A Critique Of William J. Bennett's "Against Gay Marriage"

601 words - 2 pages

William J. Bennett, a great spokesman for American conservatives, has powerfully argued as the title indicates in his article "Against Gay Marriage." One does not have to agree with Bennett to appreciate the strength and goodness of his mind. Still, although he raises serious objections to same-sex marriage, his argument overall reads more like an outline, lacking specifics and expert opinions, referring to only one organized, careful study, and committing a number of logical fallacies which muddy and weaken his argument.For example, in his opening, Bennett makes a very strong assertion--if not an outright exaggeration-- when he says that recognizing same-sex marriage "would be the most radical step ever taken in the deconstruction of society's most important institution" (288). The reader may wonder if any studies or expert opinions exist to support Bennett's view. Of course, Bennett is respected for his personal opinions, but wasn't the question about improving?In the next paragraph, Bennett, wanting to squelch the movement toward redefinition of marriage, cites the rather outlandish example of two brothers: "On what principled grounds could the advocates of same-sex marriage oppose the marriage of two consenting brothers?" By citing two homosexual brothers, Bennett commits the "straw man" fallacy. That is, he reasons from an exceptional case that defies logic and, once recognized, does little for his argument. Who else has ever seen such an extreme example? By the way, is this a real pair of brothers, or are they merely made up and cited for the sake of argument? I suspect the latter as the two brothers remain nameless--and place-less, as well.It appears that one logical fallacy breeds another, as in the very next paragraph, Bennett commits what strikes me as a glaring over-generalization. Referring to the traditional view of marriage, he asserts, "Nor is this view arbitrary or idiosyncratic. It mirrors...

Find Another Essay On A Critique of William J. Bennett's "Against Gay Marriage"

The Case Against Passing a Law or Bill that Would Allow Gay Marriage

1020 words - 4 pages bill believe very differently. Many believe that the law is being passed as not only a reason and license to discriminate against gay people, but against any people who’s lifestyles they disagree with. This view sees the idea of “religious freedom” as an excuse to have bigoted attitudes towards certain individuals. These laws are often compared to pre-civil rights movements laws, meaning they separate people based on differences. Gene Robinson

Comparing William Bennett's Leave Marriage Alone and Andrew Sullivan's Let Gays Marry

1561 words - 6 pages . The normal love occurs between a man and a woman. If they are gay, they love each other, why don’t they have the right to marry? Those people find out another issue to fight against gay: children. In their opinion, the function of marriage is children. Some religions believe that God created a man and a woman to give birth and increase population so gays cannot have baby which means they cannot live together. It is possible if we say gay couple

What are the reasons for and against gay marriage

2689 words - 11 pages What are the reasons for and against gay marriage Introduction Gay marriage is one of the most controversial issues in the modern world. For the past thousand years, marriage has been recognized as the social union between a man and a woman. In most cultures across the globe, homosexuality was viewed with disdain, and marriages between same-sex couples were forbidden.However, homosexual relationships are slowly gaining acceptance, as

Gay Marriage Why It Should Be Legal, And The Arguments Against It

1597 words - 6 pages people, and if society is slowly changing people, one would think it would be logical for society to agree with these changes, such as homosexuality.Actually, denying gay individuals to be married is a form of discrimination against a minority. A book, entitled "Why Marriage? : The History Shaping Today's Debate Over Gay Equality" s mentions "It is the main reason we have a Bill of Rights as well as anti-slavery and equal protection amendments

Refuting the Claims in Adam Kolasinski’s The Secular Case Against Gay Marriage

908 words - 4 pages Refuting the Claims in Adam Kolasinski’s The Secular Case Against Gay Marriage Gay marriage has been one of the most controversial topics of the twenty first century and the topic has mainly circulated around such issues as procreation and marriage benefits. Although Adam Kolasinski, the author of “The Secular Case Against Gay Marriage,” never refers to homosexual behavior as “wrong,” he argues several key points, including financial issues

Legalization of Gay Marriage

1585 words - 7 pages Legalization of gay marriage has been a major controversial topic for a long time. Although, many people do not know what it means to be homosexual, most people do not know the actual definition of homosexuality and they do not know how difficult it is to be gay in this society. There are many reasons why people are against gay marriage and homosexuals all together. Most of the reasons are based on religious bias another big reason is being

Legalization of Gay Marriage

1072 words - 4 pages legalized gay marriage had lower divorce rates, while states that passed constitutional bans of gay marriage actually had an increase in their divorce rates" (Eggleston). The argument that allowing gays to be joined in a legal union will undermine marriage entirely as an institution is an uncorroborated claim, which has more evidence against it than affirming its theory.According to the United States Declaration of Independence, every single human

Legalization of Gay Marriage

1072 words - 4 pages legalized gay marriage had lower divorce rates, while states that passed constitutional bans of gay marriage actually had an increase in their divorce rates" (Eggleston). The argument that allowing gays to be joined in a legal union will undermine marriage entirely as an institution is an uncorroborated claim, which has more evidence against it than affirming its theory.According to the United States Declaration of Independence, every single human

Issues of Gay Marriage

1192 words - 5 pages equality, liberty and justice for all. A government should not be able to prohibit any one person from declaring his or her love for someone else. Allowing the government to intervene in gay marriage represents class discrimination, denies marriage benefits, and rejects civil rights. One of the most widely known acts of discrimination would be the Loving vs. Virginia case. This case involves an interracial marriage, which was against the law in

Solution of gay marriage

819 words - 3 pages religious opinion into matter, allowing homosexual marriage does not go against the constitution. Using the tactic of showing how homosexuals are discriminated against can be a solution. Raising awareness into the issue that denying it due to it being their natural born right due to the amendment and declaration of independence.Over the years, homosexuals have received a great deal of hate and discrimination. From having people spew out hatred through

Support of Gay Marriage

1785 words - 7 pages think that being gay can be fixed with therapy, medication or counseling, but in reality, this type of therapy usually makes the individual more likely to have suicidal thoughts and other problems. Being told that you aren’t good enough because of something you cannot control is inhumane. Rulings from older court cases are often used in present cases to provide support. A fact that most people either forget or do not know is that gay marriage is

Similar Essays

Critque Of "Against Gay Marriage" Essay

1597 words - 6 pages Andrew CarrollProf. WesleyEnglish 18510/2/14Critique of "Against Gay Marriage"In his essay "Against Gay Marriage," William Bennett, a great spokesman for conservatives and former Secretary of education under President Reagan, maintains his conservative stance that allowing same-sex couples to marry would have a harmful and lasting effect on our society's intrinsic values and, in his view, would stretch the "fragile" institution of marriage

A Critique Of "For Gay Marriage," By Andrew Sullivan

523 words - 2 pages , the fact is that he could overcome much of the ambiguity of his presentation by citing more concrete studies, including long-term studies, which support his key points. For example, when he makes the assertion that "in some ways the marriage issue is exactly parallel to the military" (283), it is unclear exactly what he means. Is he referring to prejudice against gay soldiers? On the other hand, is he referring to a common requirement of self

Discrimination Against Gay Marriage Is The Voice Of Ignorance

1934 words - 8 pages Discrimination Against Gay Marriage is the Voice of Ignorance Marriage is one of the fundamental establishments of the United States. As a young person, one looks forward to many goals in their lifetime: career success, a good life, and very often marriage to the person they love and a family together. This is one of the biggest parts of our "American life" and culture. Very few heterosexuals would be willing to put their right to marry

Arguments For And Against Gay Marriage

600 words - 2 pages forms of gay marriage have been legal for years. Polling results show that most people there now recognize that the benefits far outweigh the trivial costs, and that far from threatening heterosexual marriage, gay marriage has actually strengthened it. This is simply a scare tactic used to make the ending result seem so horrid that people will not be willing to make the first step.Another thing that homosexuals having going against them are