This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Critique Of "For Gay Marriage," By Andrew Sullivan

523 words - 2 pages

In Andrew Sullivan's article, "For Gay Marriage", he is a man on a mission. He appears to be so fully committed to democratic values that he seeks to extend equal rights in marriage to homosexuals. And he makes an admirable case for equality and dignity for all people, including homosexuals. However, he could make an even stronger case by citing more studies and expert opinions.Although Sullivan's meaning is well taken by sympathetic readers, the fact is that he could overcome much of the ambiguity of his presentation by citing more concrete studies, including long-term studies, which support his key points. For example, when he makes the assertion that "in some ways the marriage issue is exactly parallel to the military" (283), it is unclear exactly what he means. Is he referring to prejudice against gay soldiers? On the other hand, is he referring to a common requirement of self-sacrifice? The answer is simply not clear because Sullivan never cites any studies of the problem he has in mind.An even more important point for Sullivan concerns child-rearing. He asserts, one may say correctly if he already shares Sullivan's opinion, that children raised by homosexual partners are as well adjusted as children raised by traditional, heterosexual parents. This would be a perfect opportunity for Sullivan to cite several well-conducted, long-term studies which bear out his view. But does he take the opportunity? Does he cite any studies? No, not one.Another key point for Sullivan concerns the relative importance of legalizing gay marriage. He asserts that "if nothing else were done at all,...

Find Another Essay On A Critique of "For Gay Marriage," by Andrew Sullivan

Legalization of Gay Marriage Essay

1585 words - 7 pages as, be safe from being fired, get married, be parents in many states, serve the military as transgendered, and be served by every business. These are many of the hardships of being a part of the LGBT society. There are many reasons for things being the way they are still today. Some of the reasons why people have such a hard time in accepting gay marriage have to do with, religion, accepting change, having parents tell you that it’s not right

Legalization of Gay Marriage Essay

1072 words - 4 pages Samantha ThorntonHD FS 276April 14, 2013Legalization of Gay Marriage"We hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" (United States Declaration of Independence). How can a society that has progressed so beautifully still debate over whether a certain human being should be allowed equal

Legalization of Gay Marriage

1072 words - 4 pages Samantha ThorntonHD FS 276April 14, 2013Legalization of Gay Marriage"We hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights; that among these are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness" (United States Declaration of Independence). How can a society that has progressed so beautifully still debate over whether a certain human being should be allowed equal

Issues of Gay Marriage

1192 words - 5 pages In the United States, the denial of the right to permit gay marriage has become a social turbulence regarding the federal government. As the gay community expands, the issue expands. There is an effort by many states to enact laws on this issue. Some cities around the country are also writing their own laws. This is a decision that should be made by the person who has to live with his or her spouse, not the person’s nation. This nation declares

Support of Gay Marriage

1785 words - 7 pages Proposition 8 in California that banned gay marriage was in fact unconstitutional based on Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses (Walker). Same-sex marriage is a civil right. A Supreme Court case, Loving v. Virginia, in 1967 confirmed that marriage is "one of the basic civil rights of man," and same-sex marriages should receive the same protections given to interracial marriages by that ruling. According to Section One of the 14th amendment

Solution of gay marriage

819 words - 3 pages (2011), "a staggering 90 percent of transgender workers report some form of harassment or mistreatment on the job." Many also have lost their jobs or have been paid unfairly due to their sexuality. Reported by the Huffington Post, "Discrimination, Gay Voices News, A teacher at a private Catholic high school in Pennsylvania says he was fired for getting his gay marriage license on Friday, reports local ABC affiliate WPVI-TV." Many homosexuals are

Legalization of Gay Marriage - 972 words

972 words - 4 pages As of 2013 more than 45% of Americans say their views have changed significantly over time. According to Pew Research Center, 18 to 29 year olds are the most supportive of this legalization. The Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) allows states to not recognize gay marriage created in other states that do allow it. DOMA was written so broadly that it touches more than a thousand federal laws and was struck down by the Supreme Court. Many same-sex

On the subject of gay marriage and homosexuality A manifesto

4163 words - 17 pages On the Subject of Gay Marriage and HomosexualityThis Gay marriage issue is a vexing one to be sure. The pro Gay marriage lobby has decided that the reason of the issue is the "Full faith and credit clause" in Article IV of the U.S. Constitution. They are claiming that if Massachusetts issues licensees for Gays to marry then all the other states of the union must honor those unions just as they do the traditional marriage between opposite sexes

A Pro-Gay Marriage Argument

1120 words - 4 pages . 27 Apr. 2011. Saletan, William. "Should Gays Adopt Kids? - By William Saletan." Slate Magazine. 7 Feb. 2002 Web. 26 April 2011 Schulman, Sam. "The Worst Thing About Gay Marriage | The Weekly Standard." The Weekly Standard | A Weekly Conservative Magazine and Blog of News and Opinion. 1 June 2009. Web. 25 Apr. 2011. Sprigg, Peter. "Warwick Beacon - Pro Family Group Ready for Gay Marriage Debate." Warwick Beacon - Breaking News, Classifieds,

A review of the book, Andrew Jackson and the Search for Vindication by James Curtis

923 words - 4 pages From his early childhood to his days in presidency, Andrew Jackson's fueled a revolution in politics and the search for vindication of the American people. In this psychoanalytical biography of Andrew Jackson, James C. Curtis explores Jackson's tenacious personality and lifelong quest for power, which was deeply rooted in his troubled past.Beginning in the backwoods of the Carolina's, young Andrew Jackson was born to a couple from Northern

Critque of "Against Gay Marriage"

1597 words - 6 pages ever seen such an extreme example? Is this a real pair of brothers, or are they merely made up and cited for the sake of argument? Whether or not these brothers are fictitious is never stated, but as Andrew Sullivan puts it in his essay "For Gay Marriage", the right to marry has been appropriately denied by the state to close family members and relatives because "familial emotional ties" are too powerful to permit a marriage contract to be entered

Similar Essays

A Critique Of William J. Bennett's "Against Gay Marriage"

601 words - 2 pages William J. Bennett, a great spokesman for American conservatives, has powerfully argued as the title indicates in his article "Against Gay Marriage." One does not have to agree with Bennett to appreciate the strength and goodness of his mind. Still, although he raises serious objections to same-sex marriage, his argument overall reads more like an outline, lacking specifics and expert opinions, referring to only one organized, careful study, and

The Pursuit Of Happiness Four Revolutionary Words, By Andrew Sullivan

858 words - 3 pages November 2001, so in no doubt was it written somewhere close to the release date. The world is changing, becoming more Americanized, with such establishments as "McDonalds and Starbucks to MTV"(Sullivan). The people of these other countries are watching the freedom that they feel we have as expressed though American television and businesses. A fear of total anarchy has arisen in the hearts of their leaders, and many are holding on for dear life to

Summary Of For Gay Marriage Essay

1106 words - 4 pages Summary of "For Gay Marriage"In his essay "For Gay Marriage," Andrew Sullivan argues that marriage isn't and has never been, in his view just a "private contract" between two people, and that now marriage is seen as a social and public recognition of such a commitment (404). Sullivan argues that to refuse homosexuals the right to marry is a public offense to their rights and equality as citizens. Sullivan makes the case in his essay that

For Gay Marriage Essay

759 words - 4 pages psychological bond between two people (Sullivan 30). By doing this, Sullivan attempted to argue that heterosexuals and homosexuals are the same. However, his lack of specific evidence and use of the logical fallacy, oversimplification, muddy and weaken his argument. This article, probably meant to show a sympathetic side in the debate about gay marriage, showed the overarching components for any marriage debate. Which, oddly enough, made Sullivan’s claims