A Different Perspective Essay

1342 words - 6 pages

When you assert that “The Gentle Boy” by Nathaniel Hawthorne is a “heart-wrenching story that presents an eloquent, sympathetic portrait of Quakers as they confront Puritan persecution in Colonial New England,” you are summarizing the story in an inaccurate manner. Although it may be true that within the short story there exists a sectarian tension between the religions, Catharine, the Quaker, is not idealized as a victim and Dorothy, the Puritan, is not portrayed as a persecutor. In actuality, Catharine is a wild, overzealous, and unpredictable woman who neglects her responsibilities as a mother. Dorothy, whom you would typecast as a narrow-minded Puritan persecutor, is an ideal mother, a ...view middle of the document...

Later on, once Dorothy has solidified her role as a mother in the life of Ilbrahim, takes him to house of worship. Hawthorne describes the kind dynamic that Dorothy creates with her husband and explains how they “set forth, each holding a hand of little Ilbrahim, like two parents linked together by the infant of their love. On their path through the leafless woods, they were overtaken by many person of their acquaintance, all of whom avoided them”(116). Hawthorne paints an almost “gauntlet” scene here as Dorothy and Tobias disregard the disapproving and hateful prejudice that other Puritans have against the Quaker boy. As they guide him to their own house of worship, they hold his hands and ensure that he is loved, something that Catharine did not provide her son. Hawthorne delineates Dorothy as the flawless and ideal mother when he describes “Her mild but saddened features, and neat, matronly attire, harmonized together, and were like a verse of fireside poetry. Her very aspect proved that she was blameless so far as could be in so, in respect to God and man”(122). In his kind and compassionate description, Hawthorne associates Dorothy with a multitude of attractive motherly traits, all of which Catharine lacks. Dorothy portrays a inviting and appealing scene, and Hawthorne uses “fireside poetry” to convey the low-key and mellow manner in which Dorothy directs her life. Dorothy is presented as a “matronly” figure whose essence and attire harmonize flawlessly, and she remains so innocent and pure, as to even be labeled as “blameless.”
Catharine, a devout Quaker and mother of Ilbrahim, vehemently conveys her passion and devotion to her religion throughout the story. She showcases her commitment when she delivers her venting rant in the church to the townspeople. Hawthorne explains how her language slowly contorted and describes her characteristics in a demeaning manner and illustrates how “She was naturally a woman of mighty passions, and hatred and revenge now wrapped themselves in the garb of piety; the character of her speech was changed, her images became distinct through wild, and her denunciations had an almost hellish bitterness”(119). Initially Hawthorne characterizes Catharine’s passionate side as a positive attribute, as she was naturally a woman of might passions” however, however he explains that now this animation is “wrapped in a garb of piety” and is simply harnessed to intensify her “hatred and revenge.” Catharine’s faith, instead of guiding her to keep her composure, simply provokes malign behavior. Hawthorne exudes the underlying wild side of Catharine and and targets the manner in which Catharine changes, which is almost a satanic, monster-like transformation that Catharine sustains, mentioning how her “speech changes,” her “images” become “distinct” and “wild,” and finally how she portrayed a “hellish bitterness” in her speech. Also, Hawthorne further contrasts both mothers in his uses of fire to describe both mothers, he...

Find Another Essay On A Different Perspective

The Discovery of America: From A Different Perspective

723 words - 3 pages There I was, hiding away in the farthest corner of the hold. We had been sailing for about a month. We set sail on the third of August, in the year fourteen hundred and ninety two. There were about one hundred men, and fifty of us rats, on board all three of the ships. The ships were named the Niña, the Pinta, and the Santa Maria. I was on the biggest one, the Santa Maria. About six days later, we stopped in the Canary Islands. We stocked

To Start Looking at Pizza in a Different Perspective

1144 words - 5 pages Pizza? Who doesn’t love pizza? Pizza is often loved by everyone and pretty much ate in any occasion. Through time, it has become a widely popular food. It is commonly viewed as a food that brings people together in harmony in one setting to eat and enjoy. Pizza has always been my family’s favorite for all occasions; whether I’m home alone, having a party, or just hanging out with my family on a Friday night. Pizza definitely brings people

In Macbeth, sleep was meant as a sanctuary or a safe haven but as the play progresses sleep becomes fear and not being able to think clearly which gives you a whole different perspective in life

886 words - 4 pages A day without sleep is bad enough with all the headaches and feeling tired. How much more if you haven't slept in weeks or even a whole year. Sleep can be defined as a natural periodic state of rest for the mind and body. In Macbeth, sleep was meant as a sanctuary or a safe haven but as the play progresses sleep becomes fear and not being able to think clearly which gives you a whole different perspective in life. Sleeping is a

How mexican american historians tell the history of america from a different perspective from the standard angle historian standpoint

634 words - 3 pages references in our history books lack emphasis as to the importance or significance of the impact the event had on our American history.From the very inception of this great nation, Hispanics have played a pivotal role. They made immense contributions to the mapping and paving the way for America to expand westward. The Spanish were building presidios, missions, and colonies in our American southwest as early as 1540. Contrary to what you have been taught

This is a creative writing piece about my friend almost drowning. It has four parts to it, each tells the same story from a different perspective

1449 words - 6 pages The PoolFlashing red and blue dominated the room. Video games were all he could see; nothing could tear him away. Engulfed in sounds of race cars and yelling fans, he sat there, clueless. No noise penetrated his ears. Fingers ran across controls at light speed, his mind focused completely on the game. The sun rose, leaving a glare on the television screen. Images of the crashing cars hid behind white light, and frustrated by the forces


789 words - 4 pages The Little Mermaid is a fairy tale written by Hans Christian Andersen. It is about a young mermaid who meets a handsome prince the first time that she is allowed to go ‘upstairs’; to the surface, to the ‘Human World’. After the encounter she tries everything to get to the world of her beloved. After many sacrifices, hardships, the painful loss of her fish tail in exchange for two legs, she finally gets to her prince. When he

How do different composers convey the concept of changing perspective?

2122 words - 8 pages Robert), display how different composers, dealing with similar or different changes in perspective, portray them in their own unique way.Racism, discrimination, assimilation, social acceptance, the 'White Australia Policy' etc, all can be traced back to ethnic background. It's a sad fact, but people are judged on their ethnic background. There are exceptions, but most of the 'inferior' people that are subjected to any sort of racism will

Perspective on Different Ways to Achieve Happiness

1796 words - 7 pages “A critique of positive psychology” by Richard Schoch (2006) where Schoch goes into detail on what gives people happiness using the data of neuroscientists, behavioral scientists and psychologists as his sources for his own conclusion. Schoch’s approach is rather unbiased using facts and sources of data to back up nearly every “opinion”. Simon Critchley (2009) essay, “Happy Like God” gives a more “philosophical/biblical approach” hence the

"Che Guevara: Hero or Villain?" Argues that he is different depending on your perspective and context

2006 words - 8 pages large spectrum of contradictory traits possessed by this intriguing historic icon. As a result of this, one cannot classify Ernesto Guevara as either a hero or a villain as he clearly possesses traits of both. Because different people view him in different ways he is both a romantic idealist who wanted to create a better world for all and a power hungry murder with the belief that his ideas were superior to all others.Ernesto Guevara de la Serna

Perspectives of Justice

999 words - 4 pages Chelsea HamerlinckCJ 2209.17.13Perspectives of JusticeThere are many different perspectives of criminal justice. The two perspectives that really dominate the field are the crime-control perspective and the non-intervention perspective. These two perspectives are unconditionally opposite of each other, which is why I believe that they dominate the field. Society views crime in a number of ways and no one is sure which view is the correct one

Perspectives Effecting Personal Beliefs

646 words - 3 pages Perspectives Effecting Personal Beliefs Consider how the effect of a new perspective has been reflected and developed in a literary text or texts you have studied. Discuss the ideas developed by the text creator about the effect an individual’s perspective has on personal beliefs. Each and every individual develops some sort of perspective and opinion on many different subjects, objects, and people throughout life. However, these

Similar Essays

Reality In A Different Perspective Essay

780 words - 4 pages In the past week I have payed taxes, bought my own food, clothing, made payments on my “car”, “house”, and many other items, and I’m only in eighth grade! How is this possible you ask? Well, last Thursday I participated in a thing called Reality Store. Reality Store in general prepares you for your future. Based on your last quarter grades you find out what your life is going to be like when you’re twenty-eight if you continue on the same path

“Shakespeare’s Sister”: A Different Perspective Essay

703 words - 3 pages “Shakespeare’s Sister” exemplifies critical elements most essays should possess by making a point in a very effective way. In the essay, “Shakespeare’s Sister,” Virginia Woolf creates a fictional story to persuade her readers. The essay creates a story to exemplify women’s roles in the renaissance era. She creates a what-if situation of Shakespeare having a sister. The story demonstrates women’s inequalities during his time, and examples of

A Different Perspective Of Heathcliff Essay

857 words - 3 pages visit, wishing “no repetition of my intrusion”(7). Heathcliff acquires the dark attributes in the novel as if “a ray fell on his features”(101), stating at the beginning, Heathcliff came from a poverty-stricken country of Liverpool as a “wicked boy”(53) with “black eyes”(1), “black hair”(38), and being “dirty”(38). With Heathcliff coming from a different nationality, his childhood was uneasy. Hindley, Heathcliff’s stepbrother, adds fuel to the flame

Postcoloniality And Subaltern Studies Are Studies Done Regarding A Specific Culture Influenced By Colonialism But The Perspective In Which They Are Done Is Different

952 words - 4 pages Postcoloniality and Subaltern StudiesPostcoloniality and subaltern studies are studies done regarding a specific culture influenced by colonialism but the perspective in which they are done is different. Postcoloniality study by definition is a specifically post-modern intellectual dissertation that consists of reactions to, and analysis of, the cultural effects of colonialism. Subaltern studies on the other hand is the analysis of the