This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Defence Of Cartesian Dualism From The Attacks Of Modern Science.

1321 words - 5 pages

Dualism has been given a rough ride. This theory, ascribed mainly to Descartes that the mind is separate from the body, has been justly rejected for many reasons. Descartes theory required the existence of a substance that was mind, as well as a theater in which the mind could view what it internally perceived. As our scientific understanding of how the brain functions to produce consciousness and hence the mind has increased, these two pictures of brain function have been rejected. Some theorist would be content to reject all aspects of dualism along with those which have been shown to be false. This I perceive is analogous to throwing out the baby with the bath water. There are many facets of Cartesian Dualism that are compatible with current discoveries in brain science. This essay will be devoted to the reconciliation of current scientific advancements in brain science with a dualistic version of consciousness.What I mean by "dualism":Dualism is the obvious conclusion that people come too when asked what it is like to be conscious. When I describe my conscious day to day life, I describe events happening both internally, in my mind, and externally, in the outside world which my senses perceive and my mind interprets. This natural feeling of there being two worlds, one internal and personal and the other external and common to all is the basis for the more far fetched ideas of Cartesian Dualism cooked up by Descartes. Descartes tried unsuccessfully to reconcile this natural impression of dual worlds with what was currently understood about neurology and physiology.What I mean by "mind":Mind is where consciousness is happening. Mind is the scientific way of referring to the Cartesian theater. Mind is what we are looking into or at when we close our eyes and picture a purple elephant. Mind is what neurologists have not yet found inside our brain and it is what Descartes thought of as a separate substance from the rest of the body.Dualism is a functional way of looking at brain activities Thomas Nagel is confused by the apparent existence of more than one mind in split brain patients. It is commonly know that, "The left cerebral hemisphere is associated with the right side of the body and the right hemisphere is associated wit the left side." (Nagel, 456) "Both hemispheres are linked to the spinal column and peripheral nerves through a common bran stem, but they also communicate directly with one another, by a large transverse band of nerve fibers called the corpus callosum." (Nagel 456) Severe epilepsy can be cured by severing the corpus callosum and for a period of time this surgery was the norm in the medical community. These patients showed almost no loss of function after the surgery and only through experimental means can a flaw in the system be discovered. Due too the fact that each hemisphere of the brain has different 'jobs' to do in creating a conscious impression of the world, if the two halves of the brain can't communicate our...

Find Another Essay On A defence of cartesian dualism from the attacks of modern science.

THE DUALIST DILEMMA. This essay is a critique of substance dualism, an ontology embodied by the likes of Rene Descartes. Specifically, the essay attacks several of Descartes own dualist principles

1407 words - 6 pages mind.Necessary in a critique of a logical structure is diligent examination of its founding principles. Analysis of Meditations II and IV from Descartes Meditations on First Philosophy, and Alvin Plantinga's subsequent contemporary extension of these ideas in "Could Socrates Have Been an Alligator?" from The Nature of Necessity, provide adequate foundations of principal from which to launch an exploration of the viability of substance dualism. Descartes

The Explanation of Dualism and why it is Rejected by Science

711 words - 3 pages Throughout history there has been many different theory’s that have been presented, in numerous fashions. From psychology’s inception there has been attempts to answer many different questions, how much of our animal heritage exists, are humans basically good, is human nature neither good nor bad, do humans possess free will, is psychology really a science? There has been a persistent question throughout the ages, how are the mind and body

The future of Corporal Chastisement as a defence

1244 words - 5 pages In South Africa it is still legal for parents to make use of corporal punishment in order to discipline their children. The reason therefore is that a defence exists in South African common-law for parents when a claim based on assault is raised. This defence is known as reasonable disciplinary chastisement and it is seen as ‘n ground of justification. Physical assault, such as corporal chastisement is seen as unlawful. In the following

The Impact of Modern Science and Technology

792 words - 3 pages The Impact of Modern Science and Technology The quest for scientific knowledge should be boundless. There should not be any type of barriers to prevent such an enrichment of knowledge, and that is exactly what science presents to us. Scientific knowledge can only help us in the long run and even perhaps save us from catastrophes that may occur naturally in the world. There could be an agreement that science has produced many dangerous and

Herophilos: The Father of Modern Science

1237 words - 5 pages Herophilos, the Father of Modern Science: A Brief Biography In Ancient Greece 335 B.C.E. a child was born in Chalcedon. This child would one day become one of the most influential parts of modern science and medicine as we know it. The baby boy’s name was Herophilos. Not much is known about Herophilos except that he moved away from Chalcedon (now Turkey) and moved to Alexandria early in his life (1). When Herophilos finished his

The Abolition of the Provocation Defence

3317 words - 13 pages complete package of reform and the abolition of the defence of provocation should not be viewed in isolation. As evidenced by Osland, battered women could not necessarily rely on the defence to successfully reduce a conviction from murder to manslaughter anyhow. The Victorian Government have adopted the bulk of the VLRC recommendations and the expansion of the defence of self defence and the reintroduction of excessive self defence should ensure that

The Insanity Defence, in Need of Reform?

1869 words - 7 pages the detention of insane individuals. 2. This report will concern itself, however, with the current law and it's efficacy for dealing with the 'insane'. At present, the definition of the insanity defence is found in the 'M'Naghten Rules'. To establish a defence of insanity, " must be clearly proved that, at the time of the committing of the act, the party accused was labouring under such a defect of reason, from disease of

In The Defence Of The Prince

1513 words - 7 pages "The Prince". This all changes in 1512 once European country invades Florence and deposes Piero Soderini then place House of Medici back to power. In, November Niccolo Machiavelli is ousted from the Chancery and sentenced to a years confinement inside Florentine territory. Throughout his time in expatriation, between 1513 and 1527, Niccolo Machiavelli dedicated himself to engendering political treatises explicating his conceptions and theories

Descartes’s Conception of Certainty and the Cartesian Circle

2632 words - 11 pages Introduction Descartes’s Meditations on First Philosophy are dedicated to establishing absolute certainty and “anything at all in the sciences that was stable and likely to last” (Meditations I.18). Descartes demolishes all his old beliefs and attempts rebuilds his foundations from the beginning. He employs a series of hyperbolic doubts and dismisses all his preconceived notions formerly taken for granted and works back to establish

A Comparative Study of Natural Philosophy and Modern Science

695 words - 3 pages every physical detail or object with the spiritual world because they believed that the gods were, in part, human (Ede, Cormack 17) An example would be that although there was a god of the seas, which sailors would often pray too before setting sail, the water itself was only water – not god. The separation of the real from the fictional is one of the founding principles of Natural Philosophy; as well as Science.Although today’s modern

Defence Of AU

1634 words - 7 pages attempts to assign every action a value, or utility. The principle of utility means the “principle which approves or disapproves of every action whatsoever, according to the tendency which is appears to have to augment or diminish the happiness of the party whose interest is in question” (Bentham,1781) In contemporary terms, the utility of an act x is equal to the total quantity of pain that would result from act x, subtracted from the total

Similar Essays

The Significance Of The 'cogito' For Cartesian And Modern Philosophy

2186 words - 9 pages solutions and further criticisms of this so called Cartesian circle would warrant a paper in themselves so now I will orientate towards the wider effects of the Cogito on modern philosophy. There were French followers of Cartesianism immediately during and after Descartes life but for many other philosophers the questions of epistemology, method of science and philosophy of mind were well posited by Descartes but not well answered in the Cogito

The Art Of Defence Essay

904 words - 4 pages As Emily quickly rushed out of the door, she quickly grabbed her black down coat. She suddenly got into her friend Tailor's old Toyota Prius. Taylor imminently drove off to class. Once they got to the Iris & B. Gerald Cantor Center for Visual Arts, at Stanford University where they attended, they walked into Mrs.. Basile’s contemporary art class. They quickly snatched a seat next to their friend Yael in the back of the room. The eccentric

Do All Dualists Believe That There Is Two Way Causal Interaction Between Mind And Body? Which Version Of Dualism – Cartesian Dualism, Parallelism, Or Epiphenomenalism – Is The Most Plausible Theory Of...

1103 words - 4 pages plausible as a theory of mind due to the nature in which the causal relation from material to immaterial is essentially redundant.A varying view to Cartesian dualism and is very far from the belief of two-way causal interaction between mind and body says that there is basically no connection whatever between any mental phenomena and any physical phenomena. This view is called parallelism. It says that mental and physical worlds exist, in two

The Right Of Private Defence Essay

2811 words - 11 pages ) there must have been a necessity to take lifeSection 98 gives this right against the defence of the act of a person of unsound mind by reason of youth, want of maturity of understanding, unsoundness of mind or intoxication of the person doing that act or by reason of any misconception on the part of the person.In case of free fight where both sides mean to fight from the start leading to pitched battle, the question whether who attacks