A Fictionalized Dialogue On Morality Essay

746 words - 3 pages

ENGLISH 101A FICTIONALIZED DIALOGUEAn article which was written in the New York times had raised the need for discussion. A woman who had accepted money from a couple, had agreed to be the surrogate mother of the couple?s baby. They had signed a contract which requires the surrogate mother to terminate her parental rights as soon as the child was born. After the surrogate mother delivered, she realized that she loved the child and did not want to give her up. The couples who had paid and signed that contract sends her to court to claim the child. Kobe and Gina who read this case, argues about what the outcome of the case should be.Kobe: This woman must be crazy if she thinks she can just take the couplesmoney for free. Money is hard to come by these days and it would bereally annoying if someone plays this game with you.Gina: It looks like you care most about the money and nothing else.Kobe: Yes. The money matters to me, but that?s not the only reason whyI think the surrogate mother is wrong. I feel there is no reason whya contract should be broken.Gina: I understand that personal ownership is important because it gives peoplethe incentive to work. And I also believe that contracts serve as a security, but I do think that some contracts should not be upheld because of its provisions.Kobe: Well, to my understanding, the surrogate mother accepted the couple?smoney and agreed to give up her parental rights on the day of delivery.There is no evidence that she was forced to sign the contract. And there isno showing that she is of unsound mind.Gina: Yes she agreed, but don?t you think that the money incentive of thesurrogacy contract must have coerced her in the decision making.Kobe: What you fail to understand is that, she was given a choice and she shouldbe held accountable for what ever decision she chose. It?s not like she hada gun pointed to her head.Gina: I want you to imagine yourself in a situation where the only way to getmoney to feed your family is to sell your eyes. The question is, did youreally want to sell it or you were pushed by certain...

Find Another Essay On A fictionalized dialogue on morality

Morality and Politics Essay

1971 words - 8 pages whether or not politics should be focused on morality. Plato had various different works throughout his life, however, possibly his most famous and influential was the Republic. The method that Plato used in his writing was known as the dialogue method, here Plato writes a dialogue between Socrates and another person and Socrates solves the problem that Plato proposes. Knowledge plays an important role in Plato’s works and it aids in

Morality And Power Essay

938 words - 4 pages      Thucydides’ written history of the Mytilenian Debate and the Melian Dialogue reflects the reality of a period where morality is dependent on the exercise of power and those who possess it. The main theme running through the course of these two debates is that those with the power to act as they wish inherently have the power to dictate morality. The arguments that decide the fate of the Mytilene are made not

Charles W. Chestnutt's The Marrow of Tradition

1034 words - 4 pages the novel as a significant one as evidenced by reviews in       Chautauquan, the New York Times, The Literary World, Nation, and New York       Age.         However, most reviews, even those which pointed out the important theme of       the novel, suggested that it was not a well written one, often seeming       overly dramatic and too fictionalized. Even Chesnutt's friend, W.D.       Howells, was quick to

Thrasymachus' Perspective on Human Nature

1340 words - 5 pages Thrasymachus' Perspective on Human Nature Thrasymachus' perspective of human nature is that we all seek to maximize power, profit and possessions. He gives the argument that morality is not an objective truth but rather a creation of the stronger (ruling) party to serve its own advantage. Therefore definitions of "just" and "unjust", "right" and "wrong", "moral" and "immoral" are all dependent upon the decree of the ruling party

Secular Morality and Religious Morality Inadvertently Influenced One Another

986 words - 4 pages . Moreover, to evade the almost omnipresent influence of religious morality would be nearly impossible; this allows for the almost constant melding of the two making them almost indistinguishable. While certainly not all morality is based on religion, it has become such a force that morality can scarcely be discussed without religion in mind. So, in what aspect does religious morality and secular morality intersect to create this dimension

aristophanes essay

1327 words - 6 pages The Birds and The Frogs, written by Aristophanes, show a strong dichotomy between the pragmatic and romantic. This dichotomy is prominent in both stories because it voices a perspective on the evolution of Greek culture. Although written for entertainment, many of the punchlines refer to the real life triumphs and crises of Greece. For example; both plays were written during the 4th Century BCE, during which, Athens was on the brink of war

Style and Storytelling in The Things They Carried

2421 words - 10 pages suggestion of Norman Bowker, who three years later hanged himself in the locker room of a YMCA in his hometown in central Iowa" (O'Brien 155). This sudden change leaves the reader perplexed, often many questions are left unanswered as O'Brien never elaborates on the deaths. This change from O'Brien's fictionalized character to his "real" one is a highlighted throughout the entire novel and allows the reader to examine events from different

Socrates-not perfect- I got a A- at UC Berkeley on it Essay on how Socrates arguments are contradictory and can be proven faulty. This essay proves a few of Socrates arguments faulty.

1249 words - 5 pages plan to show that Socrates argument is flawed as he leaves too many questions unanswered and his belief relies much too heavily on assumption. In addition, Socrates argument relies on a false premise, my argument reads as follows:Socrates suggests that if there are moral "experts", we should listen to them. This is a flawed statement since there is no such thing. Morality as a whole differs from opinion to opinion and person-to-person, what is

Exploring the Relationship Between Morality and Religion

1553 words - 6 pages defence of the dependence of religion on morality because it fails to provide logical justification for God's moral dictates. First, I will begin by providing a closer examination of the Divine Command Theory and its implications. Next, I will introduce Plato's famous dialogue The Euthyphro, which critiques the Divine Command Theory's definition of morality, and introduce its famous dilemma, which poses two possible explanations for the correlation

Culturally Dominant Models of How to be and Look a Man

2511 words - 10 pages female characters. The Doctor is subject to cultural developments in his masculinity depending on the hegemonic norm; he is white, middle class, independent heterosexual embodying the current extrovert nature of the young male sex symbol. Contemporary theory on masculinity in media to Baker (2006) constructs the basis of masculinity in a period as the reflection of changes in political ideology. Centralizing a thesis that ideology has a need to


1114 words - 4 pages arguments throughout the whole dialogue were very strong. Socrates looked out for his state, while Crito’s arguments were based on himself and how others would view him. Socrates’ conclusion to stay in the prison may have cost him his life, but his act saved the morality and truth of Athens. Works Cited Wolff, Robert Paul. “Ten Great Works of Philosophy”. New York: Penguin Group, 1969. Durant, William. “The Story of Philosophy”. New York: Washington Square Press Publications, 1961. Volume I, Ninth Edition. “Civilization: Past & Present”. New York: Addison-Wesley Longman, Inc., 2000.

Similar Essays

"Jane Eyre" And A Picture Of Dorian Gray's Emphasis On Individual Morality.

614 words - 2 pages It is important to read Jane Eyre and A Picture of Dorian Gray in order to catch the subtle messages about the importance of individual morality.Jane Eyre, by Charlotte Bronte provides readers with a message that morality is a manner of acting, rather than speaking. Bronte uses satire to illustrate how religion preached but not followed is useless. The first example of this comes while Jane is at Gateshead. "God will punish her: he might strike

The Dialogue A Discussion On What Philosophy Is For

864 words - 3 pages people when they get into philosophy. They ask questions and then will often come up with answers that don't match up with the way that they live their lives and will move on trying to find more answers which they obviously will never find. People do find answers to their questions in philosophy, it's just that they only accept those answers which go along with how they live. Socrates refers to the fact that it is more comfortable to live in a world

What Would Aristotle Have Thought About A State Lottery? This Essay Uses Aristotle's Views On Justice To Evaluate The Morality Of A State Lottery.

688 words - 3 pages One aspect of justice, which Aristotle elaborated on, was that which was concerned with a fair distribution and proportionate equality. These aspects are directly related to the debate about whether a state lottery would be unjust toward those citizens of the state who are the least able to afford it. For the sake of argument we will assume that a lottery is a disproportionate tax on the poor, who are more inclined to play hoping of financial

Discussion Of The View That Morality And Religion Are Linked

962 words - 4 pages view is deontological because it based on golden rules and does not look at present consequences before it is considered moral or right. This view makes morality objective as it lays down certain rules for humans to live by. The Euthyphro dialogue is what the issue of religion and morality is based around. This dialogue by Plato portrays the view that morality and religion are linked. In this dialogue, Plato’s