A Freedom Greater Than Freedom Essay

2541 words - 10 pages

It is a common misconception that those in power necessarily have more liberty than their less powerful counterparts. Intuitively, a country’s king has the freedom to act in more ways than the peasant, the rich have more options than the poor, the slave owner rules while the slave is ruled, and a government official often treads above the laws they pen for the people. However, there is a hidden assumption in this way of thought— that liberty is proportional to quality of life. From a pragmatic point of view, most would choose the life of the king over the life of the slave, the rich over the poor, the slave owners over the slaves, or the above the law status to the law abiding one, simply because the quality of life of one is so much greater than the quality of life of the other. This is not the same as having a greater amount of liberty. I contend, in fact, that if one group does have a greater amount of liberty than the other does, it is by a small amount and hardly decidable as to who has more liberty.
In this discussion, I will use freedom and liberty interchangeably, with the intended meaning of both to be that which one is able and allowed to choose to do. For instance, I am able and allowed to vote in congressional election this year, therefore I have the freedom or liberty to vote. However, while I am able to set fire to an orphanage, I am not allowed to, therefore I do not have the freedom or liberty to commit arson. Additionally, I will make a distinction between freedoms and what I call mini-freedoms. A freedom is what one is able or allowed to do by law, or in public. A mini-freedom is what one can do on the level of gestures, speech, habits, posture, eating style; it is anything that concerns an individuals slightest motion. For example, voting is a freedom, while how one chews their food is a mini-freedom. To aid in this discussion, I will examine closely Arthur Dimmesdale of The Scarlet Letter, and the cast of characters in A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court.
We begin with Hawthorne’s Puritan soap opera and one of its principal characters, certainly one of the most pitiful men in American literature, Mr. Arthur Dimmesdale (this is not to suggest that he is cruel, sinful or wicked, merely that one can at most feel pity for the way he supports a way of life that crushes him). Within the limits of Boston in the mid-1640’s Dimmesdale, being a minister, is quite revered. His faith is envied, his audiences awestruck and his role as a leader in the community assured. If we define power to be influence over another, then Dimmesdale holds great power in both his words and actions. However, compared with others in his community, did he have more freedom?
I mean by asking the question concluding the preceding paragraph to raise another question. Are freedoms only what one is allowed to do in the public arena? Or the private arena? Or in both? Certainly, our ability to speak out against a public official is one of many easily...

Find Another Essay On A freedom greater than freedom

A Struggle For Freedom Essay

1014 words - 4 pages A Struggle For Freedom In 1831 in Southampton county, a slave named Nat Turner did something so revolutionary that to this day it is still an uncomfortable subject for a small town in Virginia. With very little documented history, Stephen B. Oates tells how one slave turned the entire south upside down on one hot August Sunday. Oate's own struggle in finding the truth about the past was something that this small town of Southampton was

Religious Freedom: A Religious Trap? Essay

1962 words - 8 pages lines to carry our mass – murder operations against Jews… German S.S. and police units… murdered more than a million Jewish men, women, and children…” (“Introduction to the Holocaust” 4). The Nazi regimes systematic killing of Jews or genocide convention to guarantee nothing like the Holocaust ever happened again. Therefore Religious Freedom laws are ineffective if one must fear violence and hatred because of differences in beliefs. John Shattuck

A Guard on Religious Freedom

751 words - 3 pages Persuasive Essay #1                A Guard on Religious Freedom In the eyes of our founding fathers, few things seemed as important as the separation of church and state. The first amendment grants all Americans the freedom to subscribe to any religion they wish and promises that the government will not promote any religion above any other. Although the separation of

Abortion - A Freedom Of Choice

1760 words - 7 pages abortions vary. It may be a case of rape, physical or psychological condition. A choice needs to be available to prevent the birth of unwanted children, to avoid damage to the child as well as to safeguard the emotional and physical health of women. Preservation of life seems to be rather a slogan than a genuine goal of the anti-abortion forces; what they really want is control. Control over our behavior and power over women’s choices. Abortion is a

Abortion: A Freedom of Choice

862 words - 3 pages Abortion: A Freedom of Choice During the last twenty-five years, abortion has been one of the most heated topics being debated the world. The only topics that equal the abortion debate are race and war. Abortion is a discussion of human interaction where ethics, emotions, and law come together. People have different opinions usually only have two choices when confronted with abortion. They are either for it or against it. There is the pro

Freedom Philosophy, Rhetorical Writing to describe a connotative definition (Freedom)

688 words - 3 pages In the chaos of war that day in Yorktown, what was the prize of the long efforts of every man in the American army, what was the point of fighting, and what was the cause of the great American Revolution? What was the flicker of light in the soldiers' eyes, the hope inside every soul, the necessity of life? Freedom! The desire to live in absence of restraint; under a rational, humanist, and reasonable government. It was this desire that ignited

Freedom is a Service to Happiness

1475 words - 6 pages of freedom in what they choose to do. The Grand Inquisitor disapproved the actions Christ has done and argues with him that freewill means having “burdened spiritual kingdom of mankind with its sufferings forever” until one is able to find the right path to obtain the comfortable life of a safe community by Christ (Dostoevsky 27). He believes that “nothing has ever been more insupportable for man and for human society than freedom” because people

The Automobile: A False Sense of Freedom

2503 words - 10 pages today’s consumer culture”, (2006). It’s easy to see how this can happen to the youth of San Jose, when it’s something that affects every American. The automobile promises freedom, but at a cost. While that cost varies by person, place and time; there is no one that goes un-touched by the consequences of an auto dependent society. Amy Best continues in Fast Cars, Cool Rides, “Freedom, more often than not carries significant social and financial costs

Frankenstein: A Warning Against Masculine Individualistic Freedom

1669 words - 7 pages Frankenstein: A Warning Against Masculine Individualistic Freedom In this commentary, I wanted to examine a little further the implications of a point brought up in the presentation on Mary Shelley's Frankenstein. They briefly suggested that Victor might occupy a space of idealised masculine freedom; given Victor's less than ideal fate and Mary Shelley's Feminism, such a masculine idealisation becomes highly problematic. Victor holds a

Freedom of Choice in A Clockwork Orange

1258 words - 5 pages Freedom of Choice In the novel A Clockwork Orange, the author Anthony Burgess tells a story about a young man name Alex and his friends, every night they go around and start committing violent acts. In the novel Alex expresses his freedom of choice between good and evil. The freedom of choice is a decision that every person must make throughout his life in order to guide his actions and to take control of his own future. This Freedom of

A Discussion of Freedom by Shaw

2093 words - 8 pages Union gone mad.' The solution he proffers is, however, too ideal to be applicable- it is almost Utopian. According to him, "Sane Trade Unionism would never sanction more than one big strike at a time, with all the other traders working overtime to support it." Towards the end of his essay he recapitulates the major ideas dealt with so far. He says that the word `freedom' should be used by us in its Old English sense of `leisure'. Not only

Similar Essays

American Freedom No Greater Gift

1416 words - 6 pages American Freedom - No Greater Gift Silently they stand, tall, strong pillars of memory in a seemingly long since forgotten world. Rows upon rows of white marble glisten in the first rays of the rising sun. The shimmer of morning frost still graces their elegant arches as the brisk air begins to take on a slightly warmer tone. In this quiet hour, not quite night, yet still not day, one lone man stands respectfully next to a small, almost

Freedom Is More Valued Than Security

1812 words - 7 pages country will not allow its government to achieve either, as both will affect the country significantly in a negative spotlight. However, balancing freedom and security doesn’t take away all the problems, as having same amount of freedom and security is impossible in reality and will soon tip into either side, and having more security than freedom will make citizens protest outside and inside of the area of influence by the government, and the

A Fundamental Freedom Essay

1015 words - 4 pages legislation requiring public workers to pay union dues in order to keep their jobs. This insures the unions remain powerful and guaranteeing their ability to continually request greater benefits. Unfortunately, this stands in the way of the workers fundamental right to choose. For example, workers who do not wish to be union members, because of philosophical or religious beliefs, have no choice in the matter. Thus, their freedom of choice is violated

A Fight For Freedom Essay

1026 words - 4 pages A Fight for Freedom The Declaration of Independence had a single purpose – to declare America’s freedom from Britain’s tyranny. Thomas Jefferson crafted a strongly worded document that served this purpose but it was almost lost in the multiple styles he used. The declaration was intended to communicate the lofty ideals and sacred dreams of the citizens of the United States. Throughout the declaration, Jefferson’s style shifts between formal