movie Shrek which starts like any other fairy tale with a once upon a time, a princess trapped in a tower and her knight in shining armour. But once we see who the hero of the story is it is made obvious that this is not your typical fairy tale. I found this movie to have amazing graphics that looked almost human, a hilarious plot which is a one of a kind. The most enjoyable part was the repartee between Shrek and Donkey from Ogres having

"Rethinking Weight" by Amanda Spake, A Critique Paper Obesity is Not a Personal Problem

943 words - 4 pages . People with health insurance should look to see what is covered and seek healthier, less-expensive alternatives to fix the things that are not included. Regardless of what "Rethinking Weight" suggests, overweight individuals have an equal opportunity to replace their existing lifestyle with healthier habits.Works CitedSpake, Amanda. "Rethinking Wight." Writing and Reading for ACP Composition. Eds. Thomas E. Leahey and Christine R. Farris. Upper Saddle River: Prentice Hall, 2009. 282-88. Print.

"Corporate Financing and Investment Decisions When Firms have Information that Investors Do not have: A critique."

1672 words - 7 pages This is a critique write up on A famous paper "CORPORATE FINANCING AND INVESTMENT DECISIONS WHEN FIRMS HAVE INFORMATION THAT INVESTORS DO NOT HAVE" by Myers & Majluf (1984). This write-up investigates their motivation, research methodology, and policy implication in details.I. Introduction.Does capital structure matter? The proposition of the famous MM's argued that the firm's value is determined solely by its real assets, not by the

Critique of Article Titled "An American Attack on Iraq is not Justified"

822 words - 3 pages "An American Attack on Iraq is Not Justified" was written by John E. Farley in 2002 when congress was considering a resolution to the 9-11 attacks. Farley is a professor of sociology at Southern Illinois University and still participates in war protests to this day. Farley's argument is exactly what the title states, a war in Iraq is not justifiable. The United States ultimately went to war against Iraq on March 19, 2003. Since then, the

Is euthanasia ever morally justified in your view? If so why and under what conditions? If not, why not?

3158 words - 13 pages Alise Boehme PHIL101 - Bioethics Assessment One Student Number : 220107672 Word Count: 2737 Is euthanasia ever morally justified in your view? If so why and under what conditions? If not, why not? Many people have their own judgment on whether a human should have the ability to end their own life, some believe it would be morally acceptable if they were suffering from terminal illness or were in serious un-­‐relievable pain, but

Concert Critique of a Queen Concert - Essay

853 words - 4 pages Concert Critique QUEEN: Hungarian Rhapsody – Live in Budapest 1986 The Origins of Rock and Roll module from this week has been one of my favorites. I have always enjoyed the sounds of the instruments and the talented singers of rock and roll music since I was a kid. I remember growing up and listening to my mom and dad’s rock albums from bands like Journey, Boston, STYX, and many more bands that I have grown to love. For my concert critique, I

Critique of The Essay

619 words - 3 pages hyperbolic and preposterous, which appeared to be an obstacle for the readers grew up in the 21th century. Where were those conservative views from? Whether those conservative views represented a public view or only a small part of conservative people? Why would they only attack bicycle manufactory? Without the explanation of the social background of the so-called “conservative views”, it was really difficult for the readers of the younger generation to

A Critique of Suspense

762 words - 4 pages Sariah Durrant Essay A Critique of Suspense Evaluations Done On The Cask of Amontillado Throughout history, many renowned writers have been noticed for certain aspects of their work. Whether it be fiction or non-fiction, the authors always seem to have one general theme that goes about their stories. The all too well known intro, climax, and conclusion. It almost seems boring when you come to realize that it is in nearly every single book

Critique of a Website

1611 words - 6 pages rag on Raygun or anything, because I like A LOT of the stuff that they do, but one must not get carried away with it and ignore what one is supposed to be doing in the first place. For this reason I have chosen to pick on the Alternative X web site (http://www.altx.com/), for this paper. Well, not really pick on them, but you know what I mean. So in our quest to discover the ideal web page we must look at the following things: 1) Does it make

Critique of a Blogpost

793 words - 4 pages So I found this article via a Facebook friend. The following comment is what I wrote on that friends wall. I felt it only appropriate to allow the author to read and respond to my criticism. So, as black man who's, currently, very irreligious but was a Christian for 15 years, my perspective on this article may be different from that of the author's. While I think the author of this article has internalized the patriarchy inherent to many

Similar Essays

A Critique Of Jakob And Wilhelm Grimm's Cinderella

779 words - 4 pages no feeling for his young daughter. The story does not explain why her father ignored these actions, so one can only make assumptions. The King of the land appointed a festival which would last three days, and all of the beautiful young girls in the county were welcome so that his son could find a bride. Cinderella wanted to go to the festival; however, her step-mother and step-sisters would not let her go until she completed all of her chores

A Critique Of “ ‘Cinderella’ : A Story Of Sibling Rivalry And Oedipal Conflicts By Bruno Bettelheim

1771 words - 7 pages of Abel when his offering to the Lord was rejected while Abel’s was accepted. This caused him great agony, but he wasn’t the only one. The fairytale “Cinderella” encompases the ideas of sibling rivalry as well as the agonies and hopes that correspond with it. In the essay: “ ‘Cinderella’: A Story of Sibling Rivalry and Oedipal Conflicts”’, Bruno Bettelheim discusses how Cinderella is a story about the difficulties of sibling rivalry and the

A Critique Of “ ‘Cinderella’ : A Story Of Sibling Rivalry And Oedipal Conflicts By Bruno Bettelheim

1535 words - 7 pages . Also, Bettelheim assumes a position in which every child fits into his descriptions of sibling rivalry; however, he does not consider that many children will not behave as expected. This is important because, had he considered these ideas he could have made a more solid stance in his paper. By mentioning opposing views he could strengthen his ideas by making those views sound incorrect. Either way, Bettelheim's essay thoroughly explains why people are so fascinated with “Cinderella”. Works Cited i have 1

Critique Of Bruno Bettelheim's And Karen Kolbenschlag's Interpretation Of "Cinderella"

911 words - 4 pages discern, and are sometimes viewed quite differently by different critics. This shall be demonstrated in the synthesis of Freudian psychologist Bruno Bettelheim's work "'Cinderella': A Story of Sibling Rivalry and Oedipal Conflicts," and an excerpt from Feminist writer Madonna Kolbenschlag's work "Kiss Sleeping Beauty Good-Bye: Breaking the Spell of Feminine Myths and Models."The story of Cinderella finds its way into so many children's hearts