This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Literature Review Wrong Turn America's Counterinsurgency

1463 words - 6 pages

A key term to discuss is counterinsurgency. I found it interesting that prior to the 1950s; COIN theorists from France and Britain used the term counter-revolutionary warfare, whereas due to the context of America’s revolutionary history the U.S. wanted to change the name to counterinsurgency. With the advent of wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, a unified doctrine needed to be drafted. John Nagl, was one of the authors and stated in an officially this was not an interagency publication but it did bring, “together a mix of serving and retired military officers and a handful of civilian military scholars.” Today the definition has created a strong doctrine as such, “American counterinsurgency, ...view middle of the document...

I disagree with Gentile that “hearts and minds” doctrine was not a deciding factor in the Malayan Emergency. By the British using resettlement, policies of relocation of native people for their safety did reduce loss of civilian life and drove the conflict into the jungle. Thus, successfully cutting off supply lines to the insurgents because of removal. This was a novel plan for that era. It is unfortunate the British did not recognize human rights of the Chinese, which lead to political unrest when the MNLA gained support of the Chinese because of oppression when they were denied equal rights to vote, had no land rights, and were poverty-stricken. I found it surprising that Gentile did not credit the British military with being effective with, “use of helicopters and transport aircraft which aided the COIN forces who were skilled in Jungle craft.” This is number six of Sir Robert Thompson’s 12 Key Principles, which is an early version of the doctrine known as “comprehensive approach”. A key defining concept used today with crisis management, “NATO operations show…a comprehensive approach involving political, civilian and military instruments is necessary.”
I especially disagree with Gentile’s assessment that large-unit sweeps was critical to the fighting of counterinsurgency. French theorists Roger Trinquier maintains large-unit sweeps have time limits. Consequently, only temporarily disperse guerrilla bands rather than destroy them.
Perhaps, , Gentile was a little too harsh in his analysis of General Templer stating that there is not primary evidence that bringing in a replacement General had no effect on the outcome. Gentile seemed adamant to criticize leaders rather than going into much detail of all the facts in question to quote Gentile, “The actual continuity of British Army operations in Malaya was buried by the counterinsurgency narrative, which instead portrayed a radical transformation after the arrival of Commanding officer Sir. Gerald Templer.
The Vietnam conflict, which I will call a war, has some sharp contrast different from Malaya. This was a highly political war. President Johnson’s Administration had constraints placed on where our military could intercede. The Communists had elaborate sanctuary bases in Cambodia, Laos, and North Vietnam, which we could not touch. The Geneva Accords split the country in two located along the 17th parallel. We know the North was under Communists rule and the South under a noncommunist government allied with the United States. The American troops fought two wars on the ground and the other in the air. The Air power was called “Rolling Thunder”. Despite all the ground troops and air firepower, a Superpower wielding conventional warfare was defeated by Maoist Principles of Guerrilla warfare, which is the “Peoples War”. Several key principles are the units start small and grow to form operational military base from the countryside, they militarize rural areas, mobilizes the...

Find Another Essay On A Literature Review Wrong Turn America's Counterinsurgency

Mental Health: A literature review

769 words - 3 pages Running head: Mental health re-hospitalization 1Mental Health Re-Hospitalization 5Mental Health: A Literature ReviewEastern Michigan UniversityVanessa ThreatsThe topic of my primary research paper is re-hospitalization of the mentally ill. How the management of healthcare professionals, and the identification of risk factors can aid in the reduction of re-hospitalization. I choose this topic because I have a son that suffers with mental illness

A Literature Review on Post Occupancy Evaluation

2061 words - 9 pages Introduction: Through out this essay I will conduct a literature review on post occupancy evaluation, to give the reader and myself a better understanding what A Post occupancy evaluation (POE) is. I will also look into how it works for different people involved with the building and what benefits it may have for both the client and the users of the site. I will be looking for research to back up the use of this particular way of gathering

Temporal Lobe Epilepsy: A Literature Review

1162 words - 5 pages % decrease of minor and severe seizures scanned with an EEG. There was also a reduction in the dispersal of the convulsion by 50.2% in comparison to the sham conduction group. This implies that the shunt through the conduction electrode can dramatically decrease the production and the spread of KA induced seizures [2]. Literature review of mystical experiences in TLE discussion intertwines the concept of the brain and the spirit. The brain is

Temporal Lobe Epilepsy: A Literature Review

1326 words - 5 pages Studies of the disease were found by using the Texas A&M Corpus Christi library through electronic search of temporal lobe epilepsy. Four primary research and one review article were used to complete this literature analysis. The articles discussed are condensed in Table 1. Regarding EI in patients with TLE and patients with extra temporal lobe epilepsy was a case-control study that had three groups. Group 1 consisted of forty patients with

Laws governing unmanned aircraft: A Literature Review

1616 words - 7 pages Reform Act of 2012. If current laws governing unmanned aircraft usage by law enforcement are left unchanged, then the Fourth Amendment rights of Americans will be violated. Literature Review State v. Brossart is the first known case involving evidence from an unmanned aircraft. Brossart’s attorney Bruce Quick condemned his arrest because the Grand Forks police used a Department of Homeland Security Predator UAS to survey the Brossart property to

Incumbency Advantage - A Full Literature Review

2132 words - 9 pages In the current literature review, eight sources were cited, discussing the role of incumbency in the re-election process. Historically, incumbents are rarely defeated for re-election. The research in each of the articles describes the advantages of being an incumbent. Most sources collected data from congressional elections, although some statistics were gathered from local elections. Overall, the research suggests being an incumbent does

The Meaning of Diversity Among the Professorate—A Literature Review

671 words - 3 pages The Meaning of Diversity Among the Professorate—A Literature Review Different aspects of diversity in higher education are an ongoing topic of debate. In order for us to address the issue of diversity, we need to understand what diversity means. This paper reviews a study used at the University of Florida to assess their faculty’s meaning of diversity. It also looked at the faculty’s openness to diversity and the effect diversity has had on

Legalization of Marijuana: A Review of the Literature

2394 words - 10 pages and state level are serving time for marijuana offenses. (Armentano, 2007) In order to learn more about the usage of marijuana by adults, teens and elders, as well as learn how much information the public actually knows about the plant, four important questions must be considered. The following review on literature will provide statistics showing that most of the public is for the legalization of marijuana, discuss how many people regularly

Legalization of Marijuana: A Review of the Literature

2135 words - 9 pages believe on whether marijuana can have a negative or positive effect on a person’s health? 4. Does the public realize how many prisoners are in prison because of petty drug charges for possession of marijuana? As well as how much taxpayer’s money goes to be spent on those prisoners unnecessarily? The following review on literature will provide statistics showing that most of the public is for the legalization of marijuana, discuss how many people

Parental Involvement in Early Education: A Review of the Literature

2282 words - 10 pages Parental Involvement in Early Education: A Review of the Literature Introduction A child’s first teacher is his or her mother and father. As a parent, involvement in the education process in the early years includes engaging the child through age appropriate games, regular reading, and simply interacting on a daily basis. A child that is engaged in this way are set up to develop into students who succeed academically. Once that child

The Role of HR in Corporate Success: A Literature Review

1247 words - 5 pages Often when someone thinks of their human resource department it is assumed that HR is there is simply to process paperwork and do the things that supervisors and other management don't want to be bothered with. Though, as the authors in this review emphasize, the HR department actually plays a very active role in structuring an organization and leading it on to success. They contend that human resource management is becoming a critical point of

Similar Essays

Literature Review Wrong Turn In America's Counterinsurgency

802 words - 4 pages Colonel Gian Gentile is a retired U.S. Army seasoned combat battalion commander. He served in the Iraq War. Has taught history for the United States Military Academy at West Point. Presently, acts as senior historian for the Rand Corporation in his book Wrong Turn: America’s Deadly Embrace of Counterinsurgency questioned, “The necessity and efficacy of the doctrine of counterinsurgency (COIN) which is essentially armed nation-building

Writing A Literature Review

1022 words - 4 pages Writing a literature reviewIt is impossible to be dogmatic about the form and content of a litereature review; it depends somewhat on the topic. You do now have to follow my recipe slavishly; intelligent dissent is admired and encouraged.A literature review that is part of a thesis is different from what you are doing as part of coursework: A thesis literature review culminates in research questions and hypotheses on which the research to be

A Literature Review Concerning

1089 words - 5 pages definitions were used for the purpose of this study: 1. Baby-boomer- population born between 1946 and 1964 2. Generation X- Population born between 1968 and 1979 3. Service providers- Agencies and individuals providing medical care, mental health care and other social support services. Chapter Two Review of Literature A problem that concerns American society is how to deal with mental health issues in a

What´S A Literature Review?

2186 words - 9 pages Introduction A literature review is a study written by someone on a specific topic by researching relevant literature available and interpreting it (Aveyard, 2010). A research question is developed and by using relevant literature the question is analysed in detail (Aveyard, 2010). The literature review is important because it gives you a shorter version of all relevant literature on the topic chosen, this is so the reader does not have to