A Good Samaritan Law Is Never A Good Idea

1196 words - 5 pages

A Good Samaritan Law is Never a Good Idea

Less than one year ago, the largest television audience since the series finale of M*A
*S*H tuned in to watch the last episode of Seinfeld As the nation watched, Jerry, Elaine, George, and Kramer said farewell with the arrest, trial, and conviction of violating a Good Samaritan law. While this made for a hilarious television show, this law itself seems to both contradict its essence as well as violate the right to freedom of choice of a citizen. The Good Samaritan law, which requires a bystander to provide aid to those who are in harm’s way if there is no apparent immediate danger to the bystander, encroaches upon the rights of a citizen. This law is an inexcusable violation of American civil liberties and should be stricken from the records, leaving only people’s moral compasses as their guide.

The morality of this law is relatively simple: help those in trouble. Generally society
seems to consider it a moral obligation to prevent the injury of another person, sometimes even at risk to one’s self. People who do not help others in need are frequently bad examples for the rest of the world. For example, in Charles Dickens’s classic A Christmas Carol, Ebeneezer Scrooge is infamous for his selfishness and disregard for the well-being of others such as Bob Cratchett and his family (barely paying him and not allowing him more than a day for Christmas). Scrooge’s partner, Jacob Marley, is damned for the same type of crimes. The only path to redemption for Ebeneezer is through helping others who are in need: giving food to the Cratchetts and caring for a sickly Tiny Tim.

While Scrooge had a moral reason to help others, there was no Constitutional burden to
do so. If the federal government were to pass such a law, as several state governments have, it would violate the right to liberty since a person has the right to do whatever he or she wishes so long as that action does not infringe upon the rights of others. By requiring a person to act as opposed to merely limiting the actions, the law itself violates freedom of choice. Since the person himself is not intruding upon anyone’s rights, it is that person’s prerogative to not act, no matter how morally objectionable this act may be.

In fact, the extreme case of someone not providing aid has indeed occurred. In Septem-
ber in Las Vegas, a nineteen-year-old raped and murdered a seven-year-old girl in a casino bathroom while a friend stayed outside, knowing the other man was raping her. Since there is no Good Samaritan law in Nevada, the friend is now attending college a free man. Most people probably wonder how someone could hear a little girl’s screams and turn instead to the laughter and lights of the casino. They ask, if he could not bring himself to step in, how can he sleep at night now, knowing he caused the pain and death of an innocent child? He did not touch her or aid the rapist in any way. According to the letter of the law he...

Find Another Essay On A Good Samaritan Law is Never a Good Idea

Very Good Paper. Argumentative essay explaining why home schooling is a good idea.

1203 words - 5 pages education is by attending a public school. However, there is one very different option, home schooling. The advantages of home schooling are starting to be realized by more and more parents each year, evident by the growing number of children being home schooled. So, are there advantages to home schooling? With today's society, this seems to be growing truer all the time. Of course, there are disadvantages to just about anything; home schooling

Part-time Jobs For Students: A Good Idea

1297 words - 5 pages Part-time Jobs for Students: A Good Idea I, being employed with a part-time job, truly do believe that there is no wrong in having a part-time job while being a student. I honestly think that it is an awesome, great idea for students to have part-time jobs before they graduate from high school -- if they have the time and resources to do so. Students who are responsible, or learn responsibility, have nothing to loose but all to gain by

Would Legalizing Prostitution in Nevada, Be a Good Idea?

1466 words - 6 pages not be a good idea in Nevada The women who engage in prostitution illegal or legal are not always doing it by choice. Some women may be homeless and jobless and in desperate need for money. Some may be young high school girls on the street. Many become addicted to drugs and prostitution is quick money and the women trapped by their pimps and addictions. Men buy women, the age of the men run between 18-74 years old and the men come from every

Was selling council houses to tenants a good idea?

1609 words - 6 pages The sale of council houses to tenants has been practiced for many years, but was significantly increased by the 1980 Housing Act that was put through Parliament by Margaret Thatcher's Conservative government. This Act, and in general the sale of council houses, have had both costs and benefits, so to come to a conclusion on whether or not this was a good idea we have to analyse the changes made by the Housing Act of 1980 (and other, less

School Uniforms Are a Good Idea in Public Schools

1439 words - 6 pages Henry Ford once said, "Coming together is a beginning; keeping together is progress; working together is success." In other words, having a school uniform would be a success if public schools adopted the policy. Many good things will come because of how effective it can lead in public schools. In 1987, the first public school to adopt the uniform policy would be Cherry Hill Elementary in Baltimore, MD. Then decades and centuries later, many of

Is The Idea Of A Contract A Good Way Of Explaining Why We Ought To Do Things?

1728 words - 7 pages Theory of Politics - Week 1 Is the idea of a contract a good way of explaining why we ought to do things even though we do not want to? Is it a good way of explaining anything else? A working definition of a contract, for students such as myself who are largely unfamiliar with the definition of the term, is a promise that the law will enforce. The law provides remedies if a promise

Community Psychology essay discussing the idea of change and whether or not it is good for people as a whole.

1002 words - 4 pages requires examination of multiperson systems of interaction not limited to a single setting and must take into account aspects of the environment beyond the immediate situation containing the subject". I think what is trying to be said is that we need to look at a wide variety of things and settings by looking toward the future, not just now, and what is going to be good on a larger level as apposed be better for the individual. If we can do this I think the world will be better, but it will not happen for a very long time if it happens at all.

Good things never last

994 words - 4 pages . That's one reason running the mile every week is good for you.The Monday we didn't have school so I'm here typing this. I guess the people at school will be pissed at me but honestly I don't really care. Those people never really liked me and now they never will and it suits me fine. Well that's the story.I guess the moral of the story is to enjoy things while you can because they never last very long unless of course it's a piece of crap.

Is standardized testing a good idea? The lack of equality in today's school systems often decide a student's future. Is a standardized test the measure of a student?

1219 words - 5 pages , butif all sections of the test are not passed before the end of the senior year of high school, astudent will not receive a diploma.2At first light high school exit exams seem to be a good idea. It ensures that graduatingseniors have obtained a certain level of knowledge. It encourages schools to maintain ahigh level of academic achievement and introduces students to the world of standardizedtests that have serious repercussions. Also

With reference to relevant literature, discuss the notion that a career in the international hospitality and tourism industry is not a good idea.

2738 words - 11 pages With reference to relevant literature, discuss the notion that a career in the international hospitality and tourism industry is not a good idea.The hospitality and tourism industry is one of the largest employers in the United Kingdom and many other developed and less developed countries. Tourism is one of the fastest growing sectors within the global economy with a growing presence in virtually every country. The World Tourism Organization

War with Iraq, reasons it occurred and personal opinion on why it was a good idea.

951 words - 4 pages . The message has to be sent that the world will not stand for the mistreatment of power that Hussein has exemplified.In my personal opinion, Saddam Hussein and his regime should be wiped out by any means necessary, because it would be for the overall good of the world and no one with his frame of mind should be allowed to retain a position of power. The majority of people that join anti-war protests do so because of false ideas that this is a "Bush

Similar Essays

Condoms A Good Idea Essay

1079 words - 4 pages Condoms in Schools: A Good Idea The movie Grease. One of the best-loved movies of the twentieth century, watched by millions in the movie theatre upon its release in 1978. A newer, generation that is more modern got to experience the gang at Rydell High when it was re-released in 1998. There are many memorable scenes in the movie, but one that really stands out is the scene where Rizzo and Knicky are making out in his car. They are swept into

Is Music Downloading A Good Idea?

967 words - 4 pages consumers will buy music rather than copy it. As I am a violin player, I would like to share my recording on the Internet, but if music downloading such as out of controls that who wants become next sacrifice? Overall, I am disagreeing with music downloading as a good idea, which couldn’t 100% protect artists. Many artists can take advantages of it and become famous, but did you know they still cannot get reciprocally benefit. The problem now is that the government has to administer strict law to stop illegal downloading and websites that provide it. If people cannot follow the rules, the free music downloading should be restricted.

Adoption Reversal Is Not A Good Idea

686 words - 3 pages Adoption Reversal is Not a Good Idea Adoption is a difficult experience for all parties involved. It is because of these trials and tribulations that a parent's decision to give a child up for adoption should not be reversed. Parents should not be allowed to retain guardianship of a child that they have given up for adoption. If a parent goes through the entire process of giving up the parental right of a child, the process should not be

Cons Of Good Samaritan Law And Its Solution

1166 words - 5 pages incident is well-known as 'Genovese Syndrome', which refers to a social phenomenon where a person is less likely to offer help to another person who are in danger. It is also known as 'Bystander effect', and it is rising as a serious issue in a modern society where individualism is becoming widespread among people. Good Samaritan law is legislated in order to punish bystanders and to protect the members of society. In spite of its good purpose