The rising obesity rates in America have become quite popular debates these days. With 30 percent of children being diagnosed with type 2 diabetes as apposed to 5 percent in 1994, the big question is who to blame? Susie Orbach and David Zinczenko take two similar yet different approaches with their essays. David writing, “Don’t Blame the Eater” and Susie’s “Fat is a Feminist Issue.”
Susie’s essay is about how society has sent standards for how women should look, eat, and behave. That is not a woman’s fault she’s over-weight or obese, but society for their judgmental standards. Susie claims “A feminist perspective to the problem of women’s compulsive eating is essential if we are to move on from the ineffective blame-the-victim approach” (Orbach 201) in this quote Orbach informs the reader that the blame the eater approach is the wrong one. Instead she provides a feminist approach. She says how being fat is sometimes a woman’s way of rebelling against societies standards. To break free of the sex stereotypes. Susie also says “Fat expresses experiences of women today in ways that are seldom examined and even more seldom treated…” here susies is saying that people over look the things that women have to deal with. Such as the magazines of twig-like women, how to be beautiful, how to behave, how to act, and all the stereotypes that society puts on women.
Unlike Zinczenko and blaming the food industries, Orbach turns towards the American people. Uncovering and discussing the pressures America puts on women. Such as size, clothes, sexuality all play roles in American women’s lives. Orbach claims that if you are a true feminist, being overweight symbolizes your disproval of society’s opinion on how women should be. Thus, she describes it as being “a definite and purposeful act” that t is purposeful because of how it silently protests against conformity.
In order for a woman to be successful, the media claims they must use the top-of-the-line products, such as hairspray and make up, which are necessities. Many businesses thrive of the insecurities of women, magazines and journalists to. All the products either hide or fix the problems that women have.
Now David Zinczenko takes a different approach to the obesity issues. He blames the food industries for their lack of warning labels. He begins his essay with kids suing McDonalds for making them fat, comparing it to middle-aged men suing Porsche for making them get speeding tickets. Stating the question “What ever happened to personal responsibility?” though David does say how his sympathizes with the kids because of how he used to be over-weight. Saying he was 212 pounds at 5-foot-10. Although he stated is because he was a child of divorce who’s parents were busy working so fast food was the easy dinner. Though during college he says how he turned his life around with workouts and healthy eating, but many...