A Critique Of "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor"

3064 words - 12 pages

Since 1991, the southern half of Somalia, a poverty stricken African nation, has seen various tribal militias battle for dominance and power over individual regions of the country. Violence has plagued Mogadishu, the capital, since warlords ousted the former president. Mere months after the collapse of the government, men, women and children in torn clothes ran helplessly towards packages dropped from military planes towards the hot sand of their tiny village. This action was one of many attempts to help underdeveloped nations receive food by the United Nations' World Food Programme. Within his article titled "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case Against Helping the Poor", Garret Hardin, a well-known philosopher of ecology, analyzes the difficulty and ultimate ruin associated with providing aid to these nations. Hardin's argument for the preservation of well-to-do societies is embodied by his extended metaphor of each society as a lifeboat, with the citizens of developed nations riding calmly amongst a sea of drowning poverty-stricken individuals. Ultimately, Hardin argues for a very harsh thesis: regardless of the current situation, privileged nations simply should not provide aid to those individuals trapped within the vortex of underdeveloped nations. His argument is consequentialist: he claims that the net result of doing so would be negative and would, in the long run, court large-scale disaster. Although Hardin's argument appears logic-based, his excessive metaphors fail when applied to real-life scenarios, for oftentimes he misconstrues facts to create a claim that may be perceived as more accurate than reality illustrates. Furthermore, any counter-arguments Hardin feels may refute his claim are pushed aside, avoiding factual evidence that may prove his argument inaccurate or misleading. Much like a lifeboat, Hardin leaves the assertions of the "humanitarian apologists" to drown so as to avoid the overturn of his claim.Within the section titled "Adrift in a Moral Sea", Hardin reveals the lifeboat analogy upon which this essay is almost entirely founded, although shortly after it is presented one can see a loophole he cleverly ignores. The metaphor he creates is, nonetheless, coherent, and is used to describe the limited carrying capacity a lifeboat (rich nations), can hold:So here we sit, say 50 people in our lifeboat. To be generous, let us assume it has room for 10 more, making a total capacity of 60. Suppose the 50 of us in the lifeboat see 100 others swimming in the water outside, begging for admission to our boat … since the needs of all in the water are the same … we could take them into our boat, making a total of 150 in a boat designed for 60. The boat swamps, everyone drowns. Complete justice, complete catastrophe … we might let 10 aboard, but how do we choose? And what about the need for a safety factor? (1,2)Although logical, this metaphor is undoubtedly dubious. Hardin characterizes the safe and the drowning as rich...

Find Another Essay On A Critique of "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping the Poor"

Christianity and helping the poor--Sara Vee

1379 words - 6 pages this is read from the Bible, all that is thought of is that we are people of God and that we need to take God's commands seriously and to heart. Why, how, and how much should the needy be helped? Take a look at some examples and we can see what God commands us to do with the needy.While helping to support the needy, it is important to remember to not just give things to people who are less fortunate than others, but to "assist" them in doing things

A Case Study Depicting the Importance of Ethics in Medicine

4553 words - 18 pages action is determined as either right or wrong (Rumbold, 1999; MacIntyre, 2005). Therefore, ethics is the study of morality which is also known as moral philosophy (Sim, 1997; Thompson et al, 2006). When one moral principle conflicts with another, it is referred to as a moral or ethical dilemma (Sim, 1997). Hence, ethics provides a framework for addressing dilemmas (Rumbold, 1999). Thus, Thompson et al (2006), highlights that clients are

Irrational Pollution & Ethics: A Case Study of the Ford Excursion

1206 words - 5 pages in a web of interdependence (Shaw & Barry, 2001). The disruption of the global ecosystem has resulted in among other things, mass glacier retreat, extinction of coral reefs, droughts throughout parts of Asia and Africa, climatic storms and natural disasters, and the disruption of migration patterns from mammals to insects (TIME, 2001). In addition, heat spells and poor air quality have caused the premature deaths of untold numbers of people

the case against the case against burger

1030 words - 5 pages Burger, which is just a common daily food of Americans, suffer a lot after coming to China as debate on whether people can eat them or not has never ceased. The divergence on the answer to that problem seems to be part of the generation gap as today’s kids as crazy about burgers while their parents hate burgers. Burgers are just burgers; should there be debate on them? People should stop meaningless debate. McDonald's burgers seem to be the

A case against the minimum wag

2040 words - 8 pages that a consumer regardless of their income has the right to safety, which is knowing if a product is hazardous to their health. The right to be protected against false advertising, the right to have products and services at competitive prices, and the right to be heard.These rights have often been bent when it comes to low-income minority consumers. Often times minorities are exposed to unsafe products, have less access to information, have fewer

The Case Against Monarchy

1759 words - 7 pages The Case Against Monarchy The idea that a monarchy is the ideal form of government is a fallacy. Al-Farabi and Aquinas’ ideas about government are wrong, and are filled with irreparable holes. In modern times, the idea of a monarchy has become counter-intuitive and counter-productive. A democratic republic paired with an educated and empowered middle-class is the solution to the quandary of how to create the perfect government. While the ideas

The Case Against Euthanasia

1184 words - 5 pages A recent survey by the Canadian Medical Association discovered that “ . . . 44 per cent of doctors would refuse a request for physician-assisted dying . . . ” (Kirkey 2). Euthanasia is defined as assisting a terminally ill patient with dying early. In many countries the legalization of this practice is being debated in many countries. All doctors against assisted suicide, including the 44 percent in Canada, are on the right side of the argument

Summary of Living on a Lifeboat

958 words - 4 pages can drown. The lifeboat itself is a metaphor used to symbolize the earth and the individual lifeboats. He uses the metaphor lifeboats to illustrate that we have limited resources and space. It also questions justice and how much can we help others if we have issues of our own. "The poor world are in other, much more crowded, lifeboats".(Hardin, 1974). This quote explains the "luggage" that comes with helping people. People that come from poor

Argumentative Critique of the Essay "A Case for Torture" by Michael Levin.

757 words - 3 pages the case, it can be said that Levin really knows how to write a good persuasive argument; however, his oversights deduct from what could be an incredible persuasive essay.The overall impression of the essay was good. It seemed the argument itself was well though out, but the actual writing itself was what most needed work. Without a doubt, Levin's essay presents some very valid facts and they are rather well supported in most cases; however, to

tears of the poor

2098 words - 9 pages an underdevelopment country is, let’s take a look at the dictionary definition. (Cambridge.org dictionary) “Underdevelopment country is a country that is less developed economically than most others, with little industry and little money spent on education, health care…poor country.” But how countries can become less developed than other countries? Why do they become underdeveloped? Underdevelopment of a countries economy can be attributed to

Helping the Family of Prisoners

1067 words - 4 pages 1. Helping the Family of Prisoners According to available statistics, the number of people who are incarcerated in state and federal prisons in the United States of America increases each year. Estimation indicates a 2.5 percent increase in the number of prisoners in USA from last year; it suggests a number of 2245000 inmates in all prisons in USA (Reuter). Such a rapid growth in the number of prisoners has several consequences. More prisons

Similar Essays

Response To Garrett Hardin's Article "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor."

512 words - 2 pages I find a few things wrong with Garrett Hardin's article "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor." The dominant argument I have against his article is that it is completely one sided. Hardin fails to even glance at the people, who do not fall under his ideas of what our society, nation, world is like. He has his own opinions, which he is 100% entitled to, but he poses these ideas in his article in such a way that he leaves no room for

Justice Vs. Reality In "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor" By Garrett Hardin

570 words - 2 pages The essay titled "Lifeboat Ethics: the Case against Helping the Poor" by Garrett Hardin, was very interesting. The first part of the essay used a metaphor of the rich people of the earth in a lifeboat and the poor people in the sea drowning. The rich people could only allow a few people in and if they let, too many people in they will sink the boat and all die. The best thing for the rich people to do is not to let anyone in so they will have

Garrett Hardin In "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against The Poor"

813 words - 3 pages Garrett Hardin in "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against the Poor" Garrett Hardin writes about saving the poor in his essay "Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against the Poor" found in The Blair Reader. Hardin writes about how the rich countries are in the lifeboat and the poor countries are swimming in the ocean. He also writes about how the United States helps other countries. Hardin feels that if the government keeps helping other

The Effective Concept Of Lifeboat Ethics

1767 words - 7 pages Lifeboat Ethics is a metaphor for the process of wealth and resource distribution as described by ecologist Garrett Hardin. In 1974, he published an article called, “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case against Helping the Poor,” that outlines his reasons that the wealthy nations of the world should not be wholly responsible for supporting the needs of the poor. Donald Kennedy and William Clark both wrote articles in regard to the concept of lifeboat