A Knight's Tale Essay

1697 words - 7 pages

The Canterbury Tales begin with The Knight’s Tale; which chronicles the tragic love triangle of Palamon, Arcite and Emilye. The following tale, which is told by the Miller, is also a love triangle, and is in many ways similar to the Knight’s tale. However, the Miller’s tale sharply contrasts the Knight’s, almost parodying it. The Knight’s tale is a tragic of nobility, heritage and focuses heavily on mythology and astrology, whereas The Miller’s tale is a comedy, focusing on the common-man and his less civilized, and bawdy lifestyle. The two stories mirror one another in many ways, but are presented from completely different sides of the spectrum. When the two tales are looked at closely, it doesn’t seem to be a coincidence that they occur back-to-back to one another as there is a stark contrast between the two.
The stories core elements are love, specifically focusing on love at first sight. The Knight tells of Palamon and Arcite, two prisoners of war, who fall for Emelye. Palamon and Arcite, who as cousins were once as close as sworn brothers, turn on one another after merely catching a glimpse of Emelye. Palamon’s love for her is so strong, that he breaks out of captivity in an attempt to find her, putting himself in great danger. Arcite, who was freed from prison by the favor of Perotheus under the condition he never return to Athens, takes his love to extremes as well, disguising himself as Philostrate, and taking up work as a page in Emelye’s chamber, just to be near her. This all culminates in the mass battle in which the winner between Arcite and Palamon will receive Emelye’s hand in marriage. The Knight’s account of love is pure and virtuous, with no hint of anything but true love.
The Miller does not share these qualities in his account, instead focusing on lust, trickery, vulgarity and adultery. Nicholas’ love at first sight is nothing more than sexual lust for Alison, who is another mans much younger wife. Nicholas does not share Palamon or Arcite’s passion for true love, and comes up with a simple hoax to trick Alison’s unintelligent husband John into leaving he and Alison alone for a night. The Miller’s story continues to stray from the Knight’s as a third luster is presented for Alison’s affection; Absalon, a parish clerk. As opposed to an epic battle for courtship, the story devolves into slapstick humor, with Absalon kissing Alison’s rear, and burning Nicholas’ in attempted revenge.
The balance of the love triangle is also thrown awry in the Miller’s tale. Not only if a fourth man present, Alison’s wife John (who is not even included in any form of romance throughout the tale) but Alison’s affection seem to only be for Nicholas. She is easily seduced by Nicholas and has little, to no romantic interest in Absalon, fooling him into kissing her rear and then laughing about it with Nicholas. These elements merely add to the Miller’s tale of perversion, distancing and parodying itself from the Knight’s tale of honor and true...

Find Another Essay On A Knight's Tale

Chaucer's Canterbury Tales - Idealism in the Knight's Tale

1834 words - 7 pages Idealism in the Knight's Tale      Despite its glorified accounts of the chivalrous lives of gentlemen, the Knight¹s Tale proves to be more than a tragically romantic saga with a happy ending. For beneath this guise lies an exploration into the trifling world of the day¹s aristocratic class. Here, where physical substance is superseded by appearance, reality gives way to disillusioned canon and emotion is sacrificed for honor. Naïve

Chaucer's Canterbury Tales - Enslavement and Freedom in the Knight's Tale

2099 words - 8 pages Enslavement and Freedom in the Knight's Tale        In the Knight's Tale, Palamon and Arcite's lives are filled with adversity and enslavement .  Not only do they live in  physical imprisonment, bound as prisoners of war in a tower, but they fall into Love's imprisonment, which leads them to suffer the decrees of cruel classical gods .  Cooper writes that there "can be no moral or metaphysical justice in the different fates that befall

An Essay entitled 'Doubt and Ambiguity in Chaucer's Knight's Tale'

1587 words - 6 pages know before, he certainly knows after listening to the Knight's Tale. By telling us that lady Dorigen is more importantly a woman of noble birth with some wealth to her name, than a beautiful heavenly creature, the Franklin makes us doubt whether Arveragus actually wants her for her beauty or for her wealth. The whole tale is certainly a glimpse of how life and love would work out perfectly well if everyone is truthful, kept to their word and

Human or Husk: Female Agency in The Knight's Tale and The Miller's Tale

2308 words - 10 pages more involved, independent Alison, over the paper-thin character of Emily. There are many aspects of The Knight's Tale that strike the reader as unusual or disturbing. When Palomon first spots Emily, he “cries out” as if he were physically injured, the injury of course being located in his heart (32). The concept of a character being struck with “love-at-first-sight” pains (reminiscent of Ovid's signs of love sickness) is a fairly common

Satire of the Knight in the Prologue and Knight's Tale of "The Canterbury Tales"

2367 words - 9 pages more subtly satirized. Chaucer satirizes knights and chivalry in two different ways: in the prologue and in the Knight's Tale. The first way in the prologue is with the pilgrim Knight's character. Chaucer wanted to present a realistic knight, but he also wanted to give the Knight some very real, and obvious flaws, as a sort of social commentary on the way that knight's were perceived in the 14th century. To that end, he gave the Knight

Love Sick: Analysis of The Knight's Tale

832 words - 3 pages affair: it is seen from the point of view of the man, whose feelings are of great interest and may be analyzed at length, while the woman exists only as an object arousing those feelings” (Spearing 11). In the Knight’s Tale two cousins swear loyalty to each other as brothers and break this bond when Emily gives them no choice but to become sick with unquenched love over her beauty.Emily’s love-invoking beauty was personified as a May


674 words - 3 pages realism of expression. There is no offensiveness or rudeness in the story in keeping with the Knight's character. The love of the two young men is noble and ideal. The young men share romanticized love for the uninterested Emelye. The only possible end of this love can be in marriage. There is no desire for a dishonest relationship. The contrast between this and the subsequent Miller's Tale deals with two men after the same woman, and both concern the

Compare and contrast: The Canterbury Tales

3366 words - 13 pages A COMPARISON AND CONTRAST:THE KNIGHT'S AND MILLER'S TALES REVISITEDThe Canterbury Tales by Geoffrey Chaucer is a classic piece wherein pilgrims tell tales during their journey to a holy shrine in Canterbury. A Knight and Miller are two of the pilgrims. Chaucer gives personality to each character wherein a drunken Miller can tell a tale that is full of brilliant characterization and also have nicely balanced action, and a tough soldier like the

Beginning with line 115, examine the ways in which Chaucer presents Alison in the Miller's Tale

781 words - 3 pages the knight's tale. So as the woman the men were fighting over in the millers tale was described with honourable intentions, the Miller is very much a different character, and Chaucer needs Alison to be described with the most sex appeal. This is sort of mocking towards the knight's ideals and virtues. Chaucer is writing for two audiences: the fictional audience of the pilgrims on their way to Canterbury, and the actual audience reading the tale

Chaucer's The Cantenbury Tales: Comparison Of The Knights Tale To The Miller's Tale

1259 words - 5 pages Abraham's A Glossary of Literary Terms defines genre as " a term that denotes types or classes of literature." (Abrams, 108) Chaucer's The Canterbury Tales opens with two tales which fall under contradicting genres. Devotion, duty and honor are the greatest themes flowing through Chaucer's "The Knight's Tale," as it is from the genre of Chivalric Romance. It depicts a "courtly chivalric age, often one of highly developed manners." (Abrams, 35

Discuss whether or not Chaucer's the miller's tale is accurately described as a fabilau

1016 words - 4 pages coarsely comic piece. To do this we must look at the humour within the tale, the aim/intended impact of the tale and also its coarseness of language and description. The miller's tale is used as a parody of the knight's tale, which is a joke aimed at the 1st fictional audience of the pilgrims travelling towards Canterbury. The coarseness in this is self evident, the parody is based on the fact the knight's tale was gentle and about chivalry

Similar Essays

Summary And Analysis Of The Knight's Tale

2295 words - 9 pages Summary and Analysis of The Knight's Tale The Knight's Tale, Part I: The Knight begins his tale with the story of a prince named Theseus who married Hippolyta, the queen of Scythia, and brought her and her sister, Emelye, back to Athens with him after conquering her kingdom of Amazons. When Theseus returned home victorious, he became aware that there was a company of women clad in black who knelt at the side of the highway, shrieking. The

The Knight's Tale In Geoffrey Chaucer's Canterbury Tales

824 words - 3 pages The Knight's Tale in Geoffrey Chaucer's Canterbury Tales The Knight's Tale is one of the twenty-two completed Canterbury Tales by the celebrated English Writer Geoffrey Chaucer (1343-1400). The Canterbury Tales are a collection of 120 stories that Chaucer began writing in 1386, and planned to complete during his lifetime. Each of the tales features a large range of characters in a great variety of medieval plots, along with interesting

Chaucer's Canterbury Tales Importance Of Order In Knight's Tale

1822 words - 7 pages The Importance of Order in Knight's Tale   Chaucer claims to place the Knight's Tale just after the General Prologue by chance, the drawing of lots. The Knight draws the short straw, and all are glad for it. The appropriateness of his lengthy tale to follow is clear on some levels, and barely perceptible on others. I intend to launch my investigation of the Knight's Tale with a scrutiny of these three statements, and perhaps we shall find

Chaucer's Canterbury Tales Emily's Strength In Knight's Tale

919 words - 4 pages Emily's Strength in Chaucer's The Knight's Tale This passeth yeer by yeer and day by day, Till it fill ones, in a morwe of May, that Emelye, that fairer was to sene Than is the lylie upon his stalke grene, And fressher than the May with floures newe - For with the rose colour stroof hire hewe, I noot which was the fyner of hem two- (1033-1039