A Man For All Seasons Essay

1784 words - 8 pages

Defence of Thomas More
Pages 17-22
Cardinal Wolsey had planned to send a letter to Rome to request for the Pope to agree to King Henry VIII’s divorce. Since Thomas More had violently opposed to that idea, Wolsey sent for him to read the letter first. More thought that Wolsey’s plan was “devious” but Wolsey felt that it was a “devious situation” so he had to use such a “devious” plan to solve it. However, More believed that there was some other simpler way to solve the problem. Wolsey then scolded More for being so moralistic and told him to be more practical instead.
After that, Wolsey asked More how he planned to give the king a male heir. More said that he would “pray for it daily” but Wolsey wanted to “secure a divorce” so that King Henry VIII could marry Anne Boleyn and most likely produce a male heir, which he felt would solve the issue immediately, since he was making the effort to do something, unlike More, who would rather pray for help.
Area of dispute: More believes that it is not right to ask the Pope to dispense with his dispensation of the Christian law (a man cannot marry his brother’s widow) just for state affairs. However, Wolsey places the country’s interests above his own personal conscience as he feels that it is his job to ensure that the king will have a male heir to ascend the throne in future.
Reason to defend Sir Thomas More: More is just thinks that his private conscience is more important than his public duties and will do what he thinks is right, not what is convenient. This is not considered High Treason as More is not attempting to betray his country in any way.
Textual evidence:
More: “Well…I believe, when statesmen forsake their own private conscience for the sake of their public duties…they lead their country by a short route to chaos.” (Page 22)
How I will use it: This quote shows More is a moralistic man. While Wolsey just wants to take the easy way out of problems, More would rather listen and follow his own conscience. More believes that this will ultimately benefit the country’s people since one’s conscience will determine the course of action one will take. If one is morally sound, he will be able to make appropriate decision to lead his country to peace and prosperity.

Pages 53-59
King Henry VIII made a “surprise visit” to More’s house on his newly launched ship, The Great Harry. After he disembarked, he spoke with More’s daughter, Margaret, for a while before requesting to speak with More in private.
During their private discussion, King Henry VIII asked for More’s opinion on his idea of the divorce, to which More replied that he was not supportive of it. This angered the king but More continued to explain himself. More stated that if he could agree to the divorce with a clear conscience, he would not mind having his arm cut off.
After the king left, Alice, More’s wife, was angry that More had annoyed the king. She then told More to “[b]e ruled” if he did not want to “rule [the king]”. In spite of...

Find Another Essay On A Man for All Seasons

Bolt's "A Man for All Seasons"

767 words - 3 pages Reading about individuals whose ways of life are dramatically different from our own provides readers with fresh insights into their own experiences and ideas. A reader of A Man for All Seasons, by Robert Bolt, may not be accustomed to the actions of the play's characters. Though, it is important to figure out and understand why the character reacts or acts as he/she does. This enables the reader to have a new or modified outlook on his/her own

Conflict in A Man for All Seasons

1686 words - 7 pages In England, during the Renaissance, Henry XIII wants to divorce hiswife, Catharine of Arigon. To look good in-front of his people, Henry asks SirThomas More, a well respected lawyer and citizen, to support the divorce.This presents Sir Thomas More with an inner conflict. In Robert Bolt's play,A Man for All Seasons, Thomas More resists pressures exerted by HenryXIII through Thomas Cromwell, The Duke of Norfolk, and Alice More.These pressures

Friendship in A Man for All Seasons

832 words - 4 pages What as friends? Charles Kingsley has said, “It is only the great hearted who can be true friends. The mean and cowardly, Can never know what true friendship means.” In the book A Man for All Seasons, Sir Thomas More--a great and wise nobleman, and his “friends” reflect the meaning of Charles Kingsley’ quote. Near the beginning of the book, Richard Rich is trying to get a recommendation from Thomas More so that he can get a position. He tells

A man for all seasons compared with other books

766 words - 3 pages Freedom is a state of mind and is a choice. It cannot be taken away from somebody if they are in shackles or in jail. Freedom means different things to different people. Certain people would also put their life on the line as long as they have freedom. Sir Thomas More in A Man for All Seasons, Richard Lovelace in "To Althea", and Lord Byron in "The Prisoner of Chillon, all have different perspectives on what freedom is and what they would do if

A Man for All Seasons: More’s Moral Stature

2050 words - 8 pages A Man for All Seasons:  More’s Moral Stature                        In some literature, a character’s moral stature plays an important role.  In the play, A Man for All Seasons, by Robert Bolt, no other character comes close to More’s moral reputation.  Thomas Cromwell and Richard Rich do not compare to More’s moral stature because both Rich and Cromwell lie, while Rich accepts bribes and Cromwell does anything King Henry VIII tells him

Conscience in "A Man for All Seasons," by Robert Bolt

648 words - 3 pages Webster's Seventh New Collegiate Dictionary defines conscience as 'the sense or consciousness of the moral goodness or blameworthiness of one's own conduct, intentions, or character together with a feeling of obligation to do right or good. In "A Man for All Seasons," each character's conscience plays the ultimate role in the outcome of the story. 'Individual conscience' is trait that each character possesses. This trait differs in intensity

"A Man for All Seasons", by Robert Bolt 1500 word essay on the position/role of women in Robert Bolt's play "A Man for All Seasons"

1539 words - 6 pages In the play, A Man for All Seasons, by English playwright Robert Bolt, the female characters are all restricted to the role as wife, mother and lover. Bolt constructs them as being constricted and disempowered, but also as being strong, intelligent women, showing that he does not endorse the idea of women being restricted to these roles. A Man for all Seasons is set during Tudor England, and at the time it was standard practice for women to be

Was Sir Tomas More Correct? A view on "A man for all seasons"

677 words - 3 pages This is a essay that I wrote after reading A Man for All Seasons -Was Sir Tomas More's decision correct?There are often many different ways to look at situations. Usually when situations are viewed from different points of view, differing opinions can be found. In A Man for All Seasons there are clearly a lot of opinions about More's silence to the oath required by the act of succession. In the play the church is represented by the Spanish

A Man For All Seasons Essay.docx - High school year 11 - Assignment

643 words - 3 pages Richmond to Chelsea, downstream, a penny half penny… coat, hat… coat, hat from Chelsea to Richmond, upstream, a penny halfpenny. Whoever makes the regulations doesn’t row a boat. Cloth… home again.” By using this dramatic technique, it makes audience to being involve to the play and give an idea of The Common Man’s thought. In conclusion, the thought provoking play called ‘A Man For All Seasons’ by Bolt uses three characters to represent three

A Man for All Seasons, by Robert Bolt. On More's Moral Dilemma

1221 words - 5 pages More's Moral DilemmaDuring the English renaissance in the 1500's, King Henry VIII wants a divorce from his wife for various reasons, but divorce is against the Catholic religion. This is why he wants Sir Thomas More's consent, because More is a highly respected Catholic, but he is such a good Catholic that he goes against divorce. In the play, A Man for All Seasons, by Robert Bolt, King Henry VIII applies pressure on Thomas More to support the

Comparison "an ennemy of the people", "A man for all seasons", and "the allegory of the cave"

1235 words - 5 pages discomfort to their lives.A connection can also be made between the Allegory and A man for all Seasons. The people that represent the enchained prisoners are the the ones living under the high authority. This includes the common man, Richard Rich, the Duke of Norfolk, Wosley, Cromwell and all the ones under the authority of the King. While facing the wall, King Henry VIII is standing behind them, as the puppeteer, projecting shadows for them to

Similar Essays

A Man For All Seasons Essay

908 words - 4 pages In the beginning of A Man for All Seasons, Sir Thomas More is introduced as a profoundly religious man focused on adhering to the laws of his country and faith. As the play progresses the audience sees More putting further faith into his belief that by abiding to the present laws and withholding his opinion about King Henry VIII’s divorce he will be protected from prosecution. The issue starts when the King wishes to divorce his brother’s wife

A Man For All Seasons Essay

1028 words - 5 pages ‘A Man for All Seasons’ is a play written by Robert Bolt, previously for BBC Radio in 1954 before revising it on stage. It was premiered on the 1st of July 1960 at the Global Theatre in London. The story begins when Sir Thomas More, a scholar and a statesman, advises Richard Rich to be a teacher instead of striving to be affluent but he fails. He then gives Rich an Italian cup that was given to him by a lady he reviewed. It was given as a bribe

Robert Bolt's A Man For All Seasons

969 words - 4 pages Robert Bolt's "A Man For All Seasons" In the play, written by Robert Bolt, 'A man for all seasons' the Common Man is a very important character and also a very important part of the play, not in the plot but in the way the play has been presented, he is both a narrator and a role player who makes the play more interesting and separates it from reality. The Common Man also introduces some of the ideas from Bertolt Brecht's work. The

English Literature A Man For All Seasons

1178 words - 5 pages When any piece of work is written a deciding factor is the context of the author. Also the context of the reader decides how they will perceive it. A Man For All Seasons written by Robert Bolt, is a play of the martyrdom of Sir Thomas More, later Saint. When reading a play one must consider the three contexts involved. The time of the writer, 1960's Europe. The time of the play, 1600's Europe. Also that of the reader and how living in a