A Look At Life During The Great Depression

2026 words - 8 pages

The United States during the early decades of the 20th Century was a nation at the dawn of a transition politically, economically and socially in the United State. It is during this time that the relationship between employers, employees, and the United States government would change dramatically. The United States by the mid-1930's will see the federal government assume a greater role in the business and personal lives of its citizens. Lizabeth Cohen's book Making A New Deal and Jennifer Klein's book For All These Rights discuss these transformations within the United States during this time period. These two authors wrote two different social histories of this era but the historical approach taken by these two authors differs in content and view point. In this paper, I will critique the similarities and differences between these two books.
Lizabeth Cohen approaches the social, working, and economic conditions from a "bottom up" approach that is generated from the perspective of the individual. She examines industrial workers attempts to understand how and why workers came together during the Great Depression and the New Deal to. They formed a strong coalition that was able to mobilize the union movement. The thesis of Cohen's book is ”explaining how it was possible and what it meant for industrial workers to become effective as national political participants in the mid-1930's, after having sustained defeats in 1919 and having refrained from unionism and national politics during the 1920's."
The approach taken by Jennifer Klein is different. She examines welfare capitalism from the early 20th century to the 1960's. In her book, she discusses, "...viewing the 1930's as a definitive break, a chasm separating welfare capitalism from the welfare state and from collective bargaining, I emphasize continuity in the provision of social benefits from the 1920's, into the post-World War II period." Klein like Cohen takes a social history approach to her analysis, but Klein's approach examines the early 20th Century, the Great Depression, and beyond from the perspective of the insurance industry and corporations, a top down approach. Klein spends most of her book discussing the impact of government legislation and policies on companies. Her book discusses the insurance industry and the corporate reaction and interpretation to these changes.
A major difference between the two authors is their approach to welfare capitalism and its impact on workers. According to Cohen, employers during the early 20th Century believed that "Workers had to be driven to labor efficiently and respect the boss's authority." During the 1920's employers sought to change this relationship with employees to satisfy worker complaints, quell the fear of labor militancy, and to prevent unions from entering into corporations during the 1920's. Welfare capitalism helped to create an "enlightened corporation."
These enlightened corporations created a...

Find Another Essay On A Look At Life During the Great Depression

Canada during the Great depression. Essay

2894 words - 12 pages levels, prices of products were falling and purchasing power was getting very weak. To try to help out unemployed people, mostly men, the government introduced relief camps. During the 1930's in Prairie Canada, the Great Depression created harsh conditions and it was a struggle until it ended. The event which triggered the Great Depression was the Stock Market crash of October 24, 1929 in New York. Another important cause was that: Later in the

Movies as a Distraction During the Great Depression

918 words - 4 pages During The Great Depression films were an upright distraction for people in the 1930’s. Some examples of films are, “Public Enemy,” released in 1931, “Gold Diggers,” in 1933, next was “Modern Times,” 1936, lastly was “Room Service,” released in 1938. These films all served as a distraction of The Great Depression for people, and also showed what it was like during the time in some different ways. For example, the treatment of women was portrayed

The Movie Industry During the Great Depression

645 words - 3 pages own lives to the main characters or plots in the film. In the movies “The Public Enemy” and “Modern Times” show the directors/producers look at life during the Great Depression. Comedy movies seemed to boom during this time period. Laughing at a comedy at the movies turned into a weekly routine for adults. In the movie “Modern Times” Charlie Chaplin stars as the regular factory worker, an obvious relation to the 1930’s the machine age, and goes

The Social Effects During The Great Depression

595 words - 2 pages The social effects during the great depression.In the early 1930's there was the great depression. This was caused when the market went into recession and did not recover causing the markets to crash and people lost all of their money. The great depression effected all of the people in many ways, one of the ways was socially. Firstly: The most effected people were the working class. Secondly: The class which was effected a little was the middle

The Film Industry During the Great Depression

1020 words - 5 pages new types of movies like: gangster films and musicals. It was a hard time for people in this era to get by. Most people spent their time watching movies like: gangster films, musicals and comedies, like Modern Times and The Public Enemy and get away from the bad times of the Great Depression. Each film showed the Great Depression in different ways but both ways worked will.

Sea Glass: Hardships during the Great Depression

1421 words - 6 pages , farmers were endangered. Many farmers were forced out of their homes because their farms were unsuccessful (Nishi 25). This happens to Alphonso’s family. They originally own a farm, but are driven into the city (Shreve 310). The difficulties McDermott and Alphonso must go through demonstrate the true hardships of individuals living during the Great Depression. Vivian Burton displays the life of someone who not directly affected by the Great

relief efforts during the great depression

1717 words - 7 pages unemployed of the ability to go after their American Dream. The American Dream, a life of great accomplishments in the new world is one that may just as well stay a fantasy for those that suffered drastically during the Great Depression. Most incoming immigrants believed what they were going to achieve in America would be a home they could call their own, or owning an automobile. Unfortunately… these Americans with high hopes had found themselves

Fsa Photography During the Great Depression

1230 words - 5 pages they are the accurate or right words? During the 1930s, photographers were hired by the FSA to photograph the events of the Great Depression. These photographers used their images, posed or accurate, to sway public opinion concerning the era. Their work displayed an attempt to fulfill the need to document what was taking place and the desire to influence what needed to be done. The 1920s were a time of leisure and carelessness. The Great War

Mexicans in America During the Great Depression

1713 words - 7 pages While many remember the Great Depression as a time of terrible trials for Americans, few understand the hardships faced by Mexicans and Mexican Americans in the U.S. This paper examines the experiences of Mexicans in America during the Great Depression and explores the devastating impact of repatriation efforts. America has an extensive history of accepting Mexican workers when they are needed for cheap labor, and demanding that they be

Government Programs During the Great Depression

1175 words - 5 pages Wagner Act all provided a stable foundation for the workforce and up until World War II were keeping many Americans from committing acts of violence, crime, riots, and alive. In the hardship of the Great Depression numerous citizens found it to be the easy way out by ending their lives. At one point, as a sick joke, the clerks at hotels were asking people at check-in, “For jumping or sleeping?” FDR had established himself as a president who would be remembered for his acts of unselfishness by helping the American people rise up and take a step towards the future of prosperity. Works Cited The American Pageant

Growing Up During the Holocaust: A Look at the Other Side of World War II

2036 words - 9 pages from past to present time, the switching is from Liesel’s current memory to her memory before the Hubermann family, and Max’s life before and after he had to run from the Nazis. I do feel like there is a lot of point of view switching between characters and at times that can get a bit confusing. However, the characters are spectacular and the message comes across loud and clear as you progress in Liesel’s life and her adventures as a book thief

Similar Essays

A 360 View On Life During The Great Depression

1411 words - 6 pages . One of the major impacts that the Great Depression had on many families was salary income. The economic collapse of the 1930’s was overwhelming in the way that it was affecting the citizens. “Unemployment jumped from less than 3 million in 1929 to 4 million in 1930, 8 million in 1931, and 12.5 million in 1932.” In just one year, a quarter of the nation’s families did not have any salaries entering their household, and during the first three

A Distraction During The Great Depression

696 words - 3 pages During the Great Depression, everyone was looking for a distraction from the terrible times around them. One way to put their mind at ease was to go to the theater and watch movies. Even during this era of distress, 60 to 80 million people a week still managed to go to the movies. Comedies were a great way to look at the bright side of situations and to put off the stress. In contrast, gangster films showed the fear that maybe what you are doing

The Life Of America During The Great Depression

2824 words - 11 pages before us to comprehend what has happened in the past. We know that the Depression occurred and we have heard testimonies of it. All we need to do now is to learn from it. Remembering that The Great Depression was a long, unhappy and miserable time period, but not dwelling in it, will help us to acknowledge and count all the riches that we've been bestowed with and create the life of America at this point in time.

Film During The Great Depression Essay

678 words - 3 pages During the Great Depression, people went to the movies to get their mind off things and to forget about things temporarily. Life was portrayed a few different ways during the Great Depression. Different genres of film gave different perspectives on what life was like. The three genres compared are comedy, gangster, and musical films. Room Service and Modern Times are two films in the comedy genre and they portrayed a worry-free lifestyle. The