A Critique Of The Article "Psychosocial Evaluation And Prediction Of Compliance Problems And Morbidity After Heart Transplantation", Written By Shapiro Et Al.

1736 words - 7 pages

In the journal article "Psychosocial evaluation and prediction of compliance problems and morbidity after heart transplantation", the authors attempt to answer the question of whether preoperative psychosocial evaluations have reliable predictive value for heart transplant outcomes (Shapiro et al., 1995). Organ transplant programs use differing selection criteria and screening procedures to establish which patients are within established risk factor limits to safely receive and benefit from heart transplantation surgery. Such screening is necessary due to fact that heart transplantation is an expensive and risky operation which requires the utilization of scarce resources and has limited life prolonging benefits. In this study, the authors followed a group of 125 adult patients who underwent heart transplantation surgery between 1992-1994. The subjects were all patients at the same hospital and each were evaluated by a psychiatrist, a social worker and a transplant nurse coordinator as part of the standardized patient screening process for that centre.Data gathered on each patient included demographic information, medical diagnoses, and psychiatric data obtained through a semi structured clinical interview. The variables of interest were the presence or absence of psychiatric disorders, substance abuse, cognitive impairment, personality disorders, quality of social support, and the patient's motivation and understanding of the transplant procedure. Also, a summary or overall assessment of the patient's likelihood of developing postoperative compliance and behavioral problems were provided by the interviewing psychiatrist. This summery, referred to as the "global psychosocial risk", is represented by a single data point and it is the psychiatrist's overall impression and assessment of the patient which encompasses many of the independent variables of interest discussed above. Postoperatively, the surviving patients who lived to be discharged from the centre were assessed and rated by their respective primary transplant nurse coordinator. Variables rated by the nurse included the number of postoperative infections, rejection episodes, missed follow-up appointments, ideal weight maintenance, coronary angiography data and compliance problems with medication management.The results indicate several significant associations between preoperatively diagnosed psychosocial predictor variables and a number of postoperative outcomes. Overall, 34.4% of patients were rated as being somewhat to extremely noncompliant to their prescribed medications and regimes. Significant correlations were found between postoperative nonadherence and the patients history of substance abuse, personality disorders, living arrangements and the global psychosocial risk assessment. The most significant of these findings is that of the predictive reliability of preoperative substance abuse and the global psychosocial risk factor as it pertains to postoperative nonadherence problems....

Find Another Essay On A critique of the article "Psychosocial evaluation and prediction of compliance problems and morbidity after heart transplantation", written by Shapiro et al.

Reaseach Critique of the Article Shaping Juror Attitudes by Malouff and Schutte

935 words - 4 pages Amanda Maybaum Research Critique After reading the article, Shaping Juror Attitudes: Effects of Requesting Different Damage Amounts in Personal Injury Trials, one might notice the elements of research conducted throughout this study, focusing on the many strengths and weaknesses. The following research critique will discuss the fundamentals of the study, the quality of validity and reliability, strengths and limitations as well as future

“Drawing on the work of Hau et al (2012) discuss how employee knowledge sharing intentions are affected by individual motivation and social capita

1173 words - 5 pages , commitment and involvement in a specific context”. On the other hand explicit knowledge is “easily expressed and can be communicated in for form of written documents” (Hau et al, 2012, 256). It can be identified that tacit knowledge is harder to share while explicit knowledge is based on objective rather than subjective and therefore is not open to interpretations, thus preventing any misunderstanding when shared. The study discusses the idea

Critique of the gifted and talented evaluation scales

1019 words - 5 pages assessed by one’s ability to actively participate in group settings and influence others; artistic expression is assessed on the student’s performance in the visual and performing arts. The GATES contains a manual and 50 response/summary forms. The manual also contains directions on how to administer, score, and interpret the tests. The gifted and talented evaluation scales (GATES) test assesses children ranging from the ages of five to eighteen

Criticism of the journal ‘Creation of a Bacterial Cell Controlled by a Chemically Synthesized Genome’ by Gibson et al., published in Science on the 2nd of July 2010

1528 words - 6 pages LIN1603 Assignment Critical Evaluation of a Scientific PaperIntroductionThe paper, chosen for critique is 'Creation of a Bacterial Cell Controlled by a Chemically Synthesized Genome' by Gibson et al., published in Science on the 2nd of July 2010.1Summary of PaperThe paper reports the experiment which was carried out by Craig Venter and his research team. Synthesis of the genome of a bacterial cell and the transplantation of such genome into

Fetal Neural Transplantation in the Treatment of Parkinson's and Huntington

1522 words - 6 pages Two Diseases, One Hope: Fetal Neural Transplantation in the Treatment of Parkinson's and Huntington's Disease Parkinson's Disease (PD) and Huntington's Disease (HD) are neurodegenerative diseases that are caused by malfunctions within the motor sector of the nervous system. These malfunctions, which are caused either by the surplus (as in HD) or absence (as in PD) of hormones, are a direct result of neural cell deterioration within the

MEMORANDUM REGARDING THE ETHICS AND MORALS OF ORGAN TRANSPLANTATION

753 words - 4 pages US legal system finds that a postmortem body is res nullis, owned by no one. In short, while the courts may find that the body of a possible donor is up for grabs; the family may counter and contest which can hold up a possible donor beyond the ability to perform a much needed transplant. Set forth is the following procedure for establishing who should receive organ transplantation. Not all persons qualify as the right candidate for the

The Life of Alan Shapiro and Analysis of “Country Western Singer”

1051 words - 5 pages “Sleet” by Alan Shapiro beautifully encompasses his feeling of grief and sorrow due to the loss of his siblings. Alan Shapiro was born in Boston, Massachusetts, on February 18th, 1952. He is the son of Harold and Marilyn Shapiro. Growing up Shapiro was a part of a Jewish household. Shapiro received his education at Brandies University. While attending Brandies University he discovered that his one and only passion was for the astounding art of

Critique of a Research Article about Incarceration in the Household by Loper & Nichols (2012)

2528 words - 10 pages incarceration status added prediction beyond that offered by the control variables. A logistic regression analysis was then conducted, with parental, sibling, and other household member’s incarceration status as independent variables. The sampled related to the hypothesis in that data from a national, longitudinal survey to examine the influence of having a household member incarcerated on educational outcomes, above and beyond the contribution of

The story "Heart of Darkness" written by Joseph Conrad

974 words - 4 pages The story "Heart of Darkness" written by Joseph Conrad, and the movie Apocalypse. Now, produced and directed by Francis Ford Coppola, both portray the same mysterious journey into the jungle and without doubt demonstrate how each character faced many different events and situations that inevitably changed their perspective mainly Marlow in Heart of Darkness and Willard in Apocalypse Now.Both the novel Heart of darkness and the movie create the

Summary, Discussion and Evaluation of the article 'Capacity of bottle-nosed dolphins for generalization based on a relative sign'

2400 words - 10 pages SUMMARY OF INTRODUCTION'This study investigated weather bottle-nosed dolphins could recall their own recent behaviors and reveal those recollections on the basis of an abstract (i.e. highly generalizable) rule. Two dolphins were trained to respond to a specific gesturual command by repeating the last behavior they performed. Unlike previous studies with other species, the behaviors the dolphins were asked to recall in this experiment included a

The Importance of Biosocial Cognitive and Psychosocial Measures

2138 words - 9 pages familiar objects or actions in a deliberate way to solve problems. For example, when completing a puzzle, Klara attempts to turn the puzzle piece around until it fits in its appropriate spot. Curiosity and initiative is the child understands of new activities or materials. Klara is at the building stage for curiosity and initiative (CDE, Measure 30, 2010). Klara involves with new materials or activities by observing, investigating, and asking questions

Similar Essays

Analysis Of Article: “Influence Of Mass Media On Body Image And Eating Disordered Attitudes And Behaviors In Females” By Jordi Fauquet, Et Al

846 words - 4 pages that the media portrays, like dieting articles to perfect image advertisements, allows females to gain a new social perspective. This slightly new understanding of media permits an individual to decide on their own how to view “body norms” without being submerged by the surrounding stereotyped misconceptions of body image. Works Cited Lopez-Guimera, Gemma, et al. "Influence Of Mass Media On Body Image And Eating Disordered Attitudes And Behaviors In Females: A Review Of Effects And Processes." Media Psychology 13.4 (2010): 387-416. Academic Search Complete. Web. 12 Mar. 2014.

Africa. The Problems Faced By Africa In The 21st Century And An Evaluation Of Those Problems

8514 words - 34 pages IntroductionNormally when you ask a person what they think of when you say Africa, they will tell you about its terrible poverty and in what conditions the Africans have to live under. All of what they will say will most likely be based on information given to them by a charity group, as it is unlikely that the person in question researched the subject by him/herself. I have written this report to answer some important questions:* How did Africa

The Transplantation Of Organs And Tissues

1372 words - 6 pages transplants less available to them because they cannot pay. That is not justice; that is greed. After reviewing both sides of the argument, I believe that legalizing the buying and selling or organs is ethically wrong. I do believe that by putting a price tag on human life, it is devalued. By making human life worth less, it is easier to justify whatever means necessary to obtain those organs, which can compromise other morals. Even if the government

"The Secret Sharer" And "Heart Of Darkness" Written By Joseph Conrad

1181 words - 5 pages In the stories The Secret Sharer and Heart of Darkness written by Joseph Conrad, the characterization in the short stories is common in both. Joseph Conrad describes the true inner self of humans throughout both novels and he begins to do this directly in the titles. Conrad ultimately demonstrates how evil exists in all of us through his unique writing style. Both of these stories tell the tale of two characters realization of the hidden, dark