A Day In Court In ‘Keeping Aboriginal And Torres Strait Islander People Out Of Custody’ By Chris Cunneen And David Mc Donald

974 words - 4 pages


On the 11th of March 2014 at the Melbourne Magistrates Court, the lowest Court in the judicial hierarchy, a criminal hearing (file number D12223078) took place in Court 4 between the defendant, Adam Caleb Hines and Victoria Police CIU Transit. Senior Constable Ryan was the Informant in this matter. Magistrate Rozencwajg conducted the Court proceedings on this day.

The defendant was late and as a result the hearing was adjourned for half an hour.

When Court resumed the Clerk communicated to the Court to ‘please stand’ when Magistrate Rozencwajg entered the room, and to ‘please be seated’ once Magistrate Rozencwajg was seated.


The defendant was indigenous. The defendant was in clear violation of the Crimes Act (1958) (Vic), and was facing multiple charges including:

• attempted armed robbery (2 accounts), breaching s 75A – Armed Robbery,
• being armed with criminal intent (2 accounts) breaching s 75A – Armed Robbery,
• threat to inflict serious injury (2 accounts), breaching s 21 – Threats to inflict serious injury,
• assault with weapon (2 accounts) breaching s 31 - Assaults and;
• obtain property by deception (2 accounts), breaching s 81 – obtaining property by deception.

All of the convictions were indictable offences. s 21, s 31, s 75A and s 81 all posed high and low level imprisonment terms if found guilty. This includes a level 2 imprisonment term of a 25 year maximum sentence per offence if the defendant was found guilty of breaching s 75A.


The defendant’s representation was a young female duty lawyer. When asked by the Magistrate the reasoning for the defendant’s truancy in attending his Court case, she replied that the accused was taking a strong concoction of medicinal drugs that caused him to enter a very heavy sleep and that he simply ‘slept in’.

Magistrate Rozencwajg was not satisfied with this answer and spoke very abruptly, loudly and rudely to duty lawyer, belittling her and laughing at the absurdity of the reason. The duty lawyer was visibly uncomfortable and responded very quietly with with ‘yes your Honour’, and ‘no your Honour’ whenever she was spoken to. In comparison to that, when the Informant was spoken to, he would reply loudly and did not appear to feel uncomfortable under Magistrate Rozencwaig.

Magistrate Rozencwaig was very sarcastic in his ruling, stating that had he himself not been late to Court on that day, then he would not have been so lenient and allowed bail for the defendant. He continued his sarcastic dialogue by stating that the defendant slept in at the cost of the taxpayers and the government.

Magistrate Rozencwaig made point to the fact that Victorian prisons had an over-representation of Indigenous offenders within the institutions. Magistrate Rozencwaig believed an intervention strategy would be of benefit to the defendant.

The book ‘Keeping Aboriginal and Torres Strait...

Find Another Essay On A Day in Court in ‘Keeping Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People out of Custody’ by Chris Cunneen and David McDonald

Review of the Racial Discrimination Act (Australian) and It's Influences on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders

852 words - 3 pages be justified if proven to be reasonable and relevant to specific circumstances. However not all acts which treat one group of people unfairly based on their color, descent or national or ethnic origin is illegal. In certain circumstances special measures need to be taken with those who have been affected by a disadvantage in the past, in order to help them live equally with the rest of society. What The Racial Discrimination Act Is: The Racial

An analysis of the ATSIC (Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission) website - the question being "Consider the aims of ATSIC for their site how effective do you find it?"

1057 words - 4 pages structure."Land is at the core of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander culture, heritage and identity"Australian Indigenous culture is directly dependent on the land. By embracing the technological 'landscape' of the western world, the website assists in the reconciliation of western and Australian Indigenous culture.ATSIC is able to successfully merge both the real and synthetic landscapes. This merger implies a level of post-modernism and

It is only since 1945 that any real progress has been made in advancing the rights and freedoms of Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders.

1253 words - 5 pages Essay Question: It is only since 1945 that any real progress has been made in advancing the rights and freedoms of Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders.The first real attempt to raise awareness of the lack of equality facing Indigenous Australians, was the Day of Mourning campaign of 1938. Indigenous activist and community members, walked a silent protest to the Australian Hall and this protest took place on Australia day. The Day

Certain "social indicators" have been identified as underlying issues in the RCIADIC Report. Discuss how these indicators contribute to the over representation of Aboriginal people in custody

1701 words - 7 pages Briefing Paper on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health, Feb 2001 accessed at %20bad%20is%20aboriginal%20health?Butt-Beckett L, Dispossession, 14 (5) Connexions Oct/Nov 1994 pgs 18 - 20Cooper A, Locked Out: Do Aboriginal People Have Real Housing Choice?, (2003) 7 FJLR 103 pgs 103 - 113Hoey M & Flynn M, Death In Custody The Royal Commission 10 Years On, Alternative Law Journal, Vol

Ethnomethodology Experiment. an essay on an Ethnomethodology experiment, taking people out of their every day norms

780 words - 3 pages out loud did somebody fart. At first I thought that my moms boyfriend had went too far with that comment, but it was perfect because not only did he break the rules by taking people out of their norms, but embarrassment would soon settle in on most of the people in the elevator. Kind of like that old phrase kill two birds with one stone. After he had made that comment everybody in the elevator let out a chuckle. But I don't think they thought it

Aboriginal deaths in custody - history of colonization in Australia, Australian society, statistics, western society. Includes extensive bibliography - A- mark

2635 words - 11 pages custody could be related to the lack of care and responsibility towards Aboriginal people by the authorities within institutions. These statistics indicate that there is a distinct cultural bias against Aboriginal people compared to non-Aboriginal people. ATSIC (1997) suggest that the disadvantage of Aboriginal people be directly related to the history of colonization in Australia. It is evident that there is extreme inequality between Aboriginal

A Brief Moment in the Life of Angus Bethune, by Chris Crutcher and The Scarlet Ibis, by James Hurst

1288 words - 5 pages life by the end of their stories, one due to a conversation, the other because of a horrible event that takes place. In “A Brief Moment in the Life of Angus Bethune” and “The Scarlet Ibis,” the conflict of the story shows that people can change considerably as a result of a revelation. Angus Bethune, “the Fat Kid with Perverted Parents”(Crutcher 1), starts off in a state of self-doubt, but by the end of this moment in his life, he learns to

The Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody - Includes Bibliography

1107 words - 4 pages government action to address the issue of the high rates of Aboriginal people in custody and of their deaths. Even during the three-year investigation by the Royal Commission, deaths were mounting up. By 30th November 1988, the total number of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander deaths in custody was 103 and rising. At this same point in time, the Commission had only investigated twenty-five of the ninety-nine deaths and Aboriginal groups were

Criminal Investigations, In Custody and Miranda Warnings

853 words - 4 pages station at times also; in cases there might not be time to pick out a place for an interview, especially at a crime scene. At a crime scene one may be approached by witnesses and or the victims; at that time one will have a short notice and will have to write down information pertaining to the crime scene. After the scene is safe and secure, all medical staff has taken care of the injured / wounded, it then will determine who the complainant are and

A discussion on whether or not success is the sum of small efforts repeated day in and out

701 words - 3 pages Many people think that success is just handed to them. No work, no nothing, just money is needed. This in fact is not true. Robert Collier said, “Success is the sum of small efforts, repeated day in and day out.” One should agree with this remark as it is entirely true. Robert Collier’s quote is true and one should agree with it because success is only built from a starting foundation, it grows little by little each day, and through persistence

The Individualism of Henry David Thoreau and Chris McCandless

934 words - 4 pages trying to prove to himself what he was capable of doing. Other people may have done this simply for the money and that is what Chris was always trying to avoid. The writer Henry David Thoreau, in the essay Walden also shares many of the views as Chris. In Walden, Henry David Thoreau explains his reasoning behind his move into the woods, the benefits of doing so and how it affected his life. Thoreau’s beliefs all stem deeply from individualism and

Similar Essays

An Overview Of The Impacts Of Diabetes In Aboriginal And Torres Strait Islander Population Report

2438 words - 10 pages . According to the Australian Bureau of Statistics: The Data presented are for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people who have been reported by a doctor or nurse that they had diabetes. People reporting high sugar levels are assumed to have a long-term health condition. In 2012?13 Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Survey, one in twelve (8%) of the Indigenous people reported they had diabetes and/or high sugar levels in their

Family Violence And Abuse In Aboriginal And Torres Strait Islander Communities

2256 words - 9 pages : Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Commissioner, 2006. ‘Ending family Violence and abuse in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Communities - Key Issues,’ An overview paper of research and findings by the Human Rights and Equal Opportunities Commission 2001-2006 Canberra.Atkinson, J 1996 ‘A Nation is Not Conquered’, Aboriginal Law Bulletin, Vol.3, No. 80. P8Atkinson. 1990 ‘Violence Against Aboriginal

Issues Relating To The Use Of Digital Technologies With Aboriginal And / Or Torres Strait Islander Students Essay

1220 words - 5 pages surrounding consumer usage with no languages to accommodate their native dialect. An opposing view to the issue of a digital divide and stated by Tony Abbott in 2015, is that if aboriginal and Torres strait islander people lived in urban regions and adopted the western culture and lifestyle, their life expectancy, educational opportunities and access to essential services would increase. Whilst this could be seen as a reality in

A Report On The Australian Aboriginal And Torres Straight Islander Sexual Health Program

2357 words - 9 pages communities, the program was designed with the intention that the message be taken back to the home community once prisoners had been released.Turgeon goes on to state that the project commenced in February 1995 and was launched in December 1995. There were approximately 800 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in secure custody in Queensland when this program was being developed. This number had increased to 1100 by 1998. In 1995 approximately 50