This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Critical Comparison Of Gothic Architecture In Italy, France And Germany

1400 words - 6 pages

Gothic was first used as a term of contempt during the late renaissance. The Goth's were barbarians- which leads to many theories as to why "Goth" was the chosen title for a style that required extreme engineering as well as technical and artistic know how. Since then vast efforts have been made to rename the style with a term that better encompasses the idea of gothic style.

The Gothic style was an over exaggerated, awe-inspiring attempt to become closer to God. The worshipper was not only drawn to the altar, but experienced an ascent to heaven at the same time.1 These artistic gems are a grand testament to historical technology and the imaginative approach and vision of skilled craftsmen. The gothic style is one of the most extraordinary achievements in European history, typically characterized by slender, vertical piers, counterbalancing buttresses, vaulting, pointed arches and stained glass.

The strength of a gothic building is made to reside in a finely organized framework rather than in its walls. This framework, which consists of perfectly placed piers, arches and buttresses, frees up any unessential impediment of walls and presents a light feeling. The stability of the building depends only on inert massiveness in its outermost parts, whose opposing forces counteract each other in a perfect stability of thrust and counterthrust. Gothic architecture is an artistic, strategic system of engineering, schemes for building were followed for elevations, termed quadratum (four sided) and triangulorum (three sided). 2 This system allowed them to raise their ideal structures according to symbolic measure and numbers reflecting the geometry of the New Jerusalem and its prototype, the Temple of Solomon. (Figure 1.1)

France is typically referred to as the birthplace of the gothic style, at St. Denis Abbey, just north of Paris. (Figure 1.2) Abbot Suger, head of St. Denis Abbey, believed that St. Denis should be the spiritual center of France. He also felt that St. Denis should be the pilgrimage church to outshine all others as well as provide a focal point for all religious and patriotic emotion for the French people. 3 He had grand visions for his church, which were carried out by an anonymous master builder.

Through the use of sketching techniques (the ability to create fast, understandable views of objects with only a pencil and a piece of paper- still used by engineers, designers, architects, builders, and craftsmen, today), the French had developed greater animation in their gothic decoration than their followers. They emphasized soaring heights and light qualities that were later adopted across Europe.

The French flying buttresses became so elaborate that they had the appearance of being purely ornamental, which led to this period being coined flamboyant. Although many areas of Europe had accepted and adopted the style, the French buildings were generally vaster and more commanding in scale. (Figure 1.3) Outside...

Find Another Essay On A Critical Comparison of Gothic Architecture in Italy, France and Germany

Gothic Architecture in Europe Essay

1848 words - 7 pages The research paper, shall be concerned with discussion Gothic architecture in Europe-namely England, France, Germany, and Italy starting from 12th to the 16th Centuries. Architecture was the most original and lasting form of art during the Gothic Period, which lasted for four centuries starting from the mid 12th century. The impetus for this architecture was the Roman Catholic Church, which sought to portray their houses of worship as


798 words - 3 pages has emerged in France. And this type has spread to all Europe Romanesque architecture development this reason whereby gothic architecture occurred. Instead of gothic architecture is renaissance architecture in time. There have been changes in its own from 13th century to 15th century. Gothic architecture reached peak in the 15th century. And this tendency had been named gothic architecture by international group. There are in all branches of

Romanesque and Gothic Architecture

1130 words - 5 pages that church plans (as seen from above) are in the form of a crucifix; a feature usually associated with the later Gothic styles but which had originated in the Romanesque period . The Romanesque structures include Durham Cathedral, England; the Benedictine Monastery in Cluny, France; Sainte Foy Abbey in Southern France; Speyer Cathedral, Germany, along with many others. The growing importance of the Roman Catholic Church during the 11th and

Classical and Gothic Architecture

820 words - 3 pages throughout the region of Greece and Italy. Gothic style art and architecture began in the areas surrounding Paris in the sixteenth century (Sporre, 2010). Similarly, the Gothic architecture of the late medieval era is best exemplified in places of worship. The Gothic cathedral is described by Sporre (2010) as a, "synthesis of intellect, spirituality, and engineering, perfectly expressing the medieval mind"(p.242). There are significant similarities

Origins of Gothic Architecture

978 words - 4 pages original structure was constructed sometime around 475 followed by two, possibly three distinct iterations on the same site based on Professor Sumner McKnight Crosby’s findings. (citationpage 6 early gothic Saint-Denis). Each iteration seemed to increase in lavishness along with a strong association to royalty. With the exclamations of the miraculous events occurring at the Cathedral and Christ “consecrating” the nave, how could such a divine place not

Architecture in France

3184 words - 13 pages plans for a new business centre in La Defense but Paris lacked a central institutionalised cultural apparatus. The project for an institutionalised cultural centre emerged as a logical necessity because it was nonetheless apparent that various government sponsored activities and initiatives in the cultural domain were too fragmented and dispersed.In 1969 George Pompidou, a professor turned politician, was elected the President of France. As an

Compare and Contrast the rise and forms of Fascism in Germany and Italy

1003 words - 4 pages , however in Italy, and in Germany, Fascism became the government of choice in the post World War One era. How is it possible that a government, which at its core denies basic civil right, could become popular in the eyes of the masses? This paper will show the rise and forms of Fascism in Italy and in Germany.In Italy starting in 1920, many were disgusted by the terms of the peace treaties specifically the lack of territorial gains. In addition too many

Finding Fascism: Fascism Defined in the Context of Mussolini’s Italy and Nazi Germany

1510 words - 7 pages pursued an ‘organic state’, and promoted a national ‘rebirth’. Similar to Italy, Germany was left in shambles after World War One. The Treaty of Versailles led Germany’s economy into a spiraling depression, which caused Germany’s currency to become worthless, and led to a rising hostility in German citizens. The German people sought out a leader to restore their country to greatness; eventually they found Adolf Hitler. In true fascist form

Totalitarianism in the Soviet Union, Italy, and Germany

587 words - 2 pages Totalitarianism in the Soviet Union, Italy, and Germany(by the way, all my essays are not very in depth because we have to write 2-3 600 word essays every week!)A totalitarian government is a modern autocratic regime in which the state controls all phases of society. It not only seeks to control the economical and political aspects of society, but also tries to direct the daily lives of its citizens. Totalitarianism strives to influence the

Comparision of Gothic Cathedral Architecture of England and Europe

1251 words - 5 pages cathedral, to be healed at St. Thomas Becket's hand.Canterbury Cathedral, rich in English Gothic (Perpendicular) architecture is one of the oldest and most well known cathedrals of its time.The next Gothic cathedral we discuss is the Peterborough Cathedral. The Peterborough Cathedral was build during the 7th century when a monastery at Medeshamstede was founded by the first Christian King of Mercia. It was dedicated to Saint Peter, Saint Paul and

Key Characteristics of Gothic Architecture

1538 words - 6 pages What architectural changes were necessary in the shift from Romanesque to Gothic cathedrals in Europe and what inspirational changes influenced these changes? A. Plan of Investigation This investigation’s purpose is to analyze the changes in the architectural technique of the Romanesque style of architecture and come to a conclusion as to whether the shift in technique led to the rise of the more grandiose Gothic architecture in Europe. All art

Similar Essays

The History Of Gothic Architecture In Italy

1692 words - 7 pages Architecture in Italy shows the gradual transition from simple Roman work to Romanesque and Byzantine and lastly to Gothic architecture. In Italy Gothic had no much impact on career perspective like it had in other part of Europe, liken France, Germany and England. Gothic Architecture in Italy led to constant knowledge of grand works of classic period which the influence was from the East. The first buildings used for worship in Italy had no

Comparison Of The Unifications Of Italy And Germany

1824 words - 7 pages , Cavour had made a smart move by involving Italy in the Crimean War on the side of Britain and France and actual gained quite a bit of support from the Great Powers. If Cavour had not gotten involved in the Crimean War, Piedmont would not have had the faithful support of Napoleon III, which proved crucial in unification.Unitary vs. Federal StatesThe results of each of the unifications were different. In Germany, the nation was established as a

"Gothic Architecture In France" This Paper Talks About The Abbey Of St. Denis, The Chartres Cathedral, Amiens Cathedral, Abbot Suger, Robert Luzarches, With Quotes From Scholar H.W. Janson, Etc

1321 words - 5 pages . Amiens is a great example of elegant and grandiose Gothic form.After the 14th century, people began a more approachable aspect to architecture. The idea of detail, rather than height, was the focus. This concludes the Gothic era, butthe aftermath of this period is resounded in many of the cathedrals that still stand today as a 'living' testament to an era passed. Before the Gothic architecture of France, rarely anywhere else was religious and

Analyzing The Unification Of Italy And Germany

1932 words - 8 pages . The Congress of Vienna played a huge role in the unification of Italy and Germany because it divided territories promoting the idea of nationalism.The rise and subsequent fall of Napoleon, was a major factor in the need for the Congress of Vienna. "When Napoleon abdicated his thrown and accepted his enemies' offer of exile to the Mediterranean island of Elba, thus bringing to an end to more than twenty years of nearly constant warfare between