This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

"A Good Manager Will Always Be A Good Leader" Leadership & Management, Differences Between.

2607 words - 10 pages

A Good Manager Will Always be a Good LeaderIn this essay I will demonstrate how a good manager can often be a good leader, but why I also believe that explicit differences in characteristics; attitudes and methods prove them to be unique. I will do this by firstly, defining what I feel a good manager is, and what I feel a good leader is. In doing this, I will compare and contrast the two concepts in order to finally draw conclusive similarities and distinctions between the two.American philosopher James Burnham (1941) christened the post-"industrial revolution" epoch in the title of his book; "The Managerial Revolution"1. In contrast to the bygone period in which the primary economic progress lay in technological progress, Burnham emphasised that the "contemporary era" depended heavily on human resources- on the leadership skills of men and women to "impel economic development" with their direction and co-ordinating of others' individual efforts in the business of living. There has been an evident 're-invention', as such, of the term management. It has thus become increasingly difficult to successfully define it. Whereas traditionally, French industrialist Henri Fayol's (1916) humble description of one who "plans, organises, co-ordinates and controls" has dominated our perceptions, today we take a more precise and realistic approach to the meaning of this title.Leadership too lacks a definite, universally accepted meaning, except of course in the literal sense of the adjective leading; "to show the way by going with ... to serve as the means of reaching a place" (Hanks, 1986). Clegg et al. (2008) describes it as a term that is "one of the most over-theorised, over-researched, and empirically messy areas of management and organisation". The issue with leadership is not that the meaning has evolved (like management), but that the term is "tossed around promiscuously", and is used to describe a vast array of characteristics, that might only vaguely represent the true fundamental aspects of leadership. An age-long controversy arises here when we ask is leadership a science or an art? Can it be learned, or must one be born with it? Clegg describes the "trait theorists" as those who believe leadership to be a "question of unique traits that people are born with". The "behaviourist school" on the other hand, defines it as a "specific way of behaving that makes you either an effective or ineffective leader." As Drucker said, "mathematicians are born, but anyone can learn trigonometry". In essence, leadership can mean whatever you want it to mean, as there is such a broad spectrum of thought and varied opinion surrounding it.In my opinion leadership "is the power of one individual to guide the actions of another. Leaders are individuals who guide others toward the accomplishment of goals in such a way that followers want to follow" (Dailey). It is an attribute commonly found in those whose positions, titles or status are regarded as being 'above' others....

Find Another Essay On "A Good Manager Will Always Be a Good Leader" -Leadership & management, differences between.

Difference Between A Leader and A Manager

1123 words - 4 pages IntroductionAccording to Muenjohn, Boucher and Tran 2010, ‘Leadership is theability to inspire confidence and support among the people who needed to achieve organizational goals.’ In this module, we learn the differences between what makes a leader and a manager. And the purposeof this assessment is to do a reflection on an analysis of anotherleader for my leadership improvement by applying the relevant theoriesand concepts learned in this

What Makes a Good Leader? Essay

3220 words - 13 pages What makes a good leader? It depends. Most organizations look for individuals that have something to offer when they look at credentials or a great interview but looks can be deceiving does a good manager necessarily mean that a good leader I do not think so. Leadership is a topic that will have to be address by every organization .In my opinion no organization will be able to prosper without good leadership. Even though no two

Is Ralph a Good Leader?

914 words - 4 pages in time will only leave a priority of hunting, abandoning the chance for rescue. Ralph strongly encourages to Jack that without order there is nothing. After all, Ralph was chosen leader. Following the important traits of bravery and order, Ralph displays his trait of morality and honesty. Ralph subtly keeps the fairness between all of the boys. Ralph looking for more understanding of Piggy, saw that he was hurt and crushed. He hovered between

Differences Between Individuals Will Always Occur In Work Organisation. Ideally, Good Management Practice Should Use Performance Appraisal Information In Ways That Will Promote Equality Amongst...

734 words - 3 pages company determined norms, it is a mean of increasing the element of control over the employment.2) To enhance the consistency between employee actions and corporate goals in order to bring coporate objectives to the employee.3) To improve the quality of human resources planning 4) To improve the quality of salary reviews 5) To provide a record in case of dismissal, demotion, grievance or appeal and therefore employee needs to be able to justify

Progress, Not Always a Good Thing

2345 words - 9 pages together in spirit, but in reality stratified the society so only a few could reap the rewards of others' sacrifice. Progress was intended to bring America greatness, but not everyone could agree on that, some thought the idea was to have land and be able to produce for yourself, while others saw business and industrialization as the future. It is the basic misperception in America that progress is always good and that it will help everyone

Foreign Direct Investment: Always a Good Choice

1206 words - 5 pages will continually stimulate the development of Chinese economy once the transformation has accomplished. Moreover, foreign investment is exerting positive effects on China’s balance and stability of economy. To be more exact, a nation’s level of GDP and its level of net export are highly related, and so are the relationship between net export and foreign investment (Lau & Garry, 2008). In another word, theoretically, there is a strong connection

Characteristics that Make a Good Nurse Leader

1531 words - 7 pages , one must possess certain characteristics that not only define who they are but inspire those who they lead. In order to explore these characteristics an in depth exploration will be done on a nurse leader who exhibits many good nursing leadership qualities. Nurse Leader I currently work in the Home Care arena and have worked for my present company for about a year. My nurse manager always exhibits exceptional leadership qualities. She has

Captain Picard: Is He a Good Leader?

1754 words - 7 pages his office and asks "how is the crew's spirit?" ("The Defector") This definitely proves that he is keeping the crew in mind, which is a very crucial aspect to being a good leader. If the Captain cannot maintain good morale, then the crisis will consume the Enterprise and the Romulans will win. However, because he has concern for his crew they have confidence in him. They trust his decisions. This complete trust between leader and crew allows the

Julius Caesar - Qualities of a Good Leader

968 words - 4 pages Selecting a good leader for a country is like dominoes. The leader needs to be somebody that won't make the occasional mistake that would, in dominoes, hit one of the others and make them all fall down. If the leader does their job correctly, the country will be strong. A good leader must be able to make his own decisions because if he cannot, he will be considered a weak leader. A country's leader must be able to communicate with the people as

Was King Louis XIV a good leader?

616 words - 2 pages Was Louis XIV a good leader?Louis XIV was born on September 5th, 1638. At the age of 4, he was able to become King of France but obviously he was too young. He became king in 1661 at the age of 22. Some people think he was a good leader. Some think he was a bad leader. They have their reasons with enough evidence to support them. But, what reasons were good for France? Were the people happy? Louis XIV was a horrible King politically, socially

Lessons on Being a Good Leader Described in John Maxwell's Book, Be a People Person

520 words - 2 pages is trying to show just how to become the kind of person people will listen to and have the kind of attitude people want to contend with. In this book, one primary focus is on the idea that there should never be a time where there is a lack of leadership (63). A leader must always go above and beyond the call of duty. This means that if something needs done and no one else is accomplishing the task, you must personally take care of it. When you go

Similar Essays

To Be A Good Leader Essay

1568 words - 6 pages without having to ask more questions; instead they would use their notes. It is the leaders’ responsibility to make sure that their team is on track with their project and that it is completed by its dead line (Rich). A good leader should always be decisive even if they do not have all of the information (Frank). A leader will need to make quick decision, like Theodore Roosevelt once said, "In any moment of decision, the best thing you can do is

A Good Leader Essay

1112 words - 4 pages A Good Leader In this essay I will analyse different leadership styles and the contributory factors of a good leader and how succesful leadership adapts to different sports using practical examples to supplement my arguments. It is appreciated that that the leadership of a group, e.g team captain, is a crucial element affecting overall group performance. Thus leadership is seen as any behaviour that moves a group

Being A Good Leader Essay

3458 words - 14 pages -violent means for the sake of getting freedom. Among the non-violent means, most important ones are the huger strikes and Dandi March (salt march). He also had to go to jail with his followers but he never bothered these hardships coming in his way. According to Keshvan Nair (1996), good leadership can be destroyed if there is a feeling of distrust among people because of not being able to understand the vision of their leader. Gandhi

Octavius A Good Leader Essay

1041 words - 5 pages Octavius Augustus Ceasar is probably the most important person in the history of Rome. Octavius ruled from 27 BC to 14 AD. During his time as ruler, the Roman Empire experienced its longest time of peace. Because he knew his people, had a strong military background, knew how to solve problems, Patience, and created a new government, this is why Octavius “Augustus” Ceasar was a great leader. One reason Caesar was a good ruler was his strong